User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Test Server Discussion
Page:
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
Some more ideas....

Team owners can sign up to be testers for a limited amount of time. Preference for owners from high level leagues and with multiple seasons of ownership experience. Say you go into the test group for a week or two, then drop out and are replaced. The rotation would cause people in the group to help make sure documentation is being done properly in the blog. By rotating a few at a time they'd learn on the job so there wouldn't need to be a massive orientation.

I really think there are some people here who'd take a season off to help with testing and development for nothing more than flex points. I also think you're underestimating the coolness factor of saying you helped with testing and development of an online MMORPG for the resume of someone in college. Heck, bring 10-15 people in as unpaid interns. I guarantee among your user base with a high percentage of college males there are people who'd jump at the opportunity to help you do some development work and testing.

 
Padre
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DL24
Originally posted by Padre97

Originally posted by Nuge20


Originally posted by Krunchy



Originally posted by Bort






There will not be an open public test server for everyone to test with willy-nilly. Even ignoring exploit-city problems, the live site uses over 30 servers just to run the website, and there are separate sim servers as well. I'd need the same to support a test server open to the public, and there is no way we have the resources for that. Besides, it's far easier to deal with focused reports from a small group of testers than 50,000 people screaming about the game they just ran where the RB went left instead of right.


Then give me my money back, shyster. I didn't pay so you and your buddies can have your own set or rules and advantages.


ITS BORTS GAME, HE SETS THE RULES!!!!!!!!!!!!


+1


Screw that, you suck ups. He wont give you free Flex, he'll just lie publicly to you and manipulate you even moar.

Ignorant assholes


Another example why Bort has no reason to listen to any of this crap.
 
Cerneo
offline
Link
 
So bort,

Will we be getting names? If not its safe to say I would not be spending anymore(lolnomoremoneymmopostimo), the reason is its just not a level playing field. I can spend hours here and there looking at builds finding whats working and whats not, but I can never match someone who can do whatever he wants to test.

I can't spend 200+ just to test something on this game, I know others can, but I can't. Asking me to do that why you let a select few do it for free is bullshit. Thats why test servers in other mmos are open to the public. Its also why they have patch notes(Took you a hell of a long time to add them). I understand you don't have an extra 30 servers to blow on a open test server. So the best way to go about it is picking people who don't own teams or gm. You should already know leaks are impossible to fix, I have no doubt your testers are already letting things slip or rerolling players in the peewees with some knew knowledge. Thats unavoidable.

So, names and accountability or you have one less player(olnomoremoneymmopostimo).

Oh, also what ever mod was locking post about this should also be looked into, he/she clearly understood the massive impact of know all this insider info and wanted to sweep it under the rug, if that person could see it that quickly then for sure you already know.
 
Pac-boy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Skanker irl
Leave Bort alone and let him get the fucking season started.

DO NOT QUESTION THE BORT.


is a tester
 
atingwald
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ress5609
Originally posted by atingwald

Originally posted by ress5609


Originally posted by atingwald




so you are saying that he built this random generating program for all these teams, but he couldn't do it for say 100 teams of his own... with special builds built in to each of those 100 teams??

Those 100 teams could play each other over and over on a random loop, and the statistical anomalies could not be determined thru statistical analysis??? So a computer is slower than the humans?? LOL

I find that very hard to believe.... in 100 teams, you could generate millions upon millions of matchups, and the oddities would expose themselves in two weeks, guaranteed.... every two weeks, you can adjust those 100 teams, and that would lead to new tests...

how long do you think a game truly lasts??? with a random generator, it takes minutes at most... you can run millions of games in two weeks....


I think you misunderstand what the "easier said than done part" is. You're assuming that all bugs can be found through statistical analysis. Unfortunately, that is not the case. There's no guarantee that a particular bug will show up as a statistical anomaly, and further more writing the logic in code to detect any possible bug would take longer than just sitting down and watching every single play of every single sim.


team A plays team B 100 times... results should be pretty similar over 100 games...

team C plays team B 100 times.. again, these results should be pretty similar over those 100 games

team A has guys with 20 points more confidence than team C... wouldn't you be able to see a statistical difference??

you don't have to write that into code... you can print out data and see the % difference....


The problem is that example is so far over simplified that it doesn't just work that way.

For example, the results of each game are already stored. Comparing all of those results together isn't going to tell you why the TE sometimes runs the wrong direction in the middle of a play. You might be able to see where it happens but it doesn't tell you why.

Additionally if the coordinates of that TE are still within an acceptable area of movement (i.e. the field), then it wouldn't show up as an anomaly. So then you'd have to setup a list of parameters for every scenario.


I don't think the testers are looking for that... or are they Bort?

I think they want to know if confidence is too powerful... or if power thru is realistic or not...
not whether the tight end goes left or right...

I could be wrong, but clarification from Bort or one of the admins would help
 
Legatus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by UsCtRoJaNs1820


Originally posted by Bort



Originally posted by awesome




Originally posted by Bort





So...if all the current testers (at least those who wish to continue testing) gave up their teams and whatnot, and then announced themselves, would that be a solution? I know some of them wouldn't really mind, 'specially if we gave them free points, etc.


No. All testing information must be made public. We should have access to everything that they have access to. After all, when they return, they will still have the advantage.


What if we write up a report of what we've found so far? Tpat sounds like would certainly be willing. Compiling all the replays and stuff to be downloadable would not really be feasible.

We haven't really gotten too far beyond getting things set up (took a while to make the prototype teams, etc) and testing out some of the proposed exploit D plays at this point, anyway.


Won't work. It still gives them an unfair advantage as some won't announce anything. Bort if you want to run a business you can't play favorites you have to give EVERYONE the same opportunity. Even if you right up a blog about it the testers still have an unfair advantage. Is it ok to allow some players to have an unfair advantage over others? Nope bc we're paying customers just like them and we are getting cheated.



There will not be an open public test server for everyone to test with willy-nilly. Even ignoring exploit-city problems, the live site uses over 30 servers just to run the website, and there are separate sim servers as well. I'd need the same to support a test server open to the public, and there is no way we have the resources for that. Besides, it's far easier to deal with focused reports from a small group of testers than 50,000 people screaming about the game they just ran where the RB went left instead of right.


Bort, got to separate the testers from playing the game. There is a reason why prizes are not given out to people affiliated with the company giving them out. GLB is losing credibility, you are losing credibility with this.


Absolutely.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
How many of you seriously thought that in a game that was ever changing, that there was no test server or testers?

Specifically how many of you that are demanding money back now, thought that?

Seriously?


I am not demanding my money back and I knew there was a test server but I did NOT know they allowed normal GLBers to be testers and allowed them to test player builds out which gives them a big advantage. They also know what things are going to get nerfed/strengthened and can fix their builds on that notion before the rest of us can.
 
Padre
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Krunchy
Originally posted by Nuge20


ITS BORTS GAME, HE SETS THE RULES!!!!!!!!!!!!


Yes, its his game but we are customers and have recourse.


Yes. To stop playing.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CinTex
Originally posted by krwynn
I have an idea. Let the testers review game data only, not builds. Let them watch the replay of the game. Let them send you notes on what they see. You could have anyone test or review that data and relay what they see to you. Keep build data away from testers. Only stats and replays.

game data only not builds....


already added...

[POTENTIAL SOLUTIONS MENTIONED BY OTHERS SO FAR]
- hide specific test builds from testers
testers
- hire paid testers (that aren't also players)
- current testers give up teams/etc
- dismiss current testers, bring back testers willing to be public
- quarantine testers into their own league
- open all testers' builds
information
- testers' blog
- publish testing results
- screenshots/details of testing interface
access
- give everyone access to test server
- give everyone access to test data
other
- hire customer service person
- revisit why initial threads were summarily locked/moved/etc
- remove the beta tag

 
Weather
offline
Link
 
Approximately how many users have access to this "Test server"?
 
77racing
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Skanker irl
Leave Bort alone and let him get the fucking season started.

DO NOT QUESTION THE BORT.

How much chapstick did you put on before you kissed his ass?

 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
Originally posted by weather999

Jesus. This is like MLB and Steroids.


Only it's not really an issue whatsoever.


How can you say that? I've all but told you guys which tester has been leaking me test results, and I won a pro league this season.
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Padre97
Originally posted by Krunchy

Originally posted by Nuge20



ITS BORTS GAME, HE SETS THE RULES!!!!!!!!!!!!


Yes, its his game but we are customers and have recourse.


Yes. To stop playing.
 
Binestar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nuge20

ITS BORTS GAME, HE SETS THE RULES!!!!!!!!!!!!


I agree with this if he wasn't intent on changing the rules.

The accepted rule is that all agents are created equal. Their ability is based on the effort they put into the game. the 30 or so testers now have an advantage, because no matter how much effort the other agents put into the game, they have no way of getting the insider information those 30 have, unless they happen to be on a team with them, in which case lets say each of those 30 gives the information to 10 agents, that's 300.

Out of 50,000.


If this was information that anyone had the ability to get, I'd say fine, the lazy doesn't get it, but it's not that way, this is information those testers can get and no one else can.
 
Nuge20
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DL24
Originally posted by Padre97

Originally posted by Nuge20


Originally posted by Krunchy



Originally posted by Bort






There will not be an open public test server for everyone to test with willy-nilly. Even ignoring exploit-city problems, the live site uses over 30 servers just to run the website, and there are separate sim servers as well. I'd need the same to support a test server open to the public, and there is no way we have the resources for that. Besides, it's far easier to deal with focused reports from a small group of testers than 50,000 people screaming about the game they just ran where the RB went left instead of right.


Then give me my money back, shyster. I didn't pay so you and your buddies can have your own set or rules and advantages.


ITS BORTS GAME, HE SETS THE RULES!!!!!!!!!!!!


+1


Screw that, you suck ups. He wont give you free Flex, he'll just lie publicly to you and manipulate you even moar.

Ignorant assholes


Read his post, he said he didnt pay so Bort can set the rules...clearly its Borts game and he sets the rules (it has been apparent since Season 1
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.