User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > GLB Notes > CPL > Free Gart888
Page:
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by Malachorn

Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


Originally posted by Malachorn




This thread seems to have JUST been added (this afternoon, I'm pretty sure):
# Please note that just becomes something is not listed here, does not mean it will not be eligible for moderation. We are attempting to maintain a clean and fun environment for all users. Attempting to find loopholes in the rules to "get away" with things does not help promote that sort of environment.


Wow, that's an obvious rule, but I don't like it's wording.


Um... it is a brand new rule.
Hard to call it an "obvious rule," as it is brand new and wasn't a rule until this afternoon...


How is that not obvious? I'm curious as to what you think the rules on the forum should be?


I think you're trying to argue that it should "obviously" have been a rule.
I'm just saying that it was not an "obvious rule" and would argue it was the least obvious of the rules we have, as it is the newest and I think very few people have seen that it exists.
Again... wasn't even a rule a day ago.
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Right, and it's still excessive. Very few things a normal poster will do can lead to banning.


Have you seen the new rule?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by Malachorn


Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder



Originally posted by Malachorn





This thread seems to have JUST been added (this afternoon, I'm pretty sure):
# Please note that just becomes something is not listed here, does not mean it will not be eligible for moderation. We are attempting to maintain a clean and fun environment for all users. Attempting to find loopholes in the rules to "get away" with things does not help promote that sort of environment.


Wow, that's an obvious rule, but I don't like it's wording.


Um... it is a brand new rule.
Hard to call it an "obvious rule," as it is brand new and wasn't a rule until this afternoon...


How is that not obvious? I'm curious as to what you think the rules on the forum should be?


I think you're trying to argue that it should "obviously" have been a rule.
I'm just saying that it was not an "obvious rule" and would argue it was the least obvious of the rules we have, as it is the newest and I think very few people have seen that it exists.
Again... wasn't even a rule a day ago.


The rule, unless I'm misreading, says "The rules aren't limited to the things specifically mentioned herein". That's pretty obvious imo.
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
The rule, unless I'm misreading, says "The rules aren't limited to the things specifically mentioned herein". That's pretty obvious imo.


lol - I believe you would think that!!!
I mean... that's how all the mods behaved.
But until this afternoon they had NO right to behave that way.
 
Lazer Noble
offline
Link
 
might be time for this option lads

http://goallineblitz.com/game/new_message.pl?to=8093
http://goallineblitz.com/game/new_message.pl?to=1766
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

The rule, unless I'm misreading, says "The rules aren't limited to the things specifically mentioned herein". That's pretty obvious imo.


lol - I believe you would think that!!!
I mean... that's how all the mods behaved.
But until this afternoon they had NO right to behave that way.


Of course they did, the original TOS made mention of the fact that the rules were subject to the interpretation and desertion of the administrative staff. How is that in any way uncommon.

The sign forbidding "disorderly conduct" in your local grocery store might not specifically mention "not shitting on the floor" but you can bet if you do they'll ask you to leave.
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Of course they did, the original TOS made mention of the fact that the rules were subject to the interpretation and desertion of the administrative staff. How is that in any way uncommon.

The sign forbidding "disorderly conduct" in your local grocery store might not specifically mention "not shitting on the floor" but you can bet if you do they'll ask you to leave.


You're forgetting that you're not an admin.
I said MODS had NO right.

Mods, it even says as much in the forum rules, are bound by the rules as are all users.
Obviously, admins are a little "special."

You, sir, are NOT an admin.
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Oh, is this the bump when you dump thread now?
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Of course they did, the original TOS made mention of the fact that the rules were subject to the interpretation and desertion of the administrative staff. How is that in any way uncommon.


Also, link or it didn't happen.
I can think of two parts that you may be mistaken over.
NEITHER really jives with what you seem to be trying to argue there... not that it matters and it's a worthwhile argument, tbh.
 
MasTR
offline
Link
 
thread lacks catullus, a three way would be awesome right now.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Of course they did, the original TOS made mention of the fact that the rules were subject to the interpretation and desertion of the administrative staff. How is that in any way uncommon.

The sign forbidding "disorderly conduct" in your local grocery store might not specifically mention "not shitting on the floor" but you can bet if you do they'll ask you to leave.


You're forgetting that you're not an admin.
I said MODS had NO right.

Mods, it even says as much in the forum rules, are bound by the rules as are all users.
Obviously, admins are a little "special."

You, sir, are NOT an admin.


I'm not sure what this has to do with anything. If I have a question about a thread, I ask Pallow and he gives the admin-side of the story. Not that hard to grasp really. I don't need to make any judgment calls and I'm not sure why you assumed that was the case.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Oh, is this the bump when you dump thread now?


Sure, why not.
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by Malachorn

Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


Of course they did, the original TOS made mention of the fact that the rules were subject to the interpretation and desertion of the administrative staff. How is that in any way uncommon.

The sign forbidding "disorderly conduct" in your local grocery store might not specifically mention "not shitting on the floor" but you can bet if you do they'll ask you to leave.


You're forgetting that you're not an admin.
I said MODS had NO right.

Mods, it even says as much in the forum rules, are bound by the rules as are all users.
Obviously, admins are a little "special."

You, sir, are NOT an admin.


I'm not sure what this has to do with anything. If I have a question about a thread, I ask Pallow and he gives the admin-side of the story. Not that hard to grasp really. I don't need to make any judgment calls and I'm not sure why you assumed that was the case.


You were not supposed to make any "judgment calls" at all.
You'll concede that point? Because I was definitely under the impression that you were arguing that mods were supposed to have some kind of entitlement in the way of doing what was in their best judgment even if the rules didn't allow for the mods to do this...
 
Feudel
offline
Link
 
Honestly if you think this is bad try posting on gamefaqs

its like Nazi Germany mixed with Soviet Russia
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by Malachorn


Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder



Of course they did, the original TOS made mention of the fact that the rules were subject to the interpretation and desertion of the administrative staff. How is that in any way uncommon.

The sign forbidding "disorderly conduct" in your local grocery store might not specifically mention "not shitting on the floor" but you can bet if you do they'll ask you to leave.


You're forgetting that you're not an admin.
I said MODS had NO right.

Mods, it even says as much in the forum rules, are bound by the rules as are all users.
Obviously, admins are a little "special."

You, sir, are NOT an admin.


I'm not sure what this has to do with anything. If I have a question about a thread, I ask Pallow and he gives the admin-side of the story. Not that hard to grasp really. I don't need to make any judgment calls and I'm not sure why you assumed that was the case.


You were not supposed to make any "judgment calls" at all.
You'll concede that point? Because I was definitely under the impression that you were arguing that mods were supposed to have some kind of entitlement in the way of doing what was in their best judgment even if the rules didn't allow for the mods to do this...


You're bridging two issues here.

Do mods have authority to make discretionary calls as to whether something is breaking a rule or how server it is?
Yes

Do mods have authority to make rules?
No
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.