User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Wide Open Incompletion Case Study - Intended to answer Borts questions about the frequency of this error
Page:
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
Yeah, if they decide that the variable will be Vision - I'm all for that.
If they decide that the variable will be catching - I'm all for that.

I just want there to be something that I can work on, to correct the problem myself.

But, if this isn't correctable by my players' build, then I want to know that as well.

Point being, I (and everyone else) just want to be kept in the loop, especially with something as significant as this.


And another note: All of the people that were in this thread just for harassment purposes - take note. If you see my name behind a "Bugs" thread, I'm not here for the fun of it. There seems to be a group of people that frequent this bugs forum, just to try and cause a stir by acting as if there isn't a real problem. IMO these people need to be dealt with, even more so than people having a little fun on the main board.


Agree one hundred percent with this. I have never posted on here in 3.5 seasons of playing this game except for on this issue, and the number of idiots that crawled out of the woodwork to insist this wasn't a problem or was the result of 'poor builds' was staggering. To all of those morons - I think the fact that Bort has not only taken the time to respond here but to formulate possible fixes for this problem proves beyond a doubt that you all are not as smart as you think you are.
 
im4ut999
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Mike Rogers

While I have to accept that Bort has found a sequance out of order, what I cant see is how that alone accounts for a sudden spike in this occurances this season.


It has to do with the ever increasing QB throwing power and WR speed, and how it relates to the granularity of update polling. We've probably just hit a point with certain combinations that hasn't come up before, and with the passing styles it's amplified it to be more noticeable.

General explanation of what I'm talking about with granularity. Obviously we can't sim every nanosecond of the play, so it's broken down into ticks every so often.

Example, with made up numbers:

If on tick 10, it says that the ball is 10 feet away, you're not going to be able to catch it on that tick. If on tick 11 it says that the ball is now only 1 foot away, you can now catch it. If it's also hitting the ground on tick 11, though, and we check that first, then you don't get a chance to catch it because it supercedes any "how close am I" checks.

It also might have to do with the additions of the passing styles I added last season, since they affect angles used to throw the ball, and decrease the randomness therein that used to be used instead, which probably "hid" things some.

Like I said before, the best "fix" is just to add some additional checks at increased granularity for catching. Once I do that, though, the QB percentages are going to go up since some of those passes that were incomplete are now going to be more catchable. Therefore, it will require some rebalancing of QB accuracy, especially on long throws, to ensure we don't have everyone at 90% completions all the time.


It does sound like increased granularity is needed...the order of the check does not need to be adjusted if in the vicinity of a player, the ball movements are checked more often...

Adjusting (down) the completion percentage against double coverage could be a trade off most would agree on...and could offset this change fairly equally and without too much objection, as long as the QB understands the risk in throwing into double coverage and checks down to single coverage WR properly.
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
A QB and WR could do absolutely everything perfectly, and, depending on when the ticks/pass happen, the WR will have no chance of catching the ball.

How is that NOT a bug?

Another thought - are the stronger QBs having the biggest problem? The good QBs on good teams I have access to have varying strength, and the higher strength ones have the lowest completion %. Purely anecdotal evidence, but a thought nonetheless.

It would kind of make sense, if the ball has a traveling speed based on strength. The pass would travel farther per tic, making this issue more pronounced. It would also explain why we started to see it last season a bit and why we're seeing it more this season. Also, it would make sense based on the fact some QBs are seeing this more than others.
 
lazloth
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er
Another thought - are the stronger QBs having the biggest problem? The good QBs on good teams I have access to have varying strength, and the higher strength ones have the lowest completion %. Purely anecdotal evidence, but a thought nonetheless.


On my team, no. I rotate two QBs - significantly different in strength - have seen the problem with both. Your higher strength guy may have lower completion % because other dude has higher vision, able to dink & dunk?
 
west
offline
Link
 
this is interesting... thanks for posting this, i will look into it for my WR
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lazloth
Originally posted by j10er

Another thought - are the stronger QBs having the biggest problem? The good QBs on good teams I have access to have varying strength, and the higher strength ones have the lowest completion %. Purely anecdotal evidence, but a thought nonetheless.


On my team, no. I rotate two QBs - significantly different in strength - have seen the problem with both. Your higher strength guy may have lower completion % because other dude has higher vision, able to dink & dunk?


Certainly a possibility - more strength means less in vision/throwing.

Any clue if the stronger QB sees the issue more often? Or if it's always to the same WR for both QBs? Yours would be a good team to find some kind of pattern.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Maybe I just need to put a cap on the velocity the QB can throw the ball until I can work out the balance issues? Then the ball will be unable to travel so fast to cause any problems, and the QB would be back to what he was doing before. Would need to figure out what that cap should be though, prolly through some trial and error.
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Maybe I just need to put a cap on the velocity the QB can throw the ball until I can work out the balance issues? Then the ball will be unable to travel so fast to cause any problems, and the QB would be back to what he was doing before. Would need to figure out what that cap should be though, prolly through some trial and error.


My only problem with that is that wouldn't it also limit the range of the QBs with more arm strength? That would severly hurt the players who have built their qbs to stretch the field a bit. Also, teams with really fast recievers need QBs with big arms to take advantage of the speed. I'm still in favor of changing granularity or increasing catching radius as the best solution. If you think about it, the effect shouldn't be that great because the core issue here is that the wide recievers aren't attempting to catch balls that they should be able to catch, which means the completion percentage on the longer pass plays would go up but the medium and short pass plays should stay the same - and just because the wr attempts to catch the ball doesn't necessarily mean he will catch it - there could still be drops as well.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rj414
Originally posted by Bort

Maybe I just need to put a cap on the velocity the QB can throw the ball until I can work out the balance issues? Then the ball will be unable to travel so fast to cause any problems, and the QB would be back to what he was doing before. Would need to figure out what that cap should be though, prolly through some trial and error.


My only problem with that is that wouldn't it also limit the range of the QBs with more arm strength? That would severly hurt the players who have built their qbs to stretch the field a bit. Also, teams with really fast recievers need QBs with big arms to take advantage of the speed. I'm still in favor of changing granularity or increasing catching radius as the best solution. If you think about it, the effect shouldn't be that great because the core issue here is that the wide recievers aren't attempting to catch balls that they should be able to catch, which means the completion percentage on the longer pass plays would go up but the medium and short pass plays should stay the same - and just because the wr attempts to catch the ball doesn't necessarily mean he will catch it - there could still be drops as well.


I've done some tests and the completion %'s do go up by 5-10% in general. I just don't want to see 80% completion become the norm for everyone.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by rj414

Originally posted by Bort


Maybe I just need to put a cap on the velocity the QB can throw the ball until I can work out the balance issues? Then the ball will be unable to travel so fast to cause any problems, and the QB would be back to what he was doing before. Would need to figure out what that cap should be though, prolly through some trial and error.


My only problem with that is that wouldn't it also limit the range of the QBs with more arm strength? That would severly hurt the players who have built their qbs to stretch the field a bit. Also, teams with really fast recievers need QBs with big arms to take advantage of the speed. I'm still in favor of changing granularity or increasing catching radius as the best solution. If you think about it, the effect shouldn't be that great because the core issue here is that the wide recievers aren't attempting to catch balls that they should be able to catch, which means the completion percentage on the longer pass plays would go up but the medium and short pass plays should stay the same - and just because the wr attempts to catch the ball doesn't necessarily mean he will catch it - there could still be drops as well.


I've done some tests and the completion %'s do go up by 5-10% in general. I just don't want to see 80% completion become the norm for everyone.


Capping the speed at which a QB can throw doesn't seem like a good idea to me. My QB throws bullets and I like it that way. Either it's right on the money, or nobody catches it. Won't my QB start throwing INTs if you cap the speed at which he can throw the ball? This seems even worse than the incomplete problem.
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by rj414

Originally posted by Bort


Maybe I just need to put a cap on the velocity the QB can throw the ball until I can work out the balance issues? Then the ball will be unable to travel so fast to cause any problems, and the QB would be back to what he was doing before. Would need to figure out what that cap should be though, prolly through some trial and error.


My only problem with that is that wouldn't it also limit the range of the QBs with more arm strength? That would severly hurt the players who have built their qbs to stretch the field a bit. Also, teams with really fast recievers need QBs with big arms to take advantage of the speed. I'm still in favor of changing granularity or increasing catching radius as the best solution. If you think about it, the effect shouldn't be that great because the core issue here is that the wide recievers aren't attempting to catch balls that they should be able to catch, which means the completion percentage on the longer pass plays would go up but the medium and short pass plays should stay the same - and just because the wr attempts to catch the ball doesn't necessarily mean he will catch it - there could still be drops as well.


I've done some tests and the completion %'s do go up by 5-10% in general. I just don't want to see 80% completion become the norm for everyone.


For my QB, at level 31, a 10% increase would get him up around 70. I think the guys who are currently completing 70+% are throwing more short and medium passes, and thus I don't think this change would affect them as much.
 
cosmoxl
offline
Link
 
I'm seeing pretty high completion percentages in games I'm involved in. I guess I'm in the camp that passing is too easy already.
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cosmoxl
I'm seeing pretty high completion percentages in games I'm involved in. I guess I'm in the camp that passing is too easy already.


Ok, but just looking at your last game - the guy completed 80% of his passes at 5.2 an attempt. That means he's not throwing deep, and this change shouldn't affect him very much.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Is there any way we can fix the problem for those who are having the problem? Because I agree, I don't want to see completion percentages go up 10% GLB-wide, but it is still unfair to those who's QB throws very quickly, and who use deep passes.

I know it's a tough decision to make, I'm just stating my opinion.
 
nitetrain
offline
Link
 
i havent seen any problem with my QB. My qb throws quick and also deep. Where is the problem. Maybe QB builds? Maybe WR builds try carrying and strength..

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=404308

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=163663

now it appears that the QB is throwing stupid passes that are 2 or 3 yards from the receiver. Also had a few passes tipped by DL, which never happened before. Maybe the QB was throwing to high before to avoid DL and WR didnt have no jumping.


Oh well, always got to be ready for changes from the complaining (paying) customers. That isnt nothing new in GLB. then the cycle starts. Then one day someone will complain about something else and the cycle starts again..
Last edited Sep 28, 2008 14:15:06
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.