User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
Page:
 
ugk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by ugk

Originally posted by sjmay


Originally posted by Cerneo



Originally posted by ress5609
Originally posted by AgentTBC

Well, yeah, obviously at this point the most necessary thing is transparency: People need to know exactly what these testers can do. Specifically, the following:

1) Can testers see the builds of other players in the game?
2) Can testers create players with whatever stats they want and test them in games?
3) Can testers set up scrimmage games with existing GLB teams, modify the offense/defensive tactics, and see the results?

Those three things are critical knowledge. Any of them are just begging for abuse; all of them would be disastrous from a PR standpoint.

this imo. i don't care who the testers were. i just want to know IF they're truly being given an unfair advantage or not.


1. No, absolutely not.
2. Yes wouldn't be much of a test site otherwise
3. No, absolutely not.


Testers are some mods who are interested in it and some other users who have demonstrated their altruistic interest in testing for the benefit of the game and not for their own personal gain. If a tester is found to have been disseminating knowledge from the game to get his team an unfair advantage he will not be a tester for long. Having testers know a lot about the game is unavoidable. That is why you try to find guys who are genuinely concerned about others. For example all my player builds are open. I would not do that if I was only concerned about "dominating".


---

And thats Tpats other post wbout them making player builds.


Yep, which makes sense, how the hell do you test something without allowing the testers to build?

My POINT IS, and HIS POINT IS, there are so many freaking variables, that it is insane to think that the testers are getting an advantage BECAUSE of the inordinate amount of variables in the game.


Once you're done with the basics you're good to go for testing any player build, (if it's player builds we're talkin bout). I understand if you're supposed to test plays or some shietz


Read the post I quoted from TPAT's again, please, in it, it states, OBVIOUSLY a + 15 to confidence is going to make your QB better, but how much, against who, against what defense, etc etc, each team is so different, how do you test all those?? Seriously?


Note, when you get the base. You dont need a team specifically to benefit that player.

Once you get the teams up, do they go away after every game? Then you can just do minor changes.
It's still a big advantage.
 
Cerneo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay

You don't think it's rock paper scissors?? What do you think a RNG is?


This I have to hear.
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cerneo


The testing started on Feb 1st. That was during the playoffs its impossible to know if it helped anyone with out names.

Get your facts right.


What use would a list of names have? Would everyone on that list who was on a team in the playoffs instantly become a scapegoat? The list of names is just not nearly enough information to determine if there was cheating involved, and I doubt that Bort is going to post the log files for you to poor over.

Besides, the testers wouldn't even have to be ON the team to pass on privileged information. They could quite easily do so over the phone or by IM. The list of names just isn't going to make you sleep better at night, no matter what names are on it.

 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by awesome

Originally posted by sjmay


Besides, if it is only been going on since Feb 1st, you really think they had time to create that much variables to test out how +10 jumping in DE's worked?? Cmon now, use your brain.


You play the role of irrational apologist quite well.


I am irrational yet you guys are whining about testers, testing a game,

Ok.


Nope. We are complaining about OTHER USERS being able to test builds FOR FREE, IMMEDIATELY while the rest of us have to pay money and spend several months to learn the same information.
 
Cerneo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cryptotich
Originally posted by Cerneo



The testing started on Feb 1st. That was during the playoffs its impossible to know if it helped anyone with out names.

Get your facts right.


What use would a list of names have? Would everyone on that list who was on a team in the playoffs instantly become a scapegoat? The list of names is just not nearly enough information to determine if there was cheating involved, and I doubt that Bort is going to post the log files for you to poor over.

Besides, the testers wouldn't even have to be ON the team to pass on privileged information. They could quite easily do so over the phone or by IM. The list of names just isn't going to make you sleep better at night, no matter what names are on it.



As I have said about 50 times by now.

We need the names to see to what extent it helped those 30ish players next season.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by boondocksaint
Originally posted by sjmay

From TPAT, makes a TON of sense.

Originally posted by tpaterniti
Also I want to briefly address the scenario some people have mentioned of testing what a player would look like with this or that build. First of all, I know it sounds like a simple thing to say, what if my player had 15 more confidence, what would that do? But think about what you would really have to do to set this up. You could make that character easy enough, but to test what he would do? Against who? Against what? You would have to set up a whole team to test it out against. For example, let's say you want to test what your QB could do with 15 more confidence. Well what type of team are you playing? We have absolutely no ability to rip teams from the game to test against so you would have to set up a team yourself. What kind of team would they be? Pass rushing? Fast CBs? Run stopping? In other words what is a "typical" team you would test against or is there even any such thing as a "typical" team? Most teams on GLB right now are a blend of agents and builds, some very good, some average, some below average and many teams are quite different from each other. Then for your own team, how do you set them up? Consider the possibility that you could make your own offense too good because the real issue would be how to interpret your test results? What if your QB plays great? What does that mean? Was that simply due to adding 15 confidence to him? Did you make your D too bad, or your O too good? And if you learn that 15 confidence makes your QB better against the team you played, does that translate to GLB? What is the likelihood that any teams are similar to the one you made? Well surely some will be similar, but not all and not all in the same way. You could play a SA based team and still not have enough confidence. Then again, and this is the real point, did you really learn anything about confidence from your test? I think everyone would concede that since confidence is a major attribute for QBs, adding 15 more of it would make him play better. But exactly how much better did he play? And how did he play better? Did he seem to deteriorate less over the game, or did he throw farther, avoid sacks better, etc etc etc. What does your test tell you about confidence for a QB that you didn't really know already that would give you a huge advantage over anyone else?

I hope this case study is helpful. My point is that while it seems like a simple matter to say, Well a tester could just "preview" his next boost to see what is most effective, this would be an extremely complex and time-consumming thing to do, and I would seriously question the quality of any results you would get from that because of huge problems interpreting your results.

Quotes from TPAT,

Tell me what advantage there is there, please.


I've gotta say... I like what you're trying to say, but it's just failed logic.

To say that a user that had access to the now infamous "test server" doesn't have an advantage is just stupid. And as evidenced in Tpat's post also. He makes mention of the fact that "this would be an extremely complex and time-consumming thing to do", but that doesn't mean that no one would/hasn't.

I think it's complete and total bullshit that I can't "test" what I'd consider flaws in the game, or in my players' builds, yet others, that I compete against, with my team full of trusting agents have that "advantage".

Call it whatever you want, but it sucks.


Hey Boon,

Read my post on Medellin, it tells you how much I care about this issue lol,

To respond to your post here, I don't see it as failed logic, simply because, he is right. Let's take your amazing FS who you refused to sign with me and test him out.

A. How many different offenses to test him out?
B. How many different WR builds to test him out?
C. How many different TE builds to test him out?
D. How many different FB builds to test him out?
E. How many different HB builds to test him out?
G. How many different defenses to test him out in?

Anyone care to do the math on that just on how many different groups can be made there? But we are gonna go through all that to test out how effective jumping makes him vs catching, for interceptions?

We have to believe that the testers, don't have a job, don't have a family, don't have their own players/teams on GLB, and only create EVERY SCENARIO, to test on.

Cmon now.
 
ugk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cryptotich
Originally posted by Cerneo



The testing started on Feb 1st. That was during the playoffs its impossible to know if it helped anyone with out names.

Get your facts right.


What use would a list of names have? Would everyone on that list who was on a team in the playoffs instantly become a scapegoat? The list of names is just not nearly enough information to determine if there was cheating involved, and I doubt that Bort is going to post the log files for you to poor over.

Besides, the testers wouldn't even have to be ON the team to pass on privileged information. They could quite easily do so over the phone or by IM. The list of names just isn't going to make you sleep better at night, no matter what names are on it.



This, this is why I would much prefer having the data (bort post) instead of guessing.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cerneo
Originally posted by sjmay


You don't think it's rock paper scissors?? What do you think a RNG is?


This I have to hear.


You do realize there is a RNG generated for every play, WTF do you think Bort is talking aobut when he mentions a vision check, or a pass deflection check etc?

It is build vs build, but it's not only that, cmon , you seriously didn't know this?
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ugk
Originally posted by Cryptotich

Originally posted by Cerneo




The testing started on Feb 1st. That was during the playoffs its impossible to know if it helped anyone with out names.

Get your facts right.


What use would a list of names have? Would everyone on that list who was on a team in the playoffs instantly become a scapegoat? The list of names is just not nearly enough information to determine if there was cheating involved, and I doubt that Bort is going to post the log files for you to poor over.

Besides, the testers wouldn't even have to be ON the team to pass on privileged information. They could quite easily do so over the phone or by IM. The list of names just isn't going to make you sleep better at night, no matter what names are on it.



This, this is why I would much prefer having the data (bort post) instead of guessing.


UGK,

Wouldn't that make the game just WAY to easy for you?

honestly, knowing what to do instead of having work at it, why would anyone want that? It just defeats the purpose of the game.
 
Romeorr
offline
Link
 
i cant wait for the posts, join my team some of my gm's were testers, get inside info.... yadda yadda yadda
 
ugk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by boondocksaint

Originally posted by sjmay


From TPAT, makes a TON of sense.

Originally posted by tpaterniti
Also I want to briefly address the scenario some people have mentioned of testing what a player would look like with this or that build. First of all, I know it sounds like a simple thing to say, what if my player had 15 more confidence, what would that do? But think about what you would really have to do to set this up. You could make that character easy enough, but to test what he would do? Against who? Against what? You would have to set up a whole team to test it out against. For example, let's say you want to test what your QB could do with 15 more confidence. Well what type of team are you playing? We have absolutely no ability to rip teams from the game to test against so you would have to set up a team yourself. What kind of team would they be? Pass rushing? Fast CBs? Run stopping? In other words what is a "typical" team you would test against or is there even any such thing as a "typical" team? Most teams on GLB right now are a blend of agents and builds, some very good, some average, some below average and many teams are quite different from each other. Then for your own team, how do you set them up? Consider the possibility that you could make your own offense too good because the real issue would be how to interpret your test results? What if your QB plays great? What does that mean? Was that simply due to adding 15 confidence to him? Did you make your D too bad, or your O too good? And if you learn that 15 confidence makes your QB better against the team you played, does that translate to GLB? What is the likelihood that any teams are similar to the one you made? Well surely some will be similar, but not all and not all in the same way. You could play a SA based team and still not have enough confidence. Then again, and this is the real point, did you really learn anything about confidence from your test? I think everyone would concede that since confidence is a major attribute for QBs, adding 15 more of it would make him play better. But exactly how much better did he play? And how did he play better? Did he seem to deteriorate less over the game, or did he throw farther, avoid sacks better, etc etc etc. What does your test tell you about confidence for a QB that you didn't really know already that would give you a huge advantage over anyone else?

I hope this case study is helpful. My point is that while it seems like a simple matter to say, Well a tester could just "preview" his next boost to see what is most effective, this would be an extremely complex and time-consumming thing to do, and I would seriously question the quality of any results you would get from that because of huge problems interpreting your results.

Quotes from TPAT,

Tell me what advantage there is there, please.


I've gotta say... I like what you're trying to say, but it's just failed logic.

To say that a user that had access to the now infamous "test server" doesn't have an advantage is just stupid. And as evidenced in Tpat's post also. He makes mention of the fact that "this would be an extremely complex and time-consumming thing to do", but that doesn't mean that no one would/hasn't.

I think it's complete and total bullshit that I can't "test" what I'd consider flaws in the game, or in my players' builds, yet others, that I compete against, with my team full of trusting agents have that "advantage".

Call it whatever you want, but it sucks.


Hey Boon,

Read my post on Medellin, it tells you how much I care about this issue lol,

To respond to your post here, I don't see it as failed logic, simply because, he is right. Let's take your amazing FS who you refused to sign with me and test him out.

A. How many different offenses to test him out?
B. How many different WR builds to test him out?
C. How many different TE builds to test him out?
D. How many different FB builds to test him out?
E. How many different HB builds to test him out?
G. How many different defenses to test him out in?

Anyone care to do the math on that just on how many different groups can be made there? But we are gonna go through all that to test out how effective jumping makes him vs catching, for interceptions?

We have to believe that the testers, don't have a job, don't have a family, don't have their own players/teams on GLB, and only create EVERY SCENARIO, to test on.

Cmon now.


lulz, your whole post is failed logic, you truly think they'd test every scenario?
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay

We have to believe that the testers, don't have a job, don't have a family, don't have their own players/teams on GLB, and only create EVERY SCENARIO, to test on.

Cmon now.


What makes you think that that level of testing is necessary? Seriously, how obtuse can you be? You should know that you would only need to run one scrimmage with an extreme build to see if the results are dramatically different.

Oh wait...I forgot who I was talking to. This guy is an idiot of the highest level. Don't feed the troll.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ugk
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by boondocksaint


Originally posted by sjmay



From TPAT, makes a TON of sense.

Originally posted by tpaterniti
Also I want to briefly address the scenario some people have mentioned of testing what a player would look like with this or that build. First of all, I know it sounds like a simple thing to say, what if my player had 15 more confidence, what would that do? But think about what you would really have to do to set this up. You could make that character easy enough, but to test what he would do? Against who? Against what? You would have to set up a whole team to test it out against. For example, let's say you want to test what your QB could do with 15 more confidence. Well what type of team are you playing? We have absolutely no ability to rip teams from the game to test against so you would have to set up a team yourself. What kind of team would they be? Pass rushing? Fast CBs? Run stopping? In other words what is a "typical" team you would test against or is there even any such thing as a "typical" team? Most teams on GLB right now are a blend of agents and builds, some very good, some average, some below average and many teams are quite different from each other. Then for your own team, how do you set them up? Consider the possibility that you could make your own offense too good because the real issue would be how to interpret your test results? What if your QB plays great? What does that mean? Was that simply due to adding 15 confidence to him? Did you make your D too bad, or your O too good? And if you learn that 15 confidence makes your QB better against the team you played, does that translate to GLB? What is the likelihood that any teams are similar to the one you made? Well surely some will be similar, but not all and not all in the same way. You could play a SA based team and still not have enough confidence. Then again, and this is the real point, did you really learn anything about confidence from your test? I think everyone would concede that since confidence is a major attribute for QBs, adding 15 more of it would make him play better. But exactly how much better did he play? And how did he play better? Did he seem to deteriorate less over the game, or did he throw farther, avoid sacks better, etc etc etc. What does your test tell you about confidence for a QB that you didn't really know already that would give you a huge advantage over anyone else?

I hope this case study is helpful. My point is that while it seems like a simple matter to say, Well a tester could just "preview" his next boost to see what is most effective, this would be an extremely complex and time-consumming thing to do, and I would seriously question the quality of any results you would get from that because of huge problems interpreting your results.

Quotes from TPAT,

Tell me what advantage there is there, please.


I've gotta say... I like what you're trying to say, but it's just failed logic.

To say that a user that had access to the now infamous "test server" doesn't have an advantage is just stupid. And as evidenced in Tpat's post also. He makes mention of the fact that "this would be an extremely complex and time-consumming thing to do", but that doesn't mean that no one would/hasn't.

I think it's complete and total bullshit that I can't "test" what I'd consider flaws in the game, or in my players' builds, yet others, that I compete against, with my team full of trusting agents have that "advantage".

Call it whatever you want, but it sucks.


Hey Boon,

Read my post on Medellin, it tells you how much I care about this issue lol,

To respond to your post here, I don't see it as failed logic, simply because, he is right. Let's take your amazing FS who you refused to sign with me and test him out.

A. How many different offenses to test him out?
B. How many different WR builds to test him out?
C. How many different TE builds to test him out?
D. How many different FB builds to test him out?
E. How many different HB builds to test him out?
G. How many different defenses to test him out in?

Anyone care to do the math on that just on how many different groups can be made there? But we are gonna go through all that to test out how effective jumping makes him vs catching, for interceptions?

We have to believe that the testers, don't have a job, don't have a family, don't have their own players/teams on GLB, and only create EVERY SCENARIO, to test on.

Cmon now.


lulz, your whole post is failed logic, you truly think they'd test every scenario?


Uh no, kinda the point there genius.
 
ugk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by ugk

Originally posted by Cryptotich


Originally posted by Cerneo





The testing started on Feb 1st. That was during the playoffs its impossible to know if it helped anyone with out names.

Get your facts right.


What use would a list of names have? Would everyone on that list who was on a team in the playoffs instantly become a scapegoat? The list of names is just not nearly enough information to determine if there was cheating involved, and I doubt that Bort is going to post the log files for you to poor over.

Besides, the testers wouldn't even have to be ON the team to pass on privileged information. They could quite easily do so over the phone or by IM. The list of names just isn't going to make you sleep better at night, no matter what names are on it.



This, this is why I would much prefer having the data (bort post) instead of guessing.


UGK,

Wouldn't that make the game just WAY to easy for you?

honestly, knowing what to do instead of having work at it, why would anyone want that? It just defeats the purpose of the game.


Then remove the test server? All or nothing imo
 
Cerneo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by Cerneo

Originally posted by sjmay



You don't think it's rock paper scissors?? What do you think a RNG is?


This I have to hear.


You do realize there is a RNG generated for every play, WTF do you think Bort is talking aobut when he mentions a vision check, or a pass deflection check etc?

It is build vs build, but it's not only that, cmon , you seriously didn't know this?


Ahahaha.

I am talking about arch types.

No shit I how this stuff works, been playing mmos/pnp forever. Your just creating strawmans, you don't have any real point other than "No your worng its not that big a deal". When clearly it is. You had mods trying to cover it up, bort posting on it, 2000+ post on it is just hours, its a big god damn deal.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.