Originally posted by Sweet Daddy
The example given was Champ Bailey, a professional NFL player, arguably the top player at his position. It was stated that he would gain no experience from playing against anyone other than the most skilled wideouts in the league.
Flaws in this argument
-Champ Bailey is handsomely rewarded, regardless of who lines up against him, thus he has motivation and encouragement to perform well.
-We are not paid money by Bort to do well at this video game. The analogy suffers here.
If we are not rewarded as individual paying customers, or even punished, for doing well, what is our motivation for continuing to give Bort and his cronies our money?
I do not live in a society where people are encouraged to succeed by doing inferior work, or putting out less effort than people that work hard, or are smarter. I do not want to encourage a socialist game or culture where you can win or succeed simply by existing. This is a game. A game based on a game that is a competition or sport. One does not put weights on Champ Bailey's legs so that Eddie Kennison has a fair shot of doing something with the balls passed his way. Eddie Kennison gets better, or gets replaced by the Hunts or Carl Peterson.
-uh, your player still gets their game check just like champ does. compare apples to apples.
-
"motivation for continuing to give Bort and his cronies our money?"??? you don't HAVE to if you don't want to.
we're talking about our PLAYER's statistics/motivation/experience...not YOUR's as an agent. your PLAYER doesn't gain as much experience playing against lower level people, just as champ doesn't playing against lower skilled wr's.
and i didn't say "NO" experience for champ, i said "less".
i'm not sure i'd agree with -15%. maybe -10%. dunno, i'll let bort/dd make the call. i'm just trying to enjoy the game.
