User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by cdcollins
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by cdcollins


Originally posted by Bort



Maybe blocking should give the player a higher radius at which he can engage the block? Right now it just determines how well you can hold it when you do engage, but everyone's distance to engage is the same.

That would seem to make some sense, no?

Other idea: Maybe guys with 8 vision shouldn't get the instant jump on the snap, either. I could easily extend the "snap delay" code to D-line guys on pass plays.


Here, SI. I did the work for you. Happy, now?


why would a person be able to block further than their arms can reach? Your arms don't get longer the more you play football? How are you going to block without your arms??


You missed the point entirely. And you bring up something about arm length, which has zero bearing in GLB.

I don't know if you ever played O-Line, and if you haven't the concept is foreign to you. Good O-Linemen work consistently on improving their block radius: the distance they can move from side-to-side, shifting in order to engage in blocks at wider radii. If I've understood Bort correctly, this is the exact same for every player, no exception. As it stands, this is a bit strange, and not an accurate representation of any football I've ever seen, real or fictional. Agility and speed, yes, should have a role to play in this, as you need agility to shuttle. But blocking should have an increased importance because, I don't know, isn't a lineman's job to BLOCK?


boy you are misunderstanding everything. My understanding of block radius is how far away from the OT the DE can be and still be engaged. You seem to be factoring speed into that equation.

I think Bort is saying should we make blocking extend the distance from the middle of the dot that a OT would "engage or lock up" with that DE. This would be AFTER all the shuffling and speed are already played out and they are nearing a collision.

Bort is saying that all players regardless of speed, agility, or strength now engage or lock up with a DE at the exact same distance. Nothing else. And that is the way it should be unless you take arm length into consideration.
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ron2288
Derick Thomas had 7 sacks against anon agile and slow OT...but when he went against a guy that did have some speed and agility..he was shut down..hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm


Call me crazy, but isn't this the NFL record for a single game? The all-time record? The never been broken in the 10000+ games of NFL history record?

If this is the case, is it such a leap of faith to be up in arms when DEs get 5+ commonplace? Just not a valid argument, IMO.
 
chief31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ron2288


then if speed and agility is not need in RL..think what guys like Charles Haley, jevon Kerse, Derrick Thomas would have done against guys that stood like a stone...oh wait Derick Thomas had 7 sacks against anon agile and slow OT...but when he went against a guy that did have some speed and agility..he was shut down..hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm


I didn't say that AGILITY isn't needed. I said that SPEED isn't. I am implying that AGILITY is needed.

 
ron2288
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cdcollins
Originally posted by ron2288

Derick Thomas had 7 sacks against anon agile and slow OT...but when he went against a guy that did have some speed and agility..he was shut down..hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm


Call me crazy, but isn't this the NFL record for a single game? The all-time record? The never been broken in the 10000+ games of NFL history record?

If this is the case, is it such a leap of faith to be up in arms when DEs get 5+ commonplace? Just not a valid argument, IMO.


well lets see hmm you got 1000's onpon 1000's more player on glb then in the nfl..so you got that many more different builds going against each other,,so you add the all the possibilities and out comes out..you will get 1000's onpon 1000's different results. again you want to say speed and agility are not needed for an OT..I have
shown why they are...and this rebuttal is all you have..hmmm
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by cdcollins


Originally posted by Bort



Maybe blocking should give the player a higher radius at which he can engage the block? Right now it just determines how well you can hold it when you do engage, but everyone's distance to engage is the same.

That would seem to make some sense, no?

Other idea: Maybe guys with 8 vision shouldn't get the instant jump on the snap, either. I could easily extend the "snap delay" code to D-line guys on pass plays.


Here, SI. I did the work for you. Happy, now?


why would a person be able to block further than their arms can reach? Your arms don't get longer the more you play football? How are you going to block without your arms??



No, but you could get better at reaching out and making those blocks as the guy goes past. The suggestion I was thinking of wouldn't make you have a 10 foot radius or something; maybe just dial the min range back by half a foot and the max up by half a foot from what they are currently.


Personally, I think things were fine as they were last year. 50% of the sacks were against gutted teams. 25% were caused by poor builds. And 10-15% could be eliminated with the TE and RB options. I don't think OT's need any more help to be honest.

Whether OT's like it or not, the game is very boring with no sacks. DE's are bored to death and OT's have no way to measure themselves.

My team only gave up 25-30 sacks a year for the last 2 years. Even then, most of those were against back-ups. I think that is very realistic - 1 or 2 a game? Do we really need to cut that back?
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by cdcollins

Originally posted by SteelersInsider


Originally posted by cdcollins



Originally posted by Bort




Maybe blocking should give the player a higher radius at which he can engage the block? Right now it just determines how well you can hold it when you do engage, but everyone's distance to engage is the same.

That would seem to make some sense, no?

Other idea: Maybe guys with 8 vision shouldn't get the instant jump on the snap, either. I could easily extend the "snap delay" code to D-line guys on pass plays.


Here, SI. I did the work for you. Happy, now?


why would a person be able to block further than their arms can reach? Your arms don't get longer the more you play football? How are you going to block without your arms??


You missed the point entirely. And you bring up something about arm length, which has zero bearing in GLB.

I don't know if you ever played O-Line, and if you haven't the concept is foreign to you. Good O-Linemen work consistently on improving their block radius: the distance they can move from side-to-side, shifting in order to engage in blocks at wider radii. If I've understood Bort correctly, this is the exact same for every player, no exception. As it stands, this is a bit strange, and not an accurate representation of any football I've ever seen, real or fictional. Agility and speed, yes, should have a role to play in this, as you need agility to shuttle. But blocking should have an increased importance because, I don't know, isn't a lineman's job to BLOCK?


boy you are misunderstanding everything. My understanding of block radius is how far away from the OT the DE can be and still be engaged. You seem to be factoring speed into that equation.

I think Bort is saying should we make blocking extend the distance from the middle of the dot that a OT would "engage or lock up" with that DE. This would be AFTER all the shuffling and speed are already played out and they are nearing a collision.

Bort is saying that all players regardless of speed, agility, or strength now engage or lock up with a DE at the exact same distance. Nothing else. And that is the way it should be unless you take arm length into consideration.


Wow, for someone who accused me of trying to take out speed entirely, and couldn't find evidence of it when I called him out on it, now saying that I'm factoring speed into the equation looks a little retrospective, doesn't it?

I don't think I'm misunderstanding anything, boy. It's the distance *to* engage the block, not engaging the block *at* the same distance. A slight difference in semantics with a fairly striking difference. And it takes this weird "arm length" you envision out of the equation

But of course, no one can ever, ever be wrong on teh internets. But I could very well be wrong on this legislation assignment for tomorrow. Good night, everyone.


 
chief31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by chief31



And I believe that that is how GLB intends for AGILITY to work. If a real life OT doesn't need SPEED to be a good pass-blocker, then it is silly to make a GLB OT need SPEED for that purpose.

He may as well be needing PUNTING. Whatever unneccessary attribute that you are making OTs build, it is still not right.

People come here for the "football SIM". If we aren't rtrying to simulate real football, then what are we trying to do?



speed is how quickly you get from point A to point B. Nothing more, nothing less. Distance/time.

If we are try to figure out how to get the OT to move quicker from point A (where he started) to point B (where he needs to be to get in the way of the DE), isn't the LOGICAL thing to do.....to increase the speed?

P.S. and "nimble" isn't the correct word either - it has quickness in it also and is just another synonym for agile. A better word would be more like "turning".


You go tell the dictionaries not to use the word nimble. I haven't used it. Just quoted the definition.

As far as getting from point A to point B, one might have thought that SPEED made sense, before the start of season four.

 
Talon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Talon

Originally posted by Bort


Maybe blocking should give the player a higher radius at which he can engage the block? Right now it just determines how well you can hold it when you do engage, but everyone's distance to engage is the same.

That would seem to make some sense, no?

Other idea: Maybe guys with 8 vision shouldn't get the instant jump on the snap, either. I could easily extend the "snap delay" code to D-line guys on pass plays.


On your first thought, I always thought that was part of blocking. The fundamental problem right now appears to be the stat itself having no apparent counterpart for the defensive players. Meaning, what is 'anti-blocking'? The OP's complaint was that the Speed/Agility DE ran right by him, and people responded he needed more Speed/Agility. So if the LOTs start training Speed and Agility, they neglect Blocking. If a defender concentrates on Speed and Agility, he loses little right now.



shed block is the anti-blocking.


So how much each point of Shed Block negates how many points in Blocking? Is it 1 for 1?
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ron2288
Originally posted by cdcollins

Originally posted by ron2288


Derick Thomas had 7 sacks against anon agile and slow OT...but when he went against a guy that did have some speed and agility..he was shut down..hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm


Call me crazy, but isn't this the NFL record for a single game? The all-time record? The never been broken in the 10000+ games of NFL history record?

If this is the case, is it such a leap of faith to be up in arms when DEs get 5+ commonplace? Just not a valid argument, IMO.


well lets see hmm you got 1000's onpon 1000's more player on glb then in the nfl..so you got that many more different builds going against each other,,so you add the all the possibilities and out comes out..you will get 1000's onpon 1000's different results. again you want to say speed and agility are not needed for an OT..I have
shown why they are...and this rebuttal is all you have..hmmm


You've shown 1 stinking replay, and reiterated your same exact post 3 times. What a rebuttal yours was and has been. That wouldn't win an elementary debate club, friend.

You've also had 1000s upon 1000s of DEs going up against 1000s upon 1000s of OTs in the NFL. They had hundreds of different 40-yard dash time, hundreds of different shuttle times, hundreds of different bench-presses, etc. The point being, if GLB wishes to be anything resembling an accurate representation of RL football, it should try to mirror RL a bit more.

Edit:
You go out of your way to show that I obviously don't want speed/agility to be taken into account. Except I have. EXPLICITLY.
If SI can't do it, obviously you're not going to be able to. I swear to all that's good, I posted it on THIS VERY PAGE that speed/agility should be necessary. It's obvious the kid hasn't read any of this thread.

Last edited Nov 12, 2008 01:04:40
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
SI is right about the speed attribute - a guy with 10 speed is slow as dirt no matter what he is doing. Speed determines the limit on how fast you can go, and if your top speed is 1 pixel per second, no amount of agility is going to make you go any faster. You'll just be able to shift your 1 pixel per second speed into a different direction quicker.



Chief-

Here is your answer straight from Bort:

agility doesn't make you move from point A to point B. Neither does strength or blocking. The only thing that is going to get your OT's ass in front of the DE is speed. Think of it as movement, call it quickness if that helps you sleep better at night. But speed = how quickly your OT moves.

Don't need to argue about the definition that the game uses, DD make it clear early on what agility is defined as (how quickly your player can TURN). If you watch the sims, you would know that as well. Turning isn't a football term and would be more complicated as "turning" has alot of meanings also.

But like I said earlier: Agility can be shown if you are sitting on an axis. The more agility, the faster you can turn on that axis. That's it. It doesn't get you from point A to point B. Period.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Talon
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by Talon


Originally posted by Bort



Maybe blocking should give the player a higher radius at which he can engage the block? Right now it just determines how well you can hold it when you do engage, but everyone's distance to engage is the same.

That would seem to make some sense, no?

Other idea: Maybe guys with 8 vision shouldn't get the instant jump on the snap, either. I could easily extend the "snap delay" code to D-line guys on pass plays.


On your first thought, I always thought that was part of blocking. The fundamental problem right now appears to be the stat itself having no apparent counterpart for the defensive players. Meaning, what is 'anti-blocking'? The OP's complaint was that the Speed/Agility DE ran right by him, and people responded he needed more Speed/Agility. So if the LOTs start training Speed and Agility, they neglect Blocking. If a defender concentrates on Speed and Agility, he loses little right now.



shed block is the anti-blocking.


So how much each point of Shed Block negates how many points in Blocking? Is it 1 for 1?


No one knows.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by chief31

You go tell the dictionaries not to use the word nimble. I haven't used it. Just quoted the definition.

As far as getting from point A to point B, one might have thought that SPEED made sense, before the start of season four.



I thought you were suggesting that nimble would be a better word to use in the sim instead of agility. Now that you know what the sim uses (agility doesn't include any speed or movement at all), what word is better than agility to use?

Speed? season 4? huh? what are you talking about?
 
Talon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Talon

Originally posted by SteelersInsider


Originally posted by Talon



Originally posted by Bort




Maybe blocking should give the player a higher radius at which he can engage the block? Right now it just determines how well you can hold it when you do engage, but everyone's distance to engage is the same.

That would seem to make some sense, no?

Other idea: Maybe guys with 8 vision shouldn't get the instant jump on the snap, either. I could easily extend the "snap delay" code to D-line guys on pass plays.


On your first thought, I always thought that was part of blocking. The fundamental problem right now appears to be the stat itself having no apparent counterpart for the defensive players. Meaning, what is 'anti-blocking'? The OP's complaint was that the Speed/Agility DE ran right by him, and people responded he needed more Speed/Agility. So if the LOTs start training Speed and Agility, they neglect Blocking. If a defender concentrates on Speed and Agility, he loses little right now.



shed block is the anti-blocking.


So how much each point of Shed Block negates how many points in Blocking? Is it 1 for 1?


No one knows.


I guess I'm curious how few SP put into Shed Block make far more SP spent on Blocking irrelevant.
 
Black Peter
offline
Link
 
So O-lineman should really just stop around the first soft-cap for blocking skill, and just let it auto-level from there, then if it's so irrelevant. That way they'd have the points to buff up str/spd/agility/vision as needed. Who'd of thunkit? Doesn't seem right, but if that's the way blocking works then it seems right. No wonder blocking FBs don't need much blocking to work right.
 
ron2288
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cdcollins
Originally posted by ron2288

Originally posted by cdcollins


Originally posted by ron2288



Derick Thomas had 7 sacks against anon agile and slow OT...but when he went against a guy that did have some speed and agility..he was shut down..hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm


Call me crazy, but isn't this the NFL record for a single game? The all-time record? The never been broken in the 10000+ games of NFL history record?

If this is the case, is it such a leap of faith to be up in arms when DEs get 5+ commonplace? Just not a valid argument, IMO.


well lets see hmm you got 1000's onpon 1000's more player on glb then in the nfl..so you got that many more different builds going against each other,,so you add the all the possibilities and out comes out..you will get 1000's onpon 1000's different results. again you want to say speed and agility are not needed for an OT..I have
shown why they are...and this rebuttal is all you have..hmmm


You've shown 1 stinking replay, and reiterated your same exact post 3 times. What a rebuttal yours was and has been. That wouldn't win an elementary debate club, friend.

You've also had 1000s upon 1000s of DEs going up against 1000s upon 1000s of OTs in the NFL. They had hundreds of different 40-yard dash time, hundreds of different shuttle times, hundreds of different bench-presses, etc. The point being, if GLB wishes to be anything resembling an accurate representation of RL football, it should try to mirror RL a bit more.

Edit:
You go out of your way to show that I obviously don't want speed/agility to be taken into account. Except I have. EXPLICITLY.
If SI can't do it, obviously you're not going to be able to. I swear to all that's good, I posted it on THIS VERY PAGE that speed/agility should be necessary. It's obvious the kid hasn't read any of this thread.



try agin...I post the same play twice..but I also threw in a different play...so who is not reading everything!!!


http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=223987&pbp_id=1410622


http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=223987&pbp_id=1410559


one play is the OT going one on one with my DE..the other is the same OT going against a LB and My DE...so evidently you did not rad all post..hmmm

so again your argument is shot down


if you look close enough you will even see one is on 1st down and the other 2nd down...hard to be the same play on two different downs....


so kiddo...read everything....kid...

also Kid if you want I can find a lot more....
there again ones who want to cry and complain....it is getting old
Last edited Nov 12, 2008 02:09:15
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.