User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Provide a Refund to the Nashville Team in USA AA#1
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
One last comment on this thread... I think...

I personally am very glad that this discussion came up, and I bet there are a lot of others are as well... Or rather, I am very glad that the QB's stats were put up - because otherwise this discussion would have been pretty worthless.

As it is, there is now evidence to point to (if any was needed) that greedy players who maximize their stamina in order to get more play time, might not be the best players to have on the field when the opposition is good.

Stamina doesn't help a Player throw the ball better, or catch the ball better - throwing and catching do. Points spent on stamina are points which are not spent on catching and throwing. Better to have 2x level 16 QB's with 66 throwing and 40 Vision/Confidence than to have 1 level 25 with lower useful attributes.


+1
I could understand MAYBE, if your guard had 52 stamina since they don't have many stats to pump up, that is a big maybe though since at least 15 of those points would be better served elsewhere. In the case of the QB it could of been better served in confidence and strength which are very low, especially for a level 25 QB.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by Serenity

Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader


Have someone explain the term to you. Then you'll understand why 10 INTERCEPTIONS by a single team doesn't occur in playoff games.



Because those teams have QB's who are actually good?



Not even "bad" PLAYOFF QB's throw TEN in a game. Not in the pros, not in college.

Today's sim was a bad joke.



It hasn't even happened in the NFL that a QB not good enough to make the playoffs (or a team starting such a QB) has thrown 10 interceptions in a game.

Tim Couch, the Browns' first first-round draft pick after Cleveland got the franchise again, who was a huge bust but got 5 seasons of trying and failing to play well, never threw 10 interceptions in a game.

He threw 21 interceptions in his worst *season* for interceptions. Given above records for turnovers in a game that are posted, I can say with certainty that he never threw above 7 (and probably never threw above 4 or 5) in a game.

And we're talking about a bad QB (probably among the worst 10% of QB's who started in the NFL for 3 or more years) on a bad team (in those days). He couldn't even get a backup job after the Browns released him.

This happening in a Beta, I'd call understandable. This not being seen as a problem by some, not so understandable.
 
hambone77us
offline
Link
 
i would hate it for that guy if he had to run to the bathroom really fast because he is slower than smoke off of shit in the winter time.
 
Checkmate187
offline
Link
 
I bet nobody will underestimate confidence again.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi


As it is, there is now evidence to point to (if any was needed) that greedy players who maximize their stamina in order to get more play time, might not be the best players to have on the field when the opposition is good.



He wasn't "greedy". Further, there was nothing in PREVIOUS SIMS to suggest that we need be concerned with TEN interceptions in a single game. But then again--we all imagined we were playing a game that simulated (American) football--not whatever this joke of a sim churned out this afternoon.

 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dee
Originally posted by wombat killer



Just because it happened doesn't mean it is a good thing. Maybe the "death spiral" is so unrealistic it needs to be looked at. Or maybe other settings need to be put in place to be able to deal with it.



Possibly, but then how worthless would Confidence be?
This thread has more or less proven the worth of confidence. We remove the need to have confidence, a QB needs 3 stats? Throwing/Strength/Vision?
If his QB had only 29 throwing, and had this bad of a game, would we be asking the sim to be changed so that 29 throwing at level 25 is enough?

Its our job as the players to try to find the good builds. Lesson to be learned is that confidence AT TIMES, is more important than any other stat. How important it is? I dont know.


I don't think anyone involved wants to nerf confidence. I think the idea is that how extreme an effect morale can have should be limited.
 
Link
 
Checkmate, yea they will. And you know they will.
 
Footballmike
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi



As it is, there is now evidence to point to (if any was needed) that greedy players who maximize their stamina in order to get more play time, might not be the best players to have on the field when the opposition is good.



He wasn't "greedy". Further, there was nothing in PREVIOUS SIMS to suggest that we need be concerned with TEN interceptions in a single game. But then again--we all imagined we were playing a game that simulated (American) football--not whatever this joke of a sim churned out this afternoon.



maybe Bort is an alien and plays Alien football.....

seriously you ever heard of street football or pick up games etc.....come on American football that we see on T.V. isn't the only football games out there


saying that though I do agree that sim was bull
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

Originally posted by Serenity


Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader



Have someone explain the term to you. Then you'll understand why 10 INTERCEPTIONS by a single team doesn't occur in playoff games.



Because those teams have QB's who are actually good?



Not even "bad" PLAYOFF QB's throw TEN in a game. Not in the pros, not in college.

Today's sim was a bad joke.



It hasn't even happened in the NFL that a QB not good enough to make the playoffs (or a team starting such a QB) has thrown 10 interceptions in a game.

Tim Couch, the Browns' first first-round draft pick after Cleveland got the franchise again, who was a huge bust but got 5 seasons of trying and failing to play well, never threw 10 interceptions in a game.

He threw 21 interceptions in his worst *season* for interceptions. Given above records for turnovers in a game that are posted, I can say with certainty that he never threw above 7 (and probably never threw above 4 or 5) in a game.

And we're talking about a bad QB (probably among the worst 10% of QB's who started in the NFL for 3 or more years) on a bad team (in those days). He couldn't even get a backup job after the Browns released him.

This happening in a Beta, I'd call understandable. This not being seen as a problem by some, not so understandable.


You clearly do not get it. The reasoning has already been explained out in the thread.

You don't see 255-0 scores in the NFL, yet few seem to complain about their lack of realism.

The fact is that clearly there's no QB in the NFL that's bad enough to throw 10 interceptions in a game (and the coach wouldn't let the QB stay in the game), as the players have to be pretty good already to make the NFL.
 
GmanV2
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Checkmate187
I bet nobody will underestimate confidence again.


LOL, I'd agree, and I'll bet a WHOLE lot of people reading this thread went and changed some of their players daily training to confidence, .
 
Footballmike
offline
Link
 
maybe Bort is an alien and plays Alien football.....

seriously you ever heard of street football or pick up games etc.....come on American football that we see on T.V. isn't the only football games out there


saying that though I do agree that sim was bull
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Checkmate187
I bet nobody will underestimate confidence again.



Today's sim makes the "playable cheerleaders" suggestion seem like a good one--its every bit as reasonable as a playoff QB tossing nine picks in a game before his backup comes in to throw a tenth.
 
hambone77us
offline
Link
 
all i know is im a fat ass and could beat your qb in a foot race lol
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi



As it is, there is now evidence to point to (if any was needed) that greedy players who maximize their stamina in order to get more play time, might not be the best players to have on the field when the opposition is good.



He wasn't "greedy". Further, there was nothing in PREVIOUS SIMS to suggest that we need be concerned with TEN interceptions in a single game. But then again--we all imagined we were playing a game that simulated (American) football--not whatever this joke of a sim churned out this afternoon.



Yeah there was. There have been many games with tons of interceptions.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=46818

7 interceptions.

And yes, 52 stamina may not be greedy, but it's stupid. People have already said that your QB has a crap build. Deal with it.
 
Link
 
Hm, I ran the offense and defense for the winning team and I'm quite proud of myself....
Last edited Jul 14, 2008 18:33:55
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.