User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Barnsie
Originally posted by Schaffer05

Normally wouldn't do this, but since I have my HB playing 3rd string HB and FB backup I don't figure much harm could come of it... This is what a power HB builds like


Strength: 70.13 Blocking: 14.3
Speed: 51.13 Tackling: 8
Agility: 44.12 Throwing: 14.3
Jumping: 14.3 Catching: 16.3
Stamina: 32.3 Carrying: 36.59
Vision: 29.55 Kicking: 8
Confidence: 22.13 Punting: 8
2 quick cut, 2 first step
33331 power back


yea str may be one of the main attributes for fumbling, but guess what, speed is a main attribute to a good RB too. I've not neglected speed or agility like you elusive backs have neglected str and carrying.


My power HB has way more STR than you (by a lot), more carry, and more cover up SA. He's fumbling all the time this season. He fumbled 1 time last season.


You don't even have a HB. Are you referring to somebody on your team?
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
I'm guessing he's referring to someone on his team, and I doubt he has WAY more since he only has 15 more SPs than I do.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Vandiar I'm not singling you out, but these people complaining were saying fumbles are way up this season compared to last. Your HB has a history of fumbling all seasons past and i'm just pointing that out.
 
vandiar2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
But it makes no sense for agility to prevent fumbles. Face it...as a HB you're going to get tackled every once in awhile. I don't care how good you are; it's bound to happen. Strength will help you hold on to the ball. Strength and carrying. That's how it should work, because it makes sense. Why would agility prevent you from fumbling AFTER you get hit? It's a trade-off and you chose to go the elusive route. Also you still didn't tell me what your stamina was. I have a feeling that's at the root of most of these fumbling problems.

And we're not making it sound like it's just you complaining, I'm just trying to make a point that Bort already said he didn't change a thing, yet people are complaining that their backs are fumbling. Well guess what? If you're fumbling a lot, it's probably your build, not the sim. Also, 6 fumbles on the season is very reasonable. The problem is everyone always thinks their player is the best and should never fumble while breaking 20 tackles a game.


So what you are trying to say is I should just turn my elusive back into a combo back just to prevent fumbles. Thanks for the advice!
 
vandiar2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Vandiar I'm not singling you out, but these people complaining were saying fumbles are way up this season compared to last. Your HB has a history of fumbling all seasons past and i'm just pointing that out.


Yeah before I only had something like 25-30 carrying because at that time.. that was all that was needed. It wasn't until toward the end of that 15 fumble season I started to jack up carrying to prevent fumbles.
Last edited Oct 15, 2008 15:09:49
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vandiar2


So what you are trying to say is I should just turn my elusive back into a combo back just to prevent fumbles. Thanks for the advice!


You're very narrow minded, just so you know. NO YOU DO NOT HAVE TO MAKE HIM A COMBO BACK. My HB is far from a combo back, he's a POWER back and I got his speed and agility up to make him a GOOD power back. Your Elusive back is mediocre because you NEGLECTED your Str. Get your Str to soft cap NOTHING more and you won't be fumbling so often. Get your Carrying to soft cap and you'll probably fumble maybe once a season.
 
vandiar2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Originally posted by vandiar2



So what you are trying to say is I should just turn my elusive back into a combo back just to prevent fumbles. Thanks for the advice!


You're very narrow minded, just so you know. NO YOU DO NOT HAVE TO MAKE HIM A COMBO BACK. My HB is far from a combo back, he's a POWER back and I got his speed and agility up to make him a GOOD power back. Your Elusive back is mediocre because you NEGLECTED your Str. Get your Str to soft cap NOTHING more and you won't be fumbling so often. Get your Carrying to soft cap and you'll probably fumble maybe once a season.


I don't think you are still seeing my point. You brought up speed and agility (elusive primary stats) to make him a good power back.. both stats of which have one primary function. Strength on the other hand apparently has 2 functions, in which power backs have the advantage in obviously. So you can build a power back, and an elusive back in similar ways when discussing primary stats except power backs will fumble less than elusive backs. that is the point I am trying to make.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
We have a higher chance to break a tackle, less chance to fumble... so if I'm a power back with no speed that means shit... If you're an elusive back with soft capped str and carrying you're a great Elusive back because not only are you freaking fast and agile you're going to run over those puny little CBs on the corners and then outrun everyone else on the team, while my power back will run over that puny little CB but get caught 5 yards later by the quick LOLB
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vandiar2
Originally posted by Sik Wit It

But it makes no sense for agility to prevent fumbles. Face it...as a HB you're going to get tackled every once in awhile. I don't care how good you are; it's bound to happen. Strength will help you hold on to the ball. Strength and carrying. That's how it should work, because it makes sense. Why would agility prevent you from fumbling AFTER you get hit? It's a trade-off and you chose to go the elusive route. Also you still didn't tell me what your stamina was. I have a feeling that's at the root of most of these fumbling problems.

And we're not making it sound like it's just you complaining, I'm just trying to make a point that Bort already said he didn't change a thing, yet people are complaining that their backs are fumbling. Well guess what? If you're fumbling a lot, it's probably your build, not the sim. Also, 6 fumbles on the season is very reasonable. The problem is everyone always thinks their player is the best and should never fumble while breaking 20 tackles a game.


So what you are trying to say is I should just turn my elusive back into a combo back just to prevent fumbles. Thanks for the advice!


No, I was trying to say that an elusive back should have decent strength. Your back has okay strength, but 6 fumbles isn't even that bad in the first place.

And I'm not saying you should turn into a combo back, just a back that has enough strength to hold onto the ball when they get tackled...

People get too caught up in what type of player they're trying to build and what the ideal build would look like rather than just building a solid, balanced player that makes sense.
 
vandiar2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
We have a higher chance to break a tackle, less chance to fumble... so if I'm a power back with no speed that means shit... If you're an elusive back with soft capped str and carrying you're a great Elusive back because not only are you freaking fast and agile you're going to run over those puny little CBs on the corners and then outrun everyone else on the team, while my power back will run over that puny little CB but get caught 5 yards later by the quick LOLB


in order to achieve that though we have to pump up a lot of speed and agility. speed without agility is nothing. strength on the other hand for power backs, is the ONLY stat that needs to be significant over the others. in turn, you fumble less. Like you said, not only do you break tackles you fumble less. Two for the price of one. Elusive backs don't get this advantage. i just don't see the balance here.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
the balance is we can break a tackle but can't run for the TD... how aren't you seing this? when someone misses a tackle on you guys you're GONE... Just to show you that you're not all out of wack

Adrian Perterson of the Vikings has 129 carries and 3 fumbles on the year
Larry Johnson of the KC Chiefs has 93 carries with 3 fumbles on the year
Jamal Lewis (A POWER BACK) 90 with 0 fumbles
Reggie Bush 78 carries with 2 fumbles (prime example of a elusive back)

Stats aren't out of wack compared to Pros... Suck it up.
 
vandiar2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
the balance is we can break a tackle but can't run for the TD... how aren't you seing this? when someone misses a tackle on you guys you're GONE... Just to show you that you're not all out of wack

Adrian Perterson of the Vikings has 129 carries and 3 fumbles on the year
Larry Johnson of the KC Chiefs has 93 carries with 3 fumbles on the year
Jamal Lewis (A POWER BACK) 90 with 0 fumbles
Reggie Bush 78 carries with 2 fumbles (prime example of a elusive back)

Stats aren't out of wack compared to Pros... Suck it up.


I understand what you are saying, I am just trying to get you to see where I am coming from. If I break even run long run, but fumble twice in a game there is a huge possibility it could be negated. Essentially, protecting the ball always come first.. in which power backs have a clear advantage of. Good argument though, ya'll are making the time go by fast for me at work lol
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Yes, protecting the ball should always come first, but not putting your str to soft cap is not my fault, it's your own. Bort didn't keep it a secret that Str+carry=less fumbles, elusive backs just ignored this.
 
vandiar2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Yes, protecting the ball should always come first, but not putting your str to soft cap is not my fault, it's your own. Bort didn't keep it a secret that Str+carry=less fumbles, elusive backs just ignored this.


lol too bad you still don't see my point. let me see if I can give a good analogy. I don't know if you have ever played everquest or not but.. in everquest necromancers main stats were intelligence, and stamina. primary stats increased power pool for your class and each class had 2 primary stats. necromancers were highly unbalanced because their primary stats not only increased their power pool but stamina also increased their over all health. 2 for the price of 1. they were eventually nerfed....
Last edited Oct 15, 2008 15:31:53
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Yes, protecting the ball should always come first, but not putting your str to soft cap is not my fault, it's your own. Bort didn't keep it a secret that Str+carry=less fumbles, elusive backs just ignored this.


That's what I'm saying. Use some common sense when building your player. Do you think a HB with 30% strength will never fumble?

Also, you still never answered the stamina question.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.