Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
You're bridging two issues here.
Do mods have authority to make discretionary calls as to whether something is breaking a rule or how server it is?
Yes
Do mods have authority to make rules?
No
The first question? Not really. I mean... you would have to use your best judgment to figure out the rules... sure. But you were implying that it was "obvious" that the mods were already not "limited to things specifically mentioned" in the rules. No. Either it was in the rules... or it wasn't. In effect, you seemed to be arguing that mods COULD "make the rules."
No. They could not. You're right now and in that post. They had NO right.
You're bridging two issues here.
Do mods have authority to make discretionary calls as to whether something is breaking a rule or how server it is?
Yes
Do mods have authority to make rules?
No
The first question? Not really. I mean... you would have to use your best judgment to figure out the rules... sure. But you were implying that it was "obvious" that the mods were already not "limited to things specifically mentioned" in the rules. No. Either it was in the rules... or it wasn't. In effect, you seemed to be arguing that mods COULD "make the rules."
No. They could not. You're right now and in that post. They had NO right.






























