User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
Page:
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by Malachorn


Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder



Ok, let's try a new approach.

Why should I be up in arms about a tester running the test you mention?


Because it was his own test.


Agree.


Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by Malachorn


Originally posted by Malachorn



Basically, it looks like Mike Rogers (IMO) very blatantly and obviously was testing the impact that agility has on speed... and no one cares.


I absolutely care. I'm happy he did it. It's good to know not only what AGI does vis a vis SPD, but also whether or not it was working correctly.



Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

What? Why? Mike running his own tests is a good way to fix things. Having to have Bort stamp everything someone thinks is broken is a great way to slow things down, but not accomplish much else.


I mean... this is okay then?
I wouldn't have raised such a fuss if you just told us from the start that testers are allowed to do whatever they want.

I just know that we were told that testers would only run tests that Bort specifically told them to run and it would be unacceptable to run any of your own tests on the server.

If you just tell us that the testers are allowed to do whatever they want then I'll shut up about Mike's test, tbh.
 
DM
offline
Link
 
this thread has run its course. It began as a good way to express your opinions, but now it has just become a whine fest. Lets keep constructive speaking in here next time. Ca Click
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn

Does that pretty much mean that VT's opinion is shared by everyone involved with testing and you're okay with tester's testing things that Bort didn't tell them to test?

I mean... what would a tester have to do to get in trouble then?


I know it's sorta your "thing" and all, but why do you keep repeating this after you've been told that it isn't true.

Simply because Bort didn't say "Mike, test the effects of AGI on SPD (and I have no idea if he did or not) doesn't mean Mike did anything "on his own" (though, again, I'm fine if he does that).

Bort might have said something that required that test, or something that involved that test.
Last edited Mar 5, 2009 16:53:48
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Bort might have said something that required that test, or something that involved that test.


No... saying that recognises that that is a separate and distinct test.
It was. It was something other than what he was asked to do.

No way around that.
You guys are ONLY supposed to be doing what you are told is needed.
NOTHING more.


If you testers really can't appreciate that then it is VERY scary and disconcerting.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Bort might have said something that required that test, or something that involved that test.


No... saying that recognises that that is a separate and distinct test.
It was. It was something other than what he was asked to do.

No way around that.
You guys are ONLY supposed to be doing what you are told is needed.
NOTHING more.


If you testers really can't appreciate that then it is VERY scary and disconcerting.


Not at all.

If Bort wants to test something that takes multiple tests to properly nail down, he doesn't need to illustrate all of them. That's impractical.
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Not at all.

If Bort wants to test something that takes multiple tests to properly nail down, he doesn't need to illustrate all of them. That's impractical.


That's fine and fair.
But all of those tests should still have to be testing exactly what Bort asked someone to test.

Mike was running a test that shows the impact of agility on spd.
Based on all accounts, that test was not something Bort asked him to run.
Based on all accounts, testers aren't supposed to be running those kind of tests.

Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Simply because Bort didn't say "Mike, test the effects of AGI on SPD (and I have no idea if he did or not) doesn't mean Mike did anything "on his own" (though, again, I'm fine if he does that).

Bort might have said something that required that test, or something that involved that test.



He didn't have to run THAT test and wasn't asked to run THAT test.
He was supposed to be running a different test and there was no reason to run a test that would give him the obvious information that that test seems to be trying to yield.

And that is my point here.
You're ONLY supposed to be running tests that are to help the game and are told by Bort to you that you should test.
NOTHING more.

Running other tests should be a huge no-no.
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


Originally posted by Malachorn



Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder




Ok, let's try a new approach.

Why should I be up in arms about a tester running the test you mention?


Because it was his own test.


Agree.


Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


Originally posted by Malachorn



Originally posted by Malachorn




Basically, it looks like Mike Rogers (IMO) very blatantly and obviously was testing the impact that agility has on speed... and no one cares.


I absolutely care. I'm happy he did it. It's good to know not only what AGI does vis a vis SPD, but also whether or not it was working correctly.



Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


What? Why? Mike running his own tests is a good way to fix things. Having to have Bort stamp everything someone thinks is broken is a great way to slow things down, but not accomplish much else.



And you've already said that you don't care.
At least you're being a little honest there.

But you SHOULD care.
It's not supposed to be up to you... it's supposed to be up to Bort and we've been told that Bort doesn't want you running anything other than what he tells you to run.

Your opinion shouldn't matter then and you should only be doing what Bort tells you to run... and it should be your duty to throw any tester that isn't doing Bort's wishes to the wolves.
Last edited Mar 5, 2009 17:16:02
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


What? Why? Mike running his own tests is a good way to fix things. Having to have Bort stamp everything someone thinks is broken is a great way to slow things down, but not accomplish much else.


Basically, your opinion shouldn't matter there.
Bort said that he IS supposed to stamp everything and that should be that.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder



What? Why? Mike running his own tests is a good way to fix things. Having to have Bort stamp everything someone thinks is broken is a great way to slow things down, but not accomplish much else.


Basically, your opinion shouldn't matter there.
Bort said that he IS supposed to stamp everything and that should be that.



And Bort does, just not in the way I'm guessing you think.
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by Malachorn
You guys are ONLY supposed to be doing what you are told is needed.
NOTHING more.



Not at all.


 
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder



Originally posted by Malachorn




Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder





Ok, let's try a new approach.

Why should I be up in arms about a tester running the test you mention?


Because it was his own test.


Agree.


Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder



Originally posted by Malachorn




Originally posted by Malachorn





Basically, it looks like Mike Rogers (IMO) very blatantly and obviously was testing the impact that agility has on speed... and no one cares.


I absolutely care. I'm happy he did it. It's good to know not only what AGI does vis a vis SPD, but also whether or not it was working correctly.



Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder



What? Why? Mike running his own tests is a good way to fix things. Having to have Bort stamp everything someone thinks is broken is a great way to slow things down, but not accomplish much else.



And you've already said that you don't care.
At least you're being a little honest there.

But you SHOULD care.
It's not supposed to be up to you... it's supposed to be up to Bort and we've been told that Bort doesn't want you running anything other than what he tells you to run.

Your opinion shouldn't matter then and you should only be doing what Bort tells you to run... and it should be your duty to throw any tester that isn't doing Bort's wishes to the wolves.


Any, you completely miss the point and assume whatever best fits your delusion.

1) I don't know what Mike and Bort talked about, so everything I told you, like I repeatedly mentioned, was speculation.
2) Bort does tell testers what to test, at least generally.
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by Malachorn

Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder




What? Why? Mike running his own tests is a good way to fix things. Having to have Bort stamp everything someone thinks is broken is a great way to slow things down, but not accomplish much else.


Basically, your opinion shouldn't matter there.
Bort said that he IS supposed to stamp everything and that should be that.



And Bort does, just not in the way I'm guessing you think.


Well, Bort didn't tell Mike Rogers to test spd/agility.
That seems to be a fact.

Mike Rogers did test spd/agility.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Not at all.

If Bort wants to test something that takes multiple tests to properly nail down, he doesn't need to illustrate all of them. That's impractical.


That's fine and fair.
But all of those tests should still have to be testing exactly what Bort asked someone to test.

Mike was running a test that shows the impact of agility on spd.
Based on all accounts, that test was not something Bort asked him to run.
Based on all accounts, testers aren't supposed to be running those kind of tests.


You mean: Based on the accounts you choose to believe.

Originally posted by

Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Simply because Bort didn't say "Mike, test the effects of AGI on SPD (and I have no idea if he did or not) doesn't mean Mike did anything "on his own" (though, again, I'm fine if he does that).

Bort might have said something that required that test, or something that involved that test.



He didn't have to run THAT test and wasn't asked to run THAT test.
He was supposed to be running a different test and there was no reason to run a test that would give him the obvious information that that test seems to be trying to yield.

And that is my point here.
You're ONLY supposed to be running tests that are to help the game and are told by Bort to you that you should test.
NOTHING more.

Running other tests should be a huge no-no.


How do you know what Mike and Bort talk about? Seriously, you've done a ton of assumption throughout this thread.
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
1) I don't know what Mike and Bort talked about, so everything I told you, like I repeatedly mentioned, was speculation.
2) Bort does tell testers what to test, at least generally.


Everyone seems to agree that Mike Rogers wasn't supposed to be testing spd/agility.
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
How do you know what Mike and Bort talk about? Seriously, you've done a ton of assumption throughout this thread.


I'm basing everything on what YOU TESTERS have told me, thanks.
I don't know for a fact... but, according to every report, Mike Rogers wasn't supposed to be testing that there.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.