User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > GLB Insider: The truth behind all the teams leaving.
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by drifter


Originally posted by Tito716



Originally posted by drifter





That's only half the solution. Things are too imabalanced right now to only implement half a solution.


Then what's the other half of the solution?

Maybe Bort could make CPU players be worth a damn so people could ignore what they feel are outrageous FA demands and also allow soldback/gutted teams to finish their season without being so imbalanced before being sold to a new owner and relegated?



One time restructuring to get the best teams at the top and the worst at the bottom. From there allow normal promotion and relegation with the exception of gutted teams that get relegated to the bottom tier at the end of the season and allow for an equal amount of 1 tier promotions for everyone in between when that occurs.


And when people find that they still can't compete, or that teams are still getting gutted early in the year?



Teams will always get gutted for any number of reasons. That's why you need to relegate them to the bottom tier at the end of the season.


And for that reason, it really doesn't matter.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by islander1


Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder



Originally posted by j4mzf0rm0d




2 examples of the Domino Effect in action.

USA BBB #2 - In the beginning of the year Team 1 gives up, Team 2 sees team 1 who was in a better position than they were selling, and does the same. Team 3 waits to about mid season and decides to join the fire sale. A fifth team does the same.

Add those to the 2 gutted teams inherited from the A leagues, and there you have it a real sheet show for the guys trying to play the game right.

Example 2: USA AAA #2 As many as 7 teams, have or will sell out of a high level league. Leaving it in shambles.


In other words, when people can't compete right away, some choose not to accept a challenge. Not exactly news.


when they see a game that is economically working against them - where the rich keep getting richer - they ask themselves what's the point?

What's the point of busting your ass to finish with a 11-5 record, finish seventh, win two games in the playoffs, and still have NOTHING to show for it financially?


Where are you guys getting this. I made 8 mil my first year excluding the playoffs and paid players 1.75 mil. That gave me ~~6.25 mil to spend on my stadium (again, excluding additional builds from the playoffs). That's a ton of money when sections cost 1-1.5 mil a piece.

Spending more is optional, and if you choose that, don't look to place blame outside.


So did I. But you're still missing the point.

While you are slow building your stadium, spending wisely, over the course of let's say 4 seasons (that's how long my stadium will take to complete), other teams are raking in 10's of millions in playoff revenue.

This didn't matter back when players were level 16. Everyone could afford equipment for their team. At level 24, this number decreased a good bit. At level 32, it's going to decrease spectacularly.

This is the edge teams with tons of cash like you have in recruiting. This is where balance in the game is skewered. I've managed my money as intelligently as possible. But it's easy to look like a wizard when you are being artificially inflated by sky high fan support (due to being 14-2), and getting a massive gravy train of playoff income while the 5-8th place teams get jack crap.



Is the last year of the game this year? THe game doesn't even start until players start retiring. That's a big part of this. We're waaaay to early to judge a lot of these things because teams like mine that have been around since Season 1 will always have a level advantage on later teams. That is until my players start to retire, then we're all on equal temporal footing.

If you've been smart on building your stadium, then you're going to have all the money you need in later years.
 
Statbase
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by supp0007
Originally posted by drifter

I don't see a conflict of interest owning more than one player and having them on different teams. Maybe I didn't understand what you are trying to say?


I don't either and I don't think it's any different than being GM for multiple teams.


Gm's can trade, cut, sign and/or renegotiate with players. If a person GM's for more than one team and trades with himself, you have collusion. I'm not saying you are doing it yourself, I am saying it is happening.

Last edited Aug 29, 2008 12:01:18
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by drifter

Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


Originally posted by drifter



Originally posted by Tito716




Originally posted by drifter






That's only half the solution. Things are too imabalanced right now to only implement half a solution.


Then what's the other half of the solution?

Maybe Bort could make CPU players be worth a damn so people could ignore what they feel are outrageous FA demands and also allow soldback/gutted teams to finish their season without being so imbalanced before being sold to a new owner and relegated?



One time restructuring to get the best teams at the top and the worst at the bottom. From there allow normal promotion and relegation with the exception of gutted teams that get relegated to the bottom tier at the end of the season and allow for an equal amount of 1 tier promotions for everyone in between when that occurs.


And when people find that they still can't compete, or that teams are still getting gutted early in the year?



Teams will always get gutted for any number of reasons. That's why you need to relegate them to the bottom tier at the end of the season.


And for that reason, it really doesn't matter.


What? That makes absolutely no sense whatsoever
Last edited Aug 29, 2008 12:01:19
 
shield.bearer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by islander1

Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


Originally posted by j4mzf0rm0d



2 examples of the Domino Effect in action.

USA BBB #2 - In the beginning of the year Team 1 gives up, Team 2 sees team 1 who was in a better position than they were selling, and does the same. Team 3 waits to about mid season and decides to join the fire sale. A fifth team does the same.

Add those to the 2 gutted teams inherited from the A leagues, and there you have it a real sheet show for the guys trying to play the game right.

Example 2: USA AAA #2 As many as 7 teams, have or will sell out of a high level league. Leaving it in shambles.


In other words, when people can't compete right away, some choose not to accept a challenge. Not exactly news.


when they see a game that is economically working against them - where the rich keep getting richer - they ask themselves what's the point?

What's the point of busting your ass to finish with a 11-5 record, finish seventh, win two games in the playoffs, and still have NOTHING to show for it financially?


Where are you guys getting this. I made 8 mil my first year excluding the playoffs and paid players 1.75 mil. That gave me ~~6.25 mil to spend on my stadium (again, excluding additional builds from the playoffs). That's a ton of money when sections cost 1-1.5 mil a piece.

Spending more is optional, and if you choose that, don't look to place blame outside.

When are you going to get that spending more for players is NO LONGER OPTIONAL. Only the very best teams get the option of bringing guys in for such a small amount. You can look at the salaries on my team and see that I've kept costs down well for a team in the current environment. We were a top 3 team in our conference last season. The #2 team (made it to the Conference Title game) pulled in a huge chunk more cash with the extra home game and have left us in the dust. FA's now want stupid $$, and most people simply cannot (or will not in my case) compete for their services.
 
Sao
offline
Link
 


Just thought of another reason...


14 pages and no C-Level Exec has added a thought or two to the discussion.


At the very least you should see someone interrupt and say "Good discussion guys. We will take this into consideration and try to do what is best for you and the future of the game"


The poor management of the game doesn't stop with coding or forum structure. Public Relations here is so lacking, cynics like me have no choice but to think this Beta is just a way to line pockets while they can and either close shop or sell the site to someone who has a clear vision for the future when sales fall dramatically.


This idea had so much potential it's not even funny. From that to this in 180 days is stunning.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 

Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


Is the last year of the game this year? THe game doesn't even start until players start retiring. That's a big part of this. We're waaaay to early to judge a lot of these things because teams like mine that have been around since Season 1 will always have a level advantage on later teams. That is until my players start to retire, then we're all on equal temporal footing.

If you've been smart on building your stadium, then you're going to have all the money you need in later years.


I won't disagree. But I'm talking about now. Not in 5 years/seasons. Teams are trying to win now. And quite honestly, there is no good reason 3 or 4 teams now should have a ridiculously advantage over the rest.

Right now, they do.

Moreover, what makes you think every franchise is going to stay around past the first run of players? Mine's not.
Last edited Aug 29, 2008 12:07:21
 
Link
 
Drift,

I'm going to break the chain here.

It doesn't matter because if we assume teams are always going to get gutted as a result of preceived difficult competition, then it doesn't matter if we demote them, it will just happen again.
 
shield.bearer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ming Sao


Just thought of another reason...


14 pages and no C-Level Exec has added a thought or two to the discussion.


At the very least you should see someone interrupt and say "Good discussion guys. We will take this into consideration and try to do what is best for you and the future of the game"


The poor management of the game doesn't stop with coding or forum structure. Public Relations here is so lacking, cynics like me have no choice but to think this Beta is just a way to line pockets while they can and either close shop or sell the site to someone who has a clear vision for the future when sales fall dramatically.


This idea had so much potential it's not even funny. From that to this in 180 days is stunning.

Leave it to my cynical GM to find the clearest reasoning of all in the midst of a poop storm...
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Drift,

I'm going to break the chain here.

It doesn't matter because if we assume teams are always going to get gutted as a result of preceived difficult competition, then it doesn't matter if we demote them, it will just happen again.


But is it fair to the teams not gutting in lower divisons to look up and see 6-8 dead teams in the league above them?

I think not.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1

I won't disagree. But I'm talking about now. Not in 3 years. Teams are trying to win now. And quite honestly, there is no good reason 3 or 4 teams now should have a ridiculously advantage over the rest.

Right now, they do.

Moreover, what makes you think every franchise is going to stay around past the first run of players? Mine's not.


Huh? If you aren't going to be around for the full game, why would your complaints be valid?
 
shield.bearer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by islander1


I won't disagree. But I'm talking about now. Not in 3 years. Teams are trying to win now. And quite honestly, there is no good reason 3 or 4 teams now should have a ridiculously advantage over the rest.

Right now, they do.

Moreover, what makes you think every franchise is going to stay around past the first run of players? Mine's not.


Huh? If you aren't going to be around for the full game, why would your complaints be valid?

Because he's SPENDING FRICKING MONEY!!!
 
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Drift,

I'm going to break the chain here.

It doesn't matter because if we assume teams are always going to get gutted as a result of preceived difficult competition, then it doesn't matter if we demote them, it will just happen again.


But is it fair to the teams not gutting in lower divisons to look up and see 6-8 dead teams in the league above them?

I think not.


But that won't matter will it, as we've already cleared up the fact that many players/owners aren't here for competition, but to be the best of the best (a spot sadly reserved for only 1).
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
actually vanilla, feel free to brak my quote chain too. I'll edit it now
 
Link
 
Originally posted by shield.bearer
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by islander1



I won't disagree. But I'm talking about now. Not in 3 years. Teams are trying to win now. And quite honestly, there is no good reason 3 or 4 teams now should have a ridiculously advantage over the rest.

Right now, they do.

Moreover, what makes you think every franchise is going to stay around past the first run of players? Mine's not.


Huh? If you aren't going to be around for the full game, why would your complaints be valid?

Because he's SPENDING FRICKING MONEY!!!


So we should mortgage the future of the game for people that won't be around?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.