User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > UGLY GAME 4s - We think something is wrong with the passing in the sims
Page:
 
claystone
offline
Link
 
Here is what I think.

What are players value, are we pop warner or High school players? When do we become college and when do we become pro. This is important to understand our players build. If we use this base, then teams with college level players should not be playing high scholl players. This also allows us to get a grasp on stats that our players put up.

I agree with the statments above that RB, and o-lineman should be down played. A lot of RB rush for 5 to 6 yac. Lineman have 22 or more pancakes?!?!? Lets get all skills to apply to the players we are. If we are pop warner then we play like pop warner, and so on.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Considering the 10 year plateau, then is it really accurate to define Season 2, Level 14 QBs as Pop Warner?

If we assume that a Real Life QB reaches his Plateau around age 30, and starts playing Football at the age of 10(?) then our 10 season GLB window becomes 20 years of a real life QBs career.

So each GLB season is the equivilant of playing 2 years, right?
(That would mean that after season 10 you could be effective for two more seasons, but from then on would be only good for third string duties?)

So we started the second season aged 12?

I still think its wrong to say that Season 2 QBs should be EXPECTED to complete less than 50% of passes though.

A Good QB (+33 in throwing, strength, vision, confidence) throwing to a Good WR (+33 in Catching and confidence) should be able to complete any pass where the QB is not hurried and the WR is open.
Especially for under 10 yards, which seems to be impossible now having watched some replays?

I am confident that this will be worked out in time, especially seeing as the QB and WR positions are probably two of the biggest generators of income after Team Ownership.
Last edited May 2, 2008 18:00:40
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Ok, I'll change back the adjustment to pass quality. I still think you will find yourself affected by stamina and morale, though, and will probably not notice much of a change to completion pcts, and it will maybe go back up by 10% or so.

I did run a bunch test sims with these settings before putting them live and the QB's were getting between 45 and 65% completion %'s at lvs 8-12, so it's not like I didn't test it out.
 
Link
 
This just in (From Bort) "
Ok, I'll change back the adjustment to pass quality. I still think you will find yourself affected by stamina and morale, though, and will probably not notice much of a change to completion pcts, and it will maybe go back up by 10% or so.

I did run a bunch test sims with these settings before putting them live and the QB's were getting between 45 and 65% completion %'s at lvs 8-12, so it's not like I didn't test it out."

Edit: Damn, he beat me to the punch and I just took that from another thread.
Last edited May 2, 2008 17:59:01
 
panther17
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by claystone
Here is what I think.

What are players value, are we pop warner or High school players? When do we become college and when do we become pro. This is important to understand our players build. If we use this base, then teams with college level players should not be playing high scholl players. This also allows us to get a grasp on stats that our players put up.

I agree with the statments above that RB, and o-lineman should be down played. A lot of RB rush for 5 to 6 yac. Lineman have 22 or more pancakes?!?!? Lets get all skills to apply to the players we are. If we are pop warner then we play like pop warner, and so on.


That was my train of thought at first too. But then I realised that we are getting paid so we are all different levels of pro.
 
hostyle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Ok, I'll change back the adjustment to pass quality. I still think you will find yourself affected by stamina and morale, though, and will probably not notice much of a change to completion pcts, and it will maybe go back up by 10% or so.

I did run a bunch test sims with these settings before putting them live and the QB's were getting between 45 and 65% completion %'s at lvs 8-12, so it's not like I didn't test it out.


This is what I was getting before the change at level 8, although I havent played a game with this change. I just thought it odd that people under 10 were putting up such ridiculous numbers.
 
Whatsdafus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Ok, I'll change back the adjustment to pass quality. I still think you will find yourself affected by stamina and morale, though, and will probably not notice much of a change to completion pcts, and it will maybe go back up by 10% or so.

I did run a bunch test sims with these settings before putting them live and the QB's were getting between 45 and 65% completion %'s at lvs 8-12, so it's not like I didn't test it out.



when is this change?
 
BP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Ok, I'll change back the adjustment to pass quality. I still think you will find yourself affected by stamina and morale, though, and will probably not notice much of a change to completion pcts, and it will maybe go back up by 10% or so.

I did run a bunch test sims with these settings before putting them live and the QB's were getting between 45 and 65% completion %'s at lvs 8-12, so it's not like I didn't test it out.


Thank you Bort.

 
claystone
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Ok, I'll change back the adjustment to pass quality. I still think you will find yourself affected by stamina and morale, though, and will probably not notice much of a change to completion pcts, and it will maybe go back up by 10% or so.

I did run a bunch test sims with these settings before putting them live and the QB's were getting between 45 and 65% completion %'s at lvs 8-12, so it's not like I didn't test it out.



Bort, can't you assign levels of players to be "Pop warner / High School / college / Pro. We can understand more why our players are not so good if this was the case. It will also help against huge mismatches. Say level 13 playing level 5.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Whatsdafus
Originally posted by Bort

Ok, I'll change back the adjustment to pass quality. I still think you will find yourself affected by stamina and morale, though, and will probably not notice much of a change to completion pcts, and it will maybe go back up by 10% or so.

I did run a bunch test sims with these settings before putting them live and the QB's were getting between 45 and 65% completion %'s at lvs 8-12, so it's not like I didn't test it out.



when is this change?


Immediately, obviously....
 
E-A-G-L-E-S
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Ok, I'll change back the adjustment to pass quality. I still think you will find yourself affected by stamina and morale, though, and will probably not notice much of a change to completion pcts, and it will maybe go back up by 10% or so.

I did run a bunch test sims with these settings before putting them live and the QB's were getting between 45 and 65% completion %'s at lvs 8-12, so it's not like I didn't test it out.


I don't think changing the pass quality was necessarily a bad idea, but you kind of forgot about the little guys in doing so.
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Thanks Bort.
 
panther17
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Ok, I'll change back the adjustment to pass quality. I still think you will find yourself affected by stamina and morale, though, and will probably not notice much of a change to completion pcts, and it will maybe go back up by 10% or so.

I did run a bunch test sims with these settings before putting them live and the QB's were getting between 45 and 65% completion %'s at lvs 8-12, so it's not like I didn't test it out.


Stamina increase is staying right?
 
CWickson
offline
Link
 
The QB facing my team this week was lvl 10. I had 2 lvl 1 CB and a lvl 2 SS. He completed 34.7% of his passes and threw 3 picks, 0 TDs.

 
E-A-G-L-E-S
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by claystone
Originally posted by Bort

Ok, I'll change back the adjustment to pass quality. I still think you will find yourself affected by stamina and morale, though, and will probably not notice much of a change to completion pcts, and it will maybe go back up by 10% or so.

I did run a bunch test sims with these settings before putting them live and the QB's were getting between 45 and 65% completion %'s at lvs 8-12, so it's not like I didn't test it out.



Bort, can't you assign levels of players to be "Pop warner / High School / college / Pro. We can understand more why our players are not so good if this was the case. It will also help against huge mismatches. Say level 13 playing level 5.


I coulda sworn there were A, AA, AAA and Pro Leagues...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.