User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Bort answered Questions/Concerns about restructure here (after a few pages of complaints about thread-locking)
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Originally posted by fallingmercury

We need a meaningful level cap really bad. Either make it impossible for players to sign into inappropriately low level teams or penalize them in a meaningful way.

I understand that there's concern that preexisting too-high-level players would be penalized unjustly. The answer is to grandfather them into the system. Let them be for now but block or penalize all further signings.


If a good answer to solve it for the future came up, another reshuffle for teams who are already way over the cap could fix it short-term.


Holy crap, Jed. Just make a level 46 capped league and that solves a lot of the problem right there....

 
Jed
offline
Link
 
That just solves short-term problems, that doesn't solve the problem of a 21-cap league actually meaning level 27 players by day 1.

But yea, there should be higher caps since there's a difference between level 46 and 60.
 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury


Holy crap, Jed. Just make a level 46 capped league and that solves a lot of the problem right there....



Lol. *Watches the GLB staff look at hoofmarks in the dirt, and wonder what zebra made them*
 
Link
 
To sort of echo what GMathiasf said I have realized that my personal feelings about things cannot change the game so I figure why waste the effort in fighting. This game may ultimately wind up being very successful for many years. In contrast it could also fail once it gets out of Beta. When you have an online game like this there is the broad spectrum of things that could happen in the future and whether I am here or not does not make a huge difference in the grand scheme of things. I just have to focus on my own enjoyment. Each person though should decided what method is best for them. Bring back Bort!
Edited by quzur on Jun 5, 2009 20:49:01
 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
Why not establish now that over the next couple seasons, the cap is going to change from a suggested level cap, to a soft-cap, to a hard cap? That way, everyone gets going in the right direction, and you don't have this chaos.
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by GMathiasf

Originally posted by The Avenger


Originally posted by fallingmercury



People have legit comments about the overhaul and you guys are locking like crazy and forcing them to post in an officially-titled, easily-dismissed "crying thread".

This defines the arrogant and often bogus moderation we have here. Do we need new mods or are you guys going to cut the crap?

And yes I know you'll probably lock this which only goes to prove my point...


Most of them were actually, and since when is this Communist GLB??? Freedom of speech!!

GMathiesf you ever fight for something or just jump up and down behind a big crowd and raise your hand and say "look at me, i'm back here too!"



Are you kidding me? I've complained about the moderation here for a long time. The fact is that the big crowd that you speak of is as usual, very small. Most of the people are in the middle and realize that their every day GLB experience really won't change too much. Most of the people are able to put a little perspective in their life and realize that getting all upset over a change to an online video game that they don't fully understand, is well...silly.

Almost everyone in here today whining are people or personally feel like their team or some team they are on got "screwed" by the shuffle. The truth is that most of these teams would have been worse off wherever they were before. Is the shuffle perfect? Of course not. I couldn't come up with a better solution though and I'm certain that with the limited critical thinking skills displayed on here today, you couldn't either. Just shut up. Enjoy the game. And realize that if your level 32-33 team can't compete in a level 38 capped league, then you weren't going to win anything in the level 34 capped league either.


Listen doof, I have no players screwed by the shuffle. Stop trying to dismiss me and others as being sore losers.

In fact I have only one player in the minors at all and he's in a league where his team will roll to an easy 16-0 schedule and may win most games 255-0 ish.

As to people posting with no solutions, uncover your eyes. Solutions posted include having another 40-something capped league, making a real league level cap, and other ideas.


lol doof. No, but you're one of these people that whines every time anything happens so your credibility is a little low. At least some of these people are a little respectable.

All of those "solutions" have their problems. A 40-something capped league is making the pyramid climb even higher than it already is. You have to stop somewhere. I think the soft cap that was basically put in was great because it allowed teams that are slow-building to stay together instead of boot their Punter to the curb. If a hard cap existed, it wouldn't be the end of the world, but I think you're being a little dramatic to think that Bort's solution is such a big deal.
 
Link
 
Every time Bort has made changes there have been initial problems and then things get worked out. I bet Bort is working hard right now on trying to come up with solutions to make all of you happy.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foofighter24
Why not establish now that over the next couple seasons, the cap is going to change from a suggested level cap, to a soft-cap, to a hard cap? That way, everyone gets going in the right direction, and you don't have this chaos.


Because no matter what, we're going to have people who join a level 21-cap team who has a level 20 player join, then be pissed when 2 games into the season he's suddenly not on a team.

Or a team who has been together for a while and wants to stay together but didn't win enough to get promoted, then is forced to break up.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by GMathiasf
Originally posted by fallingmercury

Originally posted by GMathiasf


Originally posted by The Avenger



Originally posted by fallingmercury




People have legit comments about the overhaul and you guys are locking like crazy and forcing them to post in an officially-titled, easily-dismissed "crying thread".

This defines the arrogant and often bogus moderation we have here. Do we need new mods or are you guys going to cut the crap?

And yes I know you'll probably lock this which only goes to prove my point...


Most of them were actually, and since when is this Communist GLB??? Freedom of speech!!

GMathiesf you ever fight for something or just jump up and down behind a big crowd and raise your hand and say "look at me, i'm back here too!"



Are you kidding me? I've complained about the moderation here for a long time. The fact is that the big crowd that you speak of is as usual, very small. Most of the people are in the middle and realize that their every day GLB experience really won't change too much. Most of the people are able to put a little perspective in their life and realize that getting all upset over a change to an online video game that they don't fully understand, is well...silly.

Almost everyone in here today whining are people or personally feel like their team or some team they are on got "screwed" by the shuffle. The truth is that most of these teams would have been worse off wherever they were before. Is the shuffle perfect? Of course not. I couldn't come up with a better solution though and I'm certain that with the limited critical thinking skills displayed on here today, you couldn't either. Just shut up. Enjoy the game. And realize that if your level 32-33 team can't compete in a level 38 capped league, then you weren't going to win anything in the level 34 capped league either.


Listen doof, I have no players screwed by the shuffle. Stop trying to dismiss me and others as being sore losers.

In fact I have only one player in the minors at all and he's in a league where his team will roll to an easy 16-0 schedule and may win most games 255-0 ish.

As to people posting with no solutions, uncover your eyes. Solutions posted include having another 40-something capped league, making a real league level cap, and other ideas.


lol doof. No, but you're one of these people that whines every time anything happens so your credibility is a little low. At least some of these people are a little respectable.

All of those "solutions" have their problems. A 40-something capped league is making the pyramid climb even higher than it already is. You have to stop somewhere. I think the soft cap that was basically put in was great because it allowed teams that are slow-building to stay together instead of boot their Punter to the curb. If a hard cap existed, it wouldn't be the end of the world, but I think you're being a little dramatic to think that Bort's solution is such a big deal.


No, I'm the guy coming up with solutions. In fact, I PREDICTED that we'd have these problems and suggested a fix even before the restructuring took place.

There's nothing wrong with adding a level 40-something capped league. Especially since levels are still spreading out, it doesn't make sense for capped leagues to end in the 30s. I'm sure you could come up with some small drawback but it's severely outweighed by the benefit gained.
 
dudley
offline
Link
 
Nice title edit.
Stay classy.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Originally posted by foofighter24

Why not establish now that over the next couple seasons, the cap is going to change from a suggested level cap, to a soft-cap, to a hard cap? That way, everyone gets going in the right direction, and you don't have this chaos.


Because no matter what, we're going to have people who join a level 21-cap team who has a level 20 player join, then be pissed when 2 games into the season he's suddenly not on a team.

Or a team who has been together for a while and wants to stay together but didn't win enough to get promoted, then is forced to break up.


Fixable and not a problem
 
Link
 
I think this is the kind of thread that might deserve a sticky. So one thing I don't get about the restructuring is that now it appears that there are no A or BBB teams below the USA AA teams. Who funnels into the AA spots now?
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Fixable and not a problem


Please explain how it's fixable without the answer being for Support to handle every case individually.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Originally posted by fallingmercury

Fixable and not a problem


Please explain how it's fixable without the answer being for Support to handle every case individually.


Not 100% sure I understand what you're saying, but I think the idea of grandfathering people in has potential to circumvent the problems you speak of.
 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Originally posted by foofighter24

Why not establish now that over the next couple seasons, the cap is going to change from a suggested level cap, to a soft-cap, to a hard cap? That way, everyone gets going in the right direction, and you don't have this chaos.


Because no matter what, we're going to have people who join a level 21-cap team who has a level 20 player join, then be pissed when 2 games into the season he's suddenly not on a team.

Or a team who has been together for a while and wants to stay together but didn't win enough to get promoted, then is forced to break up.


People can't have everything. If they want to be about playing with friends, they might have to be in a league that doesn't allow them to win a title because they have too many underleveled guys. They could always play in a league where they don't exceed the cap.

Nothing is worse than being an appropriate leveled team, and knowing that no matter how well you game plan, you are gonna get owned by 3 overleveled guys on the other team.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.