User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Canadian AAA Leagues > Canada AAA #2 > Canada AAA#2 East Power Rankings
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by GuieetarBen
Originally posted by BobJoeJim

Originally posted by hoyaboy1


BJJ, I'd post that in the bugs forum . . . but probably a shorter version just focusing on the 5 timeouts so people actually read it.


I wanted to see if anyone that isn't on our team agreed that it looked potentially buggy before I did. I don't want to be that guy who whines about something just because he lost, and I don't fully trust my judgment right now. If it still seems bad to me tomorrow, or if I get some other non-Trout players agreeing that something looks off, then I'll post it in the bug forum.


Every time you guys lose a game it has to be a "bug",this is rediculous. You are definitely a very good team. It could never be the fact that there are people playing this game that came up with a gameplan to beat you. That must be a "bug" too. Oh well, guess some things will always be the same!


We've lost three games.

*1st to the Knights in our first game as a team. No bugs there that I'm aware of.
*2nd to the Knights in a game where one player had 5 sacks in almost the exact same situation against a linemen with stats not so far below his (fondol posted the DT's) that that should've happened. Others came forward with similar situations. Fairly obvious bug
*3rd to the Redskins in a game where teams were apparently given 5 timeouts a piece.

This is a work-in-progress, there are and will be bugs. We've lost those three games by a combined 9 points and have posted varifible bugs to the most recent two.

If we were losing by 24 and didn't have the PBP and/or replays to back up our claims, I'd be all for calling us whiners (or course we wouldn't say that without those things, but...). However, the fact remains that we've sited our sources, and if you want to call us whiners, the burden of proof is on you.

In other news, damn what a great game Brown v. Reading was.
 
panther17
offline
Link
 
Just curious but do you guys check for bugs when you win and post them to show everybody that the win might be tainted or just when you lose?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by panther17
Just curious but do you guys check for bugs when you win and post them to show everybody that the win might be tainted or just when you lose?


Speaking only for myself, I rarely check for bugs specifically; they are usually being brought to my attention by someone else and not vice versa.

To answer you question more specifically, no, I don't check for bugs in wins. I do hope, however, that other teams (the losing teams) do.

Guys, this is a work-in-progress, there are going to be bugs. I know everyone wants to come on here and brag about their wins and losses (I'm well aware, I own the Trout remember , we have the best shit-talkers in GLB) but it's hardly a finished game.

Championships mean very little right now compared to getting the bugs out of the gameplay and fleshing it out.

Quick example, before our most recent game with Reading, we looked at thier stats and had a convo similar to this:

Person: Wow their TE is really good
Cody: Yeah he's their top receiver I'd say
Person: So how do we stop him
Cody: Uhhhh...we don't?

It's an early version of the game, and it's not at the level of being a realistic football sim quite yet. There are things we'd like to be able to do but can't. The programming is very limited, so much so that I've made the "Rock Paper Scissors" analogy before. It's all about working within the limits of the program

Everyone would be much better served long term by thinking of these first few seasons as the pre-season and focusing on making the game the best it can be. This means hunting for bugs right and left. Look at BJJ's work if you need help, he's incredibly detailed in his investigations.

Just take a deep breath and try to remember that it all goes well, this game is going to have a very long life span, and everyone (and that means EVERYONE) is going to lose a game for a reason that makes no sense (ex. "Why did my HB run 75 yards in the wrong direction?"). Keep your eye out for bugs and remember that right now, we're each better classified as "testers" rather then "players".
Last edited May 6, 2008 07:44:27
 
rwblake
offline
Link
 
If you do not check for bugs in wins, then you are just a whiner when you lose to a good team.

Rob
 
KingDan23
offline
Link
 
I think the Trout players are 100% entitled to bring this up considering that BJJ only stumbled across it due to his passion for the game rather than actually looking for an excuse. Big games like ours end up in a lot more scrutiny of the PbP than the easy wins, its obvious that you will analyse the PbP more in a tight game such as this. Not that I feel any worse about our win from hearing it, I still think its just a game and things like this go both ways so thats just the way the cookie crumbles.

And yeah the point is that bugs need to be found and pointed out to be fixed for future games!

Once again, good game Trout
 
panther17
offline
Link
 
Yeah he's actually doing a good thing. But should look at all games instead of just ones lost. I never thought of looking at that. I'm sure others haven't either.
 
rwblake
offline
Link
 

Problem is it was not a bug in the big game. Admin. never stated it was a bug. There were different defensive plays and offensive plays on the 5 sacks. Each time the NT just got through to create havoc. That is the way our D-line works, someone always gets through. You cannot stop all of the front four all of the time in a game.


Rob

Originally posted by Kingdan23
I think the Trout players are 100% entitled to bring this up considering that BJJ only stumbled across it due to his passion for the game rather than actually looking for an excuse. Big games like ours end up in a lot more scrutiny of the PbP than the easy wins, its obvious that you will analyse the PbP more in a tight game such as this. Not that I feel any worse about our win from hearing it, I still think its just a game and things like this go both ways so thats just the way the cookie crumbles.

And yeah the point is that bugs need to be found and pointed out to be fixed for future games!

Once again, good game Trout


 
dlk9s
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


In other news, damn what a great game Brown v. Reading was.


No kidding. I was watching the PBP without knowing the result and I was on the edge of my seat.

As for only looking for potential bugs in losses, it's not that someone on Trout said, Dammit, we lost. There's got to be a bug. We would never lose straight up," and then went to look for a bug (in fact, we knew there was a good chance we'd lose to Reading and Wall). Both of the Trout's latest losses (Conference Championship last season and yesterday) were one-score games that went down to the wire. In both, an obvious odd scenario that might have (or might not have) changed the complexion of the game held up a flashing neon sign that said, "HEY! THIS IS WEIRD! LOOK AT ME!"

Frankly, the oddities were extremely difficult to miss, especially because they happened in tight games, where each play was under a microscope.

They don't seem like "exploitable" bugs in that it doesn't look like anyone can control the game play enough to purposely make them occur, but they do seem like bugs or some sort of flaws in the AI.

Like Vanilla said, though, part of Beta testing is finding these things and bringing them to the attention of the developers. It's probably unrealistic to expect everyone to sift through every play of every game to look for oddities, but when things do come up, it is always good to present them for other, less biased eyes to view.


 
kidcolin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rwblake
If you do not check for bugs in wins, then you are just a whiner when you lose to a good team.

Rob


god you're retarded. Logic ftw.
 
kidcolin
offline
Link
 
How come KKKnights can't be more like KingDan? You're good people Dan. Nice win.

Originally posted by
Yeah he's actually doing a good thing. But should look at all games instead of just ones lost. I never thought of looking at that. I'm sure others haven't either.


We don't LOOK for bugs. We're not the fucking bug police. Jesus people. We watch play by play of every game in order to accrue* as much data* as possible and go from there. When we notice something, we bring it up. The timing thing was weird, though not as egregious as the NT thing. We admitted it didn't cost us the game.. we're more curious why we're passing when we're up late and the clock is our friend, if anything.

It's not up to us to find bugs. You want stuff to get flushed out, look for it yourselves. Try contributing instead of e-chest-bumping each other while you pound down Mountain Dew and Doritos.

*links for KKKnights:
http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/accrue
http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/data


 
hoyaboy1
offline
Link
 
For the record, all of my sacks last year were due to the bug where the LT doubled the DT and ignored the RE - and I posted about it on the forums.

This "bug" didn't affect the outcome of the game, but clearly something weird was going on with TOs, so it should be reported. That's the point of a Beta.
Last edited May 6, 2008 12:55:44
 
panther17
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kidcolin
How come KKKnights can't be more like KingDan? You're good people Dan. Nice win.

Originally posted by

Yeah he's actually doing a good thing. But should look at all games instead of just ones lost. I never thought of looking at that. I'm sure others haven't either.


We don't LOOK for bugs. We're not the fucking bug police. Jesus people. We watch play by play of every game in order to accrue* as much data* as possible and go from there. When we notice something, we bring it up. The timing thing was weird, though not as egregious as the NT thing. We admitted it didn't cost us the game.. we're more curious why we're passing when we're up late and the clock is our friend, if anything.

It's not up to us to find bugs. You want stuff to get flushed out, look for it yourselves. Try contributing instead of e-chest-bumping each other while you pound down Mountain Dew and Doritos.

*links for KKKnights:
http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/accrue
http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/data





Thats racist.
 
Link
 
That's not racist... that's adorable. kidcolin is just so cuuuuuuute when he gets his dander up.
 
dlk9s
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JuniorMcSpiffy
That's not racist... that's adorable. kidcolin is just so cuuuuuuute when he gets his dander up.


You're spending too much time with Fondletotz.
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kingdan23
I think the Trout players are 100% entitled to bring this up considering that BJJ only stumbled across it due to his passion for the game rather than actually looking for an excuse. Big games like ours end up in a lot more scrutiny of the PbP than the easy wins, its obvious that you will analyse the PbP more in a tight game such as this. Not that I feel any worse about our win from hearing it, I still think its just a game and things like this go both ways so thats just the way the cookie crumbles.

And yeah the point is that bugs need to be found and pointed out to be fixed for future games!

Once again, good game Trout


Thanks Dan. You certainly shouldn't feel any worse since you would've won anyway (if we had hit a hail mary at the end this "bug" could have even cost YOU the game ). I want to let you know how much I appreciate your behavior on the boards, both last season and this season, you carry yourself well. If by some fluke Brown doesn't earn the promotion to Pro this season (perhaps due to a bug? nudge nudge, wink wink, *feeds the trolls*, hehe) then I hope you get that spot instead. And once again, good game!

In addition to the timeouts and the sacks, which came in games we lost, I know for a fact that it was someone from our team who pointed out the bug where on punts, because the center was the wrong color, he was going unblocked. This was after a game we won, where our center blew up the opposing punt returner twice. Personally, I will post any potential bug I see, regardless of whether it helped or hurt my team. My odds of noticing a bug, though, are directly proportional to how closely I look at the game. You'll have to forgive me for the fact that I generally look closer at games I lost by one score than at blowout wins. I can assure you I probably wouldn't look very closely at a blowout loss either if one were to happen.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.