User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > UGLY GAME 4s - We think something is wrong with the passing in the sims
Page:
 
panther17
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lump7502
Originally posted by panther17

I would like to see teams with good depth play a game and see if they are effected this bad. If it is truly because of stamina being increased, then a team with a lot of depth should not be as effected by this as people who carry 1 QB or 2 QB's.


most nfl only carries 2 qb's the 3rd is an in-active emergency guy


This is true and in which I think how stamina effects QB's should be changed which I already said earlier. The rest should stay the same.
 
lump7502
offline
Link
 
i dont think it favors the offense to much but it gives to much weight to a mismatch which is some thing the offense can control where as on defense its all pretty much read and react
 
Will2k
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NewEnglandCoach
Originally posted by lump7502

Originally posted by panther17


I would like to see teams with good depth play a game and see if they are effected this bad. If it is truly because of stamina being increased, then a team with a lot of depth should not be as effected by this as people who carry 1 QB or 2 QB's.


most nfl only carries 2 qb's the 3rd is an in-active emergency guy


My honest belief is that hte game favors offense way too much, I'm not even going to trip about the change, to me it makes things more realistic, and thus, realism = people bitching.



So you honestly don't care that QB ratings overall will go down throughout the season? Basically have % normal for a game be about 30-40%. I mean if we are going to make it as real as possible, got to fix running since people get up to the 5's and 6's ypc. Blocking going to change because of all the pancakes. Plus other things as well.

Face it, it's just a bad sim and needs to be fix.
 
panther17
offline
Link
 
Tweaked sounds about right.
 
Curufin
offline
Link
 
Yep, the team we just played featured a 35% completion passing attack with 4 interceptions.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Will2k
Originally posted by NewEnglandCoach

Originally posted by lump7502


Originally posted by panther17



I would like to see teams with good depth play a game and see if they are effected this bad. If it is truly because of stamina being increased, then a team with a lot of depth should not be as effected by this as people who carry 1 QB or 2 QB's.


most nfl only carries 2 qb's the 3rd is an in-active emergency guy


My honest belief is that hte game favors offense way too much, I'm not even going to trip about the change, to me it makes things more realistic, and thus, realism = people bitching.



So you honestly don't care that QB ratings overall will go down throughout the season? Basically have % normal for a game be about 30-40%. I mean if we are going to make it as real as possible, got to fix running since people get up to the 5's and 6's ypc. Blocking going to change because of all the pancakes. Plus other things as well.

Face it, it's just a bad sim and needs to be fix.


Really now? You don't think it favors offense? We only see 500-0 blowouts everyday, but of course it can't favor the offense. :S Like I said, I'm not going to trip about the new changes. I do believe the HB should be toned down if the passing is going to be however, to balance it out. Perhaps something went wrong? You guys are solely blaming one thing, without being ambiguous enough to look at what else could have caused the problem. That's my problem with your guys' argument.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
QB pass quality was adjusted slightly downward last night. Combined with the recent chemistry updates and stamina effects, it could contribute to some lower completions %'s or dropped passes.

I have to ask this, though: didn't you find it odd that even Lv 5-6 QB's were consistently passing for 80+%? Payton Manning's career passing pct is 64%. I would say he's a bit higher than lv 10.


my guy must have been throwing to invisible receivers. I had a 35% completion percentage, by far my worse one yet. Please no more negative tweaks to the system.

 
Link
 
You see, to be honest, I couldn't care less that my QB put up bad numbers. He is a low level compared to where he'd be in a few seasons, a second year player at the moment, not a veteran. The problem is, this coming in at this point has all but ass raped any teams who are not built to run primarily. As I said, today we lost because we barely ran (I don't know if that was gameplanned, or if it altered in game) wheras our opponent ran on us all day long. Had this been the case from day one, owners could've planned for it, rather than having it shot at us via a cannon.

P.S. I own a team as well, and we've got a great running game, so it's going to benefit us, it just should'nt be the case coming this late in the day.
 
CWickson
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hostyle
Originally posted by matthewjnason

Originally posted by hostyle



Then what exactly is the point of leveling to 50? I thought it was to get stronger, not to stay even.


It's like in real football a guy like Colt Brennan can put up 500 yds/game for Hawaii. Let's assume Peyton Manning is a better QB, well Peyton can only put up 300 yds/game. But, I think everyone would agree that Peyton's a more talented QB.

The real point of leveling up to 50 is to be able to play in the pro leagues. Not to beat up people in the lower levels.


Ok so if thats the case, then the whole premise of the game is that your QB starts off as good as hes ever going to get at level 1. Assigning points is a task in seeing if you cant break him by the time he hits 50. I dont think its acceptable for a level 50 to go out and have a 400 yards game and look over at a low level league and see a level 9 with a 400 yards game. As stated in another reply by an admin, its like pop warner playing pop warner, when was the last pop warner game with a 400 passing performance?



So the fact that high school running backs rush for 200 yards a game fairly often or QBs throw for 50 TDs in a season means they're better than pro QBs?
 
hostyle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CWickson
Originally posted by hostyle

Originally posted by matthewjnason


Originally posted by hostyle




Then what exactly is the point of leveling to 50? I thought it was to get stronger, not to stay even.


It's like in real football a guy like Colt Brennan can put up 500 yds/game for Hawaii. Let's assume Peyton Manning is a better QB, well Peyton can only put up 300 yds/game. But, I think everyone would agree that Peyton's a more talented QB.

The real point of leveling up to 50 is to be able to play in the pro leagues. Not to beat up people in the lower levels.


Ok so if thats the case, then the whole premise of the game is that your QB starts off as good as hes ever going to get at level 1. Assigning points is a task in seeing if you cant break him by the time he hits 50. I dont think its acceptable for a level 50 to go out and have a 400 yards game and look over at a low level league and see a level 9 with a 400 yards game. As stated in another reply by an admin, its like pop warner playing pop warner, when was the last pop warner game with a 400 passing performance?



So the fact that high school running backs rush for 200 yards a game fairly often or QBs throw for 50 TDs in a season means they're better than pro QBs?


Exactly how often, is often? Show me some stats and percentages based on total teams in the nation. Im sure those are the exception to the rule and not even at a 50% rate compared to all teams.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by hostyle
Originally posted by CWickson

Originally posted by hostyle


Originally posted by matthewjnason



Originally posted by hostyle





Then what exactly is the point of leveling to 50? I thought it was to get stronger, not to stay even.


It's like in real football a guy like Colt Brennan can put up 500 yds/game for Hawaii. Let's assume Peyton Manning is a better QB, well Peyton can only put up 300 yds/game. But, I think everyone would agree that Peyton's a more talented QB.

The real point of leveling up to 50 is to be able to play in the pro leagues. Not to beat up people in the lower levels.


Ok so if thats the case, then the whole premise of the game is that your QB starts off as good as hes ever going to get at level 1. Assigning points is a task in seeing if you cant break him by the time he hits 50. I dont think its acceptable for a level 50 to go out and have a 400 yards game and look over at a low level league and see a level 9 with a 400 yards game. As stated in another reply by an admin, its like pop warner playing pop warner, when was the last pop warner game with a 400 passing performance?



So the fact that high school running backs rush for 200 yards a game fairly often or QBs throw for 50 TDs in a season means they're better than pro QBs?


Exactly how often, is often? Show me some stats and percentages based on total teams in the nation. Im sure those are the exception to the rule and not even at a 50% rate compared to all teams.




Took the words out of my mouth.
 
Icespyder
offline
Link
 
I find it ridiculous when a dump pass to a HB cant even be done properly now. A big change like this SHOULD have been made more noticeable. My team had short and middle passing ramped up but passes were so horrible, it was one 3 and out after another.

This would have been fine if the running game wasn't so gimp no matter how good the running game and Line is if you are playing a good team.
 
kr0n
offline
Link
 
1 TD and 4 INT

=/
 
Will2k
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NewEnglandCoach
Originally posted by Will2k

Originally posted by NewEnglandCoach


Originally posted by lump7502



Originally posted by panther17




I would like to see teams with good depth play a game and see if they are effected this bad. If it is truly because of stamina being increased, then a team with a lot of depth should not be as effected by this as people who carry 1 QB or 2 QB's.


most nfl only carries 2 qb's the 3rd is an in-active emergency guy


My honest belief is that hte game favors offense way too much, I'm not even going to trip about the change, to me it makes things more realistic, and thus, realism = people bitching.



So you honestly don't care that QB ratings overall will go down throughout the season? Basically have % normal for a game be about 30-40%. I mean if we are going to make it as real as possible, got to fix running since people get up to the 5's and 6's ypc. Blocking going to change because of all the pancakes. Plus other things as well.

Face it, it's just a bad sim and needs to be fix.


Really now? You don't think it favors offense? We only see 500-0 blowouts everyday, but of course it can't favor the offense. :S Like I said, I'm not going to trip about the new changes. I do believe the HB should be toned down if the passing is going to be however, to balance it out. Perhaps something went wrong? You guys are solely blaming one thing, without being ambiguous enough to look at what else could have caused the problem. That's my problem with your guys' argument.



I agree with you on the blowouts. They can get too crazy at times. Reason we blame one thing is because that one thing was changed today for the sim. So it's easy to see why most of us point to that as the problem.

Look I enjoy the new changes around here. I like the energy and stamina changes, but if its going to be that everyone is basically going to suck until we hit a really high lvl then it kind of takes the fun out of the game.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Icespyder
I find it ridiculous when a dump pass to a HB cant even be done properly now. A big change like this SHOULD have been made more noticeable. My team had short and middle passing ramped up but passes were so horrible, it was one 3 and out after another.

This would have been fine if the running game wasn't so gimp no matter how good the running game and Line is if you are playing a good team.


This, I agree. But I'm not solely blaming the ONE change Bort made, other factors could have worked with it to affect what happened.

EDIT: "Look I enjoy the new changes around here. I like the energy and stamina changes, but if its going to be that everyone is basically going to suck until we hit a really high lvl then it kind of takes the fun out of the game." <-- I agree with this statement also.
Last edited May 2, 2008 17:57:45
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.