User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > The time has come to remove the Click and Drag of the Defensive Line in the DPC
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Originally posted by RAPB

Originally posted by kurieg


Originally posted by jdbolick



Originally posted by lolMurp




What started this issue?

Bort added a speed boost when you break a block. The idea was to prevent the old bumper-cars OT/DE interaction where the DE would just get immediately blocked again after shedding a previous block, but the issue now is that the boost is getting defensive linemen past the offensive line's allowed angle for blocking if those defenders are positioned in gaps.


Why is that a problem?

Why, exactly, is it a problem for a failed block attempt to result in the DE shooting through the line and killing the QB?

We're down to worrying exactly what particularly turn in the spreadsheet caused it?


The root cause is - the LG gets owned super-fast.


Now I want to know what you think of this plays:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587174&pbp_id=14859797
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587174&pbp_id=14859874
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587174&pbp_id=14860397

[x] 90+ blocking (100+ on the LG)
[x] mid 70s agility
[x] 50+ speed
[x] 60 vision

[x] failed badly



How is that related?

1&2) Complete overload blitz. Nobody picks up the DT at all. 7 guys vs. 5-6 blockers. Oops.
3) Overload on the strong side. Still involves bouncing and eventually getting through.



It's related, but not directly what this thread is about. It's another example of the defensive formations confusing the hell out of the neanderthal O-line AI though. The DPC is kinda half-baked.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
It's related, but not directly what this thread is about. It's another example of the defensive formations confusing the hell out of the neanderthal O-line AI though. The DPC is kinda half-baked.

The DPC is fine. It's not that people weren't already trying everything they could think of before this season. The difference is in the shed block burst.

Edited by jdbolick on Jul 17, 2009 13:41:34
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Just because you insist on using a certain word doesn't mean that you're using it properly. And no, fixing something Bort created but didn't intend would not be a nerf. DEs got nerfed after S6 when Bort decided that they were too dominant. Not that something he did made them too dominant, but they were too dominant in general. Elusives also got nerfed because Bort felt like there were too many outside runs going the distance. Not that something he did made them too effective and needed to be corrected, but that they were working too well and put the game out of balance. Those things are "nerfs."

And Bort already decided. He agreed with something I said yesterday about the culprit being the combination of break block speed bursts and blocking angles, then said he would experiment with some potential fixes. So there's really no need to debate this as if anyone is going to persuade him.



Really, really go back and think about that bolded part again. Really.

Think about how it could be possible that Elusives were doing something in the game that Bort wasn't responsible for.

 
tdm13
offline
Link
 
And the offense is kinda half-overpowered. Fix the offense and then fix this bug.
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
It's related, but not directly what this thread is about. It's another example of the defensive formations confusing the hell out of the neanderthal O-line AI though. The DPC is kinda half-baked.


You realize those kinds of blitzes are often picked up, right?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by fallingmercury

It's related, but not directly what this thread is about. It's another example of the defensive formations confusing the hell out of the neanderthal O-line AI though. The DPC is kinda half-baked.

The DPC is fine. It's not that people weren't already trying everything they could think of before this season. The difference is in the shed block burst.



Well yeah.

What I should have said was that the DPC is fine, but:

1) The shed burst is not fine (shooting out of a cannon thing)
2) The O-line AI was not upgraded when the DPC came out, further exposing it as a very weak, underdeveloped facet of this game.
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by jdros13

Originally posted by tdm13


If the defense can generate pressure before this problem, and then the bug is fixed and defenses can no longer generate pressure, then it's a NERF. It may be an unintended consequence, but if he's going to fix this bug and nerf the DEs, then he needs to counter-nerf the O-Line. Otherwise, we are back to season 8 more-or-less.




this is what I'm concerned about. I truthfully couldn't care less if this "bug" is squashed, even though I don't really think it is a bug. Ultimately what is going to happen though (imo) is that a change will have a sweeping effect on the game rendering 95% of DE's impotent again and turning every OT dot into Anthony Munoz.


IMO further adjustments are needed to keep DEs nice and pass rushey. But relying on a bug/exploit/unindended consequence, etc is not the way to go.

I think Bort is probably aware of the issues facing DEs


The DLine is playing just fine this season and this squeeze technique simply isn't that big a deal. I've seen the consequences of OLine/DLine interaction "fixes" before and survived them while still generating a pass rush with my dots. Most teams couldn't do a damn thing though and it allowed every offense to just load up on strength on all their OLinemen which was dumb.

I play a team that did this pretty heavily in their last game tonight. Maybe I'll sing a different tune after that. I really don't expect my team to suddenly start giving up 10+ sacks per game though.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Really, really go back and think about that bolded part again. Really. Think about how it could be possible that Elusives were doing something in the game that Bort wasn't responsible for.

I refused to go into academia because I get tired and frustrated whenever students don't understand a point but think they do. *sigh*

When Bort makes a change specifically to one type of player or an ability featured by one type, and he then goes on to believe that his change was too powerful or had consequences that he didn't intend, then fixing that change is not a nerf. On the other hand, it's most certainly a nerf when Bort decides that he doesn't like DEs getting 60+ sacks in a season and reduces the effectiveness of the position in order to prevent that. S7's powerback tackle breaking was a result of a change Bort had made. Scaling back that change was not a nerf. Bort looking at elusives putting up massive stats and deciding that the game is unbalanced was a nerf. This shouldn't be that hard to differentiate.
Edited by jdbolick on Jul 17, 2009 13:46:33
 
Link
 
jdros, I dont blame you for being wary of D-line adjustments.

My DE is one of my oldest players... I've been riding the feast-or-famine train like everyone else. Except it's more of a famine train... Especially as a season 3.5 player since my DE was too young to fully experience the sack boom in s7.
Edited by fallingmercury on Jul 17, 2009 13:49:57
 
tdm13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by jdbolick

Originally posted by fallingmercury


It's related, but not directly what this thread is about. It's another example of the defensive formations confusing the hell out of the neanderthal O-line AI though. The DPC is kinda half-baked.

The DPC is fine. It's not that people weren't already trying everything they could think of before this season. The difference is in the shed block burst.



Well yeah.

What I should have said was that the DPC is fine, but:

1) The shed burst is not fine (shooting out of a cannon thing)
2) The O-line AI was not upgraded when the DPC came out, further exposing it as a very weak, underdeveloped facet of this game.


The O-Line AI doesn't need to be updated! Let me explain:

Let's put a number on the O and D line AIs before this season's updates. Let's say that, when compared, the O-Line AI was an 8 and the D-Line was a 4. The O-Line won nearly every engagement, no matter what the build.

Now, after the changes, both numbers are at 8. Interaction is where it should be. You're saying the O-Line AI needs a buff? That would bring it to a 10, when the D-Line is at an 8. So O-Line wins more engagements again, despite poor builds (Etc).


And this comparison can be slapped on offense vs defense as well. Despite all the complaining of the offense being limited, there's still not any way for defenses to designate specific plays for specific packages the offense sends out. The offense can still move the chains at will and they are still overpowered. There should be no buffs to either line. Let this "bug" sit and wait until bigger problems are fixed (NERF THE OFFENSE).
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
jdros, I dont blame you for being wary of D-line adjustments.



I'm not worried about MEM or BDC tbh. JJ has been bort-proof and so has Denver (although he's a LB) on BDC. Hell, even my personal DE on BDC was somewhat bort-proof except for last season when he was pitiful.

There are a lot of "good" builds out there though (not outstanding, but not terrible either) who have spent seasons doing absolutely nothing though and they are back making some plays again this season. Sacks are up, but not to a ridiculous level for most teams. If there is a fix to the OLine to have better reactions to a DLine that is attacking the gaps, fine, but if toning down the DE is the "fix" it is going to fuck everything up again.
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
I refused to go into academia because I get tired and frustrated whenever students don't understand a point but think they do. *sigh*

When Bort makes a change specifically to one type of player or an ability featured by one type, and he then goes on to believe that his change was too powerful or had consequences that he didn't intend, then fixing that change is not a nerf. On the other hand, it's most certainly a nerf when Bort decides that he doesn't like DEs getting 60+ sacks in a season and reducing the effectiveness of the position in order to prevent that. S7's powerback tackle breaking was a result of a change Bort had made. Scaling back that change was not a nerf. Bort looking at elusives putting up massive stats and deciding that the game is unbalanced was a nerf. This shouldn't be that hard to differentiate.


Irony imo. All of those things were nerfs. Anytime the playerbase has been allowed to build their players and change their AIs and make widespread use out of a game mechanic, reducing the effectiveness of that game mechanic is a nerf. For goddamn sure reducing the effectiveness of DEs that spent seasons languishing under the nerf of seasons ago is going to be called a nerf, regardless of our little semantic debate.

The question is whether this mechanic needs to be nerfed.
 
Link
 
I'm not suggesting that the O-line needs to be better at winning engagements. I'm saying that their movement needs to not be so damned brainless, and their cones need to be moveable.


I agree with you that offense is overpowered. But fixing it without focusing on parity improvement is why Bort isn't getting this thing right.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Originally posted by jdbolick

I refused to go into academia because I get tired and frustrated whenever students don't understand a point but think they do. *sigh*

When Bort makes a change specifically to one type of player or an ability featured by one type, and he then goes on to believe that his change was too powerful or had consequences that he didn't intend, then fixing that change is not a nerf. On the other hand, it's most certainly a nerf when Bort decides that he doesn't like DEs getting 60+ sacks in a season and reducing the effectiveness of the position in order to prevent that. S7's powerback tackle breaking was a result of a change Bort had made. Scaling back that change was not a nerf. Bort looking at elusives putting up massive stats and deciding that the game is unbalanced was a nerf. This shouldn't be that hard to differentiate.


Irony imo. All of those things were nerfs. Anytime the playerbase has been allowed to build their players and change their AIs and make widespread use out of a game mechanic, reducing the effectiveness of that game mechanic is a nerf. For goddamn sure reducing the effectiveness of DEs that spent seasons languishing under the nerf of seasons ago is going to be called a nerf, regardless of our little semantic debate.

The question is whether this mechanic needs to be nerfed.


Just declare what your formal definition of a nerf is IMO, so we know where we all stand.
 
tdm13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
I'm not suggesting that the O-line needs to be better at winning engagements. I'm saying that their movement needs to not be so damned brainless, and their cones need to be moveable.


I agree with you that offense is overpowered. But fixing it without focusing on parity improvement is why Bort isn't getting this thing right.



So we can FINALLY agree on something lol. This is the list I would like to see fixed by next season:

1.) I would like the offense to take a major nerf. Make them actually have to put time into scouting their opponent's defense like defenses have to do.
2.) I would like to see the O-Line with a slightly increased radius, just so that the D-Line cannot stack boost through the line at the snap.
3.) I do NOT want to see the D-Line interaction take any sort of nerf or "fix" or anything. Interaction is where it should be and if the DPC of the defense takes a hit then GLB will have an uprising.


If these are not worked on together, then we might as well kiss another season goodbye. It will be a ping-pong OT/DE interaction with 80-60 final scores.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.