User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Someone give me cliffs on the weight fix
Page:
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
I'll tell you right now, you're not going to get an answer to any of this yet. There are a couple of players who are being used to test and they don't play today. Bort said on the mod forum that because we're not going to see results on this today, we need to see those results tomorrow, so he's going to work on other stuff today instead.

Once it's all figured out and resolved, just as I've done my best to get info for the general public so far, I'll try to get some more solid answers.


i understand there is no info available right now - but if the "people" aren't making some noise - there won't ever be info given out (my opinion)
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DaMayan
About the beta part:
Part of a beta always is reporting of bugs and issue's. It's the developers responsibility to look at them and check if they are right or if it is just perception.
Even then both of those things are a problem that need adressing: if the perception is that something is wrong then (even if it is right) the user experience is deminished.

The whole reason for a beta is getting feedback and fix bugs or perception issue's. It's actually called an Alpha if your not ready for feedback and just want to keep developing on your own. Bort clearly listens and adjusts to bug-reports and general whining/testing. So he does want and use feedback. And we, the userbase, generally except and agree with what Bort does.

The only point here is that this issue has been reported as early as season 3 and only until it has grown to mythical proportions is it properly checked. This is clearly a trust issue for the userbase as even PT is now feeling let down.

...imho.


I can't speak for anyone else on this, but up until yesterday, here's what I heard as the definition of the "X-factor":

'something behind the scenes put in place which the end user both can't see and can't adjust to intentionally make one player better than the other, even with everything else being equal'

That's not a bug report, that's a conspiracy theory. Not only that, but THAT part is something Bort has said in the past isn't the case (the part where it would always make one better than the other).

Yesterday, Larry Roadgrader said, "hey, maybe it's there, but maybe there's a bug causing something like that to happen." That's when I took it seriously, checked it out, and got on it for real.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
I called it a conspiracy theory until the Pierre Thomas WR data, which is actually tangible.
 
Vagrant God
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
I called it a conspiracy theory until the Pierre Thomas WR data, which is actually tangible.


 
jamz
offline
Link
 

Truth of the matter is the general player base has always known theres been something out there that causes similar players to perform at drastically different levels for prolonged periods of time (See a whole Career)

Whether they're hidden variables or a bug, it's so much more than morale, energy and the RNG and differences in matchup and game plans.

It's not like these 'superstars' are only doing this every couple of weeks.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
I called it a conspiracy theory until the Pierre Thomas WR data, which is actually tangible.


Is that the ones DB has been working with, too? Because it was those that I saw which made me agree that there probably is something to there being a bug.
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
I can't speak for anyone else on this, but up until yesterday, here's what I heard as the definition of the "X-factor":

'something behind the scenes put in place which the end user both can't see and can't adjust to intentionally make one player better than the other, even with everything else being equal'

That's not a bug report, that's a conspiracy theory. Not only that, but THAT part is something Bort has said in the past isn't the case (the part where it would always make one better than the other).

Yesterday, Larry Roadgrader said, "hey, maybe it's there, but maybe there's a bug causing something like that to happen." That's when I took it seriously, checked it out, and got on it for real.


That isn't really how I remember it. I recall you making a pretty dumb post claiming that people wont take responsibility for builds and tactics until Bort posted something in the mod forum indicating that he never denied an x-factor and that it could exist then suddenly you got bent out of shape and hated the idea.
 
CapnEnnui
offline
Link
 
Something evokes a conspiracy theory? Why, it must be completely made up if tons of people suspect something about odd numbers in a mathematically concrete game! Better not even think about it or listen and react antagonistically instead.
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Is that the ones DB has been working with, too? Because it was those that I saw which made me agree that there probably is something to there being a bug.


That was a month ago when it was first presented.
 
steellithium
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
I called it a conspiracy theory until the Pierre Thomas WR data, which is actually tangible.


I always agreed with his example being a major question mark. I just thought the leap past another factor we weren't seeing or a bug to x-factor was just as insane as ignoring the data.
 
hydrosmak
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jamz

Truth of the matter is the general player base has always known theres been something out there that causes similar players to perform at drastically different levels for prolonged periods of time (See a whole Career)

Whether they're hidden variables or a bug, it's so much more than morale, energy and the RNG and differences in matchup and game plans.

It's not like these 'superstars' are only doing this every couple of weeks.


+1
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
That isn't really how I remember it. I recall you making a pretty dumb post claiming that people wont take responsibility for builds and tactics until Bort posted something in the mod forum indicating that he never denied an x-factor and that it could exist then suddenly you got bent out of shape and hated the idea.


The post by Larry was between those 2. I presented something to Bort because I was wondering if there was a bug. I got bent out of shape because I thought a player's success was pre-determined. (It's not, at least not on purpose)
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vagrant God

I called it a conspiracy theory until the Pierre Thomas WR data, which is actually tangible.



Pierre convinced me when breaking down dots on CCCC. We had a pretty lengthy convo about dots builds, and there on field performance. He showed me how he was bringing in "Replay monsters" Guys who dominate higher competition despite inferior builds. He explained how he had 6 dt's better than leon Lett in every possible way, and yet leon was the most dominant bar none, comparatively. He also showed me how the 3 best players on his 4C team, were the worst 3 builds on either the turtles, or CCCC, and since he couldn't explain other than to say there is an X factor these guys have it, and despite being our worst players, they perform at the highest level.
This is when I knew.

How bad does it suck that guys like Pierre who scream off the roof tops for seasons that this exists, then he goes out fills his roster with the X factor players, despite inferior builds, only to have bort just "Fix the problem".

I really don't think it was a height weight issue btw, I Think bort went and turned off the taco Bell X factor in which he intentionally put into the sim, to have stand alone stars. Only to realize this was an absolutely terrible decision.

Hey Bort, if you really fixed this problem with a simple check, then I am sure you could have put a code in to determine which of these players were "X factor" and if this is the case just make sure to post a list of every player who was "Boosted", and "Doomed" due to this error, I don't think you will do this because you turned off the code that gave players special abilities. Now we will just have more denials, and people freaking out over their player being nerfed. Here's to Bort coming clean about this, so we can get past it.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Originally posted by Iceman16

I called it a conspiracy theory until the Pierre Thomas WR data, which is actually tangible.


Is that the ones DB has been working with, too? Because it was those that I saw which made me agree that there probably is something to there being a bug.


Can't say. Probably not, unless they put Pierre's WR on the server. Which I don't think happened. Could be wrong though, obviously.
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
Has anybody called this weight-gate yet?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.