User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Tagging players is ready
Page:
 
PING72
offline
Link
 
I was thinking about this, and at first I was very excited.

I see the advantage of this: If the rushing QB is in the game you can run different AI, or if the other team puts in a specific HB for pass plays, all that is great. The DC in me was excited.

Then the OC in me started to think how to exploit this. It seems like it'll be pretty easy to exploit. Put in your rushing QB to run a FB dive, etc. Teams will have to be more creative, but I think you can set things up in a way that it is too difficult to make these settings worth much.

Then I began thinking again as a DC. The new inputs for this is going to be ridiculously complicated. I think it's much more than the "if their rushing QB is in the game, run this play where we blitz our safeties." You will have to create a bunch of different inputs and place them all in a pecking order. Think of all the combinations, based on personnel. If your opponent has their rushing qb, their receiving HB, and their blocking FB all in the game, only 1 input will fire, unless you create all of the possible combinations.

In lower levels, a throwing QB has enough strength to actually hold is own at TE. You're simply going to see teams putting in the rushing QB for a lot of other HB or FB run plays, as well as some screens and passes. You'll see the speed HB in the game for FB dives, etc.

So, in essence, a smart OC will be able to get around the tagging system, which means the DC has to be pretty much prepared for everything regardless of tags (unless an upper level QB really can't throw at all), which means the whole tagging system won't really add anything to the game at all.

The more I think about this, the more I realize it's something that will appease all of the people calling for it, but won't really offer a viable solution against well coached teams. So, those complaining about the time, I really don't think you'll need to use tagging to be competitive.
Edited by PING72 on Sep 22, 2009 12:48:39
 
seanb1979
offline
Link
 
Well when you really think about how most teams run their offense, you shouldn't need to change much. Mine will probably have presets like 'scat back, speed back, power back' and 'combo backs, scat backs' 'rushing qb power backs scat backs' etc etc... just tag whos who on the team you face and if you called the right plays (ie there are only so many plays a power hb is good on, etc) you should be fine. Rushing qbs will be much more challenging since they can hand off to whoever.


Combo backs will be unaffected by this and this tagging feature is more or less the death of the pure power back.
 
taurran
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by taurran

I disagree.

The best DC's run generic plays that blanket the field in any given situation. You can set up a 4-3 with no blitzes, and LB/CB coverage set up so it is effective for any offensive play.

The only current adjustment required for a well run defense is against the outside run/screen. Everything else can be handled with generic defensive formations and coverage assignments.


lmao


Yeah, you'd like to make things more complicated than that, but with the current state of pass coverage, LB reads, and limited offensive selection of plays, you really can shut down an opposing offense with a generic gameplan.

As I stated, the only real way to exploit defensive weaknesses vs a well thought out defense is to alternate outside runs and screens. Everything else, for the most part, is just picking the highest % success plays and hoping they succeed. It's been true since season 7, unfortunately, and is why myself and others have based their entire offensive planning around HB passes. Of course, it's getting even harder to do that now that it's well known that HBs are the key to the passing game, and it will only become exceedingly difficult with the newest changes.

The passing game is hurting badly, and needs some major restructure for it, and WRs, to be valid again. This will only serve to hurt it even more. Cutting HB/FB passes out of the picture takes the offense back to a point where it was pre custom slots. Either find HBs that can do it all, or pass deep to the WRs in coverage and hope for the best.

There still will be ways to gameplan to exploit holes in defenses, but it won't be very realistic at all. It will be more a question of doing funky ass stuff with players you know are tagged, such as running them out of position to knowingly deceive the defensive AI tags. Pretty gay if you ask me. At that point it's less about football strategy and more about working the system.
 
PING72
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by seanb1979
Combo backs will be unaffected by this and this tagging feature is more or less the death of the pure power back.


I'm not completely sure about that. If you're keeping in your HB to block anyway, throw in your powerback. Now teams have to worry about the pass and running up the gut. Or use your powerback as the FB and run with him (it looks like you might only be able to give a player one tag). Creative OC's will get around this.

What I do think this will do is increase the usefulness of a FB. Teams trying to limit the scatback or speedback could leave some big holes for a good FB.

What I'm concerned with, though, is there is not a real good way to scout any of this. Is there any way to know what plays are called with the FB1 or FB2 in the game w/o watching every game and making notes?
 
taurran
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PING72
Originally posted by seanb1979

Combo backs will be unaffected by this and this tagging feature is more or less the death of the pure power back.


I'm not completely sure about that. If you're keeping in your HB to block anyway, throw in your powerback. Now teams have to worry about the pass and running up the gut. Or use your powerback as the FB and run with him (it looks like you might only be able to give a player one tag). Creative OC's will get around this.

What I do think this will do is increase the usefulness of a FB. Teams trying to limit the scatback or speedback could leave some big holes for a good FB.

What I'm concerned with, though, is there is not a real good way to scout any of this. Is there any way to know what plays are called with the FB1 or FB2 in the game w/o watching every game and making notes?


Yeah, I can see this becoming a shell game with the custom slots. It's going to be ridiculous.
 
PING72
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by taurran
Originally posted by PING72

Originally posted by seanb1979


Combo backs will be unaffected by this and this tagging feature is more or less the death of the pure power back.


I'm not completely sure about that. If you're keeping in your HB to block anyway, throw in your powerback. Now teams have to worry about the pass and running up the gut. Or use your powerback as the FB and run with him (it looks like you might only be able to give a player one tag). Creative OC's will get around this.

What I do think this will do is increase the usefulness of a FB. Teams trying to limit the scatback or speedback could leave some big holes for a good FB.

What I'm concerned with, though, is there is not a real good way to scout any of this. Is there any way to know what plays are called with the FB1 or FB2 in the game w/o watching every game and making notes?


Yeah, I can see this becoming a shell game with the custom slots. It's going to be ridiculous.


I agree it will be at first, but eventually (unless changes are made) I think most DC's will find it's a waste of time to try and do. Other than in very blatant situations against a handful of uncreative teams, I think most DC's will scrap this idea and continue to run balanced defenses like they do currently.

Once OC's figure out how to gameplan against it, I think that 90% of the time it won't be used.
Edited by PING72 on Sep 22, 2009 13:11:34
 
seanb1979
offline
Link
 
You pretty much have to watch replays, look at each players stats and make notes. Then tag appropriately. Or find a way to hack their account/ai.
 
headsigh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Carpy
I am an OC on a Pro team that has a great running QB (who is also a decent passer).

To be honest, I think this is a great addition (but also agree that there is no reason why we don't get QB2 slots now).

This means that "scrambling" built QBs are very useful and players built as pure rushers should be useless.

If the defense sells out to stop the QB run, then the QB should be able to beat the defense with his arm.


Too bad scrambling never works ):
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PING72
The more I think about this, the more I realize it's something that will appease all of the people calling for it, but won't really offer a viable solution against well coached teams.


Um... I never realized "well coached teams" were considered a problem that needed a solution.


I mean, that's the idea, right? Well-coached teams are going to beat poorly-coached teams. That's the way it's supposed to work. The only way a well-coached team is a problem is if you're a bad coach and you have to play them next. And the solution there is simple: become a better coach yourself.
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by taurran
Yeah, I can see this becoming a shell game with the custom slots. It's going to be ridiculous.


You may want to go back to Page 1 and take another look at the screenshots. You don't tag the custom slot. You tag the player himself, and that tag follows the player no matter what custom slot he's in, whether he's in QB1, QB2 or QB84.

I guess OC's could still try to play shell games with the custom slots, but it would be like hiding behind a flagpole and shouting "HA HA! YOU CAN'T SEE ME!" Not much point to it.
 
drakeborn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jcrossfield22
I don't do anything with DC/OC and never have. Figured I would start with that.

As for all this griping and such I find it a bit funny. DC's have complained over and over about not having the tools to put the right personnel in the game to match the offense. Now they get the power and are complaining. Is it time consuming; yes. Could it be simplified and be easier to do, most likely yes. Pretty sure that at one point it will be simplified but just be happy that this is being introduced.


"just be happy" is an awful way to give feedback on prospective changes.

There is more than one way to skin a cat. Using this method to compensate for the incredibly unrealistic and overpowered offense personnel adjustments in GLB is unnecessarily tedious.
 
coach
offline
Link
 
Speaking of unrealistic personnel adjustments... how is it that when a defense sees a FB in the huddle they somehow know where he's going to be lined up at the snap?

I, Strong I, and Weak I should look exactly the same to the defense as far as substitutions are concerned.
 
wessimo
offline
Link
 
Didn't make it through all 14 pages, but does this mean we get a custom QB slot finally?
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wessimo
Didn't make it through all 14 pages, but does this mean we get a custom QB slot finally?


no one knows
 
Bloodfart
offline
Link
 
so you can not only tag QB's, but TE's and HB's as well eh? There's gonna be some heartbreak.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.