User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Coaches - ideas for them to spend money on (and other ideas)
Page:
 
whitewolf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by David Stern
BORT, If you really want coaches to work and be realistic. Allow us to "Watch film" with our position coach. Then give us say 5 options per player.

Free safety watches film, decides team A runs 5 Favorite plays. He studies plays, and when he sees these plays he gets.

Play 1) HB Screen Ace X% boost to vis speed tackle
Play 2) Strong I slam .8X% boost to vis speed tackle
Play 3)Shotgun Screen .6x% boost
Play 4 etc
Play 5 etc
This way we could actually game plan, and use "Coaches" to give our players boosts to these teams who abuse the same 4-5 plays game in game out. Would force teams to truly devise schemes, and really come up with new game plans week to week.


This has potential, but it should involve a trade-off. If the FS is constantly watching for the HB Screen, maybe the TE has an easier time toasting him or something.
 
fbfan18
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I'd think that would naturally happen anyway.

I like drifter's idea of higher levels making the coach's morale go down if he is not in a high enough position, though. Would enforce the coach trying to improve his lot. It might be worthwhile to extend that idea to players, too, at some point...play as lv 60 in uncapped minors and you start to lose morale, etc.


Well, yes and no.... you could maybe stair-step the effectiveness of the coaches enhancements by factoring how long he has been with his current team, in current league, ect, possibly to promote a Coach to stay with a team longer, weather they get promoted up to next league or not......??
 
whitewolf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
Originally posted by Bort

Seems like it would be better for there to be a penalty of some sort for making switches willy-nilly. Either a limit to the number of switches, or it costs something every time you switch.


A simple cost might be best, but here's a random brainstorming idea. You could have something like workout groups. If a group was accustomed to practicing together they'd be a little better, and if a group member was lost they might get a little worse, at least until they'd gotten used to the new player.

So lets say a lineman coach selected 4 players to coach, giving each +1 strength at the start. Then each game (or two) that the group is together each member gains an additional +1 strength up to a maximum of +5 total. Later if the coach drops one player and adds another the strength gained for everyone in that group drops and has to be re-earned over time.



Interesting take on the team chemistry idea.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
I'm more afraid of the opposite. Players rotating amongst teams to fulfill specific intense training combos they "need". The idea in general of providing player x a superior build path to player y scares me.



Absolutely--FINAL BUILD belongs in the hand of the AGENT, not some nebulous idea of a "coach".
 
Sweet T
offline
Link
 
I don't care much for the Coach ideas since none of my players will reach that age.

But I'd like to know if this Coach stuff will affect lower level leagues and players?
there should be a level requirement for this like the VA system where only players at level 25 get VA's.

Maybe coaches can only train/help players who are level 35+?



 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whitewolf

This has potential, but it should involve a trade-off. If the FS is constantly watching for the HB Screen, maybe the TE has an easier time toasting him or something.


Just straight up boosts, because if this play develops, the player knows 100%, just like in the league. The penalty would be the offense Gets to pick 4-5 plays that they were "Coached" harder on the week before, and would get some kind of boost, albeit, no OOP penalty for OG playing FB, something fun, that would take a lot of creativity, that would start diversifying these playbooks, and make teams have to work for there edge. Not just be handed some bullshit +4 str because of them having played the game for a year and a half.
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dynasty Jammers
I don't care much for the Coach ideas since none of my players will reach that age.

But I'd like to know if this Coach stuff will affect lower level leagues and players?
there should be a level requirement for this like the VA system where only players at level 25 get VA's.

Maybe coaches can only train/help players who are level 35+?





If Snoop Dogg can coach "PeeWee", everyone deserves the bonuses a coach provides.
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris

A simple cost might be best, but here's a random brainstorming idea. You could have something like workout groups. If a group was accustomed to practicing together they'd be a little better, and if a group member was lost they might get a little worse, at least until they'd gotten used to the new player.

So lets say a lineman coach selected 4 players to coach, giving each +1 strength at the start. Then each game (or two) that the group is together each member gains an additional +1 strength up to a maximum of +5 total. Later if the coach drops one player and adds another the strength gained for everyone in that group drops and has to be re-earned over time.



I hate this. This will just make every team get the same bonus. give or take +1 str, -1 str. Seems like a really big waste of time to just basically hand out the same boost of said attribute to every team. You need a way, to make this exciting, and actually do this in a way where we can all actually partake in the coaching stuff. I Really don't want a basic boost as you are saying, why even have coaches if that is the case. Just raise flex prices, if you want us to have to pay more to have a +4 boost to str. To keep up with all of the other teams that will be doing the exact same thing.
 
whitewolf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dynasty Jammers
I don't care much for the Coach ideas since none of my players will reach that age.

But I'd like to know if this Coach stuff will affect lower level leagues and players?
there should be a level requirement for this like the VA system where only players at level 25 get VA's.

Maybe coaches can only train/help players who are level 35+?





Coaches should be able to be in any league of their level or higher.
I would think coaches should start at level 1 and be able to be in any league, that way every single league has the ability to use them, and as coaches level up they get moved to higher leagues and things can stay relatively balanced.
 
fbfan18
offline
Link
 
Dunno if anyone has brought it up yet, but there could be a possibility among Coaches as a Class to have AEQ as well?
Stainless Steel Whistle. Indestructible Clipboard. Facemask Gripper. Pat on the Butt. of course suggestions for other various items would be great too.

AEQ could potentially enhance a Coach's direct group of players hes responsible for either by a percentage increase of attribute, or a SA skill in the players tree.
 
Sweet T
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
If Snoop Dogg can coach "PeeWee", everyone deserves the bonuses a coach provides.


Pee Wee gets recycled and was supposedly be for teams to play at an even field ...so the coach stuff should definitely NOT help PW's.

But seriously, there should be a level limit for coaches to take an affect to a team. that way it helps the regular/casual players and not give all the advantages to the vets and hardcore gamers.

This is why there's not that many new GLBers in the game. Beginners have a lot of stuff to figure out...
 
v 2tha icious
offline
Link
 
The money can be used to increase his "Training" allowing for a certain percentage of Morale boost during a game.
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
The bonuses and so on are great but what are these coaches going to actually do. I mean there seems to be little payoff for coaches. This might be great as it will reduce their popularity once the luster of the new GLB feature wears off.

I like the AE crafting idea since it gives the coach something to do. The bonuses to sims, training, finances, and etc will be great for teams but the agent who owns the coach might get bored fast.

Players have stats such as TDs, sacks, INTs, and so on. I guess wins and losses will be coaches only stats to brag about. I am trying to think of other things to suggest to keep a coach active but I am drawing blanks.
 
Sweet T
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whitewolf
Coaches should be able to be in any league of their level or higher.
I would think coaches should start at level 1 and be able to be in any league, that way every single league has the ability to use them, and as coaches level up they get moved to higher leagues and things can stay relatively balanced.


There's plenty of agents and teams who don't care about moving up the caps, and likes playing in the PW and lower cap leagues.
Why give them a disadvantage?

P.S. also casual/semi-serious GLBers like myself do put money into this but just not as much as the hardcore guys.
Edited by Dynasty Jammers on Sep 3, 2009 23:26:28
Edited by Dynasty Jammers on Sep 3, 2009 23:21:18
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by David Stern
I hate this. This will just make every team get the same bonus. give or take +1 str, -1 str. Seems like a really big waste of time to just basically hand out the same boost of said attribute to every team. You need a way, to make this exciting, and actually do this in a way where we can all actually partake in the coaching stuff. I Really don't want a basic boost as you are saying, why even have coaches if that is the case. Just raise flex prices, if you want us to have to pay more to have a +4 boost to str. To keep up with all of the other teams that will be doing the exact same thing.


Well the +strength was only a very simple hypothetical example, it was more the concept I was trying to get across.

If taken to the logical next step, there would be numerous bonuses a coach could select from for each player ranging from +% bonuses, to some attributes or skills. Here's a hypothetical coach's training bar that uses 60% of his concentration:

-20% of his concentration bar to give 1 star d-linman +5% break block chance.
-10% of his concentration bar to give another d-lineman a +1% break block chance.
-10% of his concentration bar to give another d-lineman a +1% break block chance.
-20% of his concentration bar to give a blocking TE +5% to his pancake roll.

After say 5-10 games this bonus could grow to a max of:

-20% of his concentration bar to give 1 star d-linman +10% break block chance.
-10% of his concentration bar to give another d-lineman a +6% break block chance.
-10% of his concentration bar to give another d-lineman a +6% break block chance.
-20% of his concentration bar to give a blocking TE +10% to his pancake roll.

I'd also suggest that break block and hold block % bonuses etc, only be available to the lineman trainer. However they can go outside of typical lineman and bring in for instance a blocking WR to join his training group. Likewise a Receivers' coach could bring in a Scat Back and Give him +% catching bonuses if the team so desired.
Edited by Saris on Sep 3, 2009 23:30:50
Edited by Saris on Sep 3, 2009 23:27:28
Edited by Saris on Sep 3, 2009 23:26:47
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.