Originally posted by merenoise
Originally posted by dpride59
Here is where I see a HUGE problem. The 30-32 team in the "top uncapped" region. Like a group of guys who have been together who are the 31st highest median-d team. Think of this, the top tier of "A" unacpped has to be filled with 32 teams. so say there is 29-30 super powered level 45-50 teams. They still need to fill out that league. so who gets put into it? Those bottom 3 teams could basically be composed of teams like mantis team if they are the 29,30,31,32 best team in A. This is where I see a problem and even more complaints.
There is always going to be some disparity. It certainly exists now. This would just remove some of it. Instead of having standings that look like this:
16-0
15-1
13-3
11-5
11-5
10-6
9-7
8-8
8-8
7-9
5-11
4-12
3-13
1-15
0-16
0-16
They would look like this:
14-2
13-3
12-4
11-5
10-6
9-7
9-7
8-8
8-8
7-9
7-9
5-11
5-11
4-12
3-13
3-13
More meaningful games for the majority of teams. The teams at the bottom would at least have a chance to win a game or two. And even the teams in the cellar will be able to promote after a couple of seasons as their returning players will eventually outlevel what everyone else is able to recruit so they would be able to move up and stay competitive. Plus the playoff race will be far more exciting with big games setting the table for the home games and the bubble teams.
In both of your outcomes above, there is still the top, middle, and bottom of each league. That's why the better way to "reshuffle" is to push the bottom of these tiers to B (where gutted/cpu teams would reside). Then the middle tier push to BB, and the top stay in BBB. Arrange these leagues to have 8 teams in each conference and have them play each other twice a season.
Limit rebuilds/guts that drop to the B league to the same level of stadium as the new/cpu teams. They would get more of their stadium seating back as they advanced. (This would stop the gut/drop and then resign using funds from a full stadium, which is HUGE issue in the BBB leagues)
This would work better in conjunction with the current promotion/demotion set-up and make all of the B leagues more competitive without the need for league caps, although you could put them on the B and BB leagues anyway.
Originally posted by dpride59
Here is where I see a HUGE problem. The 30-32 team in the "top uncapped" region. Like a group of guys who have been together who are the 31st highest median-d team. Think of this, the top tier of "A" unacpped has to be filled with 32 teams. so say there is 29-30 super powered level 45-50 teams. They still need to fill out that league. so who gets put into it? Those bottom 3 teams could basically be composed of teams like mantis team if they are the 29,30,31,32 best team in A. This is where I see a problem and even more complaints.
There is always going to be some disparity. It certainly exists now. This would just remove some of it. Instead of having standings that look like this:
16-0
15-1
13-3
11-5
11-5
10-6
9-7
8-8
8-8
7-9
5-11
4-12
3-13
1-15
0-16
0-16
They would look like this:
14-2
13-3
12-4
11-5
10-6
9-7
9-7
8-8
8-8
7-9
7-9
5-11
5-11
4-12
3-13
3-13
More meaningful games for the majority of teams. The teams at the bottom would at least have a chance to win a game or two. And even the teams in the cellar will be able to promote after a couple of seasons as their returning players will eventually outlevel what everyone else is able to recruit so they would be able to move up and stay competitive. Plus the playoff race will be far more exciting with big games setting the table for the home games and the bubble teams.
In both of your outcomes above, there is still the top, middle, and bottom of each league. That's why the better way to "reshuffle" is to push the bottom of these tiers to B (where gutted/cpu teams would reside). Then the middle tier push to BB, and the top stay in BBB. Arrange these leagues to have 8 teams in each conference and have them play each other twice a season.
Limit rebuilds/guts that drop to the B league to the same level of stadium as the new/cpu teams. They would get more of their stadium seating back as they advanced. (This would stop the gut/drop and then resign using funds from a full stadium, which is HUGE issue in the BBB leagues)
This would work better in conjunction with the current promotion/demotion set-up and make all of the B leagues more competitive without the need for league caps, although you could put them on the B and BB leagues anyway.




Well at least you're honest.
























