User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Playable Cheerleaders Compiled Suggestion
Page:
 
Checkmate187
offline
Link
 
I am going to name my first cheerleader 'Honey Bear'
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
I'm just curious Larry, you've been with us from page 1 all the way to page 14-15 now.

Why do you hate this idea with seemingly all your soul?
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by wombat killer


Originally posted by Checkmate187



Originally posted by wombat killer




Originally posted by Laggo





Originally posted by wombat killer








Wrong. It will hurt those that don't make them if they actually have an impact on the game. Then people will do it only to have a level playing field. Having a situation where people are doing something solely for the purpose of keeping equal and getting no enjoyment out of it seems like a bad idea to me.


Wombat I see you have 2 HB's. Are you hurt that you don't have a QB because they have an impact on the game?

And about "Having a situation where people are doing something solely for the purpose of keeping equal and getting no enjoyment out of it seems like a bad idea to me." I think Ken addressed that he is not making one solely for "keeping equal" and getting "no enjoyment out of it". Nobody is forced to make a cheerleader to "keep equal". They don't affect your own players equally, they affect the team and can be hired. It's like making a WR and saying you have to have a QB or else you have nobody to pass to you. Thats not how it works.



I have no idea what the first part of your post means.

When not enough chearleaders are being made, then people will make their own just to keep up.


Dude, there would be CPU cheerleaders just like there are CPU positional players that fill out teams

What don't you get about that?


"just like there are CPU positional players that fill out teams"

Unless you are saying they will be just as good as human "players", that doesn't mean a whole lot. How many people are keeping CPU players on their team right now?


IF not enough people make them.

If enough people make them (they could have them cost only 50 FP's (and 50 FP's to boost, with only two boosts allowed per season) to make to encourage people to make them), then no one will have to make them just to keep up.

Owners will actually have to hire them (OMG!) No one else who doesn't want anything to do with the idea has to.

This should be one of several "side games" one can participate in or not, cheaply but not free, if one wants to.


You do the math. You really think people are going to make enough for the fun of it?



Okay, let's say they don't. So let's say that some teams get small advantages by having human cheerleaders rather than cpu ones.

Some teams have cpu's as backups everywhere, starters some places. Since the players matter more than the cheerleaders would, you're giving a small advantage (at a price) to teams who hire human cheerleaders.

Don't want to play the side game? Don't.
 
Checkmate187
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Laggo
I'm just curious Larry, you've been with us from page 1 all the way to page 14-15 now.

Why do you hate this idea with seemingly all your soul?


Pretty girls intimidate him. Have your logo gnaw on his ankle.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Laggo
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader



You're just winging it now--again, you have NOT ONE IOTA's knowledge of how Bort has worked "morale" into his coding algos. Yet you'd have us believe that you're reading to jump right in and implement this with NO knowledge of how THIS adjustment would affect the rest of the coding.

This thread is long over-due for a response from an admin and a lock.


Tim has already said he can't lock it btw so your at a loss if thats what your expecting.

And i'm saying im willing to jump in and help to have it implemented - nothing wrong with that.

Originally posted by wombat killer

You do the math. You really think people are going to make enough for the fun of it?


You really think people AREN'T going to make a new position? If player coaches were implemented people would flock to it - same as this.


Clearly I think people aren't going to make enough. I don't think it would even be remotely close.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Laggo
I'm just curious Larry, you've been with us from page 1 all the way to page 14-15 now.

Why do you hate this idea with seemingly all your soul?



I've made that quite clear. You've made it quite clear that you aren't LISTENING.

 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by wombat killer

Originally posted by Ken1


Originally posted by wombat killer



Originally posted by Checkmate187




Originally posted by wombat killer





Originally posted by Laggo






Originally posted by wombat killer









Wrong. It will hurt those that don't make them if they actually have an impact on the game. Then people will do it only to have a level playing field. Having a situation where people are doing something solely for the purpose of keeping equal and getting no enjoyment out of it seems like a bad idea to me.


Wombat I see you have 2 HB's. Are you hurt that you don't have a QB because they have an impact on the game?

And about "Having a situation where people are doing something solely for the purpose of keeping equal and getting no enjoyment out of it seems like a bad idea to me." I think Ken addressed that he is not making one solely for "keeping equal" and getting "no enjoyment out of it". Nobody is forced to make a cheerleader to "keep equal". They don't affect your own players equally, they affect the team and can be hired. It's like making a WR and saying you have to have a QB or else you have nobody to pass to you. Thats not how it works.



I have no idea what the first part of your post means.

When not enough chearleaders are being made, then people will make their own just to keep up.


Dude, there would be CPU cheerleaders just like there are CPU positional players that fill out teams

What don't you get about that?


"just like there are CPU positional players that fill out teams"

Unless you are saying they will be just as good as human "players", that doesn't mean a whole lot. How many people are keeping CPU players on their team right now?


IF not enough people make them.

If enough people make them (they could have them cost only 50 FP's (and 50 FP's to boost, with only two boosts allowed per season) to make to encourage people to make them), then no one will have to make them just to keep up.

Owners will actually have to hire them (OMG!) No one else who doesn't want anything to do with the idea has to.

This should be one of several "side games" one can participate in or not, cheaply but not free, if one wants to.


You do the math. You really think people are going to make enough for the fun of it?



Okay, let's say they don't. So let's say that some teams get small advantages by having human cheerleaders rather than cpu ones.

Some teams have cpu's as backups everywhere, starters some places. Since the players matter more than the cheerleaders would, you're giving a small advantage (at a price) to teams who hire human cheerleaders.

Don't want to play the side game? Don't.


While I understand this reasoning, I am against it because it puts those of us who do not, under any circumstances, want to spend money on extra crap at a disadvantage. If you want to have a separate game of cheer squads that go against each other in cheer competitions, FINE. Just don't have it affect the football game that the rest of us signed up for.
 
CLOWNBABY
offline
Link
 
The internet hit an all-time low today, Laggo. Thank you, and God bless America.
 
Checkmate187
offline
Link
 
Cheap cheerleader = something to do with your leftover FP.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by Laggo

I'm just curious Larry, you've been with us from page 1 all the way to page 14-15 now.

Why do you hate this idea with seemingly all your soul?



I've made that quite clear. You've made it quite clear that you aren't LISTENING.



The point is:

1) No one forces you to make them.

2) At most, if you're an owner, you have to take a bit of time to hire some. But if there aren't enough to go around then lots of owners will have cpu cheerleaders and you can just do that.

So, who gets hurt?

I'll even admit that if this takes tons of coding time it shouldn't be done, as other things are more important. It doesn't seem as if it would, though.
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome


While I understand this reasoning, I am against it because it puts those of us who do not, under any circumstances, want to spend money on extra crap at a disadvantage. If you want to have a separate game of cheer squads that go against each other in cheer competitions, FINE. Just don't have it affect the football game that the rest of us signed up for.


Why does it put you at a disadvantage?

It's the same as having a HB but not a TE. Why does it put individual user's at a disadvantage?

I'd like to know the answer to that question.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Checkmate187
Originally posted by awesome

Originally posted by Checkmate187


1. Cheerleaders are merely the mechanism that will affect morale. Call it cheerleaders, fans, crowd, cow shit... I don't care.

2. I think if made available, every damn one of you nay-sayers will have at least one cheerleader the next day.... as will all the people who love this idea. That means mo' money, mo' money, MO' MONEY!!


Right... such a blatant ploy to squeeze more money out of the users will be so obvious, people will LEAVE the site.


What's so different between this and having a playable coach that affects in-game play?


I stopped reading right here, so this might have been answered already, but who in their right mind would ever think that a cheer leader is as big an influence in a football game as a coach?
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
Nobody. Your completely missing the reason why that point was brought up.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Laggo
Originally posted by awesome



While I understand this reasoning, I am against it because it puts those of us who do not, under any circumstances, want to spend money on extra crap at a disadvantage. If you want to have a separate game of cheer squads that go against each other in cheer competitions, FINE. Just don't have it affect the football game that the rest of us signed up for.


Why does it put you at a disadvantage?

It's the same as having a HB but not a TE. Why does it put individual user's at a disadvantage?

I'd like to know the answer to that question.


For the ONE HUNDREDTH FUCKING TIME: If you create the position, people will have to fill them. Not everyone will want to. The teams that don't want to fill these bullshit positions will be at a disadvantage. All the players on the teams that don't have bullshit cheerleaders will be at a disadvantage. Why is this so hard for you to grasp? My god, the hormones have stripped you of all sense of reason.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Laggo
Nobody. Your completely missing the reason why that point was brought up.


And... there was no point. Hence the lack of articulation again here.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.