User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > New Plays/Playbooks
Page:
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by secondeye
Originally posted by Deathblade

Originally posted by secondeye



And you'd never see a RB taking the snap in the NFL. No sir!


And the defense would know what was coming. Currently in GLB, the defense would not adjust to it.

What's the point of HB sweeps if you can put the HB at QB and just run sweeps with an extra blocker?


Whether the QB runs or the HB runs the same amount of blockers are in the same game, are they not? If your 2nd QB can run and that's all you use him for, then it's not really any different.


Again if you had a Run focus QB coming into the game, the defense would adjust and set a LB to Spy him.

They would also play more Cover 2 to compress the CBs drop and shift the Safeties to the outside a little to help.

Then spread the LB a little to help the outside contain, and drop the MLB a step oir two to improve his field vision.

Switch to a more read react defense, and the D-Line would take outside rush routes and key on the O-line movement on the snap.

Not possible in GLB.

And are you seriously asking what the difference is between a HB running the ball and a QB running the ball ????


Last edited Nov 2, 2008 06:07:57
 
secondeye
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by secondeye

Originally posted by Deathblade


Originally posted by secondeye




And you'd never see a RB taking the snap in the NFL. No sir!


And the defense would know what was coming. Currently in GLB, the defense would not adjust to it.

What's the point of HB sweeps if you can put the HB at QB and just run sweeps with an extra blocker?


Whether the QB runs or the HB runs the same amount of blockers are in the same game, are they not? If your 2nd QB can run and that's all you use him for, then it's not really any different.


Again if you had a Run focus QB coming into the game, the defense would adjust and set a LB to Spy him.

Not possible in GLB.

And are you seriously asking what the difference is between a HB running the ball and a QB running the ball ????




I'm asking what's the difference between a QB and a HB with the exact same stats running a QB run play. That's what I'm asking.

There's nothing stopping me from using a HB at QB right now and using that extra blocker. Will the passing suck? Most likely, but we all see guys that run 80-90% as it is right now.

I'm just saying, before this blows out of proportion as it always does, that it'd be nice to be able to switch QBs when you want to run QB run plays.. I couldn't care less if it has to come with restrictions of no non-QBs. I couldn't care less. End of story.
Last edited Nov 2, 2008 06:08:57
 
JSSynister
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by secondeye
Originally posted by Bort

I left extra slots out on QB's and some other positions for a reason. Only way there will be another QB slot is if it's limited to only QB's. I don't want to see HB's running QB rollout plays.


And you'd never see a RB taking the snap in the NFL. No sir!


Anyone else see that Pats/Dolphins game or was I just having a weird ass dream?
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by secondeye



I'm asking what's the difference between a QB and a HB with the exact same stats running a QB run play. That's what I'm asking.


Lots and lots of SAs...........

 
secondeye
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by secondeye




I'm asking what's the difference between a QB and a HB with the exact same stats running a QB run play. That's what I'm asking.


Lots and lots of SAs...........



Well then they don't have the same exact stats do they? Or do you not count SAs as a stat?
 
secondeye
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JSSynister
Originally posted by secondeye

Originally posted by Bort


I left extra slots out on QB's and some other positions for a reason. Only way there will be another QB slot is if it's limited to only QB's. I don't want to see HB's running QB rollout plays.


And you'd never see a RB taking the snap in the NFL. No sir!


Anyone else see that Pats/Dolphins game or was I just having a weird ass dream?


Well yeah but the Pats "knew it was coming" is the argument. Basically, as usual, we're catering to the lowest common denominator. The cheat/exploit kiddies.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by secondeye

I'm asking what's the difference between a QB and a HB with the exact same stats running a QB run play. That's what I'm asking.


Think about the blocking assignments.

In a HB sweep, the line blocks of course, and the FB lead blocks.

In a QB sweep, the line blocks of course, and the FB lead blocks, and the HB lead blocks.

One extra blocker can make a world of difference if the QB is almost as adept at running as a HB.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by secondeye
Originally posted by Mike Rogers

Originally posted by secondeye





I'm asking what's the difference between a QB and a HB with the exact same stats running a QB run play. That's what I'm asking.


Lots and lots of SAs...........



Well then they don't have the same exact stats do they? Or do you not count SAs as a stat?


The answer to your question was already given, why run the HB Sweep, when you can put a HB at QB and run the sweep with an extra Blocker.

The QB sweep will make the HB sweep redundant, and make the QB sweep overpowered.

The argument that its the same as running the QB sweep with a QB built like a WR is an argument for the sake of an argument really, and will never happen.

A QB will never have the exact same build as a HB, due to initial rolls, Auto assigned SP, SA tree availablity, and advanced Equipment options.


This is not a choice betweeen two positions that are always similarly built.

It is in fact a choice between two players that are always and ever will be differently built.



Last edited Nov 2, 2008 06:33:02
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Deathblade

Originally posted by Santah


How about adding QB1 and QB2? Not being able to choose what QB to use on the QB rush plays makes it unusable for 90% of teams.


Noooooo

RB at QB3 position...FB's at the FB and HB position, QB sweeps all day with an extra blocker. Scary stuff.


Yeah, I'd like to limit that kind of crap.


I'd still like to see a QB1/QB2 slot. We use a two QB system and one is more adept at the long passes and it'd be nice to be able to bring him in for those specific situations.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thehazyone

I'd still like to see a QB1/QB2 slot. We use a two QB system and one is more adept at the long passes and it'd be nice to be able to bring him in for those specific situations.


The problem is...even though it would benefit a lot of people, leaving an exploit open isn't worth the benefit.

If you read the entire thread, you see people trying to come up with a way to limit exploits/lameness of the QB sweeps.
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
yea I saw it, was just 5 pages later. Would just like some kind of option to be possible. I don't see why we can't have QB depth chart positions available to QBs only.
 
Unspoken
offline
Link
 
Bort please make it so we can print out all the offensive plays in the play book. It just makes going to the tactics and working on your offense and defense alot easier.. Thanks.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Maybe a option to set the '2 Min Offense QB' would help.

I can see the legitimate reasons to have your back up QB tailor their build to be a 'Comeback King' type.

Of course it would need to be a little more flexible than 2 Min offense only, so he could become active if down 2 scores in the fourth or whenever your 'down big late in the game' input kicks in.

Maybe an addition to the energy settings;

2nd Qtr If down _ points [force starter/force back up] (QB only)
4th Qtr If down _ points [force starter/force back up] (QB only)

As long as you cant have one QB for every long pass and one QB for every short pass and another in on the QB runs, the game shouldnt suffer?



Last edited Nov 2, 2008 07:24:01
 
GG
offline
Link
 
I think we gotta stick to the one QB slot. This game tries to resemble real life, and in real life you dont have QB slots for different packages or situations. You just tailor your whole offense around a QB. Vick in Atlanta, or Manning in Indy.

Last edited Nov 2, 2008 07:54:47
 
Unspoken
offline
Link
 
I think what people will do is put a HB at the #2 QB slot and run that play. I say leave the QB slot as is.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.