Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by kurieg
Originally posted by jdbolick
I refused to go into academia because I get tired and frustrated whenever students don't understand a point but think they do. *sigh*
When Bort makes a change specifically to one type of player or an ability featured by one type, and he then goes on to believe that his change was too powerful or had consequences that he didn't intend, then fixing that change is not a nerf. On the other hand, it's most certainly a nerf when Bort decides that he doesn't like DEs getting 60+ sacks in a season and reducing the effectiveness of the position in order to prevent that. S7's powerback tackle breaking was a result of a change Bort had made. Scaling back that change was not a nerf. Bort looking at elusives putting up massive stats and deciding that the game is unbalanced was a nerf. This shouldn't be that hard to differentiate.
Irony imo. All of those things were nerfs. Anytime the playerbase has been allowed to build their players and change their AIs and make widespread use out of a game mechanic, reducing the effectiveness of that game mechanic is a nerf. For goddamn sure reducing the effectiveness of DEs that spent seasons languishing under the nerf of seasons ago is going to be called a nerf, regardless of our little semantic debate.
The question is whether this mechanic needs to be nerfed.
Just declare what your formal definition of a nerf is IMO, so we know where we all stand.
I'll give you mine. It is intentionally decreasing the effectiveness of one position, rendering the majority impotent, to bring the elite to a more realistic level. That is the story of the DE in season 7-9.
Originally posted by kurieg
Originally posted by jdbolick
I refused to go into academia because I get tired and frustrated whenever students don't understand a point but think they do. *sigh*
When Bort makes a change specifically to one type of player or an ability featured by one type, and he then goes on to believe that his change was too powerful or had consequences that he didn't intend, then fixing that change is not a nerf. On the other hand, it's most certainly a nerf when Bort decides that he doesn't like DEs getting 60+ sacks in a season and reducing the effectiveness of the position in order to prevent that. S7's powerback tackle breaking was a result of a change Bort had made. Scaling back that change was not a nerf. Bort looking at elusives putting up massive stats and deciding that the game is unbalanced was a nerf. This shouldn't be that hard to differentiate.
Irony imo. All of those things were nerfs. Anytime the playerbase has been allowed to build their players and change their AIs and make widespread use out of a game mechanic, reducing the effectiveness of that game mechanic is a nerf. For goddamn sure reducing the effectiveness of DEs that spent seasons languishing under the nerf of seasons ago is going to be called a nerf, regardless of our little semantic debate.
The question is whether this mechanic needs to be nerfed.
Just declare what your formal definition of a nerf is IMO, so we know where we all stand.
I'll give you mine. It is intentionally decreasing the effectiveness of one position, rendering the majority impotent, to bring the elite to a more realistic level. That is the story of the DE in season 7-9.






























