User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Interpreting the Polls
Page:
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vando
Originally posted by GG

That's why "representatives" would be a good idea. Selected/elected users who will fulfill the duty of "efficiently disseminating a debate" between Bort/Admin and the userbase about proposed changes and working towards a common mutual benefit.


You mean like the mods?

I like your thinking!


Actually, not like mods. I mean elected/selected actual users (non-mods) who present more of an intermediary pov. Mods have to toe the admin line, have to quell the masses, provide customer support, and generally clean up forums. But this "rep" role would be purely in context of proposed game changes. Being there to push Bort on what the community wants, and also push the divided userbase to accept certain game decisions are for the greater good. But that whole process is transparent. So that the community knows WHY. So that the reps can relay info, explain etc.

Mods, Admin, Bort all have different roles already, and they're not always the same or aware of what each other has done, is doing, wants to do, and WHY.
 
Vando
offline
Link
 
Mods already do this because they have to read the Suggestions forum.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vando
Originally posted by Deathblade

Originally posted by GG



Both good/true comments. Also, there's always gonna be people who do those things---yell until they get their way, make empty threats of quitting, engage in endless "u suck, no u" bickering that leads to nowhere, etc. That's why "representatives" would be a good idea. Selected/elected users who will fulfill the duty of "efficiently disseminating a debate" between Bort/Admin and the userbase about proposed changes and working towards a common mutual benefit.


I foresee the representatives being more hated than the mods, maybe even more hated than me.

It would be decent though, if you can find a decent handful of people with a good head on their shoulders and want to work towards making the game better to make the game better, not making the game to make themselves better.


Pro tip: the mods already do a pretty good job. People will just always whine, because they're dumb and think they suck because everyone else is cheating when they suck because they're dumb.

Its the ciiiiirrrcle of liiiiiiife


To the both of you. That's why reps are better than mods. Because they are perceived as just ordinary people like you and me, so it takes the burden off mods being tarred with a brush of cheating or favoritism etc. Meanwhile, those reps may end up being hated, but that's the role if anyone has the integrity and balls to take on the role. Ideally, it would be a committee of a handful of users. Maybe 1 person selected/elected from every region, so 8 people.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vando
Mods already do this because they have to read the Suggestions forum.


That's why reps are better than mods. Because they are perceived as just ordinary people like you and me, so it takes the burden off mods being tarred with a brush of cheating or favoritism etc.
 
Vando
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Originally posted by Vando

Mods already do this because they have to read the Suggestions forum.


That's why reps are better than mods. Because they are perceived as just ordinary people like you and me, so it takes the burden off mods being tarred with a brush of cheating or favoritism etc.


No I don't think we should pander to the stupidity of users. The mods are as neutral as anyone else is likely to be in the same role.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Originally posted by Vando

Mods already do this because they have to read the Suggestions forum.


That's why reps are better than mods. Because they are perceived as just ordinary people like you and me, so it takes the burden off mods being tarred with a brush of cheating or favoritism etc.


Deja vu....

But the representatives will be just like game developers...I don't think Bort actually wants that, I think he actually wants most of the say, and I'm sure he is able to wade through the shit and see the valid complaints.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
OK, I'm too tired to put together any logical argument...I'm out guys.

Good discussion GG, was fun.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
This thread shows to me the relationship between mods and users, admin and users, and even admin and mods, isnt functioning as a well-oiled machine. There was a whole 10 pages of grievances and people still unable to trust due to past wrongs.

 
GG
offline
Link
 
Ok nite DB. thanks for the chat and check you later.
 
Vando
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
This thread shows to me the relationship between mods and users, admin and users, and even admin and mods, isnt functioning as a well-oiled machine. There was a whole 10 pages of grievances and people still unable to trust due to past wrongs.



No, it shows you that there are a vocal minority that subscribe to a conspiracy theory as to why the top teams are at the top.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vando
Originally posted by GG

This thread shows to me the relationship between mods and users, admin and users, and even admin and mods, isnt functioning as a well-oiled machine. There was a whole 10 pages of grievances and people still unable to trust due to past wrongs.



No, it shows you that there are a vocal minority that subscribe to a conspiracy theory as to why the top teams are at the top.


Vocal minorities can also have a way to turn the indifferent to their pov and become a vocal majority. Especially if/when more slip ups might occur in future that validates or fuels that paranoia.

Anyone seen to be working FOR GLB or a mod etc, will always be considered "one of them". It's best not to have mods hated...which is what the reps would end up being.

Anyway, it was just a suggestion (representatives) from me about how to cure some of the problems i saw after reading the thread. That's my feedback to GLB after reading this thread.
 
jakobako
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by jakobako

Take your agendas and stick them up your butt everybody


Why would we want a bunch of shitty agendas?


LOOKS LIKE THATS WHAT YOUVE GOT TBF
 
PP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hud
Originally posted by BullFrogOnNet

Originally posted by tpaterniti


500 other people have a terminal illness? Did you know that there is an organization called The Make a Wish Foundation where they basically make exceptions for people with terminal illnesses and make a wish come true for them that would not happen for other ordinary people? The general consensus is that if someone is going to die soon because of an illness, you can cut them a little slack. I never thought I would see the day that someone complained about a terminal patient getting a break, but this is GLB after all so I guess I shouldn't be too surprised. I am all about expressing oneself, but I doubt you are going to gain a lot of support by making the "terminal patients get too much slack/too many breaks" argument.


So Satch's dieing wish was to have his account babysat? This has nothing to do with attacking Satch. Stop danceing around with lame BS that isn't even relevant. Ill ask these questions again - What reason is it to allow someone to babysit his account? To not let his players go inactive and continue allocating their SP? People with his players can just replace them. Is it so he doesn't lose his team? Honestly, if he recovers he can play again.


I have tried to remain quiet because I am involved in the issue, but you are dense man... what are your accusations again... mod favoritism? And your example that you know "isn't gonna go over well" is Satch. I have already explained to you privately that would this have happened to ANYONE it would be handled the same. If your problem is that satch is a Mod, then know that all this was requested by him before Bort even knew who he was. You had a problem with making a thread about it Satch because he was getting preferential treatment. You had a problem with me writing a long write up on Satch and having it stickied. You had a problem with me editing your disrespectful post in the thread. All because it is favoritism? If anyone believes that is the case, it is sad man. Satch is a different case as is evident by everyone besides you who posted in there, not because he is a mod or part of some inner circle, but because alot of people knew him and respected him way before he was a mod. The man is dying of a terminal illness. ANYONE in that situation would get the same respect. Anyone who meant nothing to the community, but was in satch's situation and asked a mod to sticky it would get it done. I would even write something nice if it made them feel better if I didn't know them or the people who asked me to, because it is a different situation. So Tpat is not dogging the issue, you are brother. Is the issue that you are not as respected by the community? Try being a bit more helpful and bit less negative. Is the issue, you feel left out? get involved more.

Let's take your example of soldiers and account baby sitting. Did you know that this is a common practice that is not frowned upon by the admins? or where you too busy trying to find problems with people being nice to other people? As a matter of fact, account baby sitting is not against the rules at all. The admins have said do it at your own risk. But taking over someone else's account for your own personal use is a problem. In the case of someone in the process of dying, I am sure the admins would let anyone get things handled before not someone else into the accounts and closing it out.

One of satch's "dying wishes" was to have his account baby sat, because he cared about the people who played on his team and about GLB. And yes, if Satch recovers he can play again. And what a day it would be because we would have another decent person to balance out the numb-skulls. I strongly suggest that if you want to know more about satch's specific case, you contact an admin, my man.


I didn't want to come out and say it, because I didn't want to reveal anything that they may have wanted to keep on the QT, but this is 100% true regarding the admins not giving special treatment to Satch because of his mod status. I personally PMed DD several times about baby sitting accounts of players that are in the military and can not access the net. Each time I was given their blessing.

I completely agree that the way the nameless former mod's activities were handled, as well as him still "being involved with the game" gives GLB a HUGE black eye, but mods getting special treatment regarding baby sitting accounts is untrue. Personally, I don't even think preferential treatment of mods occurs anywhere near as much as most think...It's just that one was allowed to get away with a ton of shit and a couple aren't policed as well as they should be, regarding their bannings, shit talking and locking of threads. Unfortunately, that makes them all look bad, even when the vast majority I truly believe are ethical players.
 
PP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tim Harper
Originally posted by 1VBChaos

There is an old saying that goes along the lines of 'Power corrupts - and absolute power corrupts absolutely'. GLB has been a case in point...........


The clever combatant imposes his will on the enemy, but does not allow the enemy's will to be imposed on him.


This is the shit that gives GLB a HUGE shinner...Mods, former mods and those "still working for GLB" shouldn't be trying to punk the game or the players. The fact that ppl like this are still associated with the game is inexcusable, IMO.

Edit: AND is the cause of the majority of the hostilities that is directed towards the current mods, as well as the source of the majority of why so many players believe mods are cheaters and given preferential treatment, IMO...Fair or not (personally think it's tremendously unfair to the majority of the current mods), a huge part of the answer to why this occurs is staring you in the face.
Last edited Sep 26, 2008 09:02:52
 
Jack Del Rio
offline
Link
 
Whoever can summarize this thread for me in Sonnet form will receive 1000 Flex Points awarded in the form of my undying love and the possibility of me licking their toes.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.