User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Test Server Discussion
Page:
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
To keep on my idea....

When I was in college I spent 10-15 hours a week working on SAE projects. (I'm an engineer) We built a mini baja car, another year I was part of a clean snowmobile team. We put those hours in to learn something and boost our resume. We weren't paid. I know people who've taken jobs as interns where they made nothing for an entire summer just to gain experiences in their field of study.

You have people all over this site working towards IT or Computer Science degrees. I have someone on my team trying to develop his own MMORPG.

Put up an announcement looking for internship positions. Have them email you resumes. Take 10-15 students who are willing to stop playing GLB and start working to help with the site. If they show promise in site administration and test server stuff maybe they get to help code some future game features. You have a highly qualified group of motivated people willing to help you out and maybe in the future if you can start to pay minimum wage or something to a few good ones they get that opportunity.

I hire a few interns every summer, and if you get good ones they're incredibly productive and eager to help out. As for the concern they may play the game in the future... as long as they're keeping a blog of some sort, I'm not sure it would matter. The SIM changes enough right now over the course of a couple seasons that by the time they created players and got them to a high level I'm guessing things will have changed some.
Last edited Feb 13, 2009 20:02:41
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Also i should add that the info that was leaked to me didn't play any roll in us winning our championship. But you can sure as hell bet it will effect how i build players from here on out.
 
Nuge20
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DL24
Originally posted by Binestar

Originally posted by DL24


I have only a small problem with the actual idea of this, as it is marginally unfair to normal agents without special privileges to view the Sim and good builds. Who knows if Tea Baggins is a product of Sim-viewing?

But my real problem is that Bort has publicly lied to thousands of customers who have made him millions of dollars. He has repeatedly stated that he is the only tester, when he KNOWS he is lying and lying on purpose. This just pisses me off so much right now. I've spent a lot of money just to have some sly dude lie and manipulate things, give people special privileges(while clearly stating otherwise many, many times) and change things every 40 days, wasting a whole season's worth of builds, success, AI, scouting and team strategies.


Testing started 2 weeks ago, Tea Baggins has been good much longer than that.


How do you know that isnt a lie too? You dont, thats the problem. Once a liar, always a liar


It would have been leaked earlier if it had been going on since season 1 tbh
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nuge20
Originally posted by atingwald
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by krwynn
I have an idea. Let the testers review game data only, not builds. Let them watch the replay of the game. Let them send you notes on what they see. You could have anyone test or review that data and relay what they see to you. Keep build data away from testers. Only stats and replays.

How would they know what to look for?

i asked/suggested this a while back... the idea is that they would report to you the results of Team #1 and Team #10 during Scenario B, but only you would know what that specifically means.
if you need the testers to have more autonomy than that, it would still seem feasible to have a generic prototype players/teams without divulging the specific build information to the testers.
think of it as a double-blind study with dots.

exactly.. did no one take statistics in college??

I take it in highschool and it would be very difficult to do a double blind study considering bort it giving people the test scrims...he knows whats happening therefore not double blind


yes, not technically double-blind... for one thing, you don't have human test subjects.

but the point still stands. there are very easy ways to have testers do real testing without knowing what exactly the results mean... all it takes is a little coordination up-front.

however, my impression is that the testers more or less have full run of the test server... which is an issue in and of itself. coordinated testing is not only better testing, but also you don't have to worry whether or not you've properly policed the testers.
 
billbates
offline
Link
 
I guess I'd be happy if they kept us informed on the results of the testing. I would also like to have the ability to get answers to questions, maybe specific forum or even a chat room.

I also think it would be nice to score free boosts for next season.
 
CONN CHRIS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CONN CHRIS

Stuff has to be tested. While the complaints about unfair advangages and business model et cetera are reasonable, the bottom line is that the best testers will always be those involved in the sim up to thier eyeballs - that's us.

All the blogs and whatnot are nice sounding but are just additional administrative drags, how about this:

1) Number of testers is fixed
2) A lottery or some sort of application process is put in place to get new testers
3) Half the testers are swapped out each season
4) All testers are announced publicaly
5) They have their own forum with access ending when their stint is up. That way their will always be 1/2 the squad with a season of experience that help the new testers along in the forum


Edit: Yes, those taht are in testing will be a bit ahead of the curve on stuff for the period that they are testing. So be it, that's the prize they get on a temp basis for doing valuable work for the rest of us. People will still hate that but it's fair and good testing is a must.



Was this a bad idea? Already mentioned? This is moving too fast to get real replys but I'll try this once more.
Last edited Feb 13, 2009 19:58:47
 
Cerneo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FairForever
I think a lot of people don't understand what the test server is supposed to do.

That being said, Bort and Co. need way better public relations. The perception is that they do a horrible job, and it is things like this that seem to enforce that belief.


Its not a perception anymore.

They are not, its beyond that, the lack of foresight that this could be an issue is astounding to me. Giving 30 people(Who have been here for a long time to earn trust, and as such should alteast be gming teams in the pros) inside info is shocking.
 
atingwald
offline
Link
 
again, the only testing that can be done with ZERO bias is done by the computer... humans can then interpret the results..
it's done every day by all kinds of businesses....

when the testers are in on the test, that just reeks of a double standard...
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by jrry32


Originally posted by sjmay



How many of you seriously thought that in a game that was ever changing, that there was no test server or testers?

Specifically how many of you that are demanding money back now, thought that?

Seriously?


I am not demanding my money back and I knew there was a test server but I did NOT know they allowed normal GLBers to be testers and allowed them to test player builds out which gives them a big advantage. They also know what things are going to get nerfed/strengthened and can fix their builds on that notion before the rest of us can.


Jrry,

It was more for the people who are trying to absolutely demand their money back, that is flat out ridiculous.

As far as regular GLB's, I doubt that, they may play the regular GLB as well as test, but you have to have some sort of faith that they aren't the normal 12 year old or 30 year old actling like 12 year old idiots that seem to invade this game.

there are quite a few people on there that I wouldn't mind at all being a tester, because I know the game is more about winning to them than it is to other people.


Sam, I wouldn't either if I trusted GLB's judgement on choosing people but after the various mods that have been bad choices, I am sorry but I can't trust that they picked all people who are 100% for the game and don't have a vested interest somewhere in there for themselves. And Bort not releasing the list makes me question it more especially with Gart saying that someone was leaking info to him. I don't know if it is true or not but what motive does he have to lie?



To start shit, like pretty much 90% of those on GLB, who just start shit to start shit.

I don't know garth except from posting so I can't tell you if he is that type or not, never interacted with him,

but I wouldn't be releasing the list either, that just invites 30000 people to PM everyone on that list relentelessly, there is no way Bort releases that list and continues to be able to test the game effectively.
 
Weather
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by LordEvil

I dont want my money back, I had fun but today is a new beginning for me. Knowing there are players in this game that have an advantage by knowing certain builds to players and watching them play is an unfair advantage. There is a reason why players are able to close their builds to keep other members from copying them if their player excels. In this case the testers have that ability to view any build in play. Advantage!
I ma just a drop in the bucket but I have lost respect for the game from this point on.


They should make all builds open IMO.

I want transparency with all the teams I'm playing against in case they're cheating.


Yeah, I like this idea.
Just makes it a more level playing field.

I used to play a virtual pet game 3 or 4 years ago (neopets, never mind this) and every person's "pet" had its "build" of strength, XP, Defense, (to fight in "battles") etc. available to everybody
No problems occurred there ^
 
Binestar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by dpell

Originally posted by dpell



I really think there are some people here who'd take a season off to help with testing and development for nothing more than flex points. I also think you're underestimating the coolness factor of saying you helped with testing and development of an online MMORPG for the resume of someone in college. Heck, bring 10-15 people in as unpaid interns. I guarantee among your user base with a high percentage of college males there are people who'd jump at the opportunity to help you do some development work and testing.



I'm quoting my own idea because it's so darn good. This is your solution Bort. Have them start helping with the test server. The guys (or gals) who show some promise may work up to the point they can help you do some coding or something.


That's a good idea, and basically what I was proposing with having some of the current testers give up their teams/players.

There will now be hate put on the idea because those "interns" could possibly play the game someday and use their knowledge.


If these players havn't done something like sign a non-disclosure then you'll still run into the issue where they tell their friend/brother/spouse (hopefully not all 3 in one) and that person has the advantage.

Or they just keep in contact with the GM of their current team.

Problem is the uneven playing field now. Some agents have access to information other agents don't.


Why do you think there is a Bort Stalker Thread? So people can get nuggets of information from you and use it to their advantage.

Now agents can get nuggets of information from the testers.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by dpell

Originally posted by dpell



I really think there are some people here who'd take a season off to help with testing and development for nothing more than flex points. I also think you're underestimating the coolness factor of saying you helped with testing and development of an online MMORPG for the resume of someone in college. Heck, bring 10-15 people in as unpaid interns. I guarantee among your user base with a high percentage of college males there are people who'd jump at the opportunity to help you do some development work and testing.



I'm quoting my own idea because it's so darn good. This is your solution Bort. Have them start helping with the test server. The guys (or gals) who show some promise may work up to the point they can help you do some coding or something.


That's a good idea, and basically what I was proposing with having some of the current testers give up their teams/players.

There will now be hate put on the idea because those "interns" could possibly play the game someday and use their knowledge.


Not some, all Bort. Can't so something half ass. This is a business you are running, be professional about it, do it right and restore your credibility and the game's credibility.
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
Gart - quit hogging the spot light and just out your source and what you were told...


 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cerneo
Originally posted by FairForever

I think a lot of people don't understand what the test server is supposed to do.

That being said, Bort and Co. need way better public relations. The perception is that they do a horrible job, and it is things like this that seem to enforce that belief.


Its not a perception anymore.

They are not, its beyond that, the lack of foresight that this could be an issue is astounding to me. Giving 30 people(Who have been here for a long time to earn trust, and as such should alteast be gming teams in the pros) inside info is shocking.


How is it not a perception? Public relations is all based on perception. Personally, I don't think they're doing a bad job, and testing is required (or else we'd be hearing complaints about broken-ness). It would've just been better if they had communicated this two weeks ago rather than keep this in secrecy.

Anyway, back to neopets (not kidding). I'm bored.
 
tshizzle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atingwald
Originally posted by Catullus 16

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by krwynn


I have an idea. Let the testers review game data only, not builds. Let them watch the replay of the game. Let them send you notes on what they see. You could have anyone test or review that data and relay what they see to you. Keep build data away from testers. Only stats and replays.

How would they know what to look for?


i asked/suggested this a while back... the idea is that they would report to you the results of Team #1 and Team #10 during Scenario B, but only you would know what that specifically means.

if you need the testers to have more autonomy than that, it would still seem feasible to have a generic prototype players/teams without divulging the specific build information to the testers.

think of it as a double-blind study with dots.


exactly.. did no one take statistics in college??


im pretty sure 100% of the mods/devs are not out of college yet...

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.