User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > XP bonus for playing at or above your level
Page:
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Right now, the average level difference between USA Pro and the lowest USA BBB league is 5.3 levels. That's hardly more than one level per tier of the pyramid. And over time, as leveling slows down, this gap will get even smaller.

Please do not penalize teams in lower leagues for managing to sign higher level players in an attempt to move up.

If anything, level caps (or some other restriction) ON NEW LEAGUES ONLY will fix the gutting and moving problem. Throw in some definitive rules on gutting and collusion, and things should be just dandy.

IMHO.
Last edited Jun 8, 2008 02:51:51
 
Donnie Brasco
offline
Link
 
I do like he idea and 15% is not so much that it would prevent players from staying together as a team of friends.
In any case I always hear the example of these "teams of friends" being punished, but how would this punish them?
It just helps the lower level teams to catch up a little faster than normal, thus making the leagues more balanced.
But as I said the 15% extra exp won't skyrocket anyone to the top, it will still take time and once a league is balanced no-one gains or looses anyway...
 
Fat Murphy
offline
Link
 
This is a lot like what Papyrus and Sierra Online did with their NASCAR Racing Series Online a few years back. If you raced someone and beat them, you got differeing amounts of points based on their rank at that track, and you could even lose XP at that track and drop a level if you kept getting beat by players of a lower level. It was a great system, and there was definitely a weeding out of those who were great and those who didn't care to get better.
 
Sweet Daddy
offline
Link
 
a.) It seems like so many of these ideas have an (unintended, I hope) side effect of rewarding teams that one, some, or all of the following: 1.) have poorly built players, 2.) have poor ownership 3.) don't scout or gameplan effectively 4.) don't manage their finances effectively 5.) just don't have the effective knowledge about football to succeed.

b.) Conversely, it (unintended, I hope) punishes teams that do all of the above well. I've got 23 players, and over the past two seasons, I've had them on several teams, and I can tell you that there is a vast swing in how teams are managed. I have yet to be on a one that has in any way been affected by people trying to "pwn noobs," nor have I played with anyone that has created or built a team with the intention of doing so. I think it's crazy that the teams that are run well get hurt because they are good at recruiting, giving advice in building, plan well, or are generally smart in how the team is run.

b2.) In Season 2 and Season 3, I've joined up on one team each season that was well planned out and recruited far in advance of teams being released. People spent money to create players for the new teams, or to provide them from other teams where contracts were expiring. To punish people for being well-prepared when others don't do their background work and get rewarded is not a way to ensure that your revenue and referral streams remain intact.

c.) Bort, on page 6, you said you're looking at doing this, not because you know that it's happening based on any objective or empirical testing, but because people are whining about it. I don't know your internet background prior to starting this project, but in the almost 10 years that I've been gaming online, and have participated on internet message boards, in my experience, a great many people whine loudly about a great many things, both real and imagined. Just because some people complain about things doesn't necessarily mean that there is a problem. I would suggest that you not change things based on internet rants, but rather based on real facts that you've discovered through your own research and examination of objective fact.
 
Sweet Daddy
offline
Link
 
d.) Many comments are made here about "discouraging" or "encouraging" players to move around to different teams. Isn't one of the common complaints that players are restricted from moving anywhere if owners don't want them moved? If a player is too high level to gain effective experience, or where his experience is being limited, because he happens to be the one star on the team, but the owner won't let him leave because he is the star, what recourse does he have, as a real person, but to sit there while his character stagnates?
 
Cedo
offline
Link
 
Again that idea will see a raising of shields and nothing will be done to satisfy the whinners.

I don't really mind but i think later i will link to thoses threads if someone whine about "not fair blablabla"

2 Options:
- Don't give a shit about rules so we must heard no more complains.
- Do some rules like this one for everyone have a chance to take pleasure from this game.
Last edited Jun 8, 2008 07:38:44
 
O-Town
offline
Link
 
say champ bailey plays against some hs team. of course he's going to get less experience than if he played against TO or randy moss.

personally, i like the idea of gaining XP based on your opponents. don't make the deduction (for playing worse teams) or addition (for playing a better team) a great deal, but it's definitely a good thought.

SD, i see your point about a player stagnating, but if you have a L23 CB playing against L6 WRs, what real experience is he going to get? he'll be dominating them all day. might as well bring a book to read while he's out there.
 
Sweet Daddy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by O-Town
say champ bailey plays against some hs team. of course he's going to get less experience than if he played against TO or randy moss.


That may be true. However, Champ Bailey is not paying Bort to be entertained. If Champ Bailey is the best player on the field, he is rewarded for that with financial compensation.

If I manage to create and build the best player on GLB, I find it odd that the reward for doing so would be to be penalized.

 
Cedo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sweet Daddy
Originally posted by O-Town

say champ bailey plays against some hs team. of course he's going to get less experience than if he played against TO or randy moss.


That may be true. However, Champ Bailey is not paying Bort to be entertained. If Champ Bailey is the best player on the field, he is rewarded for that with financial compensation.

If I manage to create and build the best player on GLB, I find it odd that the reward for doing so would be to be penalized.


I will find it normal if you play against low level...
 
Sweet Daddy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cedo
Originally posted by Sweet Daddy

Originally posted by O-Town


say champ bailey plays against some hs team. of course he's going to get less experience than if he played against TO or randy moss.


That may be true. However, Champ Bailey is not paying Bort to be entertained. If Champ Bailey is the best player on the field, he is rewarded for that with financial compensation.

If I manage to create and build the best player on GLB, I find it odd that the reward for doing so would be to be penalized.


I will find it normal if you play against low level...


As a player who is not a team owner or GM, do you decide who you play against every game? Do you decide how your opponent's depth chart or roster is built? Do you decide the skill level of the other team owners in your league, or the time they put into their teams?
 
Cedo
offline
Link
 
That's not the point. If you play lower league that make no sense if you have the best player of GLB. Being a low competition league will bring NO xp at all because what's XP? XP is something you learn from your oppoment. In a situation like that you learn nothing!

But -15% is fine
Last edited Jun 8, 2008 07:59:01
 
Sweet Daddy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cedo
That's not the point.


Sure it is, as it was my point that was being rebutted. Because you want to change the parameters of the discussion doesn't mean that the point has all of a sudden changed to fit what you want to say.

Originally posted by
If you play lower league that make no sense if you have the best player of GLB. Being a low competition league will bring NO xp at all because what's XP? XP is something you learn from your oppoment. In a situation like that you learn nothing!

But -15% is fine


The example given was Champ Bailey, a professional NFL player, arguably the top player at his position. It was stated that he would gain no experience from playing against anyone other than the most skilled wideouts in the league.
Flaws in this argument
-Champ Bailey is handsomely rewarded, regardless of who lines up against him, thus he has motivation and encouragement to perform well.
-We are not paid money by Bort to do well at this video game. The analogy suffers here.

If we are not rewarded as individual paying customers, or even punished, for doing well, what is our motivation for continuing to give Bort and his cronies our money?

I do not live in a society where people are encouraged to succeed by doing inferior work, or putting out less effort than people that work hard, or are smarter. I do not want to encourage a socialist game or culture where you can win or succeed simply by existing. This is a game. A game based on a game that is a competition or sport. One does not put weights on Champ Bailey's legs so that Eddie Kennison has a fair shot of doing something with the balls passed his way. Eddie Kennison gets better, or gets replaced by the Hunts or Carl Peterson.
 
Cedo
offline
Link
 
Doing well? all players who vote for this idea think it's DOING WRONG!

Originally posted by
As a player who is not a team owner or GM, do you decide who you play against every game? Do you decide how your opponent's depth chart or roster is built? Do you decide the skill level of the other team owners in your league, or the time they put into their teams?


By chosing your league. If you choose a low level league so you will have low oppoment. if you choose a higher league you will see high level oppoment except gutted one...

I don't mind you talking of real exemple of a player i don't know, i will just say something: trophies are not xp!
 
O-Town
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sweet Daddy


The example given was Champ Bailey, a professional NFL player, arguably the top player at his position. It was stated that he would gain no experience from playing against anyone other than the most skilled wideouts in the league.
Flaws in this argument
-Champ Bailey is handsomely rewarded, regardless of who lines up against him, thus he has motivation and encouragement to perform well.
-We are not paid money by Bort to do well at this video game. The analogy suffers here.

If we are not rewarded as individual paying customers, or even punished, for doing well, what is our motivation for continuing to give Bort and his cronies our money?

I do not live in a society where people are encouraged to succeed by doing inferior work, or putting out less effort than people that work hard, or are smarter. I do not want to encourage a socialist game or culture where you can win or succeed simply by existing. This is a game. A game based on a game that is a competition or sport. One does not put weights on Champ Bailey's legs so that Eddie Kennison has a fair shot of doing something with the balls passed his way. Eddie Kennison gets better, or gets replaced by the Hunts or Carl Peterson.


-uh, your player still gets their game check just like champ does. compare apples to apples.
- "motivation for continuing to give Bort and his cronies our money?"??? you don't HAVE to if you don't want to.

we're talking about our PLAYER's statistics/motivation/experience...not YOUR's as an agent. your PLAYER doesn't gain as much experience playing against lower level people, just as champ doesn't playing against lower skilled wr's.

and i didn't say "NO" experience for champ, i said "less".

i'm not sure i'd agree with -15%. maybe -10%. dunno, i'll let bort/dd make the call. i'm just trying to enjoy the game.
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sweet Daddy
Originally posted by Cedo

That's not the point.


Sure it is, as it was my point that was being rebutted. Because you want to change the parameters of the discussion doesn't mean that the point has all of a sudden changed to fit what you want to say.

Originally posted by

If you play lower league that make no sense if you have the best player of GLB. Being a low competition league will bring NO xp at all because what's XP? XP is something you learn from your oppoment. In a situation like that you learn nothing!

But -15% is fine


The example given was Champ Bailey, a professional NFL player, arguably the top player at his position. It was stated that he would gain no experience from playing against anyone other than the most skilled wideouts in the league.
Flaws in this argument
-Champ Bailey is handsomely rewarded, regardless of who lines up against him, thus he has motivation and encouragement to perform well.
-We are not paid money by Bort to do well at this video game. The analogy suffers here.

If we are not rewarded as individual paying customers, or even punished, for doing well, what is our motivation for continuing to give Bort and his cronies our money?

I do not live in a society where people are encouraged to succeed by doing inferior work, or putting out less effort than people that work hard, or are smarter. I do not want to encourage a socialist game or culture where you can win or succeed simply by existing. This is a game. A game based on a game that is a competition or sport. One does not put weights on Champ Bailey's legs so that Eddie Kennison has a fair shot of doing something with the balls passed his way. Eddie Kennison gets better, or gets replaced by the Hunts or Carl Peterson.


Flaws in the argument?

When the Broncos go up 40-0 guess who gets pulled in the 4th quarter when the other team send in their backups - the STARTERS.

Why? Why on earth do you need the starters to finish a game against scrubs? Now imagine playing an entire year against a league full of scrubs (by Bailey's comparitive level.

Thats the whole point of the argument - if their are tiers they are there for a reason - because the higher level/skilled players have risen top the top and the newcomers and poorly built players/poorly run teams have gravitated to the bottom.

Does that mean that those poor teams can't beat a Goliath? Nope - hence Appalachian St. beating Michigan last year. However, that is the exception not the rule - and 90 times out of a 100 that goliath team will beat them so bad they have their backups in to start the 3rd quarter.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.