User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Weight Classes
Page:
 
notthegint
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheInfinity


Minus stamina for high weight? Dude, linemen and big power backs get the most work out of anyone in the NFL, if we're doing this for realism, thats off.


And DTs are bigger than OL and tend to tire out after a handful of plays. Thus you have dline rotations going on.

The point of that was that a 300 lbs olineman should have better stamina than a 360lbs olineman, since the 360lbs is presumably getting a higher blocking bonus.

Different positions place different energy requirements on players that have nothing to do with stamina. The suggestion was about relative stamina of two players of the same position. (i.e. A 250 pound back should need more stamina to run 5 plays in a row than a 220 lbs back.)

So you could still make Earl Campbell, you'd just need to dump more points into stamina than to make Warrick Dunn.

The other variable which should be emphasized more in stamina calculations is speed.

Originally posted by TheInfinity

Second, assigning attributes like tackling is off, safeties are some of the best tacklers on a team, definitely better than the big power back or the offensive lineman. They may not have the same strength level but their technique tends to be very good.


Which would mean that to be a good tackling safety, you would need to put more points into tackling (which = good technique). Right now, speed > tackling in the tackling equation, so safeties are better tacklers than LBs cause they're faster. Introduce (or enhance I guess) the size variable and a safety would have to have better tackling technique than LBs to get the same results.

Originally posted by TheInfinity

To begin with not everyone is going to conform to their weight in life, 260lb. guys are sometimes freaks and can be faster than a 220lb. guy, it happens. They can also sometimes jump higher, LeBron James is 260lb., tell me that he doesn't have an insane vertical leap. And some smaller dudes can be very strong for their size, Terrell Owens is a bit slower than a dude like Randy Moss but much stronger and more physical. Larry Fitzgerald is the same way.


The nature of this game is that there can't be "freaks", because freaks by definition are people with better physical tools than average. Everyone gets the same tools here, cause we all paid the same money. This is why specialization is so huge, you have to find an edge on the competition somewhere.

Originally posted by TheInfinity

If strength meant anything in this game we wouldn't be worrying about this. Make strength matter in block breaking/blocking/carrying/etc and you'll have your solution without this crazy system.


I fully agree that strength needs to play more of a role, but I don't think weight and strength are mutually exclusive.

Stamina also needs to play a much larger role in this game. I keep seeing highly productive, high level builds with stamina in the 30s. That isn't right.
 
kevbk6222
offline
Link
 
i support as long as i can gain/lose weight
 
sportskidd
offline
Link
 
epic
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
Make it happen Bort.
 
clute62
offline
Link
 
only problem is we never got to choose our weight
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by clute62
only problem is we never got to choose our weight


Bort said he could put a normal training option to lose/gain weight
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knick
Originally posted by clute62

only problem is we never got to choose our weight


Bort said he could put a normal training option to lose/gain weight


Could just give everyone a chance to assign a new weight to their player, that way they can go into the class they want and start from there. It'd only be fair considering most people didn't pay attention to weight when they made their players.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
I had been suggesting to go the other direction - have your attributes determine your build type.. but this could work as well.

Here are my thoughts on how it would be implemented:

1) Determine the build types and bonuses - this you've already done.
2) Determine each Player's initial setting .... probably the best way is to allow each Player to choose their own initial, but if you wanted to come up with a formula which compares a player's physical and mental attributes to determine what their build is - that'd be cool too... Just assigning random build types to Players that have been around for 4-5 seasons would be silly though.
3) Determine how Players can change which body type they have. Nightly training could use a bar like this:
Originally posted by

Featherweight.....Middleweight.....Heavyweight
------|----------------|-----------------|----------
.............^Your Size Here..............


And then with each nightly training you have the option of increasing or decreasing by 1 tic.... maybe each class has 10 tics and a Player could be on 30% in Middleweight.... train a night to increase (going to 40%) and then start changing their mind and train 5 nights to decrease (going to 90% of the previous class).


4) Determine outside affects that might temporarily/permanently allow a Player to use the attributes of a different weight class. You mention veteran abilities, another option would be temp boosts in the item store.
 
TJ Spikes
offline
Link
 
Height and weight have always had a "small" factor. I don't see any reason not to crank up what is already in place, without having to do the whole weight class thing.

Classes in general are kind of a dumb idea. Being 259 pounds gets you a 10%, being 260 pounds gets you a 10%, being 261 pounds gets you a 20%? One pound causes a gain or loss of 10%?

It just seems like it would be easier to plug in more of a wieght factor into the secret math that's already in place.

Failing that, I'd suggest having a factor based on the total weight varience allowed in the game. Like 150 pounds, to say 350 pounds would be a 200 point scale. 250 would be in the middle. With 100 pounds in either direction, 5 pounds per 1% would yeild a 20% scale. The tricky part would be balancing the negative effects of weight with the positive ones. Speed vs. Block/Break Block. Maybe Stam vs. Tackle/Break tackle?

So at 5 pounds per %, with 250 being average, a 275 pound guy would have 5% less Speed and Stam, but also 5% more tackle/break and block/break. A 200 pound guy would have 10% more Speed and Stam, but 10% less tackle/break and block/break.

something like that anyway
Last edited Nov 25, 2008 00:10:03
 
slashxtreme
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
I'd be more for it if this is something we could wait till the off-season to implement so that at least we can fix our builds with our boosts if necessary next off-season..
 
Link
 
I say do it!
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
If something like this is done, it needs to happen:

1) At the end of the season, after ALL playoff games are done. We don't need something like this potentially screwing a team's season because they...

2) ...picked the wrong weights. Any player already made needs to be able to pick their weight class for this. It wouldn't be fair to let new players start off at whatever weight they roll now that it has a higher effect while the other guy takes awhile to lower or gain weight.

Also, the idea of making it percentage based doesn't really help anything at all. This is an MMO, with people that can and will min-max things. Do I want to give my WR 30% more chance to break blocks when he already has a very slim chance to break blocks, Or do I want to give him 30% more speed when he already has 90 speed? This is not going to promote build diversity, but will instead promote cookie cutter builds. It is also going to keep current players that have been around from season 1 or 2 from being able to adapt in a few seasons when these new min/maxxed players come around with their 160 weight and 100 speed while many S1 or S2 guys built under the theory of having a bit of balance.

This isn't going to promote realism, sadly. It is just going to promote freak builds since they would take the most advantage of this. Welcome to the world of all speed backs (since a power back breaking a few more tackles a game but being really slow at 300 points won't help when he can instead move significantly faster by being 160. I don't see many people picking anything in the balanced area except for those trying to build realistic football players (the ones that have been building guys with fairly balanced stats).

Note that I'm all in favor of height and weight having an effect on things, but having any sort of effect that directly influences a player's stats that they can put points in is a bad idea. Instead of having it make them faster, for example, have it make them more elusive. Give them a higher chance to trigger elusive SAs for being skinnier or a higher chance to trigger power SAs for being fatter.
 
Llyranwyar
offline
Link
 
At first glance, I wanna say yeah that sounds about right. But once I have thought about it past the first second I thought of a lot of problems that it would cause. I think a lot of people are taken by the whole realism, that's the way it should be aspect and don't foresee the issues that come up.

Speed is too important in this game.

Strength is too unimportant.

People who complained about speed didn't learn their lesson and put enough points in strength. WR's would have to worry about strength to hold onto the ball if safeties worked correctly.

With that said....

all players trying to be fast will be 160 or reroll. Your player is crap if he's 161, train it down.

It will just be one more hurdle or stat to min/max to get what you already had with the stats.

Might as well just make weight 'flavor text' based off some combination of str and speed or something.

TheInfinity is just plain right.

This idea will bring no end to the "reduce cookie cutter builds". Think about it. The new terminology for speed/elusive backs will be "160 backs". Power backs will be the "220 backs". "oooo....he's a 190 back, he can't run or break a tackle."

 
rhk065
offline
Link
 

It would be nice to change your weight, but maybe it should be a gradient instead of weight classes so people on the border aren't completely pissed that they built their rb to be a speed back and their barely into a higher weight class
 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
Good idea, it could work very well, but you have to make sure the bonuses gained are not over-powered, and that each bonus is equally as good. Otherwise if one type of build becomes known as the best, everyone will drift to that and really make the whole system pointless.

If you can find that near perfect balance where each weight class really helps customize players then it will be great.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.