User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vandiar2
Originally posted by Schaffer05

Nope, there are two primary stats for a power back Str and carrying, just as there are 2 primary stats for an elusive back... speed and agility. I don't know why you're arguing... just by looking at the SA tree's you can tell a power back will fumble less than an elusive back. My power back has soft capped speed, and slow to soft capped agility, but the carrying and str get most of my attention.


Okay, then there is no clear advantage to building an elusive back then. Why would you do that when you can build a power back, fumble less, and produce just as much if not more. Do you see where I am going with this? Also, that is the first time i have heard anyone say carrying is a primary stat for power backs. It is like catching to a WR, both builds need it.


Carrying leads to breaking more tackles... therefore it's a primary stat for a power back. Elusive backs are good because they can outrun people when they get out in the open field. You have no idea how many times my power back has broken a tackle only to be caught from behind by a little twit CB. Our speed back on our team can juke someone and then out run the rest of the team for a TD, which is why he has 2x as many yards and TDs as any of my other RBs. If elusive backs were useless I wouldn't have one on my team, Power backs are just good for those short yardage situations and teams with poor tackling.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Normally wouldn't do this, but since I have my HB playing 3rd string HB and FB backup I don't figure much harm could come of it... This is what a power HB builds like


Strength: 70.13 Blocking: 14.3
Speed: 51.13 Tackling: 8
Agility: 44.12 Throwing: 14.3
Jumping: 14.3 Catching: 16.3
Stamina: 32.3 Carrying: 36.59
Vision: 29.55 Kicking: 8
Confidence: 22.13 Punting: 8
2 quick cut, 2 first step
33331 power back


yea str may be one of the main attributes for fumbling, but guess what, speed is a main attribute to a good RB too. I've not neglected speed or agility like you elusive backs have neglected str and carrying.
 
vandiar2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Normally wouldn't do this, but since I have my HB playing 3rd string HB and FB backup I don't figure much harm could come of it... This is what a power HB builds like


Strength: 70.13 Blocking: 14.3
Speed: 51.13 Tackling: 8
Agility: 44.12 Throwing: 14.3
Jumping: 14.3 Catching: 16.3
Stamina: 32.3 Carrying: 36.59
Vision: 29.55 Kicking: 8
Confidence: 22.13 Punting: 8
2 quick cut, 2 first step
33331 power back


yea str may be one of the main attributes for fumbling, but guess what, speed is a main attribute to a good RB too. I've not neglected speed or agility like you elusive backs have neglected str and carrying.


I haven't neglected carrying at all. I have 49 carrying. 3 into cover up like I said.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vandiar2

I haven't neglected carrying at all. I have 49 carrying. 3 into cover up like I said.


and your str? I'm going to guess that since you didn't mention it you're conceding you did in fact neglect str.

**edit** And 3 into coverall isn't the cureall lol. That's only going to help slightly. That's like me expecting to be white lightning from 2 first step and quick cut.
Last edited Oct 15, 2008 14:47:54
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vandiar2

I haven't neglected carrying at all. I have 49 carrying. 3 into cover up like I said.


First of all 6 fumbles on the season isn't all THAT bad. There are HBs who wish they could only fumble 6 times so far.

Secondly, what is your stamina and strength?
 
vandiar2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Originally posted by vandiar2


I haven't neglected carrying at all. I have 49 carrying. 3 into cover up like I said.


and your str? I'm going to guess that since you didn't mention it you're conceding you did in fact neglect str.

**edit** And 3 into coverall isn't the cureall lol. That's only going to help slightly. That's like me expecting to be white lightning from 2 first step and quick cut.


30 strength. my point is it shouldn't matter how much strength I have. power backs shouldn't have a clear advantage over elusive backs because strength is their primary stat... without their being some balance to elusive backs. speed and agility are my primary stats, with carrying being my third highest stat. the power backs I know use strength, agility, and carrying being their third stat. so, both backs have 2 "primary" stats. but one build has the advantage over the other in fumbles. there is no equilibrium here.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Originally posted by vandiar2


I haven't neglected carrying at all. I have 49 carrying. 3 into cover up like I said.


First of all 6 fumbles on the season isn't all THAT bad. There are HBs who wish they could only fumble 6 times so far.

Secondly, what is your stamina and strength?


LOL not only does he only have 6 fumbles, he's complaining when he's had a history of fumbling problems. 7,15,8,6 this season and only 4 games left. With over 200 carries on the season.

1 FFUM on the season came from a LVL 32 SS who has 5 FFUM on the season
1 comes from LVL 31 CB (probably just a bad roll)
other 4 come from teams they destroyed...
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vandiar2

30 strength. my point is it shouldn't matter how much strength I have. power backs shouldn't have a clear advantage over elusive backs because strength is their primary stat... without their being some balance to elusive backs. speed and agility are my primary stats, with carrying being my third highest stat. the power backs I know use strength, agility, and carrying being their third stat. so, both backs have 2 "primary" stats. but one build has the advantage over the other in fumbles. there is no equilibrium here.


Agility is not a secondary stat to power backs. We just do it because we know if we neglect it like you elusive backs neglect str we'll suck. I'm going to go ahead and bet you that if you bring your str up to where my speed is you'll not have a fumbling problem for a long time.
 
vandiar2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Originally posted by Sik Wit It

Originally posted by vandiar2



I haven't neglected carrying at all. I have 49 carrying. 3 into cover up like I said.


First of all 6 fumbles on the season isn't all THAT bad. There are HBs who wish they could only fumble 6 times so far.

Secondly, what is your stamina and strength?


LOL not only does he only have 6 fumbles, he's complaining when he's had a history of fumbling problems. 7,15,8,6 this season and only 4 games left. With over 200 carries on the season.

1 FFUM on the season came from a LVL 32 SS who has 5 FFUM on the season
1 comes from LVL 31 CB (probably just a bad roll)
other 4 come from teams they destroyed...


I am complaining because the problem is universal, not just me. Why do you make it sound like its just me complaining about the fumbling problem?
 
Zickzack
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vandiar2
I am complaining because the problem is universal, not just me. Why do you make it sound like its just me complaining about the fumbling problem?

There have been enough people stating that the problem is not universal, just as usual those who are complaining are louder. There have been more than enough attempts to explain to you guys what might have caused the increased fumble rate from last season, Bort has clearly stated that there was no change to the engine, so what more do you guys need? For Bort to acknowledge something that is not true, although you want to believe it is?
Last edited Oct 15, 2008 15:00:59
 
vandiar2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Originally posted by vandiar2


30 strength. my point is it shouldn't matter how much strength I have. power backs shouldn't have a clear advantage over elusive backs because strength is their primary stat... without their being some balance to elusive backs. speed and agility are my primary stats, with carrying being my third highest stat. the power backs I know use strength, agility, and carrying being their third stat. so, both backs have 2 "primary" stats. but one build has the advantage over the other in fumbles. there is no equilibrium here.


Agility is not a secondary stat to power backs. We just do it because we know if we neglect it like you elusive backs neglect str we'll suck. I'm going to go ahead and bet you that if you bring your str up to where my speed is you'll not have a fumbling problem for a long time.


Thank you for proving my point. Power backs can jack up strength ( primary stat) , be effective, and prevent fumbles. Let me rephrase the same point I am trying to make. Why does strength for a power back have 2 benefits? Shouldn't agility for an elusive back prevent fumbles too? I mean after all, it is a primary stat for us.
 
Barnsie
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Normally wouldn't do this, but since I have my HB playing 3rd string HB and FB backup I don't figure much harm could come of it... This is what a power HB builds like


Strength: 70.13 Blocking: 14.3
Speed: 51.13 Tackling: 8
Agility: 44.12 Throwing: 14.3
Jumping: 14.3 Catching: 16.3
Stamina: 32.3 Carrying: 36.59
Vision: 29.55 Kicking: 8
Confidence: 22.13 Punting: 8
2 quick cut, 2 first step
33331 power back


yea str may be one of the main attributes for fumbling, but guess what, speed is a main attribute to a good RB too. I've not neglected speed or agility like you elusive backs have neglected str and carrying.


My power HB has way more STR than you (by a lot), more carry, and more cover up SA. He's fumbling all the time this season. He fumbled 1 time last season.
 
vandiar2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zickzack
Originally posted by vandiar2

I am complaining because the problem is universal, not just me. Why do you make it sound like its just me complaining about the fumbling problem?

There have been enough people stating that the problem is not universal, just as usual those who are complaining are louder. There have been more than enough attempts to explain to you guys what might have caused the increased fumble rate from last season, Bort has clearly stated that there was no change to the engine, so what more do you guys need? For Bort to acknowledge something that is not true, although you want to believe it is?


Oh I know what is causing it. I know there hasn't been any change to it. I am just trying to get balance, that is all.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zickzack
Originally posted by vandiar2

I am complaining because the problem is universal, not just me. Why do you make it sound like its just me complaining about the fumbling problem?

There have been enough people stating that the problem is not universal, just as usual those who are complaining are louder. There have been more than enough attempts to explain to you guys what might have caused the increased fumble rate from last season, Bort has clearly stated that there was no change to the engine, so what more do you guys need? For Bort to acknowledge something that is not true, although you want to believe it is?


No.. they want power backs to suffer as well is basically what they're getting at..
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
But it makes no sense for agility to prevent fumbles. Face it...as a HB you're going to get tackled every once in awhile. I don't care how good you are; it's bound to happen. Strength will help you hold on to the ball. Strength and carrying. That's how it should work, because it makes sense. Why would agility prevent you from fumbling AFTER you get hit? It's a trade-off and you chose to go the elusive route. Also you still didn't tell me what your stamina was. I have a feeling that's at the root of most of these fumbling problems.

And we're not making it sound like it's just you complaining, I'm just trying to make a point that Bort already said he didn't change a thing, yet people are complaining that their backs are fumbling. Well guess what? If you're fumbling a lot, it's probably your build, not the sim. Also, 6 fumbles on the season is very reasonable. The problem is everyone always thinks their player is the best and should never fumble while breaking 20 tackles a game.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.