User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > New Plays/Playbooks
Page:
 
harshmellow
offline
Link
 
[Edit] made a separate topic with my suggestion
Last edited Nov 2, 2008 08:59:47
 
PSUScott1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort


OOP penalty is fairly high for HB -> QB tho. QB is really the only position that can play QB without at least a 30-40% OOP penalty.


Does that apply across the board to all attributes? Specifically...is a HB playing QB slower than the same HB playing HB?
 
Amyrlin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
I think we gotta stick to the one QB slot. This game tries to resemble real life, and in real life you dont have QB slots for different packages or situations. You just tailor your whole offense around a QB. Vick in Atlanta, or Manning in Indy.



Um.

Try tuning in to some Saturday football sometime?
 
harshmellow
offline
Link
 
Well no one replied to my other post and it's fallen off the first page, so I'll repost here:

Let us set the % we want to use each formation from the basic tactics page. That'd make it vastly easier to favor certain formations over others without creating dozens of outputs for every input in the advanced AI.

Or, allow us to just check off however many formations we want to use with a specific output. For example, if you want to go 35% inside run on 1st down, you check off I weak I and strong I and you'll only use those formations rather than having to make 3 nearly identical outputs.
 
Valhalla
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Llyranwyar
Let's say that a QB1 spot was put in.

Let's say that there are several teams that build a pure passer and a pure runner and switch them out per play.

Lets say that bort makes the changes to allow the DC to scout the other team, identify that the Team uses a pure rushing QB1, and make a QB rush specific defensive selection.

Then lets say the team in question running the QB is aware that this is an important game against a DC who will put the time in to do all that. You still get screwed when he makes the last minute switch to pocket pass QB1 offense. He reverses his offense to put his rush QB at QB and pass QB at QB1. Suddenly everything is reversed and you are defending the run on pass plays and vice versa.

The only way I could think of to fix that, is to instead make the DC able to create a list of "seleceted player names" for your opponent that would trigger your alternate defenses. Have fun figuring out all of those special characters.

I just see that getting very complex.


I would think that this makes the most sense and I would love to see that added to the defensive AI even if the QB1 slot wasn't implemented.

It would have to be added to the input along with formation, etc to either have a specific player added (via a browse where you could select the player) or nothing which would mean "any".

So if this was doable, the input would contain these extra variables-

Player Position Slot



That way you can select a player, select the position and the slot (but keep "any" as an option for each)

That would take care of the switching scenario you're referring to and it would also lay the groundwork for eventually having outputs that would have those same options for a particular CB to cover a particular WR, etc...



Last edited Nov 2, 2008 16:41:09
 
Agent Z
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I left extra slots out on QB's and some other positions for a reason. Only way there will be another QB slot is if it's limited to only QB's. I don't want to see HB's running QB rollout plays.


wildcat O is in the Pro's now!
 
statman68
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I left extra slots out on QB's and some other positions for a reason. Only way there will be another QB slot is if it's limited to only QB's. I don't want to see HB's running QB rollout plays.


That's fine, but I think we need it. If you have a pocket passer with no speed and a rushing QB there is no way to separate the 2 right now. Isn't there something you can add in to prevent adding anything but a QB into the QB slot?
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Bort?

Not to completely derail this, but have you considered modifying your linebacker slots from right/left to weak side/strong side?

If the offense shifts the strong attack side, I would certainly like to shift my defense to cover that attack.

Other than that, I went through all the plays and just selecting three formations I can build a playbook of 55 plays to cover all situations. Not too bad..

It will be difficult to be a defensive co-ordinator this season. please consider removing the little oddities you put in to slow down the defenses (like the linebackers backing up on the snap.. Maybe some others), as the offense looks to have a bit of an advantage early.

PinTBC

Pin
 
Canadaleaf
offline
Link
 
we need some Wildcat plays imo
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Bort in the first 15 pages ...

========================================================
PLAYS


Did the Goalline plays get voted out?? Or forgotten to be uploaded? Or are they to be added later? Also, did any Goalline pass plays get created?
>> I didn't make any new goalline plays, and there's only 3 of them (2 HB, 1 FB rush) at the moment, so I didn't bother to put it into the playbook. I'll get to making some pass plays from GL and such and then there will be a reason to put it in.


Why are there no play action type sets??? For teams that like to run alot or have mobile QB's this would help make things more balanced. It would also allow for more plays in every set like the Goaline set.
>> I agree. I've been working on play action, but it's not ready for prime time yet.
I'll get more GL plays in over time.



Both Pitches and Sweeps are listed alongside off-tackle runs in the playbook. When you use the offensive AI builder, are all the "pitch-sweep" plays clearly labeled as so, and offtackle clearly not?
>> I should update the text on that - the off-tackle selection in the OAI has effectively become "non-pitch" now.
>> If there's a little dotted line from the QB to the HB, it's a pitch.


No 'Single Back Big' plays anymore Bort?
>> There was only 1 before, and I didn't get around to adding more to it, so I took it out for now. I plan to keep expanding the play selection, though, so it'll come back!


========================================================
USING THE AI


Is using "random" for formation going to cause problems? For instance, if we have inside run with "random" will it randomly choose a 5 WR set and be broken (kind of like long TE passes will break now)?
>> If you choose "inside run" with random formation it will choose one of your selected inside run plays from your playbook at random.


I would think it will pick out of all the formations you have in the play books for inside runs. Could pick a 5 WR set QB run if it is in your play book.
>> Yes, assuming you have QB run set higher than 0% in your basic settings.


Also, bort, when you create playbooks, will you have the option to use various playbooks in a game or by quarter?
>> Hm, I didn't think of that option really. Not at the moment - you just set which one you want to be active and it will use that one for the whole game.


Having a two-minute drill playbook or a down big playbook could really save OCs a ton of time.
>> That's actually very true, and a great point. Hm, I'll think on it.
I've got various other ideas to expand on the playbook settings as well, such as affinities for each play (use frequently, less frequent, etc) and possibly substitution stuff. I'm hoping that eventually using playbooks with the basic settings could help even out the field for the folks who have trouble with the AI.
I'm also thinking of doing something similar with a defensive playbook that works for the basic tactics where you choose the plays for each tactic settings (defend pass short, defend outside run, etc).



1. QB Kneel classified as how much time? 45 secs?
>> 1. QB Kneel works like any running play. It will use up clock the same as a running play would, so maximum clock if you're winning, etc. It's mainly added so you don't fumble when there's 50 seconds left on the clock.


If there's 50 secs on the clock, 4th down, and I call QB kneel will the game be over with 0 secs left? In football it's 45 secs, so just wanted to be sure it's 45 here or ??
>> I just looked in the sim engine and it runs of 45 seconds when trying to use max clock, so however long the play takes to run (prolly 1 second) plus runoff.


Bort did you decide not to set a minimum number of plays per group?? If thats the case then I can send you a PM about a planned Exploit that is already doing the rounds.
>> go for it - min plays is currently 1 per group since some groups only have 2 plays I think.
>> There's only 1 medium FB play, actually.
>> … what Mike brought up was an interesting strategy which could create a meta-game for sure. It would require very specific personnel and a very specific playbook set.
I'll test it out and see what happens; my first thought on it is that it won't nearly be as effective as people think unless the defense you play has a bad secondary.



========================================================
DEPTH CHART STUFF


any plans to add RB3 to AI becuase some teams use 3 rbs and if selected can use default rb
>> There's already 3 RB slots (RB, RB1, RB2).


How about adding QB1 and QB2? Not being able to choose what QB to use on the QB rush plays makes it unusable for 90% of teams.
Noooooo RB at QB3 position...FB's at the FB and HB position, QB sweeps all day with an extra blocker. Scary stuff.
>> Yeah, I'd like to limit that kind of crap.


Just add a restriction to the custom depth chart.
>> That's a great idea - only allow QB's or HB's or whatever the slot is for?


>> I left extra slots out on QB's and some other positions for a reason. Only way there will be another QB slot is if it's limited to only QB's. I don't want to see HB's running QB rollout plays.


>> You'll see HB's who have QB as their position instead of HB. I guess QB's wouldn't get all the SA's to head fake and power through, etc, though. Could make "Demoralize" really good though.


Does Demoralize work on QB run plays? It mentions plays made outside of the pocket, and in running plays there isn't really a pocket to make a play outside of.
>> Oh yeah, you're right - it only activates in "scrambling" mode.


>> OOP penalty is fairly high for HB -> QB tho. QB is really the only position that can play QB without at least a 30-40% OOP penalty.


I thought OOP topped out at like 15-20%, and most positions were like 5-10%.
>> Oh no. You really think a DT playing K would only get a 20% penalty? 5% penalties are for the easy position movements like CB -> FS or LB -> DE or something like that.


…is the OOP penalty for QB playing HB also around 40%?
>> Yeah, QB's don't really do well doing much else other than playing QB.

I think GG might be on the right track with general restrictions on playing OOP. Nobody's really abused it yet, but the more options we add, the more likely they will.



========================================================
DEFENSE


Defensive plays...no 3-4, that's to be uploaded before pre-season?
>> maybe, if I get to it. The plays that are in there are some of the old ones that have already been built, with a few updates for the new stuff I've put in since then. I definitely do want to expand them, though, because I have further plans.


what about the defensive book i was looking at the pre made formations and there is no quarter only dime. but there are no 4 wr sets yet. will there be plays with 5 cb?
>> I'll add more over time. These were the plays I already had in there.


Bort, with all of the added passes to FB's and HB's, will there be any more control - or built in 'smart' adjustment - to getting man coverage on them by non-blitzing LB's or the SS? Speaking mainly of the tendency to end up with double coverage on the TE and a LB having to chase the RB down from across the field.
>> All defenders have a "progression" they follow as to who to defend in man. Maybe some of the plays just need an adjustment to them.


Another worry is that when playing Cover 0 close, the FS also runs down to the line of scrimmage to meet the HB/FB at full speed. If the HB is running a fly pattern and the pass is deeper than it was last season, that can spell big trouble. If you cant use Cover 0 Close for fear of the HB getting free too often, you cant force tight double teams by the CBs anymore either...
>> I'd like to get CB -> WR matchup options put in sooner than later (including double teaming)


The problem is that the player's progression doesn't adjust to eachother. So you can't blitz a Rolb and an MLB out of the 43 cover1 and still have a running back covered in passing. You just get the TE double teamed and the RB open every play for big yards. That really limits our ability to attack the line.
>> Hm, that was certainly less of a problem with the pre-made plays, I guess.


========================================================
OTHER


When a player tries to do something, the relevant football skill(s) are compared to the relevant physical skill(s). If the football skill is lower than a certain threshold computed from the physical skills, the player incurs a penalty - again, the lower the football skill, the higher the penalty. So a player with 30 strength may only need 20 throwing to perform adequately - but a player with 70 strength would require 45 throwing to perform at the same level. A player with 70 strength and 20 throwing would throw horribly. (IMO the best solution.)
>> That's already kinda how it works. Whenever I've cranked up the effect, the bugs forum goes crazy


========================================================
Last edited Nov 2, 2008 18:11:58
 
harshmellow
offline
Link
 
Another suggestion: add a button to clone a particular output or input. That way creating 10 inputs for slightly different scenarios or creating specific outputs isn't ridiculously time consuming.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by GG

[This is kinda
the problem here, because Bort has programmed the football skills very
HIGH by default to allow low level players to actually play a good
standard of football that makes it as realistic as the pros in terms of
completions, catches, etc.


Probably because I give in to bitching too often. Everyone wants their player to be perfect.




I don't want my player to be perfect. I understand that in football there is no "perfect" player, they can only try to give it 110%. *lightbulb appears over my head*
what about a new stat - maybe - " Heart" ? ( Ever notice how in football some players -even though they may not be the strongest, or fastest player, at their position, still excell ?) That's what I call Heart. Lion Heart ( Like Barry Sanders or "RUDY") that "never give up" attitude.... another way to differentiate each player/ make them unique/ add depth.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Wow, this thread has helped me realize TONS of possible exploits for the offense.

There MUST be a way for defenses to adjust to offensive personnel, including assignments and different defensive packages based upon the HB or QB in the game
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer

There MUST be a way for defenses to adjust to offensive personnel, including assignments and different defensive packages based upon the HB or QB in the game


Team's can't specify which QB to use in which play as of yet, so no lame cheesy extra blocker HB sweeps.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by thunderdoozer


There MUST be a way for defenses to adjust to offensive personnel, including assignments and different defensive packages based upon the HB or QB in the game


Team's can't specify which QB to use in which play as of yet, so no lame cheesy extra blocker HB sweeps.


Even still... We should be able to adjust our defenses to whether the power back or a wide receiver is lined up in the backfield, or if a WR lines up in the TE2 spot, etc.

Last edited Nov 2, 2008 21:44:43
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.