User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Weight Classes
Page:
 
Kavadas
offline
Link
 
Instead of having weight classes why not just have these strengths and weaknesses dynamically based off the height/weight roll at character creation? So instead of having floors and ceilings for weight classes the values would be dynamically constant (lol) no matter what the height/weight is.

So like find out which particular weight/height would be your "neutral" starting point (no particular bonus or weakness) and work outwards from there.
Last edited Nov 25, 2008 05:20:53
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by TheInfinity

How about fixing the value of strength and carrying.


Maybe if people didn't bitch to high heaven every time their guy misses a tackle or two, I could ramp that up. That should be another thread, though.


Well that encourages the people who refuse to add strength, like LB's. There is a LB thread that basically tells all LB's to ignore strength, so ratchet it up and ignore the crybabies.
 
ProfessionalKop
Gangstalicious
offline
Link
 
i cant do math.
 
mandyross
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheInfinity
Originally posted by Knick

Originally posted by clute62


only problem is we never got to choose our weight


Bort said he could put a normal training option to lose/gain weight


Could just give everyone a chance to assign a new weight to their player, that way they can go into the class they want and start from there. It'd only be fair considering most people didn't pay attention to weight when they made their players.


It is only a good idea if everyone can reassign their height/weight, as some of us created players when it had no noticeable affect.
 
JetrawrX
offline
Link
 
that wo be cool! how bout height also lol
from 5'5 - 6'8
Last edited Nov 25, 2008 09:31:18
 
Titansfan94
offline
Link
 
This would be sick
 
TJ Spikes
offline
Link
 
just thoguht of 1 potential glitch... and a potential solution.

if 100 Speed = max 40 times (as per NFL guys), what would 50 Speed mean? Twice as slow? For the little guys that's like an 8 second 40. It seems like we'd have to stuff 100 Speed rating points into maybe 2 seconds worth of time, in order to be anywhere near realistic. That would break down into about 5 Speed attribute points knocking 1 tenth off your 40 time.

But then that doesn't allow for the acceleration mechanic either, going from a dead stop to top speed in 40 yards or less is almost as much about acceleration as it is about speed.
 
BarrySwitzer
offline
Link
 
This will just add more re-rolls.
 
GRIDIRONxGURU
offline
Link
 
yeah all of a suddent the roll becomes a necessity... on height weight... and not just the numbers... if im reading correctly... :cringes:

"E"
 
rowyho
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Just thought up this random idea while driving in the car


What do you drive?
 
NutsNutsNutz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rowyho
Originally posted by Bort

Just thought up this random idea while driving in the car


What do you drive?


Lol.
 
NutsNutsNutz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TJ Spikes
just thoguht of 1 potential glitch... and a potential solution.

if 100 Speed = max 40 times (as per NFL guys), what would 50 Speed mean? Twice as slow? For the little guys that's like an 8 second 40. It seems like we'd have to stuff 100 Speed rating points into maybe 2 seconds worth of time, in order to be anywhere near realistic. That would break down into about 5 Speed attribute points knocking 1 tenth off your 40 time.

But then that doesn't allow for the acceleration mechanic either, going from a dead stop to top speed in 40 yards or less is almost as much about acceleration as it is about speed.


Dead stop to full speed for NFL athletes is probably like 10 yards max.
 
iMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NutsNutsNutz
Originally posted by TJ Spikes

just thoguht of 1 potential glitch... and a potential solution.

if 100 Speed = max 40 times (as per NFL guys), what would 50 Speed mean? Twice as slow? For the little guys that's like an 8 second 40. It seems like we'd have to stuff 100 Speed rating points into maybe 2 seconds worth of time, in order to be anywhere near realistic. That would break down into about 5 Speed attribute points knocking 1 tenth off your 40 time.

But then that doesn't allow for the acceleration mechanic either, going from a dead stop to top speed in 40 yards or less is almost as much about acceleration as it is about speed.


Dead stop to full speed for NFL athletes is probably like 10 yards max.


world class sprinters take 30 yards to get to max speed
that is because they have a high top speed and they cover the distance relatively fast
 
Dinien
offline
Link
 
Bort Do it. Anything that makes players less of the cookie cutters that they are beginning to be is worth it.
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mandyross
Originally posted by TheInfinity

Originally posted by Knick


Originally posted by clute62



only problem is we never got to choose our weight


Bort said he could put a normal training option to lose/gain weight


Could just give everyone a chance to assign a new weight to their player, that way they can go into the class they want and start from there. It'd only be fair considering most people didn't pay attention to weight when they made their players.


It is only a good idea if everyone can reassign their height/weight, as some of us created players when it had no noticeable affect.


Reassigning weight isn't needed. Your guard weighs 298, my corner weighs 189. All the heights/weights are already realistic for their positions. We definitely need to be able to add/loose weight (I'd think instead of training, we could make it an offseason thing. On day 40, you input a target weight, guy works towards that), but the current heights/weights will put everyone in a realistic range where any bonuses/penalties are already relevant. Then, we each just need to do whatever to tweak it towards the area we prefer. Max weight may not be better, the 4th class might be ideal.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.