User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > The time has come to remove the Click and Drag of the Defensive Line in the DPC
Page:
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by kurieg

Originally posted by jdbolick


I refused to go into academia because I get tired and frustrated whenever students don't understand a point but think they do. *sigh*

When Bort makes a change specifically to one type of player or an ability featured by one type, and he then goes on to believe that his change was too powerful or had consequences that he didn't intend, then fixing that change is not a nerf. On the other hand, it's most certainly a nerf when Bort decides that he doesn't like DEs getting 60+ sacks in a season and reducing the effectiveness of the position in order to prevent that. S7's powerback tackle breaking was a result of a change Bort had made. Scaling back that change was not a nerf. Bort looking at elusives putting up massive stats and deciding that the game is unbalanced was a nerf. This shouldn't be that hard to differentiate.


Irony imo. All of those things were nerfs. Anytime the playerbase has been allowed to build their players and change their AIs and make widespread use out of a game mechanic, reducing the effectiveness of that game mechanic is a nerf. For goddamn sure reducing the effectiveness of DEs that spent seasons languishing under the nerf of seasons ago is going to be called a nerf, regardless of our little semantic debate.

The question is whether this mechanic needs to be nerfed.


Just declare what your formal definition of a nerf is IMO, so we know where we all stand.


I'll give you mine. It is intentionally decreasing the effectiveness of one position, rendering the majority impotent, to bring the elite to a more realistic level. That is the story of the DE in season 7-9.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tdm13
The O-Line AI doesn't need to be updated! Let me explain:

No, the O-line AI unquestionably needs improvement. Keeping blockers retarded isn't an appropriate response to them being overpowered when making blocks, if they are still overpowered at all. You want them behaving realistically, then make adjustments to whatever might still be out of balance. O-linemen definitely need a re-working of how they assess threats and pick which defender to engage.


Originally posted by kurieg
Irony imo.

Well of course you would think so. No one else does, however. And again, this didn't suddenly come into being because people built their players better or designed their AI better. I did all this crap with the DPC last year and while it had its use, it wasn't nearly this effective. Bort made a change and he believes that the change went too far. Scaling that back is unquestionably not a nerf, so just stop arguing with me about that. You can call it a "borf" or "berf" on your own time, for all I care, but stop trying to convince anyone else that it's a nerf. It's not.
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Well of course you would think so. No one else does, however. And again, this didn't suddenly come into being because people built their players better or designed their AI better. I did all this crap with the DPC last year and while it had its use, it wasn't nearly this effective. Bort made a change and he believes that the change went too far. Scaling that back is unquestionably not a nerf, so just stop arguing with me about that. You can call it a "borf" or "berf" on your own time, for all I care, but stop trying to convince anyone else that it's a nerf. It's not.


OMG. The everyone thinks the way I do arguement.

Scaling any game mechanic back is the definition of a nerf.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Scaling any game mechanic back is the definition of a nerf.

No, it's not. If that's how you want to define a nerf, you can, just like some mental patient can use the word antidisestablishmentarianism to mean "hungry," but that's not what nerf or antidisestablishmentarianism mean.
 
tdm13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by tdm13

The O-Line AI doesn't need to be updated! Let me explain:

No, the O-line AI unquestionably needs improvement. Keeping blockers retarded isn't an appropriate response to them being overpowered when making blocks, if they are still overpowered at all. You want them behaving realistically, then make adjustments to whatever might still be out of balance. O-linemen definitely need a re-working of how they assess threats and pick which defender to engage.




QUOTE MY WHOLE POST AND DON'T TAKE THINGS OUT OF CONTEXT!

Originally posted by tdm13

The O-Line AI doesn't need to be updated! Let me explain:

Let's put a number on the O and D line AIs before this season's updates. Let's say that, when compared, the O-Line AI was an 8 and the D-Line was a 4. The O-Line won nearly every engagement, no matter what the build.

Now, after the changes, both numbers are at 8. Interaction is where it should be. You're saying the O-Line AI needs a buff? That would bring it to a 10, when the D-Line is at an 8. So O-Line wins more engagements again, despite poor builds (Etc).


And this comparison can be slapped on offense vs defense as well. Despite all the complaining of the offense being limited, there's still not any way for defenses to designate specific plays for specific packages the offense sends out. The offense can still move the chains at will and they are still overpowered. There should be no buffs to either line. Let this "bug" sit and wait until bigger problems are fixed (NERF THE OFFENSE).



Read the analogy and then reply. Don't cut off most of my thought and then spin it how you want.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Originally posted by fallingmercury

It's related, but not directly what this thread is about. It's another example of the defensive formations confusing the hell out of the neanderthal O-line AI though. The DPC is kinda half-baked.


You realize those kinds of blitzes are often picked up, right?


Wrong.

When lining up the players in the way I pointed out and using quality players, the DT goes free ALL the time. It's not 50% or something, but 100%.

The only question is, if the DT misses the tackle.

So where's your "fix the builds" point? I must have somehow missed it.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tdm13
Read the analogy and then reply. Don't cut off most of my thought and then spin it how you want.

I cut off all but the most relevant portion because I've been on the internet longer than the last week, and I realize how unnecessary and annoying it is for threads to get cluttered by quotes of entire posts. Moreover, I addressed your entire post when I said: "You want them behaving realistically, then make adjustments to whatever might still be out of balance." You're saying that we should leave O-linemen stupid because you believe that's the only way D-linemen can currently make an impact, while I'm saying that two wrongs don't make a right. The blocking assignments for offensive linemen obviously need to be corrected, and then if they're too powerful with the blocks they make after fixing how they choose their assignments, then we can deal with that. But leaving them stupid just because that's one way to get sacks is not an acceptable proposal.
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by kurieg

Scaling any game mechanic back is the definition of a nerf.

No, it's not. If that's how you want to define a nerf, you can, just like some mental patient can use the word antidisestablishmentarianism to mean "hungry," but that's not what nerf or antidisestablishmentarianism mean.


Best result - http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=nerf "To make worse or weaken, usually in the context of weakening something in order to balance out a game. "

I.e., to scale back a game mechanic.

"nerf" (v, trans) the action of developers reducing the strength of an in-game asset where the asset is too powerful and unbalances other parts of the game. Arose when swords in UO were rebalanced and the characters felt they were hitting each other with nerf swords"

I.e., to scale back a game mechanic.


Please provide your definition. Be sure to include another retarded analogy while you're at it.
 
tdm13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by tdm13

Read the analogy and then reply. Don't cut off most of my thought and then spin it how you want.

I cut off all but the most relevant portion because I've been on the internet longer than the last week, and I realize how unnecessary and annoying it is for threads to get cluttered by quotes of entire posts. Moreover, I addressed your entire post when I said: "You want them behaving realistically, then make adjustments to whatever might still be out of balance." You're saying that we should leave O-linemen stupid because you believe that's the only way D-linemen can currently make an impact, while I'm saying that two wrongs don't make a right. The blocking assignments for offensive linemen obviously need to be corrected, and then if they're too powerful with the blocks they make after fixing how they choose their assignments, then we can deal with that. But leaving them stupid just because that's one way to get sacks is not an acceptable proposal.


It is if it's the only defensive pressure being put on a quarterback that coordinates an offense vastly overpowered to the defense. I am in full agreeance that this needs to be fixed, but only in conjunction with a huge nerf to the offense to actually make defense gameplanning fun. Being a DC right now consists of gameplanning an entire season's worth of data and then praying that the AI cooperates with you. Two wrongs don't make a right, but re-nerfing a D-Line that just went through 3 seasons of nerfs is quite unnecessarily and will lead to anarchy on these boards. Fix both problems in the offseason and make S11 the year of balanced defense and offense.
 
FBGProfessor
offline
Link
 
Right now there is definitely an exploit where teams stack the outside edge and Centers and sometimes Guards just sit there looking stupid. If the OL has enough vision, they should see these shifts and move to adjust. No Center walking to the line of scrimmage and seeing no one in front of him and scads of people on the edge would just hike the ball and stand still in the middle of the field. He would move to the overloaded side. The smart and the quicker and the better his vision, the better he would adjust.

If the defense has enough speed and agility they should succeed sometimes this way. But right now it is an exploit because it is overloaded.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Best result - http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=nerf "To make worse or weaken, usually in the context of weakening something in order to balance out a game. "

I.e., to scale back a game mechanic.

"nerf" (v, trans) the action of developers reducing the strength of an in-game asset where the asset is too powerful and unbalances other parts of the game. Arose when swords in UO were rebalanced and the characters felt they were hitting each other with nerf swords"

I.e., to scale back a game mechanic.

Please provide your definition. Be sure to include another retarded analogy while you're at it.

Jesus fucking Christ. Are you kidding me? You're wasting my time with this stupidity. If you can get more than two brain cells to function at the same time, compare what you just posted with what I said here:

Originally posted by jdbolick
Just because you insist on using a certain word doesn't mean that you're using it properly. And no, fixing something Bort created but didn't intend would not be a nerf. DEs got nerfed after S6 when Bort decided that they were too dominant. Not that something he did made them too dominant, but they were too dominant in general. Elusives also got nerfed because Bort felt like there were too many outside runs going the distance. Not that something he did made them too effective and needed to be corrected, but that they were working too well and put the game out of balance. Those things are "nerfs."


I have been exceedingly patient with you, but that's over. You have exhausted my good will and I am fed up with your belligerent ignorance. Do yourself a huge favor and shut the fuck up before you make this any worse.
 
Nitschke
offline
Link
 
no way...Leave the shifts in. We run a 3-3 stack on my teams defense and we can not do that if you take away the ability to shift the d line.
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
I haven't read all of this, but are people actually in support of dline teleporting and zipping through gaps because bort's blocking code is too simple? Stats are cool, but not when a large amount of sacks look plain silly.

I think not allowing line shifts is the easiest way to fix the teleporting problem but won't get to the heart of the matter. Kind of like trying to lessen juke ticks to slow down really unrealistic juke forcefield plays when really the whole manner of HB pathing, defensive pathing, angles and mechanics could use some work. I'd love to see the Oline/dline interaction get fixed but bort usually likes the quick easy fixes
Edited by chronoaug on Jul 17, 2009 14:12:53
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tdm13
It is if it's the only defensive pressure being put on a quarterback that coordinates an offense vastly overpowered to the defense.

No, it still wouldn't be true because O-line stupidity is not an appropriate means of addressing overpowered blocking. The appropriate fix would be to address the overpowered blocking, which Bort did as well. As others have noted, this flaw in the sim is far from the only way to get pressure on the QB, it's just one of the easiest. My own team was already having a lot of success getting sacks without this, and we'll presumably continue to do so if the speed boost or blocking angle are addressed to fix this particular problem.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Originally posted by jdbolick

Originally posted by kurieg


Scaling any game mechanic back is the definition of a nerf.

No, it's not. If that's how you want to define a nerf, you can, just like some mental patient can use the word antidisestablishmentarianism to mean "hungry," but that's not what nerf or antidisestablishmentarianism mean.


Best result - http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=nerf "To make worse or weaken, usually in the context of weakening something in order to balance out a game. "

I.e., to scale back a game mechanic.

"nerf" (v, trans) the action of developers reducing the strength of an in-game asset where the asset is too powerful and unbalances other parts of the game. Arose when swords in UO were rebalanced and the characters felt they were hitting each other with nerf swords"

I.e., to scale back a game mechanic.


Please provide your definition. Be sure to include another retarded analogy while you're at it.


So basically: everything that makes anything working even a bit less than it was before is a nerf.

That leaves "fix" for only 2 options:
- changing something - but without making anything work a bit less
- making something more powerful

Even if a certain VA combination would make a HB teleports to the endzone, by definition correcting that would be a nerf (making it less powerful). Most would consider that a fix though.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.