User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Coaches - ideas for them to spend money on (and other ideas)
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by David Stern
BORT, If you really want coaches to work and be realistic. Allow us to "Watch film" with our position coach. Then give us say 5 options per player.

Free safety watches film, decides team A runs 5 Favorite plays. He studies plays, and when he sees these plays he gets.

Play 1) HB Screen Ace X% boost to vis speed tackle
Play 2) Strong I slam .8X% boost to vis speed tackle
Play 3)Shotgun Screen .6x% boost
Play 4 etc
Play 5 etc
This way we could actually game plan, and use "Coaches" to give our players boosts to these teams who abuse the same 4-5 plays game in game out. Would force teams to truly devise schemes, and really come up with new game plans week to week.

Edit: this would take more work, but I Don't want coaches to be some BS thing that just gives people a reward for having them. I Want people to have to study, and work to get advantages out of these coaches, not just some Free pass for finding this website first.


Of everything I've seen in this thread, this has been my favorite by far.

The numerous ways that this could work out would just add a whole new flavor to gameplanning/AI. Offense with a good coach being able to pick 5 plays to get the bonus vs. a Defense that focuses on shutting down 5 plays could make for some amazing games.
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
So, I'm working all the coach stuff out, getting code written, interface finished up, etc, etc and I realize:

We really have nothing exciting for these coaches to spend money on.

Obviously, we want the coach to require the team to pay him. He needs some reason to have a salary.

We can just do training and coach equipment like players, but it might be nice to have something else as well, if there's any ideas out there.

Any ideas?


Employees of their own - Scouts, Assistants, Secretaries, Film Analysts. All of which could either provide game functions and be avatars like coaches and players or alternatively could merely be bots that some how enhance his abilities.

Props - Fancy Suits, Stogies, Horn Rimmed Glasses, Perfect Helmet Hair, silly things that add to their fame???

Public Relations - Improves their fame, and their team's fan loyalties.

Recruiting Boosting - Allow Coaches to buy equipment for other players using their own personal money. AND/OR at some exhorbitant rate of exchange allow them to buy flex points for players with their own personal money.





 
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
Well the +strength was only a very simple hypothetical example, it was more the concept I was trying to get across.

If taken to the logical next step, there would be numerous bonuses a coach could select from for each player ranging from +% bonuses to some attributes or skills. Here's a hypothetical coach's training bar that uses 60% of his concentration:

-20% of his concentration bar to give 1 star d-linman +5% break block chance.
-10% of his concentration bar to give another d-lineman a +1% break block chance.
-10% of his concentration bar to give another d-lineman a +1% break block chance.
-20% of his concentration bar to give a blocking TE +5% to his pancake roll.

After say 5-10 games this bonus could grow to:

-20% of his concentration bar to give 1 star d-linman +10% break block chance.
-10% of his concentration bar to give another d-lineman a +6% break block chance.
-10% of his concentration bar to give another d-lineman a +6% break block chance.
-20% of his concentration bar to give a blocking TE +10% to his pancake roll.




That seems like a lot of work if the goal is to simply randomize the outcome.

How do agents hone their build when they have to wade thru the clutter this "addition" adds?
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris


Well the +strength was only a very simple hypothetical example, it was more the concept I was trying to get across.

If taken to the logical next step, there would be numerous bonuses a coach could select from for each player ranging from +% bonuses to some attributes or skills. Here's a hypothetical coach's training bar that uses 60% of his concentration:

-20% of his concentration bar to give 1 star d-linman +5% break block chance.
-10% of his concentration bar to give another d-lineman a +1% break block chance.
-10% of his concentration bar to give another d-lineman a +1% break block chance.
-20% of his concentration bar to give a blocking TE +5% to his pancake roll.

After say 5-10 games this bonus could grow to:

-20% of his concentration bar to give 1 star d-linman +10% break block chance.
-10% of his concentration bar to give another d-lineman a +6% break block chance.
-10% of his concentration bar to give another d-lineman a +6% break block chance.
-20% of his concentration bar to give a blocking TE +10% to his pancake roll.




I Want their to be work behind this. How about this.

Team defense approach. Star D lineman vs play XYZ gets 5% agility 10% BB chance. If team A doesn't run these plays he gets nothing.

Offense. TE Drive. FS is in zone. You predict FS to be in zone. WR 3 gets a 5% boost to speed, and gets first roll at catching the pass, as you scouted team and knew he would be in zone. Since you predicted this correct you get the boost. If FS doubles you, or goes deep to double WR1, you would get Nothing. I Want their to be some sort of skill behind coaches, not just straight percentage boosts.

 
fbfan18
offline
Link
 
Coaching stats could be compiled......
QB Coaches - # of bad throws, # of sacks avoided, # of Field General activations?
H Backs, F Backs, TE Coaches - # of first downs, # of blitzes picked up, # of big plays, # of fumbles lost
O Line - # of sack given up, # of Hurries given up, # of Pancakes, # of offsides penalties
Receiver - # of Drops, # of big plays, # of first downs, something to do with blocking assignments/pancakes???

D line - # of Sacks, # of tackles, # of hurries, # of tackles for loss, # of missed tackles, # of reverse pancakes?
Linebackers - similar stats, but also something for Coverage?
Secondary - Again similar, but also Pass Defections, Intercepts, holding a receiver to no catches, ect

Special Teams -
PR, KR - # of fumbles, # of scores, # of broken tackles
Blockers - # of pancakes on SP Teams
Kicker - # of touchbacks, extended Kicks (Distance), Game Winning FG's
Punter - # of Coffin Corner Kicks, or Fair Catches
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
That seems like a lot of work if the goal is to simply randomize the outcome.

How do agents hone their build when they have to wade thru the clutter this "addition" adds?


I guess I didn't explain it very well if it looks like a lot of work. Basically the coach would just select the handful of players he wants to work with, he then picks the bonus for each player and that would be it. It seems pretty simple to me.



Originally posted by David Stern

Offense. TE Drive. FS is in zone. You predict FS to be in zone. WR 3 gets a 5% boost to speed, and gets first roll at catching the pass, as you scouted team and knew he would be in zone. Since you predicted this correct you get the boost. If FS doubles you, or goes deep to double WR1, you would get Nothing. I Want their to be some sort of skill behind coaches, not just straight percentage boosts.


Good idea, I like the situational bonuses also.
Edited by Saris on Sep 3, 2009 23:38:57
 
fbfan18
offline
Link
 
Also to consider would be a Limit of # of coaches per team? Also to factor in Salaries as well.
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

That seems like a lot of work if the goal is to simply randomize the outcome.

How do agents hone their build when they have to wade thru the clutter this "addition" adds?


I guess I didn't explain it very well if it looks like a lot of work. Basically the coach would just select the handful of players he wants to work with, he then picks the bonus for each player and that would be it. It seems pretty simple to me.


Seems to cookie cutter. Offensive example. Drygerian. Coach gets to pick 5 players to work with
HB Dooley, gets boost to speed agility and break tackle chance
WR Jericho. Gets boost to speed and catch ball chance
RG Bigger boost to outside blocking, and Pancake chance
FB Boost to Lead block, and Hold block chance
TE Boost to outside block Hold block chance

Their that is what they are going to do, too boring, and too simple. Why even have it at all then? I really think the idea of making teams have to game plan to get these coach benefits is the only way this will be enjoyable, and make this game better.

What is the point of having coaches if you don't do anything but just give yourself morale/chem boosts, and BS att bonuses with 0 scouting/effort. Coaches need to work, this needs to be a tactical approach IMO.
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
OTHER IDEAS

Practice

Practice would take place on non-game days of the pre and regular season.

Coaches should be able to select plays that they focus on during practice. Up to five plays may be practiced each day, per squad (5 Offense 5 Defensive). Any given play may be slotted as many times of the five as desired by the coach (ie the coach could put TE Drag down 5 times). The result of practice is +X% to vision, blocking, throwing, tackling, speed & agility for all players on the team for each repetition of the play in practice (ie 1 to 5 times). I would suggest .5% per practice session, so if a team dedicated itself wholly to one offensive play all five slots all season long they would by the time of the play offs have about a 60 percent or so bonus when the team runs that single play (or more realistically they would have about a 12% on each of five different plays).

In addition to giving coaches something meaningful to do, this would also reward teams who stick to playbooks and reduce the effectiveness of the current ability to totally change your play book from one game to the next without penalty.

Practice Facility

This could be something that a team (or the coach if you wanted this to be something for him to spend money on) could build in addition to its stadium. Say its needed to even do practice to begin with, and that each level adds .1 to the X% benefit of practicing.. Thus initially it would be a plus .1% to vision, blocking, throwing, tackling, speed & agility for each repetition of the play in practice, .2% if a second level of practice facility were built, .3% for a third and so on.

Practice Squad

Allow up to 11 roster spots (or whatever number seems funnest) of players who are on the teams practice squad, get paid salary by the team, and earn experience from games as though they had played 20 plays (representing the experience they are earning on the practice squad).

The benefit to the team is

Practice Squad players can be moved to the active roster (or to the Practice Squad) without a chemistry hit.

Each Player on the Practice Squad creates a 1% chance that the boost benefit of practice to vision, blocking, throwing, tackling, speed & agility for all players on the team for each repetition of the play in practice is doubled for that practice.



Edited by yello1 on Sep 3, 2009 23:44:40
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris


Good idea, I like the situational bonuses also.


Ya, the problem is this is too much work. I also feel like Bort just wants this to be a "Pay to get 5% to stat/Morale/Chem " type deal, come up with more ways to get us to spend money, but do so in a manner that requires 0 skill, and allow everyone to do it, and to get it with minimal effort. If Bort really is serious about coaches and actually wants this to be another tactic to the game, he will take note. Got a feeling it is going to be a "Pay to get 5% to stat/Morale/Chem " unfortunately.

 
Saris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by David Stern

What is the point of having coaches if you don't do anything but just give yourself morale/chem boosts, and BS att bonuses with 0 scouting/effort. Coaches need to work, this needs to be a tactical approach IMO.


Well using your situational idea, Drygerian could focus their defensive coaches towards bonuses that were effective vs screens (aka Bonn). They'd be a little less effective against a team like MEM or Santiago, but it would be an interesting option.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by David Stern
I also feel like Bort just wants this to be a "Pay to get 5% to stat/Morale/Chem " type deal, come up with more ways to get us to spend money, but do so in a manner that requires 0 skill, and allow everyone to do it, and to get it with minimal effort. If Bort really is serious about coaches and actually wants this to be another tactic to the game, he will take note. Got a feeling it is going to be a "Pay to get 5% to stat/Morale/Chem " unfortunately.



 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by yello1
OTHER IDEAS

Practice

I would suggest .5% per practice session, so if a team dedicated itself wholly to one offensive play all five slots all season long they would by the time of the play offs have about a 60 percent or so bonus when the team runs that single play (or more realistically they would have about a 12% on each of five different plays).



Do you have any idea what would happen?

Wr streaks Weak I. Team scouts FS covering HB too close to LOS. WR #1 has 15 trackstar/15 quick/streaky/15 w/e wr has 130 speed, and now gets a 60 percent bonus on this play. Pretty much a TD on every play, and would make this game a total joke.
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
Originally posted by David Stern


What is the point of having coaches if you don't do anything but just give yourself morale/chem boosts, and BS att bonuses with 0 scouting/effort. Coaches need to work, this needs to be a tactical approach IMO.


Well using your situational idea, Drygerian could focus their defensive coaches towards bonuses that were effective vs screens (aka Bonn). They'd be a little less effective against a team like MEM or Santiago, but it would be an interesting option.


Agree, A owner like Havoc would thrive with a system like this, and would basically be able to make up for any lack of talent with his tactics even more. But this would force heavy screen teams, to mix it up, and catch teams off guard as well.
 
fbfan18
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by David Stern
Ya, the problem is this is too much work. I also feel like Bort just wants this to be a "Pay to get 5% to stat/Morale/Chem " type deal, come up with more ways to get us to spend money, but do so in a manner that requires 0 skill, and allow everyone to do it, and to get it with minimal effort. If Bort really is serious about coaches and actually wants this to be another tactic to the game, he will take note. Got a feeling it is going to be a "Pay to get 5% to stat/Morale/Chem " unfortunately.



I disagree. I am guessing that Bort is truly interested in expanding this Coaching option, as an extension for players to continue to operate beyond thier playing declining years, and continue on in that new career track. That option in itself is inherently beneficial to Bort, as you were inferring, to keep from "busting the Piggy bank" by retiring the player and just re-using the flex.

I think the intent is to create a new aspect of the game for veteran players, not just a reason to get players to pay more......
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.