User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Playoff Profit sharing...
Page:
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by xnahog
Originally posted by McGruffHawk

Originally posted by chriscuster


Really we should just go ahead and give some free money to non-playoff teams too. Why stop with playoff teams? I surely don't mind busting my ass all season to get a good record only to give away the reward to teams that didn't.

Goddam this is a horrible idea. Bad, bad, bad.


I know a lot of low seeded playoff teams and non playoff teams that "bust their asses"


Who?


http://goallineblitz.com/game/playoff_bracket.pl?league_id=17&conference_id=0

East Coast
West Scranton
Fiji
Emerald City
Rawle Tech
Brisbane Gods
IC

All these are currently slated as low seeded teams, and all are active teams with solid recruiting and managing.

Non-Playoff Teams:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/league.pl?league_id=17

Brisbane Bandits
New England
Perth
Canberra
Wagga Wagga
Melbourne
Co-Op City
Big Island
Saipan

All non-playoff teams that are either very competitive and active, or are rebuilding the right way and are deserving of revenue sharing.
Last edited Sep 30, 2008 14:32:50
 
Crushr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chriscuster
Originally posted by Crushr

Originally posted by tmoon


Originally posted by Crushr



Originally posted by chriscuster




Originally posted by tmoon





I guess by me not saying this is not a personal attack it wasn't good enough. Nixx you are a good person for helping people. Taking your free time and dedicating it to others is an admirable thing.

So me having an opinion is crap... man that communist mentality is spreading. Lets all freakin burn the red white and blue, read some Marx and share, share everything.

When you quoted me you took only part of the text and none of the previous comments about people wanting playoff teams to share their money with EVERYONE in the league including gutted and completely worthless teams. The couple of hours I put into this everyday shouldn't be equal to a guy who does nothing and wants the same reward... i.e. revenue sharing. Communist, pure and simple communist.

Social Welfare comes to GLB... that should be the next GLB radio broadcast.



Can flex point stamps for poor people be far behind?



Socialism? Marxism?? Cmon, back to reality please. Thats so far over the top its insane. In Socialism, they wouldn't just share playoff rev 75/25 or whatever the current plan is.. They share the entire seasons revenue equally.. And again, where do you get off stating that you work any harder than an owner who's team finishes in a #5-8 playoff spot? You just stated that you spend 2 hours a day on here... Thats all you spend on glb and you think you work harder than everyone else? Dude, I spend at LEAST 4 hours on this site every day.. On top of that I have built a webpage for my team and created a fantasy football league for them so your 2 hours a day
pales in comparison to what many owners put in.


Work smarter not harder. There have been days that all of my free hours have gone to GLB, and there have been times when my free time was spent on helping old ladies across the street... its a matter of preference. Did you ask anyone else to help with the website and recruiting? Ronald Reagan was not the best President or the smartest man to ever hold office but the reason he was successful was he hired good people to advise and support him. To make your time more managable find a few people you can trust on your team that are just as dedicated as you and put them in a position to succeed. Just a suggestion. Not all of my GM's go the extra mile, but they like to help, they want to help... hell my backup SS created a team website for our team without asking for anything but us to check it out in return... He didn't even ask me to be a GM. But this is off the topic.

Don't share with underachievers, make them work harder. BTW there is never a guarantee that your team will win or lose or even make it to the playoffs no matter how hard you work, some people quit and gut their teams, some people beg for Bort to make things fair (give us money and help) others just find a way to win the next season...


First off, I don't need advice from you. You don't know my situation at all. Additionally, I am sick of this stupid argument that you are entitled to 30 times the money of the lower 4 seeded teams. Thats not the case in ANY sport. Your argument is that you insist on being rewarded exorbitantly for your teams success. My argument is that ALL playoff teams should reap the benefits of their hard work. Also, I thought you said earlier that no one worked hard if they weren't a top 4 seed yet you just stated that working hard is no guarantee of making the playoffs. Those 2 statements just don't mesh.


Playoff teams get the playoff bonuses. They ARE rewarded.

You want to reward them more, make the bonuses more.



HAHHAAAAA! 100k is a REWARD?? So you really feel that giving 1-4 seeds up to 30x's th playoff revenue is fair?
 
chriscuster
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Crushr
Originally posted by chriscuster

Originally posted by Crushr


Originally posted by tmoon



Originally posted by Crushr




Originally posted by chriscuster





Originally posted by tmoon






I guess by me not saying this is not a personal attack it wasn't good enough. Nixx you are a good person for helping people. Taking your free time and dedicating it to others is an admirable thing.

So me having an opinion is crap... man that communist mentality is spreading. Lets all freakin burn the red white and blue, read some Marx and share, share everything.

When you quoted me you took only part of the text and none of the previous comments about people wanting playoff teams to share their money with EVERYONE in the league including gutted and completely worthless teams. The couple of hours I put into this everyday shouldn't be equal to a guy who does nothing and wants the same reward... i.e. revenue sharing. Communist, pure and simple communist.

Social Welfare comes to GLB... that should be the next GLB radio broadcast.



Can flex point stamps for poor people be far behind?



Socialism? Marxism?? Cmon, back to reality please. Thats so far over the top its insane. In Socialism, they wouldn't just share playoff rev 75/25 or whatever the current plan is.. They share the entire seasons revenue equally.. And again, where do you get off stating that you work any harder than an owner who's team finishes in a #5-8 playoff spot? You just stated that you spend 2 hours a day on here... Thats all you spend on glb and you think you work harder than everyone else? Dude, I spend at LEAST 4 hours on this site every day.. On top of that I have built a webpage for my team and created a fantasy football league for them so your 2 hours a day
pales in comparison to what many owners put in.


Work smarter not harder. There have been days that all of my free hours have gone to GLB, and there have been times when my free time was spent on helping old ladies across the street... its a matter of preference. Did you ask anyone else to help with the website and recruiting? Ronald Reagan was not the best President or the smartest man to ever hold office but the reason he was successful was he hired good people to advise and support him. To make your time more managable find a few people you can trust on your team that are just as dedicated as you and put them in a position to succeed. Just a suggestion. Not all of my GM's go the extra mile, but they like to help, they want to help... hell my backup SS created a team website for our team without asking for anything but us to check it out in return... He didn't even ask me to be a GM. But this is off the topic.

Don't share with underachievers, make them work harder. BTW there is never a guarantee that your team will win or lose or even make it to the playoffs no matter how hard you work, some people quit and gut their teams, some people beg for Bort to make things fair (give us money and help) others just find a way to win the next season...


First off, I don't need advice from you. You don't know my situation at all. Additionally, I am sick of this stupid argument that you are entitled to 30 times the money of the lower 4 seeded teams. Thats not the case in ANY sport. Your argument is that you insist on being rewarded exorbitantly for your teams success. My argument is that ALL playoff teams should reap the benefits of their hard work. Also, I thought you said earlier that no one worked hard if they weren't a top 4 seed yet you just stated that working hard is no guarantee of making the playoffs. Those 2 statements just don't mesh.


Playoff teams get the playoff bonuses. They ARE rewarded.

You want to reward them more, make the bonuses more.



HAHHAAAAA! 100k is a REWARD?? So you really feel that giving 1-4 seeds up to 30x's th playoff revenue is fair?




Like I said, if you don't, increase the round bonuses. Simple. Easy. FAIR.

How much of a bonus would put a little smile on your face?
Last edited Sep 30, 2008 14:36:43
 
Scrogz
offline
Link
 
I've been of the opinion we have needed some kind of revenue sharing from the start. Anyone can look at the system in place now and see that teams who can max their stadium in 4 seasons is a broken situation. Especially with nothing else to spend their money on.

I really believe it's too late to fix the current situation.

Since I have had to learn to deal with this situation and live with these rules for 4 seasons I am not a fan of seeing them changed now.

I don't care if they give money to play off teams and other teams in the league. however, the day they start taking home play off money away from teams is the last day I ever consider buying a Flex point.

Like many of us I have contributed a decent amount of cash to this game, lived with the drastic changes and adapted but, quite frankly, I have had about enough. This change would probably be it for me. I'd still keep my players and play but I would not continue to own a team or boost my players.

I understand it's a "beta" game but there is a limit to the amount of cash i will spend on the game in the current environment of drastic changes.

I actually support wiping it all and starting over with a full flex refund. That's really the only way you can fix the situation.
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Bonuses are stupid for two reasons:

1. They are too small.

2. Even if they were more, they are money generated out of thin air. They are unrealistic. Where does the money for bonuses come from? Nowhere.

We need some kind of system that rewards all playoff teams (to varying degrees) in a way the takes into account realistic streams of revenue. Profit sharing is one possible revenue. Merchandise sales for visiting teams is another. I'm sure we could come up with more that are grounded in reality.

But increasing bonuses is lame.
 
chriscuster
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
Bonuses are stupid for two reasons:

1. They are too small.

2. Even if they were more, they are money generated out of thin air. They are unrealistic. Where does the money for bonuses come from? Nowhere.

We need some kind of system that rewards all playoff teams (to varying degrees) in a way the takes into account realistic streams of revenue. Profit sharing is one possible revenue. Merchandise sales for visiting teams is another. I'm sure we could come up with more that are grounded in reality.

But increasing bonuses is lame.


As opposed to all the fans who fill the seats...........they are all.....uh.....flesh and blood? lol

How about if we call it "TV revenue". Fixed?


So larger "TV Revenues" for teams. More than there is now.

Good?

Solution?

Fixed?

Smiles?
Last edited Sep 30, 2008 14:43:01
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
Why do you seriously think that home playoff teams deserve so much money? Seriously man, I had a team go 20-0 in it's first season and we are now set for life because we can afford to max upgrade our stadium for two seasons. Sure, we worked hard and built a great team, but you act like there's not some degree of randomness involved in sims let alone schedules. I played on a team last season that went 10-6 despite being a great team. This league is extremely competitive and this season there are 12 teams that can beat anyone in the league. 4 of those teams will receive nothing, and another 4 will receive virtually nothing. We got very lucky last season because we got the 6th seed, won the first round of playoffs and the 7 seed upset the 2 seed so we got a home playoff game. I guess we EARNED that in your mind? The 5th seed also won their first playoff game, they got $200k. We got $4M. Or maybe the fact that I've seen teams lose their 4th seed because they play the other conference's #1 in the week 16 game while the 5th seed jumps them beating some schlub at the bottom of the other conference. Do they deserve it? I've seen so many wonky sims and if you really think that the best teams always win then maybe this system of rewarding the top so greatly makes sense. I just don't see how anyone can seriously think that the best teams always win or that they always "deserve" more.
 
Crushr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GMathiasf
Why do you seriously think that home playoff teams deserve so much money? Seriously man, I had a team go 20-0 in it's first season and we are now set for life because we can afford to max upgrade our stadium for two seasons. Sure, we worked hard and built a great team, but you act like there's not some degree of randomness involved in sims let alone schedules. I played on a team last season that went 10-6 despite being a great team. This league is extremely competitive and this season there are 12 teams that can beat anyone in the league. 4 of those teams will receive nothing, and another 4 will receive virtually nothing. We got very lucky last season because we got the 6th seed, won the first round of playoffs and the 7 seed upset the 2 seed so we got a home playoff game. I guess we EARNED that in your mind? The 5th seed also won their first playoff game, they got $200k. We got $4M. Or maybe the fact that I've seen teams lose their 4th seed because they play the other conference's #1 in the week 16 game while the 5th seed jumps them beating some schlub at the bottom of the other conference. Do they deserve it? I've seen so many wonky sims and if you really think that the best teams always win then maybe this system of rewarding the top so greatly makes sense. I just don't see how anyone can seriously think that the best teams always win or that they always "deserve" more.


+ 1

 
chriscuster
offline
Link
 
So what's the problem with larger bonuses that we will call "Television Revenue" for added realism?

And how much "Television Revenue" would make you people happy?
Last edited Sep 30, 2008 14:51:26
 
Nats Kule
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GMathiasf
Why do you seriously think that home playoff teams deserve so much money? Seriously man, I had a team go 20-0 in it's first season and we are now set for life because we can afford to max upgrade our stadium for two seasons. Sure, we worked hard and built a great team, but you act like there's not some degree of randomness involved in sims let alone schedules. I played on a team last season that went 10-6 despite being a great team. This league is extremely competitive and this season there are 12 teams that can beat anyone in the league. 4 of those teams will receive nothing, and another 4 will receive virtually nothing. We got very lucky last season because we got the 6th seed, won the first round of playoffs and the 7 seed upset the 2 seed so we got a home playoff game. I guess we EARNED that in your mind? The 5th seed also won their first playoff game, they got $200k. We got $4M. Or maybe the fact that I've seen teams lose their 4th seed because they play the other conference's #1 in the week 16 game while the 5th seed jumps them beating some schlub at the bottom of the other conference. Do they deserve it? I've seen so many wonky sims and if you really think that the best teams always win then maybe this system of rewarding the top so greatly makes sense. I just don't see how anyone can seriously think that the best teams always win or that they always "deserve" more.


well said. Without the lower seeds there is no game, it only makes sense to pay them something, they earned that seed and a share of the revenue made.

No lower seed = no game = no revenue. Gotta pay 'em something or there isn't a game.
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chriscuster
Originally posted by McGruffHawk

Bonuses are stupid for two reasons:

1. They are too small.

2. Even if they were more, they are money generated out of thin air. They are unrealistic. Where does the money for bonuses come from? Nowhere.

We need some kind of system that rewards all playoff teams (to varying degrees) in a way the takes into account realistic streams of revenue. Profit sharing is one possible revenue. Merchandise sales for visiting teams is another. I'm sure we could come up with more that are grounded in reality.

But increasing bonuses is lame.


As opposed to all the fans who fill the seats...........they are all.....uh.....flesh and blood? lol

How about if we call it "TV revenue". Fixed?


So larger "TV Revenues" for teams. More than there is now.

Good?

Solution?

Fixed?

Smiles?


Where are these GLB TV's that you speak of? And how are they generating revenue?
 
Crushr
offline
Link
 




HAHHAAAAA! 100k is a REWARD?? So you really feel that giving 1-4 seeds up to 30x's th playoff revenue is fair?




Like I said, if you don't, increase the round bonuses. Simple. Easy. FAIR.

How much of a bonus would put a little smile on your face?


What part of this do you not understand? All I am saying is that giving the home playoff team 30 times more than the away team is way to unbalanced. You won't find that kind of disparity anywhere in the sports world. Even up the playoff payouts to where home seeds get 2 x's the amount that the away teams get. Thats fair. Can you live with that or is that dipping into your 'entitlement'?
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chriscuster
So what's the problem with larger bonuses that we will call "Television Revenue" for added realism?

And how much "Television Revenue" would make you people happy?


Its more than a matter of semantics. Its a matter of there being existing revenue in the game already, and IMO any "payouts" needs to come from actual revenue streams, not from revenue being generated out of thin air.
 
chriscuster
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Crushr




HAHHAAAAA! 100k is a REWARD?? So you really feel that giving 1-4 seeds up to 30x's th playoff revenue is fair?




Like I said, if you don't, increase the round bonuses. Simple. Easy. FAIR.

How much of a bonus would put a little smile on your face?


What part of this do you not understand? All I am saying is that giving the home playoff team 30 times more than the away team is way to unbalanced. You won't find that kind of disparity anywhere in the sports world. Even up the playoff payouts to where home seeds get 2 x's the amount that the away teams get. Thats fair. Can you live with that or is that dipping into your 'entitlement'?






You're dodging the question with gibberish.

So how "balanced" does it need to be to make your little heart happy?
Last edited Sep 30, 2008 14:58:52
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
Around 2:1 would make more sense to me. Quite frankly I think home teams make too much money for the playoffs. And this is coming from one.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.