User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > The Archetype Discussion Thread
Page:
 
Riceloft
offline
Link
 
I haven't read this thread at all, but I read the entire Q&A Thread that is now locked.


This is NOT changing much. Basically, insetad of choosing an RB and having a set group of sp's that get major and minor gains, you can choose one more to your liking. You can still build that player in any way you wish. In fact, it may be adventageous to choose one archetype but build it slightly different.

If DC's will be tagging archetypes instead of individual players, it might be worth it to choose one and build towards another.
 
Hanz
offline
Link
 
Just read the Archtype tread


couple things I don't like about archtypes.

1. To be a Return guy, you either A: pay 300 flex for a HB/WR or be a CB. Why can't FB be returners...the archtypes limit that choice.

2. What happens when i change my mind mid-stream. i.e. I was building a hard-hitting CB, but it didn't really pan out. But I did realize that actually his build made for a decent returner.
Now under archtypes i would be stuck with Strength and tackling going up.....instead of speed which all CB's can use.

Under the current program the speed and agility keep going up and i am not wasting more points of strength and tackling.

From how it is explained....i still feel it limits as it is harder to change your build tree mid-stream.
 
Hanz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by David Stern

Rushing qb's are completely useless ATM, so I think that is a positive thing.


Having QB's with zero passing ability is always retarded no matter how many ways you slice it.


problem with a rushing QB is it takes away from other players!!! QB rushes and HB just twiddles his thumbs.........QB rushes and the WR just twiddles his thumbs!!!

QB rushers are super glory hogs, and really detracted from other O-scorers in the game (which they paid alot of flex for)
 
Riceloft
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hanz
Just read the Archtype tread

couple things I don't like about archtypes.

1. To be a Return guy, you either A: pay 300 flex for a HB/WR or be a CB. Why can't FB be returners...the archtypes limit that choice.


You can still be a FB returner, but you can't choose the Returner Archetype when creating the player.
 
Viscount
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Staz
Originally posted by Viscount
I like the idea, but I wish we could also have our own custom archetypes so that we'd be able to choose our player's major or minor attributes, and bonus or penalty SAs.

Players could easily become over powered, in that case. For example, there is no OL with Strength, Blocking, Agility as majors, as that would be too powerful. They made archetypes and specifically considered keeping them from being "perfect" ALGs.


Good point.

However, it does limit build diversity. For example with my current combo HBs, agility is their 3rd or 4th highest attribute but in the archetype agility is only a minor attribute. I also have 6 special teams blockers (centres) but the Special teams archetypes are strictly for defensive positions and with the propsed O-line archetypes I wouldn't be able to build future ST players in the same way as my current ones.
 
Boozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mob-6
I love knowing that my newly created dots are going to be worthless next season and that they are a complete waste of time, effort, and money thanks to this new change. The only way to make this right is to offer a 100% flex refund on those newly created players


This

nearly 20 players and 4 teams created in the last few seasons. Time and money spent creating, boosting, build reccommendations posted, finance.


Not that I mind the (Arch) idea or changes in general but
A higher % of flex back for your useless players and time spent??

u gotta be joking

 
idm03
offline
Link
 
LB's and CB's will get boned, not to mention C, P, K - perhaps needingly so....

2 of the 4 LB archetypes have jumping as a major, while DB's have no choice if they want jumping as a major.......
 
Link
 
I only got though the first 9 pages of Catch's epic Archetype discussion thread, but was it asked (and answered) whether the free 300 flex is the only non-refundable part of the player(s) created with that flex? Do we still get the normal 70% back from boosts/custom?

thanks
 
robinhoodnik
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JDM998
Inb4they make a rushing QB arch-type and casual leagues get ruined. At most have pocket-balanced-scrambler-duel threat.


With pistol VA's? That'd be sweet.
 
ericb45696
offline
Link
 
I just want to know if that guy REALLY is Dustin Diamond ?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Riceloft
You can still be a FB returner, but you can't choose the Returner Archetype when creating the player.


Scatback fb archtype would work just fine as a returner.
 
BellyCheck
offline
Link
 
Guys, if you think it's coincidental that these guys polled us on our love for GLB a day prior to rollout, you got another think coming.

We don't know the growth numbers, but you have to figure that the last few seasons will be where the bulk of current players come from. Us old dinosaurs, frankly, are expendable. It's going to be a matter of evolve or die.

Given the introduction of casual leagues in the last couple of seasons, it strikes me that there's a great demand for the game to be more accessible to the "casual" player... many who have been coordinators or owners know that you *can* put hours into each game. Most people don't want that, vis., those with girlfriends or lives. This makes life easier for "more" casual players, who after all are not casual at all, by the standards of normal people. I stipulate in this characterization that I personally am not normal, and being married and old, haven't much of a life either.

Last note: every ten seconds I see someone who is slow-building complaining about how any given change in the game disrupts their multi-season slow-building strategy. This happens to me too, all the time. It's annoying and it's frustrating. The Bortosphere, however, issues statements almost as regularly that they're not big fans of the slow-building mystique.

Yes, I too am focused on making sure at the birth of a player that he gets to level 72 rather than 71 10 seasons or so in the future... blah blah blah.

Yes, I am in love with the network of teams at various levels that feed into one another at level-appropriate points, yadda yadda yadda.

But the idea of the game is that you get all excited about your L3 dot pounding the crap out of another L3 dot, and so on, from the bottom to the top. The fact that the game constantly frustrates our efforts to build vertically integrated slow-build empires for 3 seasons or so of glory is utterly immaterial to the great mass of players out there.

So yeah, from that perspective, our current teams and players seem to be if not obsolete, then at least not as advantaged as we imagined them to be when we created them, *to take advantage of the existing features of the game.*

Since the game's in beta (perpetually), this has always been a dicy proposition.

Even if this is the planet-killer asteroid of GLB for the dinosaurs among us -- and I don't think it is -- it appears to be what the game's owners/designers believe will provide them the best growth opportunity.

So we may as well file all complaints along with our belief that legalizing the forward pass destroyed the real game. The game moves on.

/rant
 
BellyCheck
offline
Link
 
Don't be this guy

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pTifdoKXoxM
 
sborats
offline
Link
 
i don't get it?

I just created a few players this season I want to keep long term. What is the down side to them if I don't retire and start over?

I get concerned that all these changes will just end up making the players and league about what level the team is (i.e. games pretty much all decided before they are played). Am I wrong?


 
zroeder
offline
Link
 
Since this game is pretty much starting over with player builds, why dont they just add some much needed extra skills. Acceleration, Arm Strength etc.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.