User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Have "Superstars" and "All-Pros"
Page:
 
feedy
offline
Link
 
-1
 
Staz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by feedy
-1


This sort of thing slightly annoys me. I can totally see how people would disagree with this, or agree with it, but to simply say "I agree" or "I disagree" adds nothing to the idea. If you don't like it, why? Perhaps the reason you don't agree with this has a simple solution that could be added to the idea to make it a stronger, more logical thought.
 
glassmatica
offline
Link
 
-1
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Carnival GLB doesn't sound like fun.
 
GwalltOren
offline
Link
 
I hate the idea im sorry to say, Youd just have the "superstars" so much better than everyone else, it would just create more problems.
 
Jackula
offline
Link
 
-1

It creates such an inbalance to the game, and people who don't want to spend hundreds on one player are at a huge dissadvantage. Although this may get a "go get a job" post, even I have a job and don't want to pour that much into this game.
 
MxPx3oh!3fan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DevilDogJAL
Interesting idea, and something new. That's a lot of money to spend on a player, but I know that's intended to be the built-in buffer.

Overall, I like it.


 
Link
 
it would give those players who have more money and therefor more FP a too dominant advantage over those who don't say if a user don't mind using 2700 FP to boost his SS player every season, then he would dominate so much over those who just created normal players or SS' who don't boost..
 
slurmewerds
offline
Link
 
The idea of All-Pros and Superstars in general is a good idea but the proposed way to go about it is too flawed, even with adjustments. If the idea were to go through i would probably retire all my players and make one superstar return man that nobody catch or tackle and when playing lower level teams i would score almost every other time unless all the superstars and allpros were playing on ST(which would most likely be a given), which is reversed to the normal thinking, and would create less playing time for backups, which in turn creates more of a gap between backups and starters.

But if it were more of a reward status it would work better. Players receive all-pro status if they meet certain attribute requirements at their level and/or lead their league in certain stat categories. Then they receive an award and receive a superstar or allpro icon next to their name. It would reward good builds and the rewards could be it would cost less cash to train to get the same amount, say intense training costs 6000 but for an allpro its 5500 and superstar just 4500(just examples). And maybe their stats dont start decreasing until season 12 or there is less of a decline than normal players per season, because all-pros and superstars usually play longer than the avg. player (anyone know brett favre?)
And at the end of the season they would play in an All-Pro or SS game where they receive a cash bonus, eq bonus, bonus token bonus, stat bonus, or even a FP bonus or option to pick a bonus between three bonuses, whichever they may be.
In short, it rewards good builds, the bonuses aren't rediculous, and they add new elements to the game(i.e. pro-bowls and bonuses) and gives anybody a chance at getting one, booster or not.

The limits to things can be adjusted, such as superstar limits or bonus limits, but it seems to be a better foundation than spending rediculous amounts of FP just to maintain one player.
 
nightstar289
offline
Link
 
Bump
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
After reading the OP, I liked the idea.

But after thinking about it, I do not. The reason being, I don't think people understand what makes a superstar in real life. Most guys that are superstars are so as much as a product of opportunity as they are natural talent. Take Daunte Culpepper for example. The guy became a superstar in Minnesota with an awesome offensive line that could consistently give him 5 seconds to throw the ball, and great receivers that could take advantage. Put him on a regular team with typical pass protection problems and he was garbage. The point is, what really makes a player special is having the talent and also capitalizing on opportunities. You don't need a special build process for that, it can already happen.
Sure, in real life there is occassionally going to be someone like Adrian Peterson who everyone can agree is just naturally better than almost everyone else. But players like that are a rare exception, not the rule. If that's what you want to emulate, then allowing 2 or even 1 superstar per account is entirely excessive. You could argue that a lot of people will screw up their superstar's builds, and end up with a guy who is really not better than regular players, and that will prevent there from being thousands of Adrian Petersons. But you're relying on bad superstar builds to separate the truly super superstars, then you have to recognize that having had the SP bonuses and the training bonuses is not what makes a superstar.
 
regoob2
offline
Link
 
Do we need to help the rich kids out any more? I dont think so.

-1
 
PatsFan94
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tim26
+10000000000000000000000000000000000000


 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
But what about the players that already have superstars through good building?
 
Meitheisman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
After reading the OP, I liked the idea.

But after thinking about it, I do not.


That, and I think it would break the game as has been explained pretty well in the first couple of pages. This shouldn't have been bumped and was fine dying slowly in the old pages of this forum imo.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.