User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Medium Coverage pushes me over the edge
Page:
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GoVikings16
Originally posted by Bort

Now that I think about it, It really sounds like people want to be able to go in and try to break up passes every time without the risk of getting beat, which isn't necessarily the best option for game balance. There does need to be a risk/reward kinda thing.

In RL, if a CB dives in and tries to break up the pass, he could easily fall down or miss it and fly past, etc.


This.

There is a reason for each setting. If one isn't working for you, try something else. There will be a setting for each player that lets him perform at his best.. just take your time,find it, and stop complaining.


Yeah, when a player falls down, the graphical representation will make it look like he fell away from the WR, and then after 24 hours there will be 6 'bug' (I use this term very loosely) threads crying about how teams are losing based on evil Bort schemes.

lol
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
As Medium is now, it has become pointless to have any significant levels in Super Vision, or even Jumping.

We should be able to use our Super Vision to determine what kind of play to make on the ball. Each pass is different, as should be our reaction.

We shouldn't just sit back on every single play, especially if we chose to Stick to WR Like Glue.

The Coverage Style and Coverage Distance should be two different things, as they aren't set up to be different anymore, which doesn't quite make sense.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Bukowski

Yeah..

A CB shouldn't be forced to go for the PD every single time.

He should be able to decide, which is the most likely for success - going for the INT, PD, or an easy tackle.

We shouldn't have to have one without the other.

A CB should be able to make a PD on one play, but then attempt to INT the ball on the next.

We shouldn't be held down, to only once choice.


Unforunately you're stuck with the one option at the moment, but I can definitely take that into consideration as I work on future tactical option.

I'd like to maybe do a 1-100% power-elusive slider for running style as well - it'd be very easy as far as the sim code goes.


This option is #1 in my book.
Would probably result in less exactly the same CB's plus it would give me something else to do every pregame
 
Dacolts
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Adderfist

Originally posted by MRIGUY


Originally posted by Dacolts



Couldn't the style be simplified to:

-Go for the Int
-Go for the Int when help over the top
-Go for the PD


i like this.


I agree, This idea is better then the slider. Simple and efficient.


There needs to be a 4th option there of "stay back no matter what" - sometimes your guy is badly outmatched and you don't want to risk it at all.

Adding a "blanket coverage" option would be the same as "Go for the PD"


Doesn't that come into play on "Man coverage distance", which far would be the option? Every defender has to make a play on the ball. No setting should allow a catch.
 
vrshah
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski


The Coverage Style and Coverage Distance should be two different things, as they aren't set up to be different anymore, which doesn't quite make sense.


exactly.
 
HydrOshocK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sirallan
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by vrshah


Bort, it seems like right now there are 9 combined coverage options for DBs as is (3 coverage x 3 INT aggressiveness).

What would a fourth option add that the other three do not?

It seems like you are making coverage more relatable to INT aggressiveness and that is not correct. Coverage should be how tight a CB sticks to a WR not how much he wants to make a play on the ball.

Coverage (loose,medium,tight) should be based on agility and somewhat vision whereas INT aggressiveness should be vision,jumping et. al.

Your definition of coverage as is, is overlapping with INT aggressiveness too much, no?


I suppose I could "create" that fourth option by making it so if you're set to "close" and "aggressive" it would do what I was thinking with a "move to just above the receiver" action or something.


What I think everyone wants is a perfect system where if there is help over the top they will go for the pick and if they miss the pick its a PD.
And if there isn't help over the top then they only go for the PD.

Basically they want a system where the WR is guaranteed to always have a CB right on him.

Then when this gets done you will have a ton of WRs on here yelling that they can never get open.



THIS
 
GoVikings16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by GoVikings16

Originally posted by Bort


Now that I think about it, It really sounds like people want to be able to go in and try to break up passes every time without the risk of getting beat, which isn't necessarily the best option for game balance. There does need to be a risk/reward kinda thing.

In RL, if a CB dives in and tries to break up the pass, he could easily fall down or miss it and fly past, etc.


This.

There is a reason for each setting. If one isn't working for you, try something else. There will be a setting for each player that lets him perform at his best.. just take your time,find it, and stop complaining.


Yeah, when a player falls down, the graphical representation will make it look like he fell away from the WR, and then after 24 hours there will be 6 'bug' (I use this term very loosely) threads crying about how teams are losing based on evil Bort schemes.

lol


Yeah. They should basically change the name of the "Bug" thread to the "My player made a horrible play, its Bort's Fault" thread.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Bukowski

Yeah..

A CB shouldn't be forced to go for the PD every single time.

He should be able to decide, which is the most likely for success - going for the INT, PD, or an easy tackle.

We shouldn't have to have one without the other.

A CB should be able to make a PD on one play, but then attempt to INT the ball on the next.

We shouldn't be held down, to only once choice.


Unforunately you're stuck with the one option at the moment, but I can definitely take that into consideration as I work on future tactical option.

I'd like to maybe do a 1-100% power-elusive slider for running style as well - it'd be very easy as far as the sim code goes.


But there was never only one option.

Even if I played Aggressive, I would sometimes go for the PD and sometimes the INT.

If I played Medium, I would go for the PD more, and the INT less. But I would still go for both, depending on the play.

We need multiple options.

My CBs have 8 in Super Vision, they shouldn't be just sitting back there, doing the same thing over and over. They should be smart enough to know whether or not they can catch the ball, or if they can just bat the ball down.

If we can't have it set up correctly, we need to just go back to what it was a few days ago. This obviously didn't have the desired affect, so we should go back until it can be implemented correctly.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Ok, I'm going to test out a "new" 4th setting. Should be easy enough to add, so I bet I can finish in the next couple hours.

I'm going to call it semi-aggressive and make the defender just head right at the player's outside shoulder when the ball is thrown his way, even without help over the top. At that position/distance he should be close enough to try knock down passes, but not really get int's very often.

Don't be surprised if he still falls down sometimes when going for the PD - it can happen!
Last edited Nov 28, 2008 21:26:13
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Ok, I'm going to test out a "new" 4th setting. Should be easy enough to add, so I bet I can finish in the next couple hours.

I'm going to call it semi-aggressive and make the defender just head right at the player's outside shoulder when the ball is thrown his way, even without help over the top. At that position/distance he should be close enough to try knock down passes, but not really get int's very often.


Sounds good and we can work from there.
And good I don't want a CB that makes the perfect play everytime. Completely takes away from the game.
Last edited Nov 28, 2008 21:27:02
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Can you tell us, where Super Vision comes into play now?

And if we don't play on Aggressive, does it now become useless to add points into?
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Ok, I'm going to test out a "new" 4th setting. Should be easy enough to add, so I bet I can finish in the next couple hours.

I'm going to call it semi-aggressive and make the defender just head right at the player's outside shoulder when the ball is thrown his way, even without help over the top. At that position/distance he should be close enough to try knock down passes, but not really get int's very often.


Is there any way we could help to break down what's happening on it?
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Adderfist
Originally posted by Bort

Ok, I'm going to test out a "new" 4th setting. Should be easy enough to add, so I bet I can finish in the next couple hours.

I'm going to call it semi-aggressive and make the defender just head right at the player's outside shoulder when the ball is thrown his way, even without help over the top. At that position/distance he should be close enough to try knock down passes, but not really get int's very often.


Is there any way we could help to break down what's happening on it?


Yes.
 
vrshah
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Ok, I'm going to test out a "new" 4th setting. Should be easy enough to add, so I bet I can finish in the next couple hours.

I'm going to call it semi-aggressive and make the defender just head right at the player's outside shoulder when the ball is thrown his way, even without help over the top. At that position/distance he should be close enough to try knock down passes, but not really get int's very often.

Don't be surprised if he still falls down sometimes when going for the PD - it can happen!


Yes, but will the coverage style settings be independent of coverage distance settings insofar as the sim perceives them?
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vrshah
Originally posted by Bort

Ok, I'm going to test out a "new" 4th setting. Should be easy enough to add, so I bet I can finish in the next couple hours.

I'm going to call it semi-aggressive and make the defender just head right at the player's outside shoulder when the ball is thrown his way, even without help over the top. At that position/distance he should be close enough to try knock down passes, but not really get int's very often.

Don't be surprised if he still falls down sometimes when going for the PD - it can happen!


Yes, but will the coverage style settings be independent of coverage distance settings insofar as the sim perceives them?


Yeah, we definitely need that.

Bort, can you comment on this?

WE should be able to choose how tight our CB plays the WR, not the SIM.
Last edited Nov 28, 2008 21:29:12
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.