User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Sorting promoting teams by record this season?
Page:
 
Fumanchuchu
fonky
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick

I'm not talking about tanking, I'm just saying that if you take the theoretical 32 "best" teams in cap 30 and put them in the same league, then presumably a lot less of them will be promoting two tiers the following season than if they were distributed randomly.


Should slant the promotions towards league #1.

League 1 top 8 promote 3, next 16 promote 2, the last 8 promote one.

League 2 top 6 promote 3, next 14 promote 2, the last 12 promote one.

League 3 top 4 promote 3, next 12 promote 2, next 12 promote one, bottom 4 stay

League 4 top 2 promote 3, next 10 promote 2.................



....and so on till the bottom leaugue only promotes the top 4-8 teams.
 
MVP Rodgers
offline
Link
 
I like the idea. Nothing worse that 12+ noncompetitive games every season.

With a gold, silver, bronze tiers I'd like to see more cash for all the gold teams. Since the bottom finishers won't get any playoff cash they could fall behind on building the stadiums and paying for eq. Basically being punished financially for fielding a good team. If they were in say the next lower tier they'd have a few home playoff games and a bunch more money.
 
Roger6363
offline
Link
 
The main complaints other than CPU/Gut job's in leagues all boils down to average player age. If you have leagues sorted by average players age you will have boosting teams together, non-boosting teams together(likely sprinkled in with some SSB) and SSB all in the same league.

How many ever CPU teams are needed put them with the oldest roster due to the likely hood of them being SSB and SSB dont mind blowout games anyways or they wouldnt SSB.

New teams would be put in the oldest leagues since their likelyhood of competing is less likely anyways and they could get a season to get their roster together.

You could assign teams to caps tomorrow and shuffle the leagues at season rollover. If a team has a plan of moving a bunch of SSB's it will at least kill chemistry and make it more difficult to do so.

CPU players would be treated as old as hell players.


 
Diggersboy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by haleykrl DTD
locked leagues imo


QFT
 
headsigh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by King Of NY
Originally posted by headsigh

If all your players leave in the middle of the offseason right after leagues get changed up I think you have an entirely different problem


No im saying i went 16-0 won champs but only like 5 players remained on the team..
so i would be promoted to gold league this season?


I think the script would recognize you're mostly CPU or gutted or something
 
NY
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Plankton
How would championship teams that opted for a 3 cap jump factor in? Clearly a 16-0 or 15-1 record in cap 34 != a 16-0 or 15-1 record in cap 38.


Good Point Planktons picks
 
Godzirra
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97


Bort, how about instead of record, you sort by winning % with the CPU teams removed? That might create a better sort but keep the exact same idea?


nothing is perfect, but I think anything that helps to improve competitiveness is worth the effort!


I agree.

This was my point several pages back. I would just like something this major completly thought thru. And anything like this worth doing... is worth doing right.
 
NY
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by headsigh
I think the script would recognize you're mostly CPU or gutted or something


and if it doesnt...then im assed out
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Fumanchuchu
Should slant the promotions towards league #1.

League 1 top 8 promote 3, next 16 promote 2, the last 8 promote one.

League 2 top 6 promote 3, next 14 promote 2, the last 12 promote one.

League 3 top 4 promote 3, next 12 promote 2, next 12 promote one, bottom 4 stay

League 4 top 2 promote 3, next 10 promote 2.................



....and so on till the bottom leaugue only promotes the top 4-8 teams.


Even that system will leave 8 teams from the gold league only getting 1 cap that probably would have all gotten 2 cap jumps the old way.
 
Adidas
offline
Link
 
Only bad thing I see is some good teams gutting due to being beat more than they are used to.
 
Plankton
OPL4Lyfe
offline
Link
 
I know I may come across as against this. I am not, as long as the end result is fair to the team's progress out of the minors. The idea of competing every week against the best teams in my cap is awesome! However, I'll pass on that if it means I will be slower getting out of the minors and never make Pros.
 
dragonslade
offline
Link
 
I like this. I hate having my team win by a lot or getting beat by a lot.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by headsigh
Yeah, I know, perhaps. Bronze leagues are kind of parked in themselves.

If a team guts or goes midseason though, are they automatically gonna get marked to get put down to the lower tier of the cap or do they just get carried along?


They'd do as normal for the next season...get moved off with other CPUs.

Of course nothing is perfect and people will manage to muck it up somehow I'm sure, but I think it will work better in the end than hoping for the best with "random sort."
 
oronis
offline
Link
 
OMG I suggested this like 8 seasons ago...

I guess I'm still a fan of the idea.
 
jcross
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by headsigh
I like this. Just shift the CPU teams to the bottom parts, then?


Think Bort already said the CPU's would go to the bottom tier already tho
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.