User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Demotion Ideas for the WPL
Page:
 
Hikariu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Galkuris

Originally posted by tautology




tautology's plan for demotions in World league that will foster success in all ways

-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=

1) Promote top 4 teams from each league, per original plan
2) Every team that does not make the playoffs in World League gets bounced back to their original Pro league
3) Conference champs from each Pro league move up every season
4) In the offseason, poll WL owners to ensure that they are not gutting. If they do, then bounce them and keep the top non-playoff team in place
5) If more teams get bounced back to a Pro region than are coming up, bounce an additional Pro team from that region back down to AAA.

-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=


Advantages:

1) Leagues retain their identities and rivalries. USAPL can see if they can (as expected) dominate the World league. The rest of us can try to fend them off.

2) The "weaker" leagues see more rapid rotation, and it will be easier to bid for the World league from them. This provides incentive for strong teams to build in those leagues, which creates better parity.

3) The World league will have both a "Worldly" feel to it, as well as insanely intense competition.



Get it done.



I'm not entirely sure what the issue with this plan is. Obviously there is something I'm missing either in peoples minds or in coding because it absolutely makes the most sense to me. It will not only eventually get the best teams up there but it will give every single league equal opportunity to have the same representation. The opportunity is there, whether it happens or not is up to the teams in question.


I posted the issue earlier in the thread. I like the idea in theory, but there is that risk of mass demotion to one region and extra teams getting demoted from spots as high as 8th place.


In theory it's possible. But it's also the best option, IMO
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I posted the issue earlier in the thread. I like the idea in theory, but there is that risk of mass demotion to one region and extra teams getting demoted from spots as high as 8th place.


Bort, look at it this way. For every team that a region has extra in the WL, that is one extra AAA team that was called up the Pro league.

IF there is a mass demotion, that's simply sending those extra AAA teams back down. Think of all the extra recruiting and media revenue they were able to receive while they were in the Pro league instead of AAA?
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Galkuris

Originally posted by tautology




tautology's plan for demotions in World league that will foster success in all ways

-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=

1) Promote top 4 teams from each league, per original plan
2) Every team that does not make the playoffs in World League gets bounced back to their original Pro league
3) Conference champs from each Pro league move up every season
4) In the offseason, poll WL owners to ensure that they are not gutting. If they do, then bounce them and keep the top non-playoff team in place
5) If more teams get bounced back to a Pro region than are coming up, bounce an additional Pro team from that region back down to AAA.

-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=


Advantages:

1) Leagues retain their identities and rivalries. USAPL can see if they can (as expected) dominate the World league. The rest of us can try to fend them off.

2) The "weaker" leagues see more rapid rotation, and it will be easier to bid for the World league from them. This provides incentive for strong teams to build in those leagues, which creates better parity.

3) The World league will have both a "Worldly" feel to it, as well as insanely intense competition.



Get it done.



I'm not entirely sure what the issue with this plan is. Obviously there is something I'm missing either in peoples minds or in coding because it absolutely makes the most sense to me. It will not only eventually get the best teams up there but it will give every single league equal opportunity to have the same representation. The opportunity is there, whether it happens or not is up to the teams in question.


I posted the issue earlier in the thread. I like the idea in theory, but there is that risk of mass demotion to one region and extra teams getting demoted from spots as high as 8th place.


Fair is fair, if your team goes 3-13 etc in Pro, the 2 teams below your are probably gut jobs, then you should be in AAA anyway. Why prolong the obvious?
Edited by jamz on Jul 27, 2009 19:19:52
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Galkuris

Originally posted by tautology




tautology's plan for demotions in World league that will foster success in all ways

-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=

1) Promote top 4 teams from each league, per original plan
2) Every team that does not make the playoffs in World League gets bounced back to their original Pro league
3) Conference champs from each Pro league move up every season
4) In the offseason, poll WL owners to ensure that they are not gutting. If they do, then bounce them and keep the top non-playoff team in place
5) If more teams get bounced back to a Pro region than are coming up, bounce an additional Pro team from that region back down to AAA.

-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=


Advantages:

1) Leagues retain their identities and rivalries. USAPL can see if they can (as expected) dominate the World league. The rest of us can try to fend them off.

2) The "weaker" leagues see more rapid rotation, and it will be easier to bid for the World league from them. This provides incentive for strong teams to build in those leagues, which creates better parity.

3) The World league will have both a "Worldly" feel to it, as well as insanely intense competition.



Get it done.



I'm not entirely sure what the issue with this plan is. Obviously there is something I'm missing either in peoples minds or in coding because it absolutely makes the most sense to me. It will not only eventually get the best teams up there but it will give every single league equal opportunity to have the same representation. The opportunity is there, whether it happens or not is up to the teams in question.


I posted the issue earlier in the thread. I like the idea in theory, but there is that risk of mass demotion to one region and extra teams getting demoted from spots as high as 8th place.



There are risks in all things...sometimes shakeups will happen.

If they do, it will keep the boards lively.

I think that's a corner case really...I think folks will be pretty psyched about competing at the World level, and the leagues will work themselves out naturally below that level.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by The Lurker


Originally posted by lukin83



1. You initially promote the top 4 from each region's pro league.

2. You divide the WL into divisions based on region (APL, USAPL, CPL, EEPL, WEPL, OPL, SAPL, and SEAPL) and set it up similar to the NFL playoffs (division winners and 4 wild cards get in from each conference).

3. The bottom 2 teams in each division after the first season relegate back to their respective region.

4. The two conference champions from each pro league then promote to the PL.


Seems simple. No one loses their regional affiliation and the top teams get to stay in WPL where they belong. The only downside I can see is that it does not guarantee you stay in the same conference when relegating, but at least everyone gets to stay in the same region.


Best way to do it if you want to ensure equal league representation.


True. But it doesn't really make the "best of the best" league at all. It's more of just a "close to the best" league when some regions are weaker than others.


These things will even out.

Think "long term"


I am thinking long term. There is really nothing that is going to force or encourage better teams into those weaker regions using this plan (unless you think teams will suddenly gravitate to the weaker regions because of the World League). The weaker regions will perpetually be getting promoted up and getting beat down.
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by the man of doom
Originally posted by the man of doom

Originally posted by the man of doom


comment on lol soccer idea Bort






 
kwankwan
offline
Link
 
Shut up doom...
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by beenlurken
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by The Lurker
Originally posted by lukin83


1. You initially promote the top 4 from each region's pro league.

2. You divide the WL into divisions based on region (APL, USAPL, CPL, EEPL, WEPL, OPL, SAPL, and SEAPL) and set it up similar to the NFL playoffs (division winners and 4 wild cards get in from each conference).

3. The bottom 2 teams in each division after the first season relegate back to their respective region.

4. The two conference champions from each pro league then promote to the PL.


Seems simple. No one loses their regional affiliation and the top teams get to stay in WPL where they belong. The only downside I can see is that it does not guarantee you stay in the same conference when relegating, but at least everyone gets to stay in the same region.


Best way to do it if you want to ensure equal league representation.


True. But it doesn't really make the "best of the best" league at all. It's more of just a "close to the best" league when some regions are weaker than others.


You guys continue to fail at seeing the longterm picture... sure, some regions (like USA) are stronger now but if you look 5,6,7 seasons down the line once the regions start to even out this should not be a problem. There will not be a perfect solution for the short term. The above solution is the best one with that takes the future into account (assuming that we with the addition of the WPL that all the regions will equal out).


Not failing to see long term, simply disagreeing that putting a cap on the number of teams from one region and making teams only compete with a couple of their regional brothers to remain in the WL is better than a more open format that allows the best teams to stay, the weaker teams to drop, and to eventually have the best in the game reside in this league. Doesn't get more long-term than that IMO. Why limit it and artificially shape the league when - if left to sort out on the dotball field - the best teams will gravitate to the WL and live in it until they can no longer compete, regardless of what region they came from.
 
ICRockets
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by tautology

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by The Lurker



Originally posted by lukin83




1. You initially promote the top 4 from each region's pro league.

2. You divide the WL into divisions based on region (APL, USAPL, CPL, EEPL, WEPL, OPL, SAPL, and SEAPL) and set it up similar to the NFL playoffs (division winners and 4 wild cards get in from each conference).

3. The bottom 2 teams in each division after the first season relegate back to their respective region.

4. The two conference champions from each pro league then promote to the PL.


Seems simple. No one loses their regional affiliation and the top teams get to stay in WPL where they belong. The only downside I can see is that it does not guarantee you stay in the same conference when relegating, but at least everyone gets to stay in the same region.


Best way to do it if you want to ensure equal league representation.


True. But it doesn't really make the "best of the best" league at all. It's more of just a "close to the best" league when some regions are weaker than others.


These things will even out.

Think "long term"


I am thinking long term. There is really nothing that is going to force or encourage better teams into those weaker regions using this plan (unless you think teams will suddenly gravitate to the weaker regions because of the World League). The weaker regions will perpetually be getting promoted up and getting beat down.


I was about to post the same thing. I don't get where anything evens out when teams are always going back to the same region like this.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by Bort

I posted the issue earlier in the thread. I like the idea in theory, but there is that risk of mass demotion to one region and extra teams getting demoted from spots as high as 8th place.


Bort, look at it this way. For every team that a region has extra in the WL, that is one extra AAA team that was called up the Pro league.

IF there is a mass demotion, that's simply sending those extra AAA teams back down. Think of all the extra recruiting and media revenue they were able to receive while they were in the Pro league instead of AAA?


ITT: Spin zone

Can I post this when the bitch threads show up of "why did I get demoted when I finished 9th place!?"
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kwankwan
Shut up doom...


u dont like lol soccer

the system that works IRL?
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by beenlurken
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by The Lurker


Originally posted by lukin83



1. You initially promote the top 4 from each region's pro league.

2. You divide the WL into divisions based on region (APL, USAPL, CPL, EEPL, WEPL, OPL, SAPL, and SEAPL) and set it up similar to the NFL playoffs (division winners and 4 wild cards get in from each conference).

3. The bottom 2 teams in each division after the first season relegate back to their respective region.

4. The two conference champions from each pro league then promote to the PL.


Seems simple. No one loses their regional affiliation and the top teams get to stay in WPL where they belong. The only downside I can see is that it does not guarantee you stay in the same conference when relegating, but at least everyone gets to stay in the same region.


Best way to do it if you want to ensure equal league representation.


True. But it doesn't really make the "best of the best" league at all. It's more of just a "close to the best" league when some regions are weaker than others.


You guys continue to fail at seeing the longterm picture... sure, some regions (like USA) are stronger now but if you look 5,6,7 seasons down the line once the regions start to even out this should not be a problem. There will not be a perfect solution for the short term. The above solution is the best one that takes the future into account (assuming that with the addition of the WPL that all the regions will eventually equal out).


Exactly! Give this a few seasons and I think we will see that the regions below the WL will start to even out. With USAPL being the coveted league right now, there is a log jam of good teams in USA AAA and USA AA. If the WL is the new coveted league and OPL gets just as much of a shot of berthing the future WL champ as USAPL (1 in 4 chance), OPL suddenly is more appealing that it once was. As a result, recruiting becomes easier for OPL owners and parity occurs.


Think long term.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by tautology

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by The Lurker



Originally posted by lukin83




1. You initially promote the top 4 from each region's pro league.

2. You divide the WL into divisions based on region (APL, USAPL, CPL, EEPL, WEPL, OPL, SAPL, and SEAPL) and set it up similar to the NFL playoffs (division winners and 4 wild cards get in from each conference).

3. The bottom 2 teams in each division after the first season relegate back to their respective region.

4. The two conference champions from each pro league then promote to the PL.


Seems simple. No one loses their regional affiliation and the top teams get to stay in WPL where they belong. The only downside I can see is that it does not guarantee you stay in the same conference when relegating, but at least everyone gets to stay in the same region.


Best way to do it if you want to ensure equal league representation.


True. But it doesn't really make the "best of the best" league at all. It's more of just a "close to the best" league when some regions are weaker than others.


These things will even out.

Think "long term"


I am thinking long term. There is really nothing that is going to force or encourage better teams into those weaker regions using this plan (unless you think teams will suddenly gravitate to the weaker regions because of the World League). The weaker regions will perpetually be getting promoted up and getting beat down.


I think teams will gravitate to the path of least resistance.
 
Gott
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by tautology

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by The Lurker
Best way to do it if you want to ensure equal league representation.


True. But it doesn't really make the "best of the best" league at all. It's more of just a "close to the best" league when some regions are weaker than others.


These things will even out.

Think "long term"


I am thinking long term. There is really nothing that is going to force or encourage better teams into those weaker regions using this plan (unless you think teams will suddenly gravitate to the weaker regions because of the World League). The weaker regions will perpetually be getting promoted up and getting beat down.


Which is why I say get rid of regions altogether. One large pyramid is the way to go.
 
Knightman
offline
Link
 
The question is whether guaranteeing 4 teams from each league will encourage players to move to the weaker leagues because they think they'll have a better shot at making it to the World League. On the one hand, I can see that happening since a league with everyone averaging L65 is likely going to be tougher than a league with everyone averaging L62. A L64 player might prefer to go to the weaker league thinking he might be able to win a Championship and promote to WPL.

OTOH, once you get there, you could just be fighting for a divisional title as all teams from a weak league may be outmanned. Will teams feel the rush of victory when they win a division title if they win with a 5-11 record over three opponents who are 0-16, 2-14, and 3-13? My guess is they'll just jump ship and sign on with another WPL team from another region, thus perpetuating the lack of talent in the weaker region when the team gets relegated back to its Pro League.

OTOH, I'm just speculating, and it's still one of the better options that I've seen in the thread so far. Of course, I like mine better, but that's just me
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.