User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Tagging players is ready
Page:
 
taurran
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AirMcMVP
Originally posted by taurran

Being an OC in this game sucks balls. It already takes 1-2 hours to gameplan for a competitive game, now it's just going to be that much more of a waste of time.


Originally posted by taurran

Who the fuck are you kidding? It takes 5x as long for an OC to plan than it does a DC. The offensive AI requires a level of detail far and above anything DCs have ever had to put up with.


So you take 1-2 hours to set an offensive for your competitive games? I spend up to 4-5 hours to set up my defense for competitive games (seriously). If you add in having to cover "tagged" players it will be ridiculous.


I agree it will be ridiculous.

I probably have one of the simplest "big" offensive AIs around, as I don't use many packages and have put a lot of effort into making anything not in the "overall" list generic between games. If I really wanted to get down on a granular level and set play calls it could certainly take me 4 hours (which is friggin ridiculous).

I have better things to do with my time than spend that much on setting a damn AI. At that point this has gone from being a "game" to a "job"... a job that you're paying for.


Note - it takes much longer for me, as an OC, on my teams, than the DC I work with, to set up the AIs. You're doing yourself a disservice if you get too in depth with defensive play calls. 95% of defensive play calling is based on nothing more than formation and down.
Edited by taurran on Sep 22, 2009 10:19:57
Edited by taurran on Sep 22, 2009 10:16:00
 
StoutOne
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by taurran


Note - it takes much longer for me, as an OC, on my teams, than the DC I work with, to set up the AIs. You're doing yourself a disservice if you get too in depth with defensive play calls. 95% of defensive play calling is based on nothing more than formation and down.


lol, sounds like a shitty DC imo.
 
taurran
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by StoutOne
Originally posted by taurran



Note - it takes much longer for me, as an OC, on my teams, than the DC I work with, to set up the AIs. You're doing yourself a disservice if you get too in depth with defensive play calls. 95% of defensive play calling is based on nothing more than formation and down.


lol, sounds like a shitty DC imo.


Nah, more like a smart one.

Spending 5 hours gameplanning as a DC in this game is just retarded.
 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
Ok, so I understand that this new feature is going to make our lives more difficult, but where was all this complaining when Bort first came out and said we were going to be doing a tagging system?

It was pretty clear when he introduced the idea that it was going to be AI dependent and it would introduce more work for DCs. Why wasn't there a big deal about it then so that a better solution could be found?
 
AirMcMVP
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by StoutOne
lol, sounds like a shitty DC imo.


+1

Sure, some teams are predictable enough to run a basic AI and I can handle many regular season games with a base AI with slight tweaks.

For the competitive games (regular season), I usually change about 50% of my tactics to counter what an opposing team does.

For a playoff game, I may change every single Input in my AI...depending on team.

I would say the opposite. The few times I've filled in as OC, I've spent maybe 30 minutes to an hour figuring out what I need to do and get it set up.
 
taurran
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AirMcMVP
Originally posted by StoutOne

lol, sounds like a shitty DC imo.


+1

Sure, some teams are predictable enough to run a basic AI and I can handle many regular season games with a base AI with slight tweaks.

For the competitive games (regular season), I usually change about 50% of my tactics to counter what an opposing team does.

For a playoff game, I may change every single Input in my AI...depending on team.

I would say the opposite. The few times I've filled in as OC, I've spent maybe 30 minutes to an hour figuring out what I need to do and get it set up.


I disagree.

The best DC's run generic plays that blanket the field in any given situation. You can set up a 4-3 with no blitzes, and LB/CB coverage set up so it is effective for any offensive play.

The only current adjustment required for a well run defense is against the outside run/screen. Everything else can be handled with generic defensive formations and coverage assignments.
 
StoutOne
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AirMcMVP
Originally posted by StoutOne

lol, sounds like a shitty DC imo.


+1



That said DC is myself tbh. and lol @ you for spending so much time on DAI.
 
seanb1979
offline
Link
 
What sucks now is we're gonna basically need seperate defensive ais for each sub-set of players. Not gonna be fun
 
seanb1979
offline
Link
 
The most I'll spend on the defensive AI is maybe a little over an hour, 2 tops, and most of that is watching replays. Doesn't take long to create a new play in the DPC. Most of the time is spent waiting for the fucking ai page to load/save.
 
coach
offline
Link
 
I just wish I'd seen this before buying more flex this morning.

<---- dumb
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by StoutOne
lol, sounds like a shitty DC imo.


Since the DPC took over, it takes me about 2+ hours just breaking down gamefilms (3-4 games) and map all the defenses I will face. With the new scouting tool I wonder if DCs spend so much time.

After the scouting is done setting up the gameplan is easy (depends how deep I want to go) but usually I can just update my packages (~ 1 hour).

Of course part of the issue is being over matched in many games. If you have a strong team you can just roll over the defenses with your high % plays.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Anarcho
Ok, so I understand that this new feature is going to make our lives more difficult, but where was all this complaining when Bort first came out and said we were going to be doing a tagging system?

It was pretty clear when he introduced the idea that it was going to be AI dependent and it would introduce more work for DCs. Why wasn't there a big deal about it then so that a better solution could be found?


I've been saying that the workload would be ridiculous for awhile...
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by taurran
I disagree.

The best DC's run generic plays that blanket the field in any given situation. You can set up a 4-3 with no blitzes, and LB/CB coverage set up so it is effective for any offensive play.

The only current adjustment required for a well run defense is against the outside run/screen. Everything else can be handled with generic defensive formations and coverage assignments.


lmao
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AirMcMVP
+1

Sure, some teams are predictable enough to run a basic AI and I can handle many regular season games with a base AI with slight tweaks.

For the competitive games (regular season), I usually change about 50% of my tactics to counter what an opposing team does.

For a playoff game, I may change every single Input in my AI...depending on team.

I would say the opposite. The few times I've filled in as OC, I've spent maybe 30 minutes to an hour figuring out what I need to do and get it set up.


lol at +1ing this comment

you got him Stout, ^5!
 
jcross
offline
Link
 
I don't do anything with DC/OC and never have. Figured I would start with that.

As for all this griping and such I find it a bit funny. DC's have complained over and over about not having the tools to put the right personnel in the game to match the offense. Now they get the power and are complaining. Is it time consuming; yes. Could it be simplified and be easier to do, most likely yes. Pretty sure that at one point it will be simplified but just be happy that this is being introduced.

The thing that I find more amusing is that the DC's have the chance to see what kind of plays the offense can run. They can also speak to other OC's and find out what plays are good and what plays are bad. From what I hear there aren't that many effective plays in the playbook. Therefore they know what exactly to try and stop and can see it. The offense can see the base sets for the defense (I think) but the defense has the DPC. Where they can manipulate everything on defense, from player position on the field to different tactics from zone to man to man.

The offense cannot do this, but I believe they should and even more. There should be the triple option, spread offenses with QB reads and playactions also motion with anyone on the field to anywhere else.

With all the changes that are in store, offenses have gotten little to nothing and definitely need something. Time for Bort to even the playing field.

Also I agree with a lot that Taurran has said. He gets it
Edited by jcrossfield22 on Sep 22, 2009 12:34:29
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.