User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Test Server Discussion
Page:
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by Iceman16



Voltron appears to have moved the thread elsewhere and tried to keep the lynch mob calm. Whether or not you stay calm isn't up to him.


If Voltron thought that moving the thread would keep the lynch mob calm he isn't smart enough to be a mod.





What would you have done, mod-to-be?
 
SwampThing13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AgentTBC


Excellent, thanks.

I posted in another thread that I've been involved in online games (MMORPGs, etc) in one way or another for most of two decades. Some of that was in a dev-like environment where I had access to the game code and such. With that background, I can guarantee you that you're underestimating how many people are using knowledge they are getting to their advantage.

I'm not saying they're going out of their way to cheat or anything; I'm saying that they will have done things like test two players with virtually the same stats except one has 30 more vision or 30 more confidence than the other, and they will have seen how much better the guy with extra vision plays. Then they'll have mentioned to their friends, in passing, "hey vision really is underrated/overrated" at that position", and their friends will know they're basing this on first-hand knowledge.

Is that absolutely game-breaking? No. Are you underplaying the potential and actuality of abuse? Almost certainly. It doesn't matter how honest the testers are; if they're also players they'll use it to their advantage, in a major way or a minor one.

The way to lessen than is to keep logs of all the tests they run. Somebody constantly testing how players with 200 strength, agility, and speed will break the game are not finding advantages. Testers who are running a lot of sims where players are similar but some have slightly higher of various stats ARE finding advantages. It's not that hard to tell; take it from me, I used to find people doing similar things.

My guess is that nobody is bothering to do that sort of oversight.



This is one of the best thought out statements and nonrants in this thread so far. I have to agree with it all
 
Modok
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by britdevine316
Originally posted by britdevine316

Originally posted by britdevine316


Originally posted by britdevine316



So basically I can create any type of player I want, say I wanted to make this guy

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=730931


So I make him and play him for a few games

Then I want to cap his carry + conf in the test server, so I make a whole new player just like that but with capped carry and conf. Then I test him and see if he performs better.


HOW THE FUCK IS THAT NOT A HUGE ADVANTAGE








Dude...enough.
 
Norsemanvike
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by C37
Nice that Voltron threatens me for trying to expose the fact the mods are using Server Gate to have a competitive advantage over everyone.

Me thinks he doth protest too much.


We don't have an advantage. Heck, I don't know the AI that well myself and I don't really care to. I'd rather let someone else who enjoys it have fun with it.
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami
The real problem with GLB's test server is that it was kept a secret and seems to be very very exclusive.

Other MMOs test servers are widely used and all the information gained on the server is documented on the web very quickly, no one can even claim a left behind feeling.


 
C37
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 5thyearcock
This is a pretty big deal to have players in a webbased game having access to something like this. When the game is based on nothing more than numbers, having access to something that allows you to manipulate and test any combo of numbers is insanely stupid and unethical.

Yes, you can cover up the massive implications of this by stating they never know the final code going out and all that, but do you know how easy it would be to find a minor exploit with some stat/play combo and not let it out?


YES and it happens ALL THE TIME
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Trying to keep the mob calm != keeping the mob calm


Trying to keep the mob calm =/= making everything disappear with no explanation
 
Pariah
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AgentTBC
Originally posted by Norsemanvike

Originally posted by tpaterniti


Originally posted by ress5609



Originally posted by AgentTBC




Well, yeah, obviously at this point the most necessary thing is transparency: People need to know exactly what these testers can do. Specifically, the following:

1) Can testers see the builds of other players in the game?
2) Can testers create players with whatever stats they want and test them in games?
3) Can testers set up scrimmage games with existing GLB teams, modify the offense/defensive tactics, and see the results?

Those three things are critical knowledge. Any of them are just begging for abuse; all of them would be disastrous from a PR standpoint.


this imo. i don't care who the testers were. i just want to know IF they're truly being given an unfair advantage or not.



1. No, absolutely not.
2. Yes wouldn't be much of a test site otherwise
3. No, absolutely not.



Confirmed.


Excellent, thanks.

I posted in another thread that I've been involved in online games (MMORPGs, etc) in one way or another for most of two decades. Some of that was in a dev-like environment where I had access to the game code and such. With that background, I can guarantee you that you're underestimating how many people are using knowledge they are getting to their advantage.

I'm not saying they're going out of their way to cheat or anything; I'm saying that they will have done things like test two players with virtually the same stats except one has 30 more vision or 30 more confidence than the other, and they will have seen how much better the guy with extra vision plays. Then they'll have mentioned to their friends, in passing, "hey vision really is underrated/overrated" at that position", and their friends will know they're basing this on first-hand knowledge.

Is that absolutely game-breaking? No. Are you underplaying the potential and actuality of abuse? Almost certainly. It doesn't matter how honest the testers are; if they're also players they'll use it to their advantage, in a major way or a minor one.

The way to lessen than is to keep logs of all the tests they run. Somebody constantly testing how players with 200 strength, agility, and speed will break the game are not finding advantages. Testers who are running a lot of sims where players are similar but some have slightly higher of various stats ARE finding advantages. It's not that hard to tell; take it from me, I used to find people doing similar things.

My guess is that nobody is bothering to do that sort of oversight.



Good info, thx.
 
C37
offline
Link
 
ServerCheaterGate ?
 
5thyearcock
offline
Link
 
QUOTE=nfratami]
The real problem with GLB's test server is that it was kept a secret and seems to be very very exclusive.

Other MMOs test servers are widely used and all the information gained on the server is documented on the web very quickly, no one can even claim a left behind feeling.

Couldn't have said it better myself.


 
Motiak
offline
Link
 
This is probably the most emo thread I have ever read.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Norsemanvike
Originally posted by C37

Nice that Voltron threatens me for trying to expose the fact the mods are using Server Gate to have a competitive advantage over everyone.

Me thinks he doth protest too much.


We don't have an advantage. Heck, I don't know the AI that well myself and I don't really care to. I'd rather let someone else who enjoys it have fun with it.


This post is a lie Norse. Everyone knows that no one enjoys the AI.
 
JazzMaster
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by kost0121

Originally posted by ArthurRiot

Originally posted by Catullus 16

► given the test server exists, drop the "beta" tag

Well.... no, that might be a reasonable argument. I see where you are coming from.

Just because there is a test server doesn't mean you need to drop the beta. GLB is just testing stuff to add into the game. By no means is GLB done we are still adding new abilities and cows and shit to the game every season. The test server is just an attempt to make the actually game not suck, doesn't mean its should loose beta.


just because a game has a test server doesn't mean it's beta. what non-beta online games out there don't have test servers?

bad argument.


This game is a beta because it is not even close to being finished. A player is set to play for about 10 - 15 seasons (We dont know yet because it hasn't happened) and thats just my point. It has a test server to stop things from blowing up, but it is no where near done thus deserves a beta tag.
 
Voltron
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by C37
Nice that Voltron threatens me for trying to expose the fact the mods are using Server Gate to have a competitive advantage over everyone.

Me thinks he doth protest too much.


No but this is a thread to discuss the test server. Not your conspiracy theories. Please get back on subject.
 
britdevine316
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Modok
Originally posted by britdevine316

Originally posted by britdevine316


Originally posted by britdevine316



Originally posted by britdevine316




So basically I can create any type of player I want, say I wanted to make this guy

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=730931


So I make him and play him for a few games

Then I want to cap his carry + conf in the test server, so I make a whole new player just like that but with capped carry and conf. Then I test him and see if he performs better.


HOW THE FUCK IS THAT NOT A HUGE ADVANTAGE








Dude...enough.


Do you not see how huge of an advantage the test server is
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.