User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > League Moving Based on Median and Max Level of Players on Team
Page:
 
Raiders12
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by merenoise
Originally posted by dpride59

Here is where I see a HUGE problem. The 30-32 team in the "top uncapped" region. Like a group of guys who have been together who are the 31st highest median-d team. Think of this, the top tier of "A" unacpped has to be filled with 32 teams. so say there is 29-30 super powered level 45-50 teams. They still need to fill out that league. so who gets put into it? Those bottom 3 teams could basically be composed of teams like mantis team if they are the 29,30,31,32 best team in A. This is where I see a problem and even more complaints.


There is always going to be some disparity. It certainly exists now. This would just remove some of it. Instead of having standings that look like this:

16-0
15-1
13-3
11-5
11-5
10-6
9-7
8-8
8-8
7-9
5-11
4-12
3-13
1-15
0-16
0-16

They would look like this:

14-2
13-3
12-4
11-5
10-6
9-7
9-7
8-8
8-8
7-9
7-9
5-11
5-11
4-12
3-13
3-13

More meaningful games for the majority of teams. The teams at the bottom would at least have a chance to win a game or two. And even the teams in the cellar will be able to promote after a couple of seasons as their returning players will eventually outlevel what everyone else is able to recruit so they would be able to move up and stay competitive. Plus the playoff race will be far more exciting with big games setting the table for the home games and the bubble teams.


In both of your outcomes above, there is still the top, middle, and bottom of each league. That's why the better way to "reshuffle" is to push the bottom of these tiers to B (where gutted/cpu teams would reside). Then the middle tier push to BB, and the top stay in BBB. Arrange these leagues to have 8 teams in each conference and have them play each other twice a season.

Limit rebuilds/guts that drop to the B league to the same level of stadium as the new/cpu teams. They would get more of their stadium seating back as they advanced. (This would stop the gut/drop and then resign using funds from a full stadium, which is HUGE issue in the BBB leagues)

This would work better in conjunction with the current promotion/demotion set-up and make all of the B leagues more competitive without the need for league caps, although you could put them on the B and BB leagues anyway.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
I think the reality with a game like this is there is a significant part of the player base that doesn't want to play in a competitive league. The live to over match a league with easy victories.

Those people are petrified of this new league restructure.
 
merenoise
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
I think the reality with a game like this is there is a significant part of the player base that doesn't want to play in a competitive league. The live to over match a league with easy victories.

Those people are petrified of this new league restructure.


I'm terrified that you are right. Goes completely against my mindset so I find it hard to come to terms with.
 
Raiders12
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
I think the reality with a game like this is there is a significant part of the player base that doesn't want to play in a competitive league. The live to over match a league with easy victories.

Those people are petrified of this new league restructure.


yes but very few of them are vocal on the threads about it.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by merenoise
Originally posted by Mightyhalo

I think the reality with a game like this is there is a significant part of the player base that doesn't want to play in a competitive league. The live to over match a league with easy victories.

Those people are petrified of this new league restructure.


I'm terrified that you are right. Goes completely against my mindset so I find it hard to come to terms with.


Well at least you're honest.
 
doug8772725
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by merenoise
Originally posted by Mightyhalo

I think the reality with a game like this is there is a significant part of the player base that doesn't want to play in a competitive league. The live to over match a league with easy victories.

Those people are petrified of this new league restructure.


I'm terrified that you are right. Goes completely against my mindset so I find it hard to come to terms with.


I want the competition, and am not scared about having to gameplan. BUT if you are in my case, there is a 50-50 probability we will get messed over on our finances. When you are in the lower tier, and have had to rebuild a gut job, you count on the big payday of home playoff games that can help build your stadium and then pay for level 32+ equip upgrades. I've suffered through 2 seasons of losing, knowing I had to wait my turn for the money. Now, if the competition is changed, when I'm on the verge of my time at the top of the financial totem pole, I stand to lose that opportunity and thus will lose the guys I've built my team upon.

The one suggestion to fix this that I have for Bort is to reward those teams affected with a one time 2 Million doller bonus (what would have been our guaranteed home playoff payday) during this transition. Then it won't screw teams like us financially, but will also allow him to make the competition better.
Last edited Apr 2, 2009 12:29:41
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Raiders12
Originally posted by dpride59

Originally posted by JcWildcat


Originally posted by dpride59



Originally posted by chaotic646




Bort, since you wont give me a direct answer to my other questions will you answer this?

I have a team full of CPU's and a level 45 K. Will that level 45 K protect my team from getting capped?

100% yes. IF you have any player over level 34 you cannot play in a capped league


Not true if he decides to go by Median level. I have a couple level 40s, but my median level is around 28.


Completely false. Your league will be determined by highest level player, and median. He does not allow any player to play above a cap. This is the reason for the restructure, and why caps are implemented. If you have anyone over say " Level 35" You are going to be uncapped. The entire point of this is to keep competitive balance, and if your "median is 28, you better shed your 35+s or you are going to be uncapped. The median is used to determine the teams who are capped, and under say 16 so if we have 32 "2's medians" there would be a 2 league. 32 "345 median" they would fill out the next branch. Most of this has been addressed through the rules of the game, and common sense, and his initial announcement.



The most important thing that needs to be unveiled is when these changes are for sure going to happen -( Don't think he knows for sure yet)
And What kind of caps are the "Canada, USA, WE, EE BBB, " leagues going to receive Hopefully it is same for all BBB, - and lower tier A leagues who do not currently have BBB teams. 24/31/34/Uncapped. But to answer the question with 100% certainty if you have any player on your roster you will be uncapped. If the median of your team if say 28, you will then be placed in the lowest tiered Uncapped league. Assuming there isn't 32 other teams with less then a 28 median that have over 35 players on there roster.


I hope your wrong...because then I have to dump several players just to stay in a league where the team as a whole can be competitive....another great way to lose owners.

Curious to see how these caps effect promotion/demotion if your correct.


If I am wrong, and you can keep players over the cap, then some jackass is gonna recruit 47 people over the cap and go 16-0 vs you. You can't say " You can keep your 3 players level 35 and over. But we are going to put you in a capped league. Just shed those 3 players. Sell them for cash, and recruit or buy 3-6 players from market place. Plenty of teams willing to pay cash for players like that, and you could even trade them for 3 34 level players. you making your roster able to get into a 34 cap isn't going to lose any owners. You need parameters in place to ensure fair play. If you could just "Be the exception" how pissed would the 31 other teams in your BBB league be?

Also the 31 or 34 capped teams in USA BBB, are going to be pretty damn competitive. I have a feeling the Lowest tier uncapped region of the worst 32 teams is going to be a cake walk. Be careful what you wish for. The bottom 32 teams in that uncapped region are going to be the lazy owners who don't spend time and effort on there team who have 4-6 level 40 guys intertwined with level 22 scrubs who are inactive. I think your best bet for wins/best season is to aim for that uncapped bottom tier. OTherwise shed your hi level guys and bring in 3 new bodies.
Last edited Apr 2, 2009 14:37:10
 
Raiders12
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpride59
Originally posted by Raiders12

Originally posted by dpride59


Originally posted by JcWildcat



Originally posted by dpride59




Originally posted by chaotic646





Bort, since you wont give me a direct answer to my other questions will you answer this?

I have a team full of CPU's and a level 45 K. Will that level 45 K protect my team from getting capped?

100% yes. IF you have any player over level 34 you cannot play in a capped league


Not true if he decides to go by Median level. I have a couple level 40s, but my median level is around 28.


Completely false. Your league will be determined by highest level player, and median. He does not allow any player to play above a cap. This is the reason for the restructure, and why caps are implemented. If you have anyone over say " Level 35" You are going to be uncapped. The entire point of this is to keep competitive balance, and if your "median is 28, you better shed your 35+s or you are going to be uncapped. The median is used to determine the teams who are capped, and under say 16 so if we have 32 "2's medians" there would be a 2 league. 32 "345 median" they would fill out the next branch. Most of this has been addressed through the rules of the game, and common sense, and his initial announcement.



The most important thing that needs to be unveiled is when these changes are for sure going to happen -( Don't think he knows for sure yet)
And What kind of caps are the "Canada, USA, WE, EE BBB, " leagues going to receive Hopefully it is same for all BBB, - and lower tier A leagues who do not currently have BBB teams. 24/31/34/Uncapped. But to answer the question with 100% certainty if you have any player on your roster you will be uncapped. If the median of your team if say 28, you will then be placed in the lowest tiered Uncapped league. Assuming there isn't 32 other teams with less then a 28 median that have over 35 players on there roster.


I hope your wrong...because then I have to dump several players just to stay in a league where the team as a whole can be competitive....another great way to lose owners.

Curious to see how these caps effect promotion/demotion if your correct.


If I am wrong, and you can keep players over the cap, then some jackass is gonna recruit 47 people over the cap and go 16-0 vs you. You can't say " You can keep your 3 players level 35 and over. But we are going to put you in a capped league. Just shed those 3 players. Sell them for cash, and recruit or buy 3-6 players from market place. Plenty of teams willing to pay cash for players like that, and you could even trade them for 3 34 level players. you making your roster able to get into a 34 cap isn't going to lose any owners. You need parameters in place to ensure fair play. If you could just "Be the exception" how pissed would the 31 other teams in your BBB league be?

Also the 31 or 34 capped teams in USA BBB, are going to be pretty damn competitive. I have a feeling the Lowest tier uncapped region of the worst 32 teams is going to be a cake walk. Be careful what you wish for. The bottom 32 teams in that uncapped region are going to be the lazy owners who don't spend time and effort on there team who have 4-6 level 40 guys intertwined with level 22 scrubs who are inactive. I think your best bet for wins/best season is to aim for that uncapped bottom tier. OTherwise shed your hi level guys and bring in 3 new bodies.


That's why this version of the BBB shuffle would be so much better,,,,fixes the majority of the issues that are in BBB right now and doesn't require caps.


" That's why the better way to "reshuffle" is to push the bottom of these tiers to B (where gutted/cpu teams would reside). Then the middle tier push to BB, and the top stay in BBB. Arrange these leagues to have 8 teams in each conference and have them play each other twice a season.

Limit rebuilds/guts that drop to the B league to the same level of stadium as the new/cpu teams. They would get more of their stadium seating back as they advanced. (This would stop the gut/drop and then resign using funds from a full stadium, which is HUGE issue in the BBB leagues)

This would work better in conjunction with the current promotion/demotion set-up and make all of the B leagues more competitive without the need for league caps, although you could put them on the B and BB leagues anyway."

Last edited Apr 2, 2009 15:16:06
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
I like the idea of a league shuffle and caps...

Just wondering why Bort doesn't implement this all the way up through at least AAA right now, rather than waiting......

Seems like it could avoid future problems by just doing this in all of the leagues except pro/world right now, rather than doing BBB this season and other leagues in future seasons....


I am in favor of caps like this...and think it should be implemented more completely.
 
NoSkillz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpride59
I also see 1 huge problem at start of season. Teams are going to fear there competition, and feel like they "Can't compete financially" and then sell off entire teams for cash and rebuild! This is going to happen when teams don't like there chances. Solution?



Maybe strip them of thier team for screwing up the league by being a selfish baby.
 
joeflex73
offline
Link
 
This is great, and I think should happen, and am glad it is.

I do think that one thing to be addressed is future releases. I don't think new releases, going forward, should be added to the current pyramids. My suggestion: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2304445

 
snatch311
offline
Link
 
What do you guys think will end up happening with my team? Went 10-6 in the regular season (7th seed), but made it to conference finals.

WAY underleveled.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=6727
 
chaotic646
offline
Link
 
Bort, I read your announcement and Im still a little concerned. Right now I have a level 45 K, the rest CPU's, and Im in a Pro league. I already have an entire roster of commits levels 33-50, but 85% are in the 30's. We will obviously be WAY under-leveled for Pro and AAA, but since we have a handful of level 40 players and one 50 guy we cant be in a capped league. Will there be an option to request a "lower leveled' uncapped league or will we be stuck in Pro?
Last edited Apr 3, 2009 16:26:59
 
AC33
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
The previously mentioned shuffling is coming up, so I thought I'd run down a couple of the questions I've gotten and what we're doing:

The main thing is that I will be adding an option for you to specify what level your team will be when the season starts. I've gotten some concerns from team owners who will be unable to sign their players until day 1, and would otherwise be shuffled into the low leveled caps. An example of what this will allow you to do:

- Right now, you have all CPU players and some lv 2's.
- Normally, you would be shuffled together with teams who also have CPU players and lv 2's.
- However, you have a whole bunch of lv 30 guys waiting to sign with you on day 1 and 2 of the next season.
- The option I will be adding will let you go to a page and say "I want a level 32 league."
- When the shuffling happens, you'll be put into a level 32 league, and you can sign your level 30 guys.

What it will NOT allow you to do:
- Right now, you have a bunch of level 50 players, or you plan to sign them soon.
- You go to the new page I add and sneakily say "I want a level 13 league" even though you have level 50 players.
- When the reshuffling happens, you will NOT be put in a level 13 league. This will be overriden by your level 50 players and you will be put in an uncapped league with other level 50 teams. If you want to get that level 13 league, make sure you cut all your players that are too high!

When I add this option, I'll let you know and it will show up as a link on your team profile page.

We will be doing the shuffling as soon as we can during the offseason, because once it's done, we can hand out the CPU teams in the newly capped leages to the waiting list and everyone can know where they stand.

This goes for ALL uncapped teams at the bottom of their region's tiers, and for the casual leagues as well. Please check out my previous announcement for where the caps are going in the casual leagues.


 
Sal Basss
offline
Link
 
So I have a team full of 20s and 21s who will be boosted to 23-24 at the end of the season. Since my team is bad, I have a punter who will be boosted to 25 at the end of the season. I was in a capped league this year (13/16) and under the old system the cap would have been 21 to start Season 9. I wouldn't want to go to a level 28 capped league because that would just hurt my team even more.

Will having a PUNTER who is one level higher than the cap cause me to automatically go to the level 28 capped league instead? That seems a bit silly.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.