this thread being moved is crap. These types of threads are allowed to go on in GLB forum all the time.
Cryptotich
offline
offline
Ok... I think I MIGHT have identified a potential issue. This is by NO means official. It just means I have an area to look at. At best it is speculation on my part.
From now on, it would be helpful if people just posted possible Ideas, or just plays, where this has been an issue. Calling each other names, won't get this issue addressed.
From now on, it would be helpful if people just posted possible Ideas, or just plays, where this has been an issue. Calling each other names, won't get this issue addressed.
Edited by Cryptotich on Jul 15, 2009 11:24:58
Rage Kinard
offline
offline
Originally posted by PackMan97
WHY SHOULD IT MATTER WHAT THE BUILDS OF THE OT/G ARE?
What you say? But builds matters!
Not in this case, they shouldn't. If I were on any team that was getting beat like this, I'd simply tell the OT and the G to close the gap and not let the DE through. It's fairly simple thing for a real team to stop.
Now, if the OT was getting faked to the outside and the DE was shooting that gap, great play. If the DE was swinging around the outside of the OT based on speed and agility, great! Heck, even if the OT was stunning either the G or the OT and swimming through the gap...great!
This is just a bad dotball play because there is no reason it would work over and over and over again. Even if there were the Cinci Shockers vs the PeeWee Scrubs, a DE shouldn't be making that play unless he's stunning both the OT and G (which he likely would insta break their double team)
Because nobody can adjust.
The defense can't change the pathing of their players when a team runs HB screens 20 times a game either.
WHY SHOULD IT MATTER WHAT THE BUILDS OF THE OT/G ARE?
What you say? But builds matters!
Not in this case, they shouldn't. If I were on any team that was getting beat like this, I'd simply tell the OT and the G to close the gap and not let the DE through. It's fairly simple thing for a real team to stop.
Now, if the OT was getting faked to the outside and the DE was shooting that gap, great play. If the DE was swinging around the outside of the OT based on speed and agility, great! Heck, even if the OT was stunning either the G or the OT and swimming through the gap...great!
This is just a bad dotball play because there is no reason it would work over and over and over again. Even if there were the Cinci Shockers vs the PeeWee Scrubs, a DE shouldn't be making that play unless he's stunning both the OT and G (which he likely would insta break their double team)
Because nobody can adjust.
The defense can't change the pathing of their players when a team runs HB screens 20 times a game either.
CinTex
offline
offline
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
this thread being moved is crap. These types of threads are allowed to go on in GLB forum all the time.
this thread being moved is crap. These types of threads are allowed to go on in GLB forum all the time.
islander1
offline
offline
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Originally posted by PackMan97
WHY SHOULD IT MATTER WHAT THE BUILDS OF THE OT/G ARE?
What you say? But builds matters!
Not in this case, they shouldn't. If I were on any team that was getting beat like this, I'd simply tell the OT and the G to close the gap and not let the DE through. It's fairly simple thing for a real team to stop.
Now, if the OT was getting faked to the outside and the DE was shooting that gap, great play. If the DE was swinging around the outside of the OT based on speed and agility, great! Heck, even if the OT was stunning either the G or the OT and swimming through the gap...great!
This is just a bad dotball play because there is no reason it would work over and over and over again. Even if there were the Cinci Shockers vs the PeeWee Scrubs, a DE shouldn't be making that play unless he's stunning both the OT and G (which he likely would insta break their double team)
Because nobody can adjust.
The defense can't change the pathing of their players when a team runs HB screens 20 times a game either.
Indirectly they can. Put them in different position to make the play. That's what I do.
Originally posted by PackMan97
WHY SHOULD IT MATTER WHAT THE BUILDS OF THE OT/G ARE?
What you say? But builds matters!
Not in this case, they shouldn't. If I were on any team that was getting beat like this, I'd simply tell the OT and the G to close the gap and not let the DE through. It's fairly simple thing for a real team to stop.
Now, if the OT was getting faked to the outside and the DE was shooting that gap, great play. If the DE was swinging around the outside of the OT based on speed and agility, great! Heck, even if the OT was stunning either the G or the OT and swimming through the gap...great!
This is just a bad dotball play because there is no reason it would work over and over and over again. Even if there were the Cinci Shockers vs the PeeWee Scrubs, a DE shouldn't be making that play unless he's stunning both the OT and G (which he likely would insta break their double team)
Because nobody can adjust.
The defense can't change the pathing of their players when a team runs HB screens 20 times a game either.
Indirectly they can. Put them in different position to make the play. That's what I do.
islander1
offline
offline
Originally posted by CinTex
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
this thread being moved is crap. These types of threads are allowed to go on in GLB forum all the time.
This - this is more likely to be ignored now, or at least put on the back burner.
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
this thread being moved is crap. These types of threads are allowed to go on in GLB forum all the time.
This - this is more likely to be ignored now, or at least put on the back burner.
tdm13
offline
offline
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by CinTex
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
this thread being moved is crap. These types of threads are allowed to go on in GLB forum all the time.
This - this is more likely to be ignored now, or at least put on the back burner.
As it should be. Hope the O-Line suffers through this for 2-3 seasons to make up for their dominance on the past few seasons while D-Line was nerfed.
FIX YOUR BUILDS.
Originally posted by CinTex
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
this thread being moved is crap. These types of threads are allowed to go on in GLB forum all the time.
This - this is more likely to be ignored now, or at least put on the back burner.
As it should be. Hope the O-Line suffers through this for 2-3 seasons to make up for their dominance on the past few seasons while D-Line was nerfed.
FIX YOUR BUILDS.
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by CinTex
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
this thread being moved is crap. These types of threads are allowed to go on in GLB forum all the time.
This - this is more likely to be ignored now, or at least put on the back burner.
good
Originally posted by CinTex
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
this thread being moved is crap. These types of threads are allowed to go on in GLB forum all the time.
This - this is more likely to be ignored now, or at least put on the back burner.
good
Originally posted by tdm13
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by CinTex
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
this thread being moved is crap. These types of threads are allowed to go on in GLB forum all the time.
This - this is more likely to be ignored now, or at least put on the back burner.
As it should be. Hope the O-Line suffers through this for 2-3 seasons to make up for their dominance on the past few seasons while D-Line was nerfed.
FIX YOUR BUILDS.
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by CinTex
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
this thread being moved is crap. These types of threads are allowed to go on in GLB forum all the time.
This - this is more likely to be ignored now, or at least put on the back burner.
As it should be. Hope the O-Line suffers through this for 2-3 seasons to make up for their dominance on the past few seasons while D-Line was nerfed.
FIX YOUR BUILDS.
Rage Kinard
offline
offline
Originally posted by islander1
Indirectly they can. Put them in different position to make the play. That's what I do.
You found a way to put change the position they start in during the middle of a game? Can you let me know how?
Offense also has ability to change formations they run plays from, and can chose to run at the DE. That alignment is susceptible to running plays coming at it.
Indirectly they can. Put them in different position to make the play. That's what I do.
You found a way to put change the position they start in during the middle of a game? Can you let me know how?
Offense also has ability to change formations they run plays from, and can chose to run at the DE. That alignment is susceptible to running plays coming at it.
PackMan97
offline
offline
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Because nobody can adjust.
The defense can't change the pathing of their players when a team runs HB screens 20 times a game either.
The DC can scout. The DC can call more than one output for that specific input. The DC can change his play calling.
Sure, once the sim starts, you can't adjust. How in the heck do you adjust to this issue? Maybe if we could shift the OL a bit, or something...but right now there is no way to "adjust" to this problem.
Because nobody can adjust.
The defense can't change the pathing of their players when a team runs HB screens 20 times a game either.
The DC can scout. The DC can call more than one output for that specific input. The DC can change his play calling.
Sure, once the sim starts, you can't adjust. How in the heck do you adjust to this issue? Maybe if we could shift the OL a bit, or something...but right now there is no way to "adjust" to this problem.
jdros13
offline
offline
Originally posted by PackMan97
WHY SHOULD IT MATTER WHAT THE BUILDS OF THE OT/G ARE?
What you say? But builds matters!
Not in this case, they shouldn't. If I were on any team that was getting beat like this, I'd simply tell the OT and the G to close the gap and not let the DE through. It's fairly simple thing for a real team to stop.
Now, if the OT was getting faked to the outside and the DE was shooting that gap, great play. If the DE was swinging around the outside of the OT based on speed and agility, great! Heck, even if the OT was stunning either the G or the OT and swimming through the gap...great!
This is just a bad dotball play because there is no reason it would work over and over and over again. Even if there were the Cinci Shockers vs the PeeWee Scrubs, a DE shouldn't be making that play unless he's stunning both the OT and G (which he likely would insta break their double team)
It doesn't work over and over again though against good teams. It did work once in a game against you guys earlier this season though. Of course it looks to me like Corn Head had a hell of a time getting past the blockers, but he did get past for the sack. DE's are allowed to win occasionally though.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587010&pbp_id=6898523
It has also not worked against you at times:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=672531&pbp_id=4835681
But worked in the same game as well:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=672531&pbp_id=4837391
WHY SHOULD IT MATTER WHAT THE BUILDS OF THE OT/G ARE?
What you say? But builds matters!
Not in this case, they shouldn't. If I were on any team that was getting beat like this, I'd simply tell the OT and the G to close the gap and not let the DE through. It's fairly simple thing for a real team to stop.
Now, if the OT was getting faked to the outside and the DE was shooting that gap, great play. If the DE was swinging around the outside of the OT based on speed and agility, great! Heck, even if the OT was stunning either the G or the OT and swimming through the gap...great!
This is just a bad dotball play because there is no reason it would work over and over and over again. Even if there were the Cinci Shockers vs the PeeWee Scrubs, a DE shouldn't be making that play unless he's stunning both the OT and G (which he likely would insta break their double team)
It doesn't work over and over again though against good teams. It did work once in a game against you guys earlier this season though. Of course it looks to me like Corn Head had a hell of a time getting past the blockers, but he did get past for the sack. DE's are allowed to win occasionally though.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587010&pbp_id=6898523
It has also not worked against you at times:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=672531&pbp_id=4835681
But worked in the same game as well:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=672531&pbp_id=4837391
Rage Kinard
offline
offline
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Because nobody can adjust.
The defense can't change the pathing of their players when a team runs HB screens 20 times a game either.
The DC can scout. The DC can call more than one output for that specific input. The DC can change his play calling.
Sure, once the sim starts, you can't adjust. How in the heck do you adjust to this issue? Maybe if we could shift the OL a bit, or something...but right now there is no way to "adjust" to this problem.
They don't run that defense against all formations. You can run at it.
There is pretty much nothing you can do short of opening yourself up to every other play to make sure you stop the HB screen if it is run enough. A defense can stop it 15-18 times, the LBs/DBs will eventually take horrid pathing that causes it to break big.
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Because nobody can adjust.
The defense can't change the pathing of their players when a team runs HB screens 20 times a game either.
The DC can scout. The DC can call more than one output for that specific input. The DC can change his play calling.
Sure, once the sim starts, you can't adjust. How in the heck do you adjust to this issue? Maybe if we could shift the OL a bit, or something...but right now there is no way to "adjust" to this problem.
They don't run that defense against all formations. You can run at it.
There is pretty much nothing you can do short of opening yourself up to every other play to make sure you stop the HB screen if it is run enough. A defense can stop it 15-18 times, the LBs/DBs will eventually take horrid pathing that causes it to break big.
headsigh
offline
offline
In my opinion, this looks to be more of a fuckup on o-line code than an exploit.
Right now, the entire blocking scheme on any offensive play is either zone pass or zone run, as there's no way to set man assignments. It works, but at the time where an o-lineman doesn't detect a player in their zone to pick up and block against, they don't pay attention to that, which appears to be what's happening here. To the o-line the DE doesn't exist. Slow-motion it and you'll see the ball isn't in the QB's hands and the DE is south of the point of attack. People can say it's builds, for now, because it's an isolated incident. I'll try it with one of my teams today (not trying to take advantage!) and see if it's a problem, even though no one ever fucking passes in pee-wee. ):
Right now, the entire blocking scheme on any offensive play is either zone pass or zone run, as there's no way to set man assignments. It works, but at the time where an o-lineman doesn't detect a player in their zone to pick up and block against, they don't pay attention to that, which appears to be what's happening here. To the o-line the DE doesn't exist. Slow-motion it and you'll see the ball isn't in the QB's hands and the DE is south of the point of attack. People can say it's builds, for now, because it's an isolated incident. I'll try it with one of my teams today (not trying to take advantage!) and see if it's a problem, even though no one ever fucking passes in pee-wee. ):
Edited by lolMurp on Jul 15, 2009 11:34:27
Rage Kinard
offline
offline
Originally posted by lolMurp
In my opinion, this looks to be more of a fuckup on o-line code than an exploit.
Right now, the entire blocking scheme on any offensive play is either zone pass or zone run, as there's no way to set man assignments. It works, but at the time where an o-lineman doesn't detect a player in their zone to pick up and block against, which appears to be what's happening here. To the o-line the DE doesn't exist. Slow-motion it and you'll see the ball isn't in the QB's hands and the DE is south of the point of attack. People can say it's builds, for now, because it's an isolated incident. I'll try it with one of my teams today (not trying to take advantage!) and see if it's a problem, even though no one ever fucking passes in pee-wee. ):
That is why it should be tested. If certain builds can consistently stop it, then it is a build problem.
In my opinion, this looks to be more of a fuckup on o-line code than an exploit.
Right now, the entire blocking scheme on any offensive play is either zone pass or zone run, as there's no way to set man assignments. It works, but at the time where an o-lineman doesn't detect a player in their zone to pick up and block against, which appears to be what's happening here. To the o-line the DE doesn't exist. Slow-motion it and you'll see the ball isn't in the QB's hands and the DE is south of the point of attack. People can say it's builds, for now, because it's an isolated incident. I'll try it with one of my teams today (not trying to take advantage!) and see if it's a problem, even though no one ever fucking passes in pee-wee. ):
That is why it should be tested. If certain builds can consistently stop it, then it is a build problem.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























