User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > South America > Renaming Conferences to Satchmo/Dizzy
Page:
 
Necroscope7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by acrnobrnja
Another thing, as long as one of us remains here we won't let it become that. Sadly I don't think we can expect the same of you. You will be the driving force behind making the names into a mockery just so you can come back to this post and say you were right.


You aren't in every thread of every conference, so you can't stop it, and even if you try, there will be people who will ignore you. I'm also not the kind of person to try and make it happen. You should stop speaking until you know anything at all about what you are talking about. Once it gets changed, I'll ignore it and move on, but I'd rather see something better done to honor the guy than this trifling bit of nothing. Once again, if you're going to do it, do it right. I've never said don't do something to honor the guy and solidify his permanent mark in GLB, I've said do something worthwhile, something with some meaning, and I've given some suggestions as to how to do it. Not a one of you has even looked at that or commented on the fact that there are other things that could be done and might be better, all you want to do is bitch because someone doesn't agree with your idea or that it is the greatest idea in the world. Try some constructive criticism sometime, like I keep trying to provide instead of just whining, bitching, and baseless accusations about my character and the kinds of things you want to believe I would do.
 
tordman
offline
Link
 
Trifling bit of nothing? Okay, I'm curious, please tell me what could be a better way to honor a guy. Because this seems to be your main argument.
 
Necroscope7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tordman
Trifling bit of nothing? Okay, I'm curious, please tell me what could be a better way to honor a guy. Because this seems to be your main argument.


I've already posted other options, try reading some of my previous posts in this thread.

Edit: Part of why I call this move trifling is that it limits its influence to SA. Without being a part of SA many people will never see those conference names or know what's going on and with Satch gone, then those people who haven't heard of him out there never will. To change a league name, though, that's out there for everyone to see, to put a permanent forum devoted to him in the main list of GLB forums, that's something for all of GLB. Things like that go beyond just SA and really spread his name and his impact to all of GLB. Conference names are something only we will see and could lead to his name eventually being lost to anyone outside of these leagues, and I think that is the opposite of what you guys want. Whether you rename the conferences or not, there will always be people in SA who remember him, but renaming the conferences will not continue his legacy to the greater GLB community. I think, if you really want to honor him, if you want him and what he's done to be remembered the gesture needs to be bigger, more widespread. I didn't know him, wasn't personally effected by him but I understand you guys' feelings and what you want to do, whether you see that in my posts or not, and I think that to really achieve your goals you need something different than this.
Last edited Jan 8, 2009 17:50:05
 
bacchuspoet
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Necroscope7

I've already posted other options, try reading some of my previous posts in this thread.

Edit: Part of why I call this move trifling is that it limits its influence to SA. Without being a part of SA many people will never see those conference names or know what's going on and with Satch gone, then those people who haven't heard of him out there never will. To change a league name, though, that's out there for everyone to see, to put a permanent forum devoted to him in the main list of GLB forums, that's something for all of GLB. Things like that go beyond just SA and really spread his name and his impact to all of GLB. Conference names are something only we will see and could lead to his name eventually being lost to anyone outside of these leagues, and I think that is the opposite of what you guys want. Whether you rename the conferences or not, there will always be people in SA who remember him, but renaming the conferences will not continue his legacy to the greater GLB community. I think, if you really want to honor him, if you want him and what he's done to be remembered the gesture needs to be bigger, more widespread. I didn't know him, wasn't personally effected by him but I understand you guys' feelings and what you want to do, whether you see that in my posts or not, and I think that to really achieve your goals you need something different than this.


I've been off GLB all day, so I haven't had the ability to reply to any of your other posts. That being said, I hope you don't include me with those who you refer to as "Not a one of you has even looked at that or commented on the fact that there are other things that could be done and might be better, all you want to do is bitch because someone doesn't agree with your idea or that it is the greatest idea in the world. Try some constructive criticism sometime, like I keep trying to provide instead of just whining, bitching, and baseless accusations about my character and the kinds of things you want to believe I would do." I'm fairly certain you are not, however I would like to make very clear that I haven't leveled any personal attacks against you whatsoever. You have a good and valid point, justifiable reasons for feeling the way you do, and you offer alternatives. That is all I asked for in my original post in the SA Pro forum.
My question to you though, would be this. If we have this big of a problem getting something as "trifling" as the conference names changed, if there are people so vehemently and vocally opposed to it, how on Earth do you think it would go over if we tried to rename the entire league? I can't read Bort's mind, but I'm quite certain that would be in the never going to happen list. As to naming the conference championship, yes we can do that in-conference but it would lose the greater impact that I was trying to preserve. And as for renaming just the SA Pro League to the Satchmo-n-Dizzy SA Pro League... the reason Bort started this thread was because he can't do something like that for one part of the league only, it has to be for the entire league. I don't know why, and it seems a little ridiculous that it can't be done, but there it is.

I'm afraid this has all gone very very off point. Just like my post in the Satchmo thread I alluded to in my post, what was it, one or two pages ago, it is beginning a downward spiral into name-calling and ridiculous taunts. And that's on both sides. It goes completely counter to the intent for the suggestion and, frankly, it sickens me a little bit. Satch would tell us all we're being idiots, to be honest. For that reason, I would request that this be officially dropped. It was my hope that we could find something to all hold hands around the campfire and sing Kumbayah together, but that was very very naive of me. You've come a long way from the ROIT's SA, and not in a good way.
 
Necroscope7
offline
Link
 
Realistically, there aren't that many opposed to this, I think I've seen maybe 4 others agree with me, but I do think renaming the league would be easier than renaming the conference, both for player support and Bort's work. From my reading, it's the conference names that can't be changed just for one league, because somewhere in the code it probably links those names to each conference in South America from one central location. Each League though, specifically Pro which isn't just a changed letter/number should have their own separate entry for league name, and therefore easy to change for just the league. I was also thinking the league trophy being renamed, not the conference ones (in fact, I imagine changing the conference ones would be as difficult as changing the conference names themselves because they are probably linked together). It's not like I'm talking about turning the SA portion of it to Satchmo-n-Dizzy, which would definitely be a bigger tribute, but also a much bigger issue. As has already been pointed out here, SA Pro clearly has the support to do what it wants within it's own League for something like this, so you don't have the small but vocal dissenters like myself to worry about there. I could be wrong on this, but that is how I understand things. I would even support doing the league name change and also the forum dedicated to him on the main pages I mentioned. I think there's a lot that can be done, and which would have a large impact, and which would honestly even be easier to do. Oh, and no, you weren't one I was including in that, and I will let acrnobrjna off the hook as well, because while I was typing that reply to him he backed off a bit as well. I know it's a hot-button thing and that I'm getting further and further from being in a lot of peoples' good books, but I don't jump in and try to argue against something like this unless I feel like I have some reasonable logic on my side, and I'm too stubborn to give up easily.
 
acrnobrnja
offline
Link
 
Baccus, for what I did to stray this away; I'm sorry. I just kind of feel that anyone opposed to this idea is opposed to honoring Satch at all. If this is such a trifling and simple thing, I never believed this much opposition to exist.


I honestly expected us to co-sign this on page one, pyramid it real quick and Bort would have this done. This much deliberation and fuss never should have had to exist...



Regardless, sorry about the fuss. I have nothing left to say.
 
Link
 
why hasnt this happened yet?
 
SwagOnLock
offline
Link
 
There have been too many posts that I agree with to quote any certain one, but I just want to throw my support behind the dissenting opinions that have been showing up in here.

I'm all for doing something else, since this internet stranger is of importance to some people that play this game. Name a trophy after him, put a dedication to him on the home page, name a flex package after him, stamp SD on the field in the play by play ala GU for gene upshaw in the NFL. All these are equally thoughtful tributes that will affect everyone in GLB, not just those of us unlucky enough to be in playing in SA. Just do anything that isn't limited to my league, and affects everyone in the game equally.

I think it's great that you guys want to honor the guy, but I'll forever be opposed to you changing the names of SA conferences.'

I want to emphasize that I mean no disrespect or insensitivity, I just wanted to voice my opinion as a longtime owner of an SA team.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bacchuspoet
I'm afraid this has all gone very very off point. Just like my post in the Satchmo thread I alluded to in my post, what was it, one or two pages ago, it is beginning a downward spiral into name-calling and ridiculous taunts. And that's on both sides. It goes completely counter to the intent for the suggestion and, frankly, it sickens me a little bit. Satch would tell us all we're being idiots, to be honest. For that reason, I would request that this be officially dropped. It was my hope that we could find something to all hold hands around the campfire and sing Kumbayah together, but that was very very naive of me. You've come a long way from the ROIT's SA, and not in a good way.


this a better version of what i was trying to say earlier.
 
bacchuspoet
offline
Link
 
I understand most of those who have dissenting opinions, and I respect your right to have those. I certainly don't agree, but it's just opposing viewpoints. Apparently, neither Bort nor the mods have any interest whatsoever in weighing in on the possibilities of the alternatives being proposed. From what I can gather so far, roughly 80-90 percent of those who have checked this thread are in favor of the idea. As someone else has mentioned, that's only a small fraction of all those it would affect. It could probably be argued that the active members of the forums are probably the only ones who would really notice, or care about, the change anyway, but that's pretty irrelevant at this point. I'm not withdrawing my support for the idea at all, but I'm not going to continue to check in and participate in a debate about something that has lost its meaning.

I wonder if there were any members of the NFL who were so vocal about their opposition to the tribute to Gene Upshaw?

I won't comment any further. Everyone have fun talking this issue to death.

And please make a donation to the National MS Society. http://main.nationalmssociety.org/site/TR?type=fr_tribute_fund&fr_id=7540&px=5525204&post_id=13628&bpg=rlist&pg=fund#p13629
 
DaBrownsRPhat
offline
Link
 
I don't know him, but either way is ok with me. Zeta, Dizzy, whatever, we will win the pink elephant conference if that is where we are
 
fakesanta
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by redskinsfan1
why hasnt this happened yet?


 
Talcion
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fakesanta
Originally posted by redskinsfan1

why hasnt this happened yet?




Agree to this 100%

This needs to happen now IMO
 
sensai101
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Talcion
Originally posted by fakesanta

Originally posted by redskinsfan1


why hasnt this happened yet?



 
Link
 
With all the drama and hard choices this game is going through, you'd think Bort would be happy to have a lay-up like this one to help appease the masses.

Make it so.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.