User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
Knicksfan20
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Air18
Originally posted by tuba_samurai

Originally posted by Deathblade


Originally posted by Deathblade



Make "wrap up" more vulnerable to getting plowed over and the ball carrier getting an extra 1-2 yards.

Make "power" less vulnerable to it, but also more likely to miss an ELUSIVE back, NOT a power back.


Basically have the different tackling styles work differently against different types or rushers.


+1 i like this



It seems like a nice idea, but it wouldn't really help considering most teams have 2 RB's - 1 power and 1 elsusive - so either way you're going to get burned by 1 of them unless you play on combo which brings us to square one.




Thats why vision needs to be important...so you can reconize who is being snapped too...and what is the best way to bring that back down.



do you think on defense...when teams are facing the giatns...and they see Jacobs...do you think they will approach to tackling himthe same way t hey would against ward? and vice versa?


Tackling/Vision and a combination of speed/agility/strength is what needs to be the formula
 
imnott
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
Originally posted by swoosh22


Any player who is being blocked or that has a bad angle should be required to have higher tackling and strength.

Any player who is not being blocked or that has a good angle at the ball carrier (a straight shot to him) should be required to have less tackle and strength.


Yeah I agree with this fully, tackling should definitely increase a defenders chance to make a tackle when getting blocked. Or at least increase the angle they can make the tackle at around the blocker. As it is high tackling is kind of pointless, this would add a new element to the game. And backs wouldn't be waltzing through blocked DT's constantly as if they weren't even there.


Farm Teams imo
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Have to add a modifier to slow true power backs down to allow for gang tackling. Let them carry a few guys down the field and they'll be happy.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Bort, the running game is CURRENTLY overpowered. Why make it harder for defenses to keep up?
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
I agree with what Deathblade said somewhere in this thread...

Power Tackling compared to Wrap up should play huge roles...

As far as what kind of build...

I dont think Tackling should play an amazing factor...70 should be for consistency...48-55 should stop it enough when you had 48-55 strength, 60-70+ Agility and Speed to it...from there it should be all about whether you are in wrap up or power...

power tackling with a 70-70 (tackle-strength) and high agility and speed should cause the FF's...

Power tackling with lower tackling and strength like 60-60 should be almost like a wrap up tackle but more susceptible to jukes and spins...

wrap up with 70-70 should stop nearly every guy...but not force fumbles and possibly give the extra dive yards every so often....

lower tackling and strength for wrap up 60-60 should stop the guy for the most part, but almost always give the extra dive yards and sometimes be stiff armed...

I am not sure what vision plays into tackling...i dont think vision should play in at all in that equation once you touch the Power Back...i could vision playing into getting to him tho and not getting juked.

I just wonder why we needed more Power Back vet abilities? As if there wasnt enough for them to plug into with SA's...now you give them more?
 
Knicksfan20
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Bort, the running game is CURRENTLY overpowered. Why make it harder for defenses to keep up?





hes trying to find an answer to stop the running game...the question he is asking how to stop them...not how to make rbs unstopable
 
yeahiateit
offline
Link
 
A formula that increases % to tackle. With the increase of STR/TKL starting from 1-100.

EX. 1STR+1TKL = 1% to tackle.
EX. 2STR+2TKL = 1 % to tackle.
EX 3STR+3TKL = 1 % to tackle

However, I do tend to like this concept a bit more....

Originally posted by Air18
IMO, I think you guys are lumping Strength + Tackling together when they should really be set apart. Lets use an anology - say Bort's Power Back somewhat resembles Brandon Jacobs.

Tackling = your tackling technique - how adept you are at actually making a tackle.

Strength = the Strength of your actual tackle.

Think of most CB's, they have pretty decent tackling but low strength. Thus, when they go to tackle Jacobs, they wrap him up but he can still plow forward / fall forward for a few extra yards, because they don't have the strength to stop him in his tracks. However, on the flip side, if you have a guy with ridiculous strength running full speed at Jacobs, he may have the strength to take him down but not the art and will miss his tackle.

Therefore, I propose that Defenders should require a decent balance of both if they want to consistently stop backs in their tacks. With the way this game is structured and the realistic peak of your skills, it's unrealistic to force defenders to get 80+ Strength and Tackling to make a consistent tackle. However, I do believe that defenders who have 80 + tackling and very low strength should be able to make tackles consistently because, in reality, they would be the types of players to "Wrap-up" the legs - sure the Back would plow/fall forward for 3 or 4 extra yards but the tackle would still be made. Strength should determine the "Force" of the tackle, not the effectiveness of the tackle itself. If a back with 60 Str and 60 Speed goes up against a defender with 60 Str and 60 Speed and the tackle is successful, the RB shouldn't be able to fall forward for a few extra yards, but would rather be stopped dead in his tracks. That, in essense, is what Power Backs do - always fall forward.

That being said, Bort, I think what you should do is make 2 checks when a Defender attempts a tackle - a Tackling check (to see if the tackle will be successful) and then some sort of "Force" check (combining strength + speed) to determine whether the back is able to fall forward or trudge for an extra yard or so.

Before you all yell at me and flame me, think of this idea realisticly in the game. How many defenders actually have 80 + tackling? Most people soft-cap it and leave it at that. With 48 tackling, a Defender going up against Bort's RB should only have, say, 50% chance of making the tackle if he is first contact, with the 2nd having a higher chance due to some sort of "dimishing returns" factor. That way Power Backs are still able to break the first tackle 50% of the time, but won't be able to consistently break 3-4 tackles every down.

I know this post is long, even for me, and I find what happens is that you're inital thought gets warped a bit during the explanation... lol.
 
swoosh22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Let's say I have a power back with:

100 STR
70 Carrying
50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too

I've seen plenty of power backs with builds similarish to this, no?

The question I pose to the community (and this is often a topic of much debate) is: what sort of tackling/strength/SA's do you think you should need to consistently stop this guy?

I've seen answers ranging from "soft cap str/tck should be enough" to "You should need 100 tackling skill and at least 70-80 strength."

I will keep my opinion to myself for the moment to keep from tainting anyone else's opinion.



Everyone is still forgetting about how low the speed and agility of this player is. 50-60 speed and agility should be REALLY slow.

To me this build should represent like an offensive lineman, or a run stuffing DT. Not someone like Brandon Jacobs or Adrian Peterson
 
Air18
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knicksfan20

Originally posted by Air18

Originally posted by tuba_samurai


Originally posted by Deathblade



Originally posted by Deathblade




Make "wrap up" more vulnerable to getting plowed over and the ball carrier getting an extra 1-2 yards.

Make "power" less vulnerable to it, but also more likely to miss an ELUSIVE back, NOT a power back.


Basically have the different tackling styles work differently against different types or rushers.


+1 i like this



It seems like a nice idea, but it wouldn't really help considering most teams have 2 RB's - 1 power and 1 elsusive - so either way you're going to get burned by 1 of them unless you play on combo which brings us to square one.




Thats why vision needs to be important...so you can reconize who is being snapped too...and what is the best way to bring that back down.



do you think on defense...when teams are facing the giatns...and they see Jacobs...do you think they will approach to tackling himthe same way t hey would against ward? and vice versa?


Tackling/Vision and a combination of speed/agility/strength is what needs to be the formula



END QUOTE

What your suggesting would eliminate the advanced tactic of Tackling Style all together, by providing a vision check to tell the defenders how to tackle... hm.. now that I think about it I actually sort of like that idea. You can maybe just make the tackling style add bonuses or penalties to the success of your tackle, but force vision to be the key as to how you tackle.
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 19:47:48
 
Air18
offline
Link
 
Quotes arnt working lol.
 
Michael Vick
offline
Link
 
60 strength
55 tackling
35 jumping
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BroncosBeTheBest
60 strength
55 tackling
35 jumping


Jumping so that they can jump high enough to land on their back?
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
what are all of these complaints of LB's not being able to make tackles

my LB just had 10 today

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=347988&pbp_id=319189
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=347988&pbp_id=319500
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=347988&pbp_id=320255
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=347988&pbp_id=321975
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=347988&pbp_id=322070
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=347988&pbp_id=322556
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=347988&pbp_id=323121
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=347988&pbp_id=323420
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=347988&pbp_id=320297
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=347988&pbp_id=323000
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 19:54:05
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by swoosh22
Bort is there anything in the system that checks for the position/angle which defenders are making the tackle?


Sort of, but not that much. It really only checks to see if you are behind the player, or if you're coming off of a block.
 
yendorii
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Air18

IMO, I think you guys are lumping Strength + Tackling together when they should really be set apart. Lets use an anology - say Bort's Power Back somewhat resembles Brandon Jacobs.

Tackling = your tackling technique - how adept you are at actually making a tackle.

Strength = the Strength of your actual tackle.

Think of most CB's, they have pretty decent tackling but low strength. Thus, when they go to tackle Jacobs, they wrap him up but he can still plow forward / fall forward for a few extra yards, because they don't have the strength to stop him in his tracks. However, on the flip side, if you have a guy with ridiculous strength running full speed at Jacobs, he may have the strength to take him down but not the art and will miss his tackle.

Therefore, I propose that Defenders should require a decent balance of both if they want to consistently stop backs in their tacks. With the way this game is structured and the realistic peak of your skills, it's unrealistic to force defenders to get 80+ Strength and Tackling to make a consistent tackle. However, I do believe that defenders who have 80 + tackling and very low strength should be able to make tackles consistently because, in reality, they would be the types of players to "Wrap-up" the legs - sure the Back would plow/fall forward for 3 or 4 extra yards but the tackle would still be made. Strength should determine the "Force" of the tackle, not the effectiveness of the tackle itself. If a back with 60 Str and 60 Speed goes up against a defender with 60 Str and 60 Speed and the tackle is successful, the RB shouldn't be able to fall forward for a few extra yards, but would rather be stopped dead in his tracks. That, in essense, is what Power Backs do - always fall forward.

That being said, Bort, I think what you should do is make 2 checks when a Defender attempts a tackle - a Tackling check (to see if the tackle will be successful) and then some sort of "Force" check (combining strength + speed) to determine whether the back is able to fall forward or trudge for an extra yard or so.

Before you all yell at me and flame me, think of this idea realisticly in the game. How many defenders actually have 80 + tackling? Most people soft-cap it and leave it at that. With 48 tackling, a Defender going up against Bort's RB should only have, say, 50% chance of making the tackle if he is first contact, with the 2nd having a higher chance due to some sort of "dimishing returns" factor. That way Power Backs are still able to break the first tackle 50% of the time, but won't be able to consistently break 3-4 tackles every down.

I know this post is long, even for me, and I find what happens is that you're inital thought gets warped a bit during the explanation... lol.



I wholeheartedly agree with this personally.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.