User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Free for All > Instead of supressing the problem, work together for a solution
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by imnotthatstupid
Why is ALINJ a bannable offence?


Because it hurts feelings that change at whim.
 
Voltron
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Voltron

Well, since you feel the need to insult my posts. I'm just going to drop out of this Convo, have fun.



That's the way to go Volt, people disagree heavily with you so you leave.


Difference between disagreeing and just down right insulting what people say.
 
Commander
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Voltron
Originally posted by JohnnyDollar

Originally posted by Voltron


Originally posted by Warren Buffett



Originally posted by Commander




some of these rules are insane. "don't insult staff"?? are you fucking kidding me? if the staff blows, then I should be able to talk about it.


It's like being told not to insult Hitler's 2nd or 3rd in command


There's a difference between criticizing their actions and just down right insulting them and attacking them. Insulting and attacking mods/other people doesn't help fix a thing.


Question is, does it HURT a thing?


Yes, it's disrespecting the site and the people who are trying to help make it better. It may not hurt anything but it's very very very far from helpful.



so, would it be better to have the people accept mediocrity? when people complain, it's because they like the game and want it to get better. when nobody complains, the game either sucks too much for people to care, or is absolutely perfect. and we know that this game is pretty far from perfect
 
JazManXII
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ฿ones


I try to amplify what it is when the situation is called for. I am a teenager, and there are times of severe immaturity as well as amazing maturity. I am trying to keep it as constant as possible, and trying to keep it as close to amazing maturity as I can.


but your making more out of a job than there is
you just use common sense
 
Darkus Black
FFA Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Voltron
Well, since you feel the need to insult my posts. I'm just going to drop out of this Convo, have fun.


This is how kids deal with situations.
 
GIEFF
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by GIEFF

Originally posted by jrry32


Originally posted by GIEFF



Originally posted by jrry32




Originally posted by GIEFF





Then maybe you should only suspend people when their actions result in a net degradation in the site experience for all users?


How do you judge that? That is giving even more judgement to the mods. Me disagreeing with you could be considered a net degradation in the site for all users by a mod that dislikes me.



How is you disagreeing with me a negative? I'm talking about things like spam in content-based forums, posting racism or pornography, or out-of-line personal attacks where the recipient actually wants it to stop.

Things that are obviously causing people to be less likely to continue to play the game. Incidentally, over-moderation is another of those things that can make people less likely to continue to play the game, which is really stupid, considering the whole point of it is to do the exact opposite.


Like I said...Giving Mods more room to make judgements = bad idea. Then they can take advantage of grudges.



None of what I posted requires very much judgment at all, and FAR less than is being applied now.

* Spam in content-based forums is very easy to spot.
* Racism is easy to spot.
* Porn is easy to spot.
* Personal attacks do require a bit of judgment, but I really think they should be allowed in non-content-based forums unless someone asks for them to stop.


Any additional rules are doing more harm than good as far as I'm concerned, assuming the whole point of moderation is to improve the site.


Those are set rules...I was more or less disagreeing with letting them decide what is breaking the rule that negatively effects others. BTW I think do away from the personal attack rule, and just make it harassing users. There are times when attacks are warranted.



I would love to do away with it completely, but I do see the need for it, from the admins' perspective. Harassing is a much better word, though.

NO SPAMMING CONTENT-BASED FORUMS
NO PORN
NO RACISM
NO HARASSMENT


I've explained how these rules improve the site; now what about all the other crap that makes threads get locked and posters get suspended?
 
Link
 
Voltron, how are you going to be a part of the solution if you run and cry when people object to a statement or point of view you hold? Hike up your panties and talk to us
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ฿ones
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by ฿ones


Originally posted by jrry32



Originally posted by ฿ones




Originally posted by Asheme





Originally posted by jrry32






Oh no you didn't Asheme!

Just being honest. I didn't support Voltron or Bones when their names came up (multiple times) for modhood.

As I said then, it was nothing personal (and I liked both of them as posters), but I didn't think, of all the possible candidates, that they would handle the responsibilities of being a moderator better than others could. And I had my reasons. And most of them proved themselves to be true.

But nobody listens to me.

I'm sorry I disappoint you Ashmeme
Please PM me ways I can improve my performance.


How about not trying to be something you aren't? Just be yourself and be mature and if you can't be mature...then don't try to be...step down because if you can't be mature then you can't be a mod.



Problem is, I am myself while I use this game.


You just said you TRY to be mature...that implies that you are trying to be something that you naturally are not.



I try to amplify what it is when the situation is called for. I am a teenager, and there are times of severe immaturity as well as amazing maturity. I am trying to keep it as constant as possible, and trying to keep it as close to amazing maturity as I can.


Bones that brings up the question...should they be hiring kids as mods? I am only 17 but even I think that they shouldn't hire people under 21 as mods...and they should try to hire people who are mature and calm almost all of the time. Like Satchmo-n-dizzy.

 
Weather
offline
Link
 
Here's my take on this (mainly towards
http://serenityglb.blogspot.com/)

I agree with you serenity. I have seen DD treat people like dirt SEVERAL times - unprofessional for the co-"leader" of GLB. That's like the principal of a school banging on some kid - just purely not the way you handle a company/organization.

However, I do disagree with you in someways. What is the definition of a GLB mod? I dunno. If it involves little to no freedom (ie no posting anything like tranny links which make GLB look bad), then you did break some rules of "modding". If you mods are allowed some type of freedoms (ie. acting like a "normal GLB/FFA" poster) then I disagree greatly with DD.

Thoughts?
 
GIEFF
offline
Link
 
This is really more of a discussion for Bort than for the moderators; it's obvious they don't really understand why they are moderators and what their goals should be.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warren Buffett
Voltron, how are you going to be a part of the solution if you run and cry when people object to a statement or point of view you hold? Hike up your panties and talk to us


Watch out for the ban hammer! Your comment is not hurting the site, but it isn't helping it. That is grounds for detention!
Last edited Dec 16, 2008 19:42:26
 
Voltron
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warren Buffett
Voltron, how are you going to be a part of the solution if you run and cry when people object to a statement or point of view you hold? Hike up your panties and talk to us


Again, they weren't objecting. All they did was call my post stupid and insult it. If that's who I'm trying to work a solution out with I'll pass.
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ฿ones
I try to amplify what it is when the situation is called for. I am a teenager, and there are times of severe immaturity as well as amazing maturity. I am trying to keep it as constant as possible, and trying to keep it as close to amazing maturity as I can.

That's why I didn't support you as a moderator. I felt you were far too young to have a good enough grasp on key concepts about human interaction to effectively moderate, despite your enthusiasm and willingness (which is admirable).

Originally posted by Voltron
Well, since you feel the need to insult my posts. I'm just going to drop out of this Convo, have fun.

And this is why I didn't support you as a moderator, Voltron. You take things far too personally. If you can't defend your actions/ideas in the face of personal attacks over the internet, you shouldn't be in charge of ensuring a site's forums run smoothly. 99% of a moderator's role involves rising above the petty shit. If you do it enough times, and people see they don't get a response out of you, they stop. But you give them a response almost every time (which is exactly what they're looking for).
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Voltron
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by Voltron


Well, since you feel the need to insult my posts. I'm just going to drop out of this Convo, have fun.



That's the way to go Volt, people disagree heavily with you so you leave.


Difference between disagreeing and just down right insulting what people say.


Grow the fuck up...coming from a kid. People insult others all the time, taking your ball and going home is the worst way to deal with it.
 
GIEFF
offline
Link
 
Seriously, how did Serenity posting those pictures degrade the site for people? I thought it was hilarious, and so did so many others.

Who did it hurt? And did it cause enough hurt to offset all the entertainment it caused? Or is this site not about entertainment?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.