User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > ATTN: Tying Flex Points to Contracts as an Incentive or Condition
Page:
 
Tiger224
offline
Link
 
Geez. I find that almost ridiculous. I want to win just as much as the next guy...but giving folks real money to sign via free FP's is stupid.

Folks doing that mess SHOULD be banned, IMO.
 
KCScott
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32


Taha because this game is not about the richest person wins...it's supposed to let people with all types of money situations play but how can a guy who can't afford to give out Flex Points get FAs when everyone else if offering 1000-2000 FPs to sign...it isn't rocket science....


Sorry - I only made it to page 8

If this suggestion has already been made then please disregard:

The only way to get Money out of the equation is to elimiate boosting and custom equipment using FP.

FP cpuld be restricted only to multiple player creation

Anything else and FP remain a currencythat will be used "undergroud" as someone previously explained.

Again - if this has already been suggested please disregard.
 
Buzzkill
offline
Link
 
I definitely agree that it shouldnt be allowed as part of contract negotiations. As far as helping team mates out, i dont feel the same. I know there are some situations where someone has been a very active part of a very close knit team, both in helping with game plans, and keeping forums active, and has proven dedicated to that team regardless of the situation. Said person runs into the situation where they arent going to be able to afford to boost their player/s, and because of it they are going to fall behind and incidentally hurt the team.

Another member of the team learns of this, and offers to pay for their boosts so that their players can continue to contribute to the team, because they realize the value of that player's agent within the team, and because a solid relationship exists with the agent. The agent who couldnt afford to boost has no intentions of going elsewhere, but by not boosting, the owner may have been forced to recruit someone to fill their position to avoid them impacting the team negatively, which may have meant trading that agent away from the team.

Its a fine line between right and wrong, but i dont see any issue with a situation like this, which is why i think looking at things on a case by case basis is the best way to deal with it.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Buzzkill
I definitely agree that it shouldnt be allowed as part of contract negotiations. As far as helping team mates out, i dont feel the same. I know there are some situations where someone has been a very active part of a very close knit team, both in helping with game plans, and keeping forums active, and has proven dedicated to that team regardless of the situation. Said person runs into the situation where they arent going to be able to afford to boost their player/s, and because of it they are going to fall behind and incidentally hurt the team.

Another member of the team learns of this, and offers to pay for their boosts so that their players can continue to contribute to the team, because they realize the value of that player's agent within the team, and because a solid relationship exists with the agent. The agent who couldnt afford to boost has no intentions of going elsewhere, but by not boosting, the owner may have been forced to recruit someone to fill their position to avoid them impacting the team negatively, which may have meant trading that agent away from the team.

Its a fine line between right and wrong, but i dont see any issue with a situation like this, which is why i think looking at things on a case by case basis is the best way to deal with it.


Except that once this becomes acceptable, the number of people lying about their financial situation will increase ten-fold because they know they will be able to take advantage of the more generous people on the site.

The more I think about it, the more I think ALL FP transactions should be banned. Period.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Buzzkill
I definitely agree that it shouldnt be allowed as part of contract negotiations. As far as helping team mates out, i dont feel the same. I know there are some situations where someone has been a very active part of a very close knit team, both in helping with game plans, and keeping forums active, and has proven dedicated to that team regardless of the situation. Said person runs into the situation where they arent going to be able to afford to boost their player/s, and because of it they are going to fall behind and incidentally hurt the team.

Another member of the team learns of this, and offers to pay for their boosts so that their players can continue to contribute to the team, because they realize the value of that player's agent within the team, and because a solid relationship exists with the agent. The agent who couldnt afford to boost has no intentions of going elsewhere, but by not boosting, the owner may have been forced to recruit someone to fill their position to avoid them impacting the team negatively, which may have meant trading that agent away from the team.

Its a fine line between right and wrong, but i dont see any issue with a situation like this, which is why i think looking at things on a case by case basis is the best way to deal with it.



why is it ok for 1 guy to receive FP's and not the other?

your reasoning: because he's a nice guy and helped the team.

my answer: the FA is a nice guy also??

What's the difference??


There isn't any. The nice guy on an alrady established team would have been a new recruit for some other team if the team let him go because he was falling behind. That other team would have been happy to have him. But because of this teammate buying his buddy FP's....now that other team gets screwed and doesn't have the FA that they would have had otherwise. In fact, they never even knew they got screwed which is even worse because the guy never even hit the market.


P.S. This system of paying for freinds already on the team helps the BEST teams stay the best (ie USA PRO). That is why this policy is being allowed for them to boost their buddies and retain all those level 27's they have....


 
Link
 
Originally posted by Tiger224
Geez. I find that almost ridiculous. I want to win just as much as the next guy... but giving folks real money to sign via free FP's is stupid.

Folks doing that mess SHOULD be banned, IMO.


So spending $10 on your player is fine, but some idiot who spends $10 on another player is an idiot??

Your logic escapes me.

Ban all FP exchanges or don't ban any. Determining "intent" is going to be near impossible. Only idiots who can't read are going to be caught.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Bort should just allow this and and charge 10%. Its going to happen anyway, might as well get a bit extra. Maybe then he can hire another programmer.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by hud
Originally posted by ACES

I guess I need clarification.....Is it ok to offer FP as a reward for say INT's, TD's, Sacks? those of course would be based on the season same as MVP of the season as I am not rich.


Any way you transfer FP, there is still risk involved, so we don't recommend it. as of right now it is not illegal.


However, if the player who receives those flex points at a later time ever wants to blackmail you, he can say that you gave him the points as a condition that you re-sign. At that point you are screwed. If 2 such players that you gave FP's to banned together because they don't like your gameplans, they could have you permanantly banned.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by hud

Originally posted by ACES


I guess I need clarification.....Is it ok to offer FP as a reward for say INT's, TD's, Sacks? those of course would be based on the season same as MVP of the season as I am not rich.


Any way you transfer FP, there is still risk involved, so we don't recommend it. as of right now it is not illegal.


However, if the player who receives those flex points at a later time ever wants to blackmail you, he can say that you gave him the points as a condition that you re-sign. At that point you are screwed. If 2 such players that you gave FP's to banned together because they don't like your gameplans, they could have you permanantly banned.


They would have to have some kind of proof. Proof they wouldn't have.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by hud
Originally posted by ACES
I guess I need clarification.....Is it ok to offer FP as a reward for say INT's, TD's, Sacks? those of course would be based on the season same as MVP of the season as I am not rich.

Any way you transfer FP, there is still risk involved, so we don't recommend it. as of right now it is not illegal.

However, if the player who receives those flex points at a later time ever wants to blackmail you, he can say that you gave him the points as a condition that you re-sign. At that point you are screwed. If 2 such players that you gave FP's to banned together because they don't like your gameplans, they could have you permanantly banned.

They would have to have some kind of proof. Proof they wouldn't have.


True, but all it takes is one accusation like that to scare off a lot of people who just read the first post of a topic without doing any research.
 
Link
 
The ONLY REASON why this is an issue is because teams want to improve. Short of waiting 10-12 seasons until the Tim Hapers / early testers players start to decline, there doesn't seem to be any way to put together the TOP team in this game.

And to make it even more unfair, you allow a policy where Tim Harper can pay to keep his level 27 and 28 players together, but you don't allow us to pay to try to take them away from him.

You make policies to allow the early testers to keep their mulitple teams, then no one else is allowed.

You make policies to allow early players to keep their farm teams even though it was implied from the beginning that it was "against the spirit of the game".

Then you even make policies to penalize high level players for leaving PRO. I'm a Pro team and I benefit GREATLY from that rule, but I think it is BS. Who cares if high level players want to play in low leagues?? Guess who this helps the most though? USA PRO and early testers of course.

That is why I keep arguing: I want a chance to win the whole thing, or I don't want to play. Others feel the same way.

We're giving you a little time to straighten things out, but I'm not putting another penny in until I see that I have a chance to own the best team in the league in less than 10-12 season. Otherwise, we are just filler teams to help pay for the USA Pro Teams and the only league that seems to matter in this game. I guess it sure helps to be friends with the owner/developer when it comes to making rules.....


If you want to make rules to protect the monopoly/chokehold that USA Pro (and 2/3 of the MODS) have on this game right now, then just say so. I'll come back in 10-12 seasons when I have a fair chance.....

....otherwise, stop cracking down on the little guys who are trying to improve and instead crack down on the guys who have dominated the game for the first 3 seasons and will continue to do so for the forseeable future.
Last edited Jul 13, 2008 18:50:18
 
Buzzkill
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Buzzkill

I definitely agree that it shouldnt be allowed as part of contract negotiations. As far as helping team mates out, i dont feel the same. I know there are some situations where someone has been a very active part of a very close knit team, both in helping with game plans, and keeping forums active, and has proven dedicated to that team regardless of the situation. Said person runs into the situation where they arent going to be able to afford to boost their player/s, and because of it they are going to fall behind and incidentally hurt the team.

Another member of the team learns of this, and offers to pay for their boosts so that their players can continue to contribute to the team, because they realize the value of that player's agent within the team, and because a solid relationship exists with the agent. The agent who couldnt afford to boost has no intentions of going elsewhere, but by not boosting, the owner may have been forced to recruit someone to fill their position to avoid them impacting the team negatively, which may have meant trading that agent away from the team.

Its a fine line between right and wrong, but i dont see any issue with a situation like this, which is why i think looking at things on a case by case basis is the best way to deal with it.



why is it ok for 1 guy to receive FP's and not the other?

your reasoning: because he's a nice guy and helped the team.

my answer: the FA is a nice guy also??

What's the difference??


There isn't any. The nice guy on an alrady established team would have been a new recruit for some other team if the team let him go because he was falling behind. That other team would have been happy to have him. But because of this teammate buying his buddy FP's....now that other team gets screwed and doesn't have the FA that they would have had otherwise. In fact, they never even knew they got screwed which is even worse because the guy never even hit the market.


P.S. This system of paying for freinds already on the team helps the BEST teams stay the best (ie USA PRO). That is why this policy is being allowed for them to boost their buddies and retain all those level 27's they have....




I knew that was coming lol. The difference is that there was no contract incentive involved. The player was staying regardless, unless the owner decided to move him to get an upgrade. The owner didnt convince the player to stay by having someone pay for his boosts, and the player didnt tell the owner he was leaving unless someone bought his boosts. The situation i described had nothing to do with ending contracts, or resigning contracts, other than the fact that eventually the owner may have been forced to replace him. The owner may very well have decided that his contribution to the team was important enough to keep him regardless of the lack of boosts, so his contract never even comes into question.

The whole intent of the rule was to prevent people from gaining an unfair advantage in recruiting, just because they are willing to pay more real money than someone else. When you have an agent who is already proven to be a dedicated part of your team regardless of the situation, i dont think recruitment is an issue there anymore.

I do agree with you that if they just did away with boosts period, and only allowed FP to be used to create players or purchase teams, it would make the whole topic a moot point. But until they do so, whether it is allowed or not, its going to take place, and i personally dont have an issue with the situation i described(note that that is my own personal opinion...feel free to disagree)
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
The ONLY REASON why this is an issue is because teams want to improve. Short of waiting 10-12 seasons until the Tim Haper's / early testers players start to decline, there doesn't seem to be any way to put together the TOP team in this game.

And to make it even more unfair, you allow a policy where Tim Harper can pay to keep his level 27 and 28 players together, but you don't allow us to pay to try to take them away from him.

That is why I keep arguing: I want a chance to win the whole thing, or I don't want to play. Others feel the same way.

We're giving you a little time to straighten things out, but I'm not putting another penny in until I see that I have a chance to own the best team in the league in less than 10-12 season.

If you want to make rules to protect the monopoly/chokehold that USA Pro (and 2/3 of the MODS) have on this game right now, then just say so. I'll come back in 10-12 seasons when I have a fair chance.....



I hadn't considered the conflict of interest perspective here. It now makes sense why not all FP transactions are banned. The moderators "unanimously" approved this new rule intentionally allowing FP transactions not tied to contracts.

I think it's time to do away with player/moderators. There is simply too much of a conflict of interest for this system to continue. Since they now seem to have the power to make the rules, of course they will draft them in a way that best suits themselves. I think a lot of people will tire quickly of throwing money into a system that they have no chance of succeeding in because they happened to be a little late to the party.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Buzzkill
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by Buzzkill


I definitely agree that it shouldnt be allowed as part of contract negotiations. As far as helping team mates out, i dont feel the same. I know there are some situations where someone has been a very active part of a very close knit team, both in helping with game plans, and keeping forums active, and has proven dedicated to that team regardless of the situation. Said person runs into the situation where they arent going to be able to afford to boost their player/s, and because of it they are going to fall behind and incidentally hurt the team.

Another member of the team learns of this, and offers to pay for their boosts so that their players can continue to contribute to the team, because they realize the value of that player's agent within the team, and because a solid relationship exists with the agent. The agent who couldnt afford to boost has no intentions of going elsewhere, but by not boosting, the owner may have been forced to recruit someone to fill their position to avoid them impacting the team negatively, which may have meant trading that agent away from the team.

Its a fine line between right and wrong, but i dont see any issue with a situation like this, which is why i think looking at things on a case by case basis is the best way to deal with it.



why is it ok for 1 guy to receive FP's and not the other?

your reasoning: because he's a nice guy and helped the team.

my answer: the FA is a nice guy also??

What's the difference??


There isn't any. The nice guy on an alrady established team would have been a new recruit for some other team if the team let him go because he was falling behind. That other team would have been happy to have him. But because of this teammate buying his buddy FP's....now that other team gets screwed and doesn't have the FA that they would have had otherwise. In fact, they never even knew they got screwed which is even worse because the guy never even hit the market.


P.S. This system of paying for freinds already on the team helps the BEST teams stay the best (ie USA PRO). That is why this policy is being allowed for them to boost their buddies and retain all those level 27's they have....




I knew that was coming lol. The difference is that there was no contract incentive involved. The player was staying regardless, unless the owner decided to move him to get an upgrade. The owner didnt convince the player to stay by having someone pay for his boosts, and the player didnt tell the owner he was leaving unless someone bought his boosts. The situation i described had nothing to do with ending contracts, or resigning contracts, other than the fact that eventually the owner may have been forced to replace him. The owner may very well have decided that his contribution to the team was important enough to keep him regardless of the lack of boosts, so his contract never even comes into question.

The whole intent of the rule was to prevent people from gaining an unfair advantage in recruiting, just because they are willing to pay more real money than someone else. When you have an agent who is already proven to be a dedicated part of your team regardless of the situation, i dont think recruitment is an issue there anymore.

I do agree with you that if they just did away with boosts period, and only allowed FP to be used to create players or purchase teams, it would make the whole topic a moot point. But until they do so, whether it is allowed or not, its going to take place, and i personally dont have an issue with the situation i described(note that that is my own personal opinion...feel free to disagree)


Of course I disagree.

No contract incentive involved? Of course there is. The contract is: "if you stay on my team, then I'll buy you flex points". You can "say" that the person was never going to leave, but you would be wrong. After 2 seasons of not boosting and falling 6 levels behind, there is NO WAY that the player would get playing time and would ask to leave the team and play somewhere else. Period. He was paid to stay with the team.


The intent of the rule also makes it very convenient for the most important people in the game (USA PRO/early testers/Bort's friends) to keep all their high level players. It's just alot more fun for them that way....

If you have the option of getting free flex points from your owner or going FA and not being able to get FP's from the new owner.....what are you going to do? I know I would stay put.


 
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by hud


Originally posted by ACES



I guess I need clarification.....Is it ok to offer FP as a reward for say INT's, TD's, Sacks? those of course would be based on the season same as MVP of the season as I am not rich.


Any way you transfer FP, there is still risk involved, so we don't recommend it. as of right now it is not illegal.


However, if the player who receives those flex points at a later time ever wants to blackmail you, he can say that you gave him the points as a condition that you re-sign. At that point you are screwed. If 2 such players that you gave FP's to banned together because they don't like your gameplans, they could have you permanantly banned.


They would have to have some kind of proof. Proof they wouldn't have.


They never said that proof was required. They said they would take it on a case by case basis. Accusations against certain owners (me) would definitely be enough IMO.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.