User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Maybe blocking should give the player a higher radius at which he can engage the block? Right now it just determines how well you can hold it when you do engage, but everyone's distance to engage is the same.

That would seem to make some sense, no?

Other idea: Maybe guys with 8 vision shouldn't get the instant jump on the snap, either. I could easily extend the "snap delay" code to D-line guys on pass plays.


Here, SI. I did the work for you. Happy, now?
Last edited Nov 12, 2008 00:32:18
 
wlarson
offline
Link
 
it's all relative. 30 speed and 50 agility is fine vs level 20 DEs. not so much vs level 30+ DEs with 67+ base speed & agility.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
SI is right about the speed attribute - a guy with 10 speed is slow as dirt no matter what he is doing. Speed determines the limit on how fast you can go, and if your top speed is 1 pixel per second, no amount of agility is going to make you go any faster. You'll just be able to shift your 1 pixel per second speed into a different direction quicker.
Last edited Nov 12, 2008 00:35:42
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cdcollins
Originally posted by SteelersInsider


why are you so against taking speed out of the OT/DE game?

It's like you want to play want to play rock, paper, scissors.......with only rock and paper.


The easy way to get the OT to expand his radius is to get his fat ass moving faster (speed).



[sarcasm]

Why not just have 1 attribute for O-linemen and call it "blocking" and get rid of speed and strength all together?

[/sarcasm]


P.S. The Middle school analogy was a poor one. I have no idea what your point was. Size and speed are the 2 things things that determine a OT's blocking radius, not the hands techniques they learn. The hand techniques/blocking only come into play when their LEGS shuffle them over to the appropriate spot to engage the DE.


If you'd care to look back a few pages, Bort explicitly stated that every player has the same block radius. I paraphrase, but this is true. I'm not against speed, and if you find where I said I was, I'll wire you $500 right now. I think it has a crucial role for offensive linemen if used correctly. But this pretty much shoots your whole argument to shreds.

And that's what I based my middle-schooler analogy on. It's called allegory.


Quoting to get these both on the same page for SI to attempt to shoot down.
Last edited Nov 12, 2008 00:34:58
 
ron2288
offline
Link
 
again a level 30 Ot shutting a higher level OLD and DE


because the speed guys did not get around the OT...now where in the play is the blocking scrwed up...a lower level OT block a higher level OLB and DE...hmmm I guess I should complain blocking is too good..but now...lets look at this with common sense..a strong OT gets his hands on a speed DE and a speed OLB..he pushes them back...hmmm

dam..1 OT blocking 2 higher level guys...hmmm
so if blocking was a messed up as the OP and other say then this play should have never happen

start sarcasm
we should have won by 200 points.....yes we did blow them out..but we should have won by more because this should have not happen...end sarcasm

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=223987&pbp_id=1410622
Last edited Nov 12, 2008 00:38:33
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Blacksheep
Agility

How fast your player can adjust their movement. If you want to dodge a tackle or head past a blocker you'll want high agility. Important for any player who needs to turn quickly...Lineman as well as speedsters. Agility also determines acceleration. You can have all the speed in the world, but without agility, you won't ever reach that top speed.


The first part is great. 100% clear. The last part about "determining" acceleration is the part that is confusing for some people. I think it means that unless you have 1 to 1 speed to agility, then you aren't going to quite accelerate as quickly. It doesn't mean that you can be fast over short distances with no speed.

So when you are 50 speed, 35 agility, you only get 35 speed for a certain time.

When you are 50 speed, 50 agility, you get all 50 speed right from the start

When you are 50 speed, 100 agility, you only get 50 speed for a certain time.

In this way, agility does "determine" acceleration, but it doesn't MOVE you from point A to point B. It only can slow you down in the beginning if you don't have enough from what I can tell.

So if you have 100 speed and 20 agility, then it would take forever to ever reach 100 speed.

10 speed and 110 agility is still going to be EXTREMELY slow and would barely move at all.


Am I the only one who gets this?
 
chief31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by chief31

Originally posted by SteelersInsider



speed is *not* running. speed = movement.

if you want your guy to move, then he better get speed.

if you want him to just stand there and let the DE go by then keep your low speed.

agility does not move you player!!!!



Originally posted by Dictionary


ag¡¤ile (aj¡äəl, -¨©l¡ä)

adjective

quick and easy of movement; deft and active


http://www.yourdictionary.com/agility


Originally posted by Dictionary


ag¡¤ile [ ¨¢jj'l ]


adjective

Definition:

1. nimble: able to move quickly and with suppleness, skill, and control


http://encarta.msn.com/dictionary_/agility.html




that is exactly my point. in this game agility is not defined the same as in real life.


In real life agility = agility + speed


In GLB, agility = ability to turn/cut quickly - SPEED NOT INVOLVED


See my example a few pages back.



The point is that if GLB is mis-interprteing the meaning of the word AGILITY, then it should be fixed.

If this is the definition of the word, then that is how it should be defined.

Originally posted by Dictionary


1. nimble: able to move quickly and with suppleness, skill, and control


And I believe that that is how GLB intends for AGILITY to work. If a real life OT doesn't need SPEED to be a good pass-blocker, then it is silly to make a GLB OT need SPEED for that purpose.

He may as well be needing PUNTING. Whatever unneccessary attribute that you are making OTs build, it is still not right.

People come here for the "football SIM". If we aren't rtrying to simulate real football, then what are we trying to do?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by cdcollins
Originally posted by Bort

Maybe blocking should give the player a higher radius at which he can engage the block? Right now it just determines how well you can hold it when you do engage, but everyone's distance to engage is the same.

That would seem to make some sense, no?

Other idea: Maybe guys with 8 vision shouldn't get the instant jump on the snap, either. I could easily extend the "snap delay" code to D-line guys on pass plays.


Here, SI. I did the work for you. Happy, now?


why would a person be able to block further than their arms can reach? Do you armst get longer.... the more you play football? How are you going to block without your arms??

Last edited Nov 12, 2008 00:40:22
 
chief31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
SI is right about the speed attribute - a guy with 10 speed is slow as dirt no matter what he is doing. Speed determines the limit on how fast you can go, and if your top speed is 1 pixel per second, no amount of agility is going to make you go any faster. You'll just be able to shift your 1 pixel per second speed into a different direction quicker.


How about matching GLB to the english language then?

 
ron2288
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chief31
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by chief31


Originally posted by SteelersInsider




speed is *not* running. speed = movement.

if you want your guy to move, then he better get speed.

if you want him to just stand there and let the DE go by then keep your low speed.

agility does not move you player!!!!



Originally posted by Dictionary



ag¡¤ile (aj¡äəl, -¨©l¡ä)

adjective

quick and easy of movement; deft and active


http://www.yourdictionary.com/agility


Originally posted by Dictionary



ag¡¤ile [ ¨¢jj'l ]


adjective

Definition:

1. nimble: able to move quickly and with suppleness, skill, and control


http://encarta.msn.com/dictionary_/agility.html




that is exactly my point. in this game agility is not defined the same as in real life.


In real life agility = agility + speed


In GLB, agility = ability to turn/cut quickly - SPEED NOT INVOLVED


See my example a few pages back.



The point is that if GLB is mis-interprteing the meaning of the word AGILITY, then it should be fixed.

If this is the definition of the word, then that is how it should be defined.

Originally posted by Dictionary



1. nimble: able to move quickly and with suppleness, skill, and control


And I believe that that is how GLB intends for AGILITY to work. If a real life OT doesn't need SPEED to be a good pass-blocker, then it is silly to make a GLB OT need SPEED for that purpose.

He may as well be needing PUNTING. Whatever unneccessary attribute that you are making OTs build, it is still not right.

People come here for the "football SIM". If we aren't rtrying to simulate real football, then what are we trying to do?


then if speed and agility is not need in RL..think what guys like Charles Haley, jevon Kerse, Derrick Thomas would have done against guys that stood like a stone...oh wait Derick Thomas had 7 sacks against anon agile and slow OT...but when he went against a guy that did have some speed and agility..he was shut down..hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by cdcollins

Originally posted by Bort


Maybe blocking should give the player a higher radius at which he can engage the block? Right now it just determines how well you can hold it when you do engage, but everyone's distance to engage is the same.

That would seem to make some sense, no?

Other idea: Maybe guys with 8 vision shouldn't get the instant jump on the snap, either. I could easily extend the "snap delay" code to D-line guys on pass plays.


Here, SI. I did the work for you. Happy, now?


why would a person be able to block further than their arms can reach? Your arms don't get longer the more you play football? How are you going to block without your arms??



No, but you could get better at reaching out and making those blocks as the guy goes past. The suggestion I was thinking of wouldn't make you have a 10 foot radius or something; maybe just dial the min range back by half a foot and the max up by half a foot from what they are currently.
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by cdcollins

Originally posted by Bort


Maybe blocking should give the player a higher radius at which he can engage the block? Right now it just determines how well you can hold it when you do engage, but everyone's distance to engage is the same.

That would seem to make some sense, no?

Other idea: Maybe guys with 8 vision shouldn't get the instant jump on the snap, either. I could easily extend the "snap delay" code to D-line guys on pass plays.


Here, SI. I did the work for you. Happy, now?


why would a person be able to block further than their arms can reach? Your arms don't get longer the more you play football? How are you going to block without your arms??


You missed the point entirely. And you bring up something about arm length, which has zero bearing in GLB.

I don't know if you ever played O-Line, and if you haven't the concept is foreign to you. Good O-Linemen work consistently on improving their block radius: the distance they can move from side-to-side, shifting in order to engage in blocks at wider radii. If I've understood Bort correctly, this is the exact same for every player, no exception. As it stands, this is a bit strange, and not an accurate representation of any football I've ever seen, real or fictional. Agility and speed, yes, should have a role to play in this, as you need agility to shuttle and speed to obtain a quick rate. But blocking should have an increased importance because, I don't know, isn't a lineman's job to BLOCK?
Last edited Nov 12, 2008 00:47:44
 
wlarson
offline
Link
 
that reach idea sounds like a holding penalty to me.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by chief31


And I believe that that is how GLB intends for AGILITY to work. If a real life OT doesn't need SPEED to be a good pass-blocker, then it is silly to make a GLB OT need SPEED for that purpose.

He may as well be needing PUNTING. Whatever unneccessary attribute that you are making OTs build, it is still not right.

People come here for the "football SIM". If we aren't rtrying to simulate real football, then what are we trying to do?



speed is how quickly you get from point A to point B. Nothing more, nothing less. Distance/time.

If we are try to figure out how to get the OT to move quicker from point A (where he started) to point B (where he needs to be to get in the way of the DE), isn't the LOGICAL thing to do.....to increase the speed?

P.S. and "nimble" isn't the correct word either - it has quickness in it also and is just another synonym for agile. A better word would be more like "turning".
Last edited Nov 12, 2008 00:45:46
 
ron2288
offline
Link
 
again here is a lower level OT blocking a higher DE...
start sarcasm

Bort DE pass rush is broken..make my De did not have a 100 sacks

end sarcasm
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=223987&pbp_id=1410644


my post are hopefully getting on guys who complains nervs and are starting to sound dumb...because the complain and crying that blocking or OT's are getting beat is

Last edited Nov 12, 2008 00:47:17
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.