Originally posted by Razup
Originally posted by Seric
No I get it more than you do. Unlike you, I understand the rules. You could change the rules to fit what you want and you'd still find something wrong with it. You can't please everyone, to even try is insanity. The rules they have now are the fairest.
What you obviously didn't bother to see with the fact I posted about my team is this. You have a team, like mine, who are doing everything they can be to be competitive but always miss the playoffs by 1 game. The first one, I decided to move up 2 caps even though I was only supposed to move up 1. The reason was to be competitive. Yet again I missed the playoffs. So forcing teams to move up 2 caps when they missed the playoffs, just because they have players over the cap on the team prior to the move, fixes what? You will end up having the same teams missing the playoffs. Then you look at you force them to move up 2 caps, you're going to have to force the teams who make the playoffs up 3 caps to make space, eventually you will have lvl 38 teams who make the playoffs end up moving straight into AA. How does your whole complaint of wanting to force teams with players over the cap into the right caps fix anything? It doesn't it creates more problems.
You don't need to force playoff teams up 3 cap levels. Jump them up two caps as well. Either the teams that lag behind season after season get better, or they quit. Or they remain content to come in 9th or 10th every season. Do the teams that finish 9th or 10th in the Pro leagues complain that it's unfair that they can't do any better? Do they think that every playoff team should get pushed into the World League so they have a shot at winning?
If you miss the playoffs against equal-leveled competition, that's not a problem with the game. If you miss the playoffs by one game, and then promote and miss the playoffs by one game again, and then promote and miss the playoffs by one game again, that's not a problem with the game. That's a problem with your tactics and/or your builds. That problem lies on your end, not with how the game mechanics are handled. Get better, or get out.
When you're playing for 2nd place at best because you're down 2-4 levels on a team in your league, with no possible way to sign players that are of equal level, that's a problem with the game. You might be able to make up a couple levels with superior tactics or superior builds, but if they're just as well built and just as tactically sound as you are, there's absolutely no competition. And that's a problem with the game.
Lets see you already have 16 teams moving up 2 caps already just from the playoffs, which takes the place of the 16 before. Then you have to take into consideration people requesting to demote down to lower caps. Then the teams that are already 12 teams from the cap right below that cap moving up 1. Do you seriously think there will be room in every league for all the teams that have players over the cap.
People need to remember, as someone esle has pointed out and I have pointed out on numerous occassions, that the caps are SIGNING caps not hard caps.
See I GOT better but STILL missed the playoffs in a league I wasn't even supposed to be going into. only 16 teams make the playoffs. You can get better but guess what, the other teams that make the playoffs got that much better than you did. So how does that little comment of yours either get better or quit fix anything? It just pretty much makes a lot more CPU teams but that REALLY fixes things doesn't it.
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by Seric
No I get it more than you do. Unlike you, I understand the rules. You could change the rules to fit what you want and you'd still find something wrong with it. You can't please everyone, to even try is insanity. The rules they have now are the fairest.
What you obviously didn't bother to see with the fact I posted about my team is this. You have a team, like mine, who are doing everything they can be to be competitive but always miss the playoffs by 1 game. The first one, I decided to move up 2 caps even though I was only supposed to move up 1. The reason was to be competitive. Yet again I missed the playoffs. So forcing teams to move up 2 caps when they missed the playoffs, just because they have players over the cap on the team prior to the move, fixes what? You will end up having the same teams missing the playoffs. Then you look at you force them to move up 2 caps, you're going to have to force the teams who make the playoffs up 3 caps to make space, eventually you will have lvl 38 teams who make the playoffs end up moving straight into AA. How does your whole complaint of wanting to force teams with players over the cap into the right caps fix anything? It doesn't it creates more problems.
its fair to have people at a higher level in a league where people cant boost to that level?
all these rules have done is slowly destroy a team of players that were built within a season of each other. That team missed the playoffs because its been torn apart from all the rules and its just become a farm team i guess until it reaches uncapped where players can finally sign together again.
Destroy a team of players? Really because I don't see a lot of teams dying out and being destroyed by this. They missed the playoffs because they weren't as good as the other teams that MADE the playoffs, not because of the caps. Get your facts straight.