User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdros13
It doesn't work over and over again though against good teams. It did work once in a game against you guys earlier this season though. Of course it looks to me like Corn Head had a hell of a time getting past the blockers, but he did get past for the sack. DE's are allowed to win occasionally though.


Honestly, the replays you posted aren't nearly as bad as the ones posted by the original. At least in those two plays it looks like the OT in one of them got a swim move put on him (as he drifts under the LG) and in the other it looks like he got stunned. Which at least says he had a chance to make a play.
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lolMurp
In my opinion, this looks to be more of a fuckup on o-line code than an exploit.

Right now, the entire blocking scheme on any offensive play is either zone pass or zone run, as there's no way to set man assignments. It works, but at the time where an o-lineman doesn't detect a player in their zone to pick up and block against, they don't pay attention to that, which appears to be what's happening here. To the o-line the DE doesn't exist. Slow-motion it and you'll see the ball isn't in the QB's hands and the DE is south of the point of attack. People can say it's builds, for now, because it's an isolated incident. I'll try it with one of my teams today (not trying to take advantage!) and see if it's a problem, even though no one ever fucking passes in pee-wee. ):


Murp....

An 'Exploit' is just what you described. An unintentional result from a coding error. Since O-Line Blocking AI was created BEFORE the DPC was created and they were coded to react to the old 'standard' D plays and did so well, when the DPC came along and people experimented and found they could force the O-Line AI/Logic to do silly things.

Using that to your advantage is 'Exploiting' the bad code.

So the O-Line Blocking AI needs a looking into and behaviour that is more in line with the way Defensses can line up now, as opposed to when defenses had very limited placements.
 
headsigh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Originally posted by lolMurp

In my opinion, this looks to be more of a fuckup on o-line code than an exploit.

Right now, the entire blocking scheme on any offensive play is either zone pass or zone run, as there's no way to set man assignments. It works, but at the time where an o-lineman doesn't detect a player in their zone to pick up and block against, which appears to be what's happening here. To the o-line the DE doesn't exist. Slow-motion it and you'll see the ball isn't in the QB's hands and the DE is south of the point of attack. People can say it's builds, for now, because it's an isolated incident. I'll try it with one of my teams today (not trying to take advantage!) and see if it's a problem, even though no one ever fucking passes in pee-wee. ):


That is why it should be tested. If certain builds can consistently stop it, then it is a build problem.


indeed. I mean, that game seems to have something of a cupcake game, but it's hard to tell if that's because of the possible glitch or not. That DE had 6 levels on the closest one opponent.

Needs more cases.
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by jdros13

It doesn't work over and over again though against good teams. It did work once in a game against you guys earlier this season though. Of course it looks to me like Corn Head had a hell of a time getting past the blockers, but he did get past for the sack. DE's are allowed to win occasionally though.


Honestly, the replays you posted aren't nearly as bad as the ones posted by the original. At least in those two plays it looks like the OT in one of them got a swim move put on him (as he drifts under the LG) and in the other it looks like he got stunned. Which at least says he had a chance to make a play.


That's because your OLine is actually good.

These 2 are basically the same play as well

one I posted: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587010&pbp_id=6898523

First example in the OP: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=590111&pbp_id=12174450

4 man line, pinched, no one else blitzing. It's the same thing but looks different on the interaction.
Edited by jdros13 on Jul 15, 2009 11:44:17
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdros13
That's because your OLine is actually good.


It shouldn't take the best OL in GLB to stop this.
 
PsychoWard
plop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Originally posted by lolMurp

In my opinion, this looks to be more of a fuckup on o-line code than an exploit.

Right now, the entire blocking scheme on any offensive play is either zone pass or zone run, as there's no way to set man assignments. It works, but at the time where an o-lineman doesn't detect a player in their zone to pick up and block against, which appears to be what's happening here. To the o-line the DE doesn't exist. Slow-motion it and you'll see the ball isn't in the QB's hands and the DE is south of the point of attack. People can say it's builds, for now, because it's an isolated incident. I'll try it with one of my teams today (not trying to take advantage!) and see if it's a problem, even though no one ever fucking passes in pee-wee. ):


That is why it should be tested. If certain builds can consistently stop it, then it is a build problem.


exactly, but you know it wont be tested and DE will get nerfed once again. thats how this game goes.

 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Enkidu98
Originally posted by lolMurp

In my opinion, this looks to be more of a fuckup on o-line code than an exploit.

Right now, the entire blocking scheme on any offensive play is either zone pass or zone run, as there's no way to set man assignments. It works, but at the time where an o-lineman doesn't detect a player in their zone to pick up and block against, they don't pay attention to that, which appears to be what's happening here. To the o-line the DE doesn't exist. Slow-motion it and you'll see the ball isn't in the QB's hands and the DE is south of the point of attack. People can say it's builds, for now, because it's an isolated incident. I'll try it with one of my teams today (not trying to take advantage!) and see if it's a problem, even though no one ever fucking passes in pee-wee. ):


Murp....

An 'Exploit' is just what you described. An unintentional result from a coding error. Since O-Line Blocking AI was created BEFORE the DPC was created and they were coded to react to the old 'standard' D plays and did so well, when the DPC came along and people experimented and found they could force the O-Line AI/Logic to do silly things.

Using that to your advantage is 'Exploiting' the bad code.

So the O-Line Blocking AI needs a looking into and behaviour that is more in line with the way Defensses can line up now, as opposed to when defenses had very limited placements.


However, I think this is more of a matter of SAs firing and OL not having enough speed/agility to react fast enough and get into position.

Testing would show if that was the case or not.

I still think the FS boost should be toned down, but I'm not discounting lack of agility/speed in the OL as being part of the problem.



 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by jdros13

That's because your OLine is actually good.


It shouldn't take the best OL in GLB to stop this.


Great defensive dots should also win individual matchups sometimes, even against great OLines.
 
headsigh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mikeandbrooke07
Originally posted by Rage Kinard

Originally posted by lolMurp


In my opinion, this looks to be more of a fuckup on o-line code than an exploit.

Right now, the entire blocking scheme on any offensive play is either zone pass or zone run, as there's no way to set man assignments. It works, but at the time where an o-lineman doesn't detect a player in their zone to pick up and block against, which appears to be what's happening here. To the o-line the DE doesn't exist. Slow-motion it and you'll see the ball isn't in the QB's hands and the DE is south of the point of attack. People can say it's builds, for now, because it's an isolated incident. I'll try it with one of my teams today (not trying to take advantage!) and see if it's a problem, even though no one ever fucking passes in pee-wee. ):


That is why it should be tested. If certain builds can consistently stop it, then it is a build problem.


exactly, but you know it wont be tested and DE will get nerfed once again. thats how this game goes.



Too many bandaids on the game as it is. I very much hope every angle of this issue is analyzed (blocking AI, testing, point of attack AI), but the realistic result is probably a tone down to the jump off the LOS.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by jdros13

That's because your OLine is actually good.


It shouldn't take the best OL in GLB to stop this.


It should take the best OL to stop the best DEs from being successfull a few times a game.

 
Kevin Smith
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by csull36
Not a bug. Guards have been built to run block for the most part, not block an agile DE like OTs have.


Those same OGs have to block DTs with WAY more agility than tpatīs DE. DTs donīt do that.
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kevin Smith
Originally posted by csull36

Not a bug. Guards have been built to run block for the most part, not block an agile DE like OTs have.


Those same OGs have to block DTs with WAY more agility than tpatīs DE. DTs donīt do that.


First Step is a huge part of this (at least imo). DT's don't have first step. Speed is also usually higher on DE's which allows first step to be even more devastating.
 
PsychoWard
plop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdros13
Originally posted by Kevin Smith

Originally posted by csull36


Not a bug. Guards have been built to run block for the most part, not block an agile DE like OTs have.


Those same OGs have to block DTs with WAY more agility than tpatīs DE. DTs donīt do that.


First Step is a huge part of this (at least imo). DT's don't have first step. Speed is also usually higher on DE's which allows first step to be even more devastating.


maybe jump the snap as well?
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mikeandbrooke07
Originally posted by jdros13

Originally posted by Kevin Smith


Originally posted by csull36



Not a bug. Guards have been built to run block for the most part, not block an agile DE like OTs have.


Those same OGs have to block DTs with WAY more agility than tpatīs DE. DTs donīt do that.


First Step is a huge part of this (at least imo). DT's don't have first step. Speed is also usually higher on DE's which allows first step to be even more devastating.


maybe jump the snap as well?


Bort's said JTS is useless once you start getting close to 60 vision (since it's a bonus to passing a somewhat easy vision check, no extra movement). The DE in the OP doesn't have JTS, but has 50 vision, which passes most checks, along with 9 first step.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kevin Smith
Originally posted by csull36

Not a bug. Guards have been built to run block for the most part, not block an agile DE like OTs have.


Those same OGs have to block DTs with WAY more agility than tpatīs DE. DTs donīt do that.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=601751&pbp_id=9076883
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=601751&pbp_id=9076937
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=601751&pbp_id=9076976

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=601790&pbp_id=13497146
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=601790&pbp_id=13497196

The first one is mine and has FS. I bet the second does as well.

The FS buff made it overpowered. Good builds can still stop it though.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.