User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Season 4 changes ARE going to cost this game alot of dedicated players.
Page:
 
markhehe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Firenze
Originally posted by markhehe

i see this train wreck of a thread still has life. Kleenex is making a mint off you guys...lol.


I don't masturbate that often...*

























*Ok, that was a lie.


ok....Huggies are making a mint off you guys....or maybe Stayfree(with wings!!!)...hehe
 
deez11010
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Longhorn1976
BETA!!!

WoW never gave out respecs to the Beta testers, so that example doesn't work.


I didnt actually partake in WoWs beta. And WoW is not the only MMORPG. I did partake in Dark Age of Camelots betas. They DID give out free respecs to players in beta so they could test everything.

I definitely dont think respecs should be given during the season. HOWEVER, to test the playability of every spec every class has to offer, there should be free respecs. How else are we going to find bugs that only occur with certain specs?

It has Nothing to do with "I fucked up my build, can I have a respec". It has everything to do with finding out if there are any bugs related to certain spec types. Bort had even said so himself, there is no wrong way to spec a player, but if everybody keeps doing cookie cutter specs and training a certain way, then we'll never find the bug and never test those other specs as viable uses.

Just like this season how we discovered the slow WR vs fast CB bug. Where CBs were backpedaling 50 times faster than the WR was running, so they exploited it taking 5-8 yard passes all day long.
 
anfiach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by deez11010
Originally posted by Longhorn1976

BETA!!!

WoW never gave out respecs to the Beta testers, so that example doesn't work.


I didnt actually partake in WoWs beta. And WoW is not the only MMORPG. I did partake in Dark Age of Camelots betas. They DID give out free respecs to players in beta so they could test everything.

I definitely dont think respecs should be given during the season. HOWEVER, to test the playability of every spec every class has to offer, there should be free respecs. How else are we going to find bugs that only occur with certain specs?

It has Nothing to do with "I fucked up my build, can I have a respec". It has everything to do with finding out if there are any bugs related to certain spec types. Bort had even said so himself, there is no wrong way to spec a player, but if everybody keeps doing cookie cutter specs and training a certain way, then we'll never find the bug and never test those other specs as viable uses.

Just like this season how we discovered the slow WR vs fast CB bug. Where CBs were backpedaling 50 times faster than the WR was running, so they exploited it taking 5-8 yard passes all day long.

There is already a wide variety of builds, this arguent doesn't hold water. We have min/max guys we have slow build guys and even balanced guys. Like I said, if Bort felt it would in any way help in testing he would do it.
 
tyrant91101
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by deez11010
Originally posted by Longhorn1976

BETA!!!

WoW never gave out respecs to the Beta testers, so that example doesn't work.


I didnt actually partake in WoWs beta. And WoW is not the only MMORPG. I did partake in Dark Age of Camelots betas. They DID give out free respecs to players in beta so they could test everything.

I definitely dont think respecs should be given during the season. HOWEVER, to test the playability of every spec every class has to offer, there should be free respecs. How else are we going to find bugs that only occur with certain specs?

It has Nothing to do with "I fucked up my build, can I have a respec". It has everything to do with finding out if there are any bugs related to certain spec types. Bort had even said so himself, there is no wrong way to spec a player, but if everybody keeps doing cookie cutter specs and training a certain way, then we'll never find the bug and never test those other specs as viable uses.

Just like this season how we discovered the slow WR vs fast CB bug. Where CBs were backpedaling 50 times faster than the WR was running, so they exploited it taking 5-8 yard passes all day long.


You can't have free respecs in this game because people have already payed so much to play GLB. Free respecs would be attuned to doing a whole wipe of the whole game and that would totally massacre all hopes of keep the current user base.

As for all the new changes, I can't be happier. So far all of the changes have done nothing but help my players. My CB has finally had a game in which he completely shut down the passing game, my WRs are doing better then ever, my QB is just plain massacring, and my O-linemen just keep pushing the defense down field
 
morbo
offline
Link
 
I don't get why everyone is acting like it's impossible to change your build. All your equipment can be changed, and if you are smart enough you hold your boosts until you are sure what's going on this season. That's 33 skill points to distribute if you are above level 16, 37 if above 24. We definately don't need respecs.
 
deez11010
offline
Link
 
Not everybody whos partaking in the beta is boosting. It costs $$ to boost and many people dont want to pay $$ to be involved in a beta, yet they still would like to test things out.

Personally, It doesnt matter all that much to me, I doubt I would be one of the people to respec, even with a drastic change cus the spec should still be tested even with the changes.

Its just, with what I've experienced so far in this game (keep in mind I didnt start til day 7 of season 3 I think it was) people mostly do coookie cutter specs, cus its what most teams want. There doesnt seem to be THAT drastic of differences with most the player specs I've seen/heard of. And imo, there should be every spectrum of specs in game being used to test them.
 
RunningMn9
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
No, I absolutely oppose free respecs.

This season was so large of a change that a 5 or even 10 point respec during the offseason might have been in order. But never, ever during a season, rendering scouting useless.


If we're just beta testing the game, why does it matter whether or not you are able to scout your opponent? That only matters if you're playing the game, not testing it.


Originally posted by
WoW never gave out respecs to the Beta testers, so that example doesn't work.


I didn't beta test WoW - but Vanguard, CoH, EQ2 and D&D Online did. Not only that - but they all gave out respecs in the live game when they made major changes to the game system. Same with Star Wars: Galaxies. If the goal is TESTING the game, why wouldn't you give out respecs when the game rules change substantially? Your goal is to test likely scenarios in that rule set. Not to test toons made in the old rule set to see how they fare in the new rule set.
 
RunningMn9
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by anfiach
There is already a wide variety of builds, this arguent doesn't hold water. We have min/max guys we have slow build guys and even balanced guys. Like I said, if Bort felt it would in any way help in testing he would do it.


With all due respect to Bort - what on Earth has given you the impression that he knows how to effectively test this game?!?

He's making fundamental mistakes in his testing process that should never be made. The people whining against respecs are making my point. They don't want respecs because it makes playing the game to hard. OUR JOB ISN'T TO PLAY THE GAME. It's to TEST the game. Fundamentally different goal, and you can't treat them the same.

I don't want free and unlimited respecs when I'm playing the game. But they're necessary to effectively test the game. When testing, your goal is to TRY TO BREAK THE GAME. I can't do that if I'm trying to win games.

This is common sense software development. Maybe you don't know or understand that - but Bort should if he wants this game to last.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
I think you would find the majority of people here feel they are playing the game, not testing it. And they are playing to win, not to break the SIM (though many of us will try that as well with a player or two).

Take that for what you will...I'm enjoying it regardless of the changes, I'll let those who really are bothered fight the good fight
 
RunningMn9
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tyrant91101
You can't have free respecs in this game because people have already payed so much to play GLB. Free respecs would be attuned to doing a whole wipe of the whole game and that would totally massacre all hopes of keep the current user base.


Jesus H. Christ on a popsickle stick. THAT'S WHY THEY SHOULD DO IT ON A SEPARATE TESTING SERVER SO THAT THE GAME CAN ACTUALLY GET TESTED LIKE IT NEEDS TO GET TESTED, WHILE THE PEOPLE THAT ARE PAYING TO PLAY THE GAME CAN ACTUALLY PLAY THE GODDAMN GAME IN A MORE PREDICTABLE ENVIRONMENT.

This isn't complicated. It's what EVERY game developer does (except Bort apparently).

 
Checkmate187
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RunningMn9
Originally posted by tyrant91101

You can't have free respecs in this game because people have already payed so much to play GLB. Free respecs would be attuned to doing a whole wipe of the whole game and that would totally massacre all hopes of keep the current user base.


Jesus H. Christ on a popsickle stick. THAT'S WHY THEY SHOULD DO IT ON A SEPARATE TESTING SERVER SO THAT THE GAME CAN ACTUALLY GET TESTED LIKE IT NEEDS TO GET TESTED, WHILE THE PEOPLE THAT ARE PAYING TO PLAY THE GAME CAN ACTUALLY PLAY THE GODDAMN GAME IN A MORE PREDICTABLE ENVIRONMENT.

This isn't complicated. It's what EVERY game developer does (except Bort apparently).



Only so much testing you can do. Bort said himself that people are using the AI in ways he never anticipated.

You can't plan for ideas coming from a couple hundred thousand players.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by deez11010
Ok, I never said "if you dont like it, quit". I said its beta and changes should be expected daily. This is beta, it should be expected to find bugs, not 95% bug free. I dont know of any game that has even launched 95% bug free. Every one I've ever seen goes live, and then has to take the servers back down usually within a couple hours of the launch because a major bug was released that was never discovered but was game altering.

Also, GLB DOES NOT charge people. NONE of us HAVE to pay a penny to play this beta. If YOU CHOOSE to pay $$, then you cant blame the admins/devs for your choice to spend $$ on a game still in BETA.

Yes I've spent lots of $$ myself, but that was my choice. Because I have also been part of many betas including MMORPG betas, I know not to expect anything except bugs and changes on a daily basis.

Once again, this is the entire point of a open beta. To stress test the servers and see what flaws the game has, with more than just 100 people testing it. The more people there are testing it, the more bugs you can find before the launch.

However I do agree, since this IS BETA, we should have free respecs available every season to compensate for the new changes to and test the new changes.


This is NOT BETA. Just because Bort or DD post it on the site that it's BETA, it doesn't make it BETA. Everything from testing to the payment system makes this game a business. If I brought my dog to your house and told you it was a cat, would it really make the dog a cat?

So if anyone post "It's BETA" on the front page then it make it a BETA? If OJ put up a sign that says "I'm not guilty" on his lawn would that really make him innocent? All you people keep calling it's a BETA because there are bugs and changes are made, well, just because something is constantly changing doesn't make it a BETA, there are a lot of established programs out there that still making changes. Whenever you charge people, and people pay for a product, it's no longer BETA. If you want to believe it's BETA, fine, you are entitled to your own opinion. BUT PLEASE DO NOT INSULT THE REST OF US BY TELLING US IT'S BETA AND USING IT AS AN EXCUSE. THIS IS JUST AS RIDICULOUS AS SAYING WE ARE GOING TO IRAQ FOR WOMD!!! THERE ARE A LOT OF PEOPLE HERE WHO ARE NOT RETARDS.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
yes, saying the game is beta is just as ridiculous as going to iraq for WOMD. There might be a lot of people here who aren't "retards"...but given your absurd use of CAPS and your silly analogies, I can't say with any confidence that you fall into that category.

Anyways, this game is not complete and is ever-changing, so if Bort and Co. want to call it a Beta, that is fine by me. And because they have no publisher, it was my choice to put money into the game, you have the same choice.

Just because other games in beta (beta testing) don't charge the testers doesn't mean it always has to be that way. Just like most MMORPG's don't force retirement of your character. And despite some MMORPG's offering free respecs, again, no reason this has to happen everywhere.

Feel free to bitch to your heart's content, but there are plenty more people actually enjoying the game than the minority who feel the urge to voice their displeasure and threaten to quit.

Now does that mean the game can't be improved? Of course not, it definitely can be. But if people were a little more constructive compared to most of the garbage that fills these forums on a daily basis, it might help move things forward at a faster pace.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
yes, saying the game is beta is just as ridiculous as going to iraq for WOMD. There might be a lot of people here who aren't "retards"...but given your absurd use of CAPS and your silly analogies, I can't say with any confidence that you fall into that category.

Anyways, this game is not complete and is ever-changing, so if Bort and Co. want to call it a Beta, that is fine by me. And because they have no publisher, it was my choice to put money into the game, you have the same choice.

Just because other games in beta (beta testing) don't charge the testers doesn't mean it always has to be that way. Just like most MMORPG's don't force retirement of your character. And despite some MMORPG's offering free respecs, again, no reason this has to happen everywhere.

Feel free to bitch to your heart's content, but there are plenty more people actually enjoying the game than the minority who feel the urge to voice their displeasure and threaten to quit.

Now does that mean the game can't be improved? Of course not, it definitely can be. But if people were a little more constructive compared to most of the garbage that fills these forums on a daily basis, it might help move things forward at a faster pace.


LOL, YOU REALLY HAD ME THERE. IT'S REALLY A GOOD THING THAT PEOPLE ARE NOT USING THE USAGE OF THE CAPS AS A STANDARD FOR INTELLIGENCE. "DO YOU USE THE CAP LOCK?", "YES I DO." "GREAT, NOW YOU ARE QUALIFIED TO TAKE THE SHORTBUS AND PARTICIPATE IN SPECIAL OLYMPICS".

I have never bitched about the the changes in the game, I simply have an issue with how some of them are carried out. I'm not here to bash Bort, DD or GLB, simply giving my suggestion as to how to make this game better.

I'm just really sick and tired of people who brings up "this is a BETA" every time as an excuse. Honestly, how many people are playing this game to "test" the game and trying to break the sim? How many people that have paid to boost their players or buying teams just so they can "test" the game?
 
Checkmate187
offline
Link
 
It's absurd to compare this to any other game. It is truly one of a kind.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.