User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > GLB Notes > CPL > Free Gart888
Page:
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
You're bridging two issues here.

Do mods have authority to make discretionary calls as to whether something is breaking a rule or how server it is?
Yes

Do mods have authority to make rules?
No


The first question? Not really. I mean... you would have to use your best judgment to figure out the rules... sure. But you were implying that it was "obvious" that the mods were already not "limited to things specifically mentioned" in the rules. No. Either it was in the rules... or it wasn't. In effect, you seemed to be arguing that mods COULD "make the rules."

No. They could not. You're right now and in that post. They had NO right.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

You're bridging two issues here.

Do mods have authority to make discretionary calls as to whether something is breaking a rule or how server it is?
Yes

Do mods have authority to make rules?
No


The first question? Not really. I mean... you would have to use your best judgment to figure out the rules... sure. But you were implying that it was "obvious" that the mods were already not "limited to things specifically mentioned" in the rules. No. Either it was in the rules... or it wasn't. In effect, you seemed to be arguing that mods COULD "make the rules."


Depends entirely on interpretation. I read that new rule as meaning that simply because, for example, the rules say "Don't call someone a 'faggot'" doens't mean that calling them a "fag" is ok.

If you take it to mean that Mods can now make rules, then I guess we'll have to ask an admin.

Originally posted by

No. They could not. You're right now and in that post. They had NO right.


NO RIGHT! WAIT A MINUTE! YOU GOT NO RIGHT!
 
cowtesticles2001
udder pressure
offline
Link
 
fag=cigarette...
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Depends entirely on interpretation. I read that new rule as meaning that simply because, for example, the rules say "Don't call someone a 'faggot'" doens't mean that calling them a "fag" is ok.

If you take it to mean that Mods can now make rules, then I guess we'll have to ask an admin.


Oh no, there were other rules that were vague enough ("personal attacks" or "hate speech" or even possibly "general trolling") that would have prevented that.
But people that were banned for something like bumping old threads (before a couple days ago when it was an actual rule) were NOT rightfully banned before... this new rule won't really allow for it... but it WILL allow for mods to more appropriately justify any times that they might ban someone when that person did not break a rule... or for any threads that are not treated right.
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Depends entirely on interpretation. I read that new rule as meaning that simply because, for example, the rules say "Don't call someone a 'faggot'" doens't mean that calling them a "fag" is ok.

If you take it to mean that Mods can now make rules, then I guess we'll have to ask an admin.

And I think that's the second time you've tried to imply that such language was something that I might have possibly construed as being allowed by the rules. Not at all, tbh.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


Depends entirely on interpretation. I read that new rule as meaning that simply because, for example, the rules say "Don't call someone a 'faggot'" doens't mean that calling them a "fag" is ok.

If you take it to mean that Mods can now make rules, then I guess we'll have to ask an admin.


Oh no, there were other rules that were vague enough ("personal attacks" or "hate speech" or even possibly "general trolling") that would have prevented that.
But people that were banned for something like bumping old threads (before a couple days ago when it was an actual rule) were NOT rightfully banned before... this new rule won't really allow for it... but it WILL allow for mods to more appropriately justify any times that they might ban someone when that person did not break a rule... or for any threads that are not treated right.


Right, it's possible, but no more so (and no more justifiable than before). Necro bumping is pretty clearly spammy though, and hardly something to spend energy defending.
Originally posted by Malachorn
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


Depends entirely on interpretation. I read that new rule as meaning that simply because, for example, the rules say "Don't call someone a 'faggot'" doens't mean that calling them a "fag" is ok.

If you take it to mean that Mods can now make rules, then I guess we'll have to ask an admin.

And I think that's the second time you've tried to imply that such language was something that I might have possibly construed as being allowed by the rules. Not at all, tbh.


In case this is in anyway unclear (and I really have no idea other than playing the victim card why you'd even point this out) I'm not referring to you when I use the example of the "faggot-fag" issue.
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Right, it's possible, but no more so (and no more justifiable than before). Necro bumping is pretty clearly spammy though, and hardly something to spend energy defending.


Not according to the rules you're supposed to be using to police the forums.
# Spamming, such as posting similar or the same thread over and over, or adding completely offtopic posts over and over to an existing thread, is not allowed.

Why would it try to define spam like that for no reason?
I think it's pretty clear in those rules that the "spam rule" was not really a justifiable reason to punish someone for necro-bumping.

Again... using such a rule in effect was creating your own rules.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Right, it's possible, but no more so (and no more justifiable than before). Necro bumping is pretty clearly spammy though, and hardly something to spend energy defending.


Not according to the rules you're supposed to be using to police the forums.
# Spamming, such as posting similar or the same thread over and over, or adding completely offtopic posts over and over to an existing thread, is not allowed.

Why would it try to define spam like that for no reason?
I think it's pretty clear in those rules that the "spam rule" was not really a justifiable reason to punish someone for necro-bumping.

Again... using such a rule in effect was creating your own rules.


Of course it was. Necro bumping is posting an offtopic message in an old thread. If something applies to the thread, post it, otherwise, you run the risk of getting banned.

The idea that necro-bumping serves any purpose other than cluttering forums is stupid.
 
DrunkenOne
offline
Link
 
plz change name of thread to "Malachorn and VT cockslap eachother for 16 pages"
 
GuieetarBen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DrunkenOne
plz change name of thread to "Malachorn and VT cockslap eachother for 16 pages"


2nded
 
Link
 
Originally posted by DrunkenOne
plz change name of thread to "Malachorn and VT cockslap eachother for 16 pages"


no u
 
GuieetarBen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by DrunkenOne

plz change name of thread to "Malachorn and VT cockslap eachother for 16 pages"


no u



no u
 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
Malachorn and VT are pretty intelligent (and stubborn) people, this could go on forever
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by Malachorn

Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


Right, it's possible, but no more so (and no more justifiable than before). Necro bumping is pretty clearly spammy though, and hardly something to spend energy defending.


Not according to the rules you're supposed to be using to police the forums.
# Spamming, such as posting similar or the same thread over and over, or adding completely offtopic posts over and over to an existing thread, is not allowed.

Why would it try to define spam like that for no reason?
I think it's pretty clear in those rules that the "spam rule" was not really a justifiable reason to punish someone for necro-bumping.

Again... using such a rule in effect was creating your own rules.


Of course it was. Necro bumping is posting an offtopic message in an old thread. If something applies to the thread, post it, otherwise, you run the risk of getting banned.

The idea that necro-bumping serves any purpose other than cluttering forums is stupid.


WAT?
Necro-bumping is only if a post was offtopic, by your thinking?
WAT?
I was under the impression that "necro-bumping" was just bumping dead threads.

If so, then this newer rule STILL isn't about your "necro-bumping" that you're now talking about:
# Please do not "bump" threads that are old, such as threads that are past the second or third page. Threads bumped in this manner may be locked.

I thought THAT was a new "necro-bumping rule," tbh.
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Necro bumping is posting an offtopic message in an old thread.


And you're conceding that, before that new rule, posting an ONTOPIC message in an old thread was allowed then?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.