User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > NERF THE FUMBLES NOW!!!
Page:
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
[What does Carrying do for an Elusive back? It ONLY helps them not fumble. It's not an even attribute. Elusive backs aren't going to be breaking tackles with just Carrying, with not much Strength, nor Power SAs.


You are wrong there. Elusive SA's are improved by decent carrying and vison as well. Carrying helps you do just about everything related to carrying the ball. It's "how well do you move with the ball."
 
maizenhops
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Bukowski

What does Carrying do for an Elusive back? It ONLY helps them not fumble.


And speed ONLY helps a power back move down the field.


Actually Carrying helps break tackles and helps the runner run more smooth, i believe.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Mufasa92
don't nerf the fumbles, its our only defense against over powered HBs.


overpowered HBs? If the HBs are overpowered, then why do you need to worry about defending them? I think you need to learn the definitions of words before you type them.

Edit: I only made 2 threads about it. One about the actual game (this one), and the other to let everyone know that they can just set their defenders to power tackler and force fumbles over and over.
Last edited Apr 26, 2009 16:33:24
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
Just like Elusive Backs.

Speed and Agility do the same thing for Power Backs, as they do for Elusive Backs.

It's Carrying that is an uneven attribute, rewarding Power Backs, while punishing Elusive Backs.


Powerbacks lacking speed doesn't punish them?

You are acting like Powerbacks only need strength and carrying, and elusives only need speed and agility, and forcing the other one to invest in the other two attributes is blasphemy.

Powerbacks DO have to invest into speed, and if they do not, it negatively impacts them.
Elusive Backs DO have to invest in carrying, if they do not, it negatively impacts them.
Last edited Apr 26, 2009 16:30:01
 
maizenhops
offline
Link
 
Beat me by 2 seconds Bort!
 
tuba_samurai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski

What does Carrying do for an Elusive back? It ONLY helps them not fumble.



It's like saying seatbelts only help you if you crash. You get hit by a truck and no seatbelt...bye bye
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Bukowski

[What does Carrying do for an Elusive back? It ONLY helps them not fumble. It's not an even attribute. Elusive backs aren't going to be breaking tackles with just Carrying, with not much Strength, nor Power SAs.


You are wrong there. Elusive SA's are improved by decent carrying and vison as well. Carrying helps you do just about everything related to carrying the ball. It's "how well do you move with the ball."


Well that would be a secret that only you would know, right

I mean, how am I supposed to know that?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks
Originally posted by BartRock

If every team isn't having this problem, there is no problem with the sim.

/thread.


Wait until every defender in GLB gets 15 points in Power Tackling and 15 in sure tackling, and set their tactics to force fumbles. This is just the beginning. This could very well turn into a pandemic. Why not stop it before it spreads? Once again, we're not talking about eliminating fumbles completely, just trying to make them more realistic.


no more VA resets is the answer, if we keep nerfing VA's and then giving more resets before long every flipping VA is going to be utter crap.

Its the fault of the reset if anything and I hate playing what if's. What if a bullfrog had wings he wouldnt bump his ass!
 
Luzod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Lord Thomas Drake

I don't understand how one game or a few guys fumbling like mad means we need change. I have seen alot of elusive backs this season with 45-50 carrying not fumbling at all, so just because some of your backs suck ass and can't hold onto the ball don't mean we need change.


I agree.

One guy had a game with 14 fumbles, made 3-4 threads about it, and the forums went crazy.


It all started with PierreThomas and his 40 carrying returner fumbling 7 times in USA Pro.

Funny, because his returner had 40 carrying and had hell a lot of plays, so he was with low energy AND morale against a fresh team.

As for the 15 fumbles HB, he has 180 plays in the game. Hell, if one HB had 180 plays in a game irl, he'd be in a funerary now.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by JcWildcat
Originally posted by GeneralMakaveli 3.0

Originally posted by JCJayhawk


Originally posted by Bort



Originally posted by Gyuri1




Originally posted by Deathblade





Anyway...I would much prefer making a viable "hold onto the ball" VA. Maybe even give it a downside to encourage high carrying builds rather than the VA. Like +3% chance to not fumble, -1% chance to gain extra yardage during the tackle?


That's a good idea. Although I like the idea of a cover up <----------------------------------> break tackle slider as well.


What if there was a tactic or something the player's AI that would make it move more and more towards cover up for each fumble you had? Perhaps cover up would slow you down a little when defenders are near, as well, since you'd be bracing for impact and not running all out. There needs to be a downside to it, so there is risk/reward.


Please just leave it the way it is. Let those that need to put more points into carrying and strength do so. This is not a problem for those that have built correctly


You dont understand players with 60 STR and 60 CAR are fumbling a lot.


Yeah and at level 50+ that 60 STR and 60 CAR isn't squat compared to guys w/100 strength and 60+ tackling.


So are you saying I should ignore every attribute but STR and CAR? Should I have 100 STR and and 100 CAR?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Bukowski

[What does Carrying do for an Elusive back? It ONLY helps them not fumble. It's not an even attribute. Elusive backs aren't going to be breaking tackles with just Carrying, with not much Strength, nor Power SAs.


You are wrong there. Elusive SA's are improved by decent carrying and vison as well. Carrying helps you do just about everything related to carrying the ball. It's "how well do you move with the ball."


Bort off topic but I need to get my account back ASAP >_< My RB doesnt have a team and need to get him a home before he misses a game.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Bukowski


[What does Carrying do for an Elusive back? It ONLY helps them not fumble. It's not an even attribute. Elusive backs aren't going to be breaking tackles with just Carrying, with not much Strength, nor Power SAs.


You are wrong there. Elusive SA's are improved by decent carrying and vison as well. Carrying helps you do just about everything related to carrying the ball. It's "how well do you move with the ball."


Well that would be a secret that only you would know, right

I mean, how am I supposed to know that?


From the ages old build guide:

"Carrying - Don't want to fumble the ball? You better practice your holding ability. The better your Carrying skill, the less you will lose the ball from a good hit. Carrying will also help you make moves to avoid or break tackles."
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Bukowski

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Bukowski



[What does Carrying do for an Elusive back? It ONLY helps them not fumble. It's not an even attribute. Elusive backs aren't going to be breaking tackles with just Carrying, with not much Strength, nor Power SAs.


You are wrong there. Elusive SA's are improved by decent carrying and vison as well. Carrying helps you do just about everything related to carrying the ball. It's "how well do you move with the ball."


Well that would be a secret that only you would know, right

I mean, how am I supposed to know that?


From the ages old build guide:

"Carrying - Don't want to fumble the ball? You better practice your holding ability. The better your Carrying skill, the less you will lose the ball from a good hit. Carrying will also help you make moves to avoid or break tackles."


DD wrote that.. I've never heard that from you.

There were a lot of old things written in those guides, that ended up being not true.

The Vision thing wasn't in there either.
Last edited Apr 26, 2009 16:32:44
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Luzod
Originally posted by Deathblade

Originally posted by Lord Thomas Drake


I don't understand how one game or a few guys fumbling like mad means we need change. I have seen alot of elusive backs this season with 45-50 carrying not fumbling at all, so just because some of your backs suck ass and can't hold onto the ball don't mean we need change.


I agree.

One guy had a game with 14 fumbles, made 3-4 threads about it, and the forums went crazy.


It all started with PierreThomas and his 40 carrying returner fumbling 7 times in USA Pro.

Funny, because his returner had 40 carrying and had hell a lot of plays, so he was with low energy AND morale against a fresh team.

As for the 15 fumbles HB, he has 180 plays in the game. Hell, if one HB had 180 plays in a game irl, he'd be in a funerary now.


YOu just hit the nail on the head, people need to stop running or playing their players so much. We don't need nerfs! Really there is nothing to see in this topic or learn other then the fact that the forums have alot of whiny bitches!

One game last season I messed up my AI and ran my elusive back like 40 plus times and he played a whole lot, guess the outcome? He fumbled like 7 times as well.

Did I go to the forums and say wahhhhh My back fumbled to much no I adjusted tactics and stopped running him as much. People are so stupid its beyond belief!

 
Luzod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GeneralMakaveli 3.0
Originally posted by JcWildcat

Originally posted by GeneralMakaveli 3.0


Originally posted by JCJayhawk



Originally posted by Bort




Originally posted by Gyuri1





Originally posted by Deathblade






Anyway...I would much prefer making a viable "hold onto the ball" VA. Maybe even give it a downside to encourage high carrying builds rather than the VA. Like +3% chance to not fumble, -1% chance to gain extra yardage during the tackle?


That's a good idea. Although I like the idea of a cover up <----------------------------------> break tackle slider as well.


What if there was a tactic or something the player's AI that would make it move more and more towards cover up for each fumble you had? Perhaps cover up would slow you down a little when defenders are near, as well, since you'd be bracing for impact and not running all out. There needs to be a downside to it, so there is risk/reward.


Please just leave it the way it is. Let those that need to put more points into carrying and strength do so. This is not a problem for those that have built correctly


You dont understand players with 60 STR and 60 CAR are fumbling a lot.


Yeah and at level 50+ that 60 STR and 60 CAR isn't squat compared to guys w/100 strength and 60+ tackling.


So are you saying I should ignore every attribute but STR and CAR? Should I have 100 STR and and 100 CAR?


You are such an ignorant Makaveli.

"My player can't fumble in USA Pro because he has 60 str and 60 carrying!". I'm gonna tell you something, in my entire team, only 2 defenders has less than 65 strength and tackling and he doesn't play STs. So, cry me a river.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.