User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Gunner65
You know, the more I read these kinds of threads and see all the BS that is going on the more I wonder if any of this crap is getting corrected or reviewed. I know there is a ton of stuff for GLB to try and look at and review but more and more of this stuff just seems to slide through the cracks and takes away from game playability & over all lack of "getting what we pay for" service.



Bort knows alot of plays don't exist, but all teams have equal chance to experiment and figure out what plays those are.

Either Bort can write a detailed explanation of what does and doesn't exist or he can fix the buttons/dropdowns to not let you call certain things or he can work on making all the plays. Personally, I'm glad he's working on new plays instead of the other 2 options.

And if it is the same for both teams, then what is the problem? It's FAIR.

And while some people say that Bort nothing having something programmed for all 50,000 combinations that you can do on offense/defense is a "bug", I say he's just not done programming yet. This is an unfinished program. That is why it is BETA. It is NOT a bug. Just give him some time.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cruzi
Situation: 2nd & 11...Own 43 yard line...Up by 10...6:04 remaining in the 2nd qtr.

Input: 2nd & 10-20...No field position specifics that should trigger...No score or time specifics.

Output: Pass. I won't get into specifics, but there's no run plays here.

Result: A fucking pitch play.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=142498&pbp_id=8411934


Anyone?


I know its a obvious statement, but check your 'close out the game' Input is QTR4 specific and not general.

I have seen a lot of examples of people posting Bugs that they are getting runs and not passes where they have set the If leading with x seconds remaining run in the general section and not the 4th Qtr.

then check that the Outputs equal 100%, as people often delete plays but dont adjust them.

Then check each Output for the actual play, not just the name of the output in the Test AI function.

I have seen too many people recently saying 'I checked it and it should be a Med Pass, but when I check their AI the drop down box says Basic or Run or something other than what they think it is.

But at the end of the day, I have Never Ever seen the AI call a run if the Input says Pass.

It doesnt matter if you enter Long FB pass, (Which doesnt exsist) it simply selects a Long pass at Random.

The inverse is true, you can call a Long TE Pass and get a 5WR set with no TE on the field.

Run/Pass is an absolute, distance is a absolute, Primary Ball Carrier is an absolute, primary reciever is NOT an absolute for putting that player on the field. (It should be).

PS: Cruzi I am sure you have done all the above, this is a general comment.
Last edited Oct 19, 2008 16:23:43
 
Cruzi
offline
Link
 
Thanks for the reply. I posted that more to vent than anything.

The OAI while exceptionally limited, seems to work like it's supposed to. Other than, as you mentioned, the "primary receiver" dropdown. Not really sure why that is. Has Bort mentioned anything about the OAI being upgraded next season?
 
iManiac
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by D-will
why cant you jsut turn it of instead of whining ....wow..if yo uwant it to be less sever hes working on it just wait


 
ronwboise
offline
Link
 
Ok,someone explain this to me. I basically have the same problem that began this thread. In our last three games I have auto adjust turned off and adjusting at 0, zip, don't change any thing. I the first two of those games we passed a total of 15 times combined, I had the percentages set at 65% pass 35% run. In our final game Warren Brotherhood (us) vs. the Spring Pigs we came out passing, first 5 plays were passes; the last pass was a 4th and 11 at the Pigs 43? It was incomplete and we turned it over. A1 option was turned off. Of the next 54 plays 53 were runs. Over the last 6 games, in 311 possessions, we passed 39 times a little over 12%. I'd say we have a problem. Wonder if I reversed the %s if it would help. Anyone have any ideas?
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Run/Pass is an absolute, distance is a absolute, Primary Ball Carrier is an absolute, primary reciever is NOT an absolute for putting that player on the field. (It should be).


I haven't really seen this come up as a specifically reported bug. Do things seem to work as far as percentages when using "use basic" instead?

I wonder if it's just the lack of plays that's causing problems? If you choose something that doesn't exist, it has to override you to something does exist. Next season will have at least one play of every type, so that shouldn't be a concern any more.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Mike Rogers

Run/Pass is an absolute, distance is a absolute, Primary Ball Carrier is an absolute, primary reciever is NOT an absolute for putting that player on the field. (It should be).


I haven't really seen this come up as a specifically reported bug. Do things seem to work as far as percentages when using "use basic" instead?

I wonder if it's just the lack of plays that's causing problems? If you choose something that doesn't exist, it has to override you to something does exist. Next season will have at least one play of every type, so that shouldn't be a concern any more.


Yes, the lack of plays caused a problem for many players. People get pissed off when they call Pass-TE-Long and get a run for instance.

I've found setting it to "basic settings" causes the most problems especially when there are TE passes and FB runs involved and any mixture of short/med/long.

Almost everyone has figured it out by now though and either accepts a few random plays or works around it another way (like not using the basic settings and calling each play % separately).

Not a big deal imo.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by ronwboise
Ok,someone explain this to me. I basically have the same problem that began this thread. In our last three games I have auto adjust turned off and adjusting at 0, zip, don't change any thing. I the first two of those games we passed a total of 15 times combined, I had the percentages set at 65% pass 35% run. In our final game Warren Brotherhood (us) vs. the Spring Pigs we came out passing, first 5 plays were passes; the last pass was a 4th and 11 at the Pigs 43? It was incomplete and we turned it over. A1 option was turned off. Of the next 54 plays 53 were runs. Over the last 6 games, in 311 possessions, we passed 39 times a little over 12%. I'd say we have a problem. Wonder if I reversed the %s if it would help. Anyone have any ideas?


I didn't quite understand your problem. I mean..... running too much, but I need more info.

Send me a GM title and AI access and I'll figure out what it wrong and PM you back (without touching anything).
Last edited Oct 23, 2008 06:26:53
 
ronwboise
offline
Link
 
definetly running too much. Let me get with the owner and I'll get back with you Steeler thanks.
 
Cruzi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Mike Rogers

Run/Pass is an absolute, distance is a absolute, Primary Ball Carrier is an absolute, primary reciever is NOT an absolute for putting that player on the field. (It should be).


I haven't really seen this come up as a specifically reported bug. Do things seem to work as far as percentages when using "use basic" instead?


Tried setting up the OAI on a 3 different teams with WR Medium and TE Medium passes, and some WR Short & TE Short. Realizing that the primary receiver dropdown did nothing, I scrapped some of the extra outputs in favor of Pass Distance + Basic Settings in place of a primary receiver. I've personally seen no change.

Tried 50/50 WR/TE in the basic AI, as well as 60/40 and 40/60. Nada.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by
fhghghg


Originally posted by
gjhjh
 
Link
 
So I just played a game where I had only 1 input for 1st down, and 4 outputs for that down. For some reason I passed out of 5WR set and shotgun when I did not even have that as an output. It was the first drive of the first quarter and through out the game.

I really wanted to see how one strong I play worked so I eliminated all the other short strong I plays but one. I have also eliminated plays from my play book and still see them called.

Whats the deal?

No auto adjust on. Yes the correct playbook is selected.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=210042&pbp_id=5768919

That was the play I wanted to see. I have the FB in to pass block and for some reason he ignored that and ran a route. I have tested my AI/outputs and it says I should only have 4 outputs but the CPU/Sim is still running plays that are not outputs.

WHY? HELP?
 
quikkag
offline
Link
 
Post edited due the fact that I'm an idiot.
Last edited Nov 25, 2008 18:28:25
 
ZeroTolerance
offline
Link
 
Seriously, I'm getting pissed at this thing. I have used every setting I can think of to limit the number of first down passes, and the sim STILL passes an absurd amount on first down. For today's game I set the offensive AI on first down to only 25% pass, and used the 'follow AI exactly' option. What happened? It passed on SEVEN OF THE FIRST EIGHT first downs. We are going to miss the playoffs for the first time in 6 seasons, and a large part of it is the fact that our offense is getting killed by first down incompletions when we have the best running game in the league. What the hell do I need to do to make the sim run the right damn plays?
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
I noticed that my AI sometimes changes a play designed to be a short into a medium.
My output is

play-type = basic
formation = singleback
distance=short
primary=WR
TE adj = basic
HB adj=block
FB adj=block
rusher = HB
FB DC = FB
HB DC=HB
TE DC =TE

The outcome is Single Back WR short Curls left (a medium WR pass with the HB not staying in pass protection)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=236102&pbp_id=574158


I had someone check my AI and could not find any mistake.
1) I have this short WR pass from the singleback formation in my playbook
2) auto-adjust is turned off
3) The AI correctly identify the input (checked with the tester + another output under the input which can be recognized uniquely)

I has this issue twice in my last game, and even though the outcome was good I don't like the play we run (since I wanted more protection and shorter routes).

Suggestion that I have heard:
1) setting play-type=basic setting make the AI ignore other fields.
2) not setting "follow my AI exactly" may cause some surprises.

I would like to see a Management comment about this issue, since I already went through the the OC forum and could not find a clear answer.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.