RE: The recent back and forth.
I think an awful lot of speculation as to who is being punished and who is being rewarded is being done and there are alarmists for both sides.
A well built team may not be punished, and a crappy team is not necessarily going to be rewarded.
What we know:
1 - Bort is looking for ideas to deal with the whining.
2 - One of those ideas involves using a slight modifier for experience gained in a game, when playing 'lesser' opponents.
What we don't know:
1 - What the modifier would be. Though there has been some dancing around 10-15%.
2 - The Formula that would be used to determine League strength.
3 - What sort of 'grace' or 'buffer' would exist/be allowed before the penaly/bonus kicked in.
My own take:
This really only becomes an issue when new teams are released and people complain that they are trying to build a team of friends/known quality OR are trying to build a successful new team that will be 'assured' to be prmoted at the end of the season.
If we look at the fact that many other people will also be building a new team when it is allowed, so many other teams might also have 'stacked' rosters, the Average/Median level for a new team/league may be being raised by multiple teams. So when the initial building period is done, more parity may also have been created.
Likewise, because we do no know the formula used and the allowed norm for disparity, (Which should be at the minimum 3 levels to allow for boosting and not double penalise the boosters) there may not be a worry at all about the 'disparity' of levels.
One possible solution for this would be, when new teams are opened up in a region the teams not be assigned to a 'league' until the day before the first day of the season. This might cause some confusion and extra work for the Admins of the game, but what it would allow for is a 'power ranking' placement of the teams into the league structure. Using the formula used to determine a teams 'strength' that will be used to also determine if extra EXP is earned/lost in a game the teams can be ranked and then placed into their relevant leagues Pro, Semi-Pro etc down the line.
Parity is now closer to being assured for _all_ the teams.
And at this point, the formula for XP lst/gained vs strength of league/opponent begins to really work. Because it is those moves down during the season that people complain most about. Bringing in a few level 16 Plaers in a league whose average is 10/11. If, once the leagues have been organised for their relevant strength, players who are inordinately our of level brought in, they might benefit or suffer accordingly and this seems fair.
This would only resolve 'new' territories (like Africa). Exisiting leagues couldn't/shouldn't be re-organised every year based on the strength of a teams average/median. BUT I would say this is still less of a problem as these leagues are 'mature' and absent intentional guting (Something Bort has been working to make less easy to do) most teams are fairly close in overal strength. There are some exceptions but those few exceptions mean that you may play one or two games where one side gets an EXP boost and one side gets a small EXP penalty but they will not be largely impactive and screw the players out of their 'due'.
I think the basic concept/idea has merit.
Last edited Jun 8, 2008 14:59:37